Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off with dd but to accept that we can't force her to do it?

481 replies

Omronron · 29/07/2021 18:01

I have three dcs. 22, 18 and 15.

I'll start by saying that Dh and I have had a really tough couple of years. We run our own business and times are very tough, not sure if we'll even have a business this time next year. We live very rurally (this is relevant!). No public transport, taxi service miles away.

Anyway, we've not had holidays for the last few years. Dh has booked a weekend away for just me and him. We told dd22 we were going to do this. She is living with us before she goes back to uni mid September. She also has a car that we pay for. Ds18 is waiting for his test to come through but can't drive.

We asked dd22 to be around that weekend as she has the car,just in case there's an emergency, I am sure they'll have to go to a shop at some point.

She agreed - but was very reluctant. I more or less begged her to do it.

Anyway she's come home today and said she has a party 3 hours drive away on the Saturday that we go away, so won't be around from Saturday lunchtime until Sunday afternoon. This means ds and dd will be in the house on their own (fair enough they are 18 and 15) but they won't have a car in case of emergency or to get to the shops. I know they will probably cope, but it would have meant I could really enjoy myself and relax knowing dd1 was here with her car.

AIBU to expect dd22 to stay at home that weekend?

Yes - you are being unreasonable and the other 2 will just have to cope without anyone here with a car

No - She's being selfish and unhelpful

OP posts:
Omronron · 30/07/2021 07:23

I'm a bit leery of parents using their older children as a free babysitting service and becoming outraged when they decline

Why? It's perfectly normal to use older children to look after younger children. If you had a 16 year old and a 8 year old would you not leave them alone to go to the shops etc?

Also, she's 22, wasn't asked to "babysit", she was asked to be around for the weekend which she agreed to.

Thank you @AtlasPine. He had the all clear a year ago Smile

OP posts:
hellcatspangle · 30/07/2021 07:20

I can understand why you're pissed off with her for changing her mind, it's selfish of her.

However, I think the others will cope fine on their own for one night.

Omronron · 30/07/2021 07:18

What would you be doing if your eldest didn't exist?

If she didn't exist and ds18 couldn't drive we wouldn't have planned the trip.

OP posts:
AtlasPine · 30/07/2021 07:12

Ridiculous to have no expectations of family support from a fit and capable young adult offspring. She is behaving very badly - it really isn’t a lot to ask. She gets a lot from you. She said she would. She has let you down. She said she would and she damn well should. Your husband has cancer. You haven’t had a break for years. She ought to be pleased she can help give you peace of mind during your break. She should be pleased you’re going, pleased you trust her, pleased she can give something back.

I’d be pretty disappointed and very reluctant to continue supporting her driving with any funding.

PepperPrig · 30/07/2021 06:51

I think YWBU to ask her in the first place, to be honest.

What would you be doing if your eldest didn't exist? Presumably getting a shop in, leaving the number of your hotel (less than 3 hours drive away!) by the fridge and ensuring your 15 and 18 year olds can remember the number '999'!

In the abreact, it's annoying that she's going back on her word in favour of a better offer, and I do think there's a general lesson to be learnt about honouring your first commitments but it's all a bit skewed for me by the fact I think it was an unnecessary request in the first place and I'm a bit leery of parents using their older children as a free babysitting service and becoming outraged when they decline.

If you're paying for her car, I think you need to be clear in your own mind whether it's a gift freely given (possibly because you acknowledge the burden it placed in your children to live so remotely at your preference?) and it is truly her car too so with as she pleases in the same way as if she were paying herself or whether it comes with strings attached. If the latter, be up front with her about those so she has the opportunity to decide whether that's a deal she wants.

Karaokehell2021 · 30/07/2021 06:50

I wouldn't be paying for her car anymore. It isnt a huge ask for one weekend considering how much you so for her!

Namechanger0800 · 30/07/2021 06:43

I get why you're pissed off - you ask for one favour from an adult child and they can't do one thing despite everything you've done. The selfishness would really piss me off and I would stop paying for the car. If she can't use the car to help you out once in a blue moon then she can fund the thing herself
From this point.

Sadly this sounds just like the sort of thing my eldest would do- the sulking is because she knows she's wrong

SusieQ5604 · 30/07/2021 06:30

Having the car is not really the point. She agreed to do it then reneged. THAT's the point. Why let her agree to things, have someone rely on her and then have her think it's ok to back out? ESPECIALLY if parents are providing the car. I'd take the car keys and she'd have to find other transportation to the party for that particular weekend.

BritWifeInUSA · 30/07/2021 06:21

Why the obsession with them not being able to “pop to a shop”? If you’ve always lived “very rural” then you are accustomed to not being able to “just pop out” for something and you plan and manage accordingly.

We probably live even more rurally - nearest place to buy groceries of any sort is a small shop almost 25 miles away, rural GP is 45 miles away and nearest town (cinema, restaurants, hospital, full-service medical center, etc) is over 70 miles away. If I run out of milk I make do. But it’s rare that I do. We have 4 freezers. We have a large pantry and have dry goods delivered in bulk. I shop for fresh things every other week and freeze stuff, can, vacuum pack, etc. I make our bread etc from scratch. I’ve never thought “oh I need to pop to a shop to get xyz”. Why would they suddenly need to buy something in the less-than-24-hour period that the one who can drive is away?

Bumblecattabbybee · 30/07/2021 06:15

You are being unreasonable. An 18 and 15 year old who can't react in an emergency without a car/make it to the shop for food on foot, or by public transport, shouldn't be left alone. A car not necessary and many people cope just fine without one! If my parents when away when I was a teen we simply did a big food shop beforehand, didn't even need to go out for food. Surely that would be the logical solution rather than making your daughter wait around in case she is needed as taxi service?

MiddleParking · 30/07/2021 06:09

Yes the foresight was to ask dd to be there

To be the designated driver.

avamiah · 30/07/2021 02:47

It’s not the end of the world is it?
Just get lots of food in and leave them with some emergency money .
It’s not like you live in Alaska is it.
Just relax and I’m sure everything will be fine.

Derbee · 30/07/2021 02:25

*give and take

Derbee · 30/07/2021 02:25

Life’s about five and take. The fact that she won’t do something for you (even if it’s unnecessary, it’s important to you and DH) would mean a new line drawn going forward.

There would be a discussion about her having unlimited access to a car that you pay for/maintain/insure. I would revoke the car privileges and tell her to make her own plans. I know my DP is softer though, which is where a compromise would be found.

But I’d be angry if I were you guys. It’s disappointing for adult DC’s to be so unwilling to do something for their parents who are still doing so much for them

Namechangeforthisquestion7 · 30/07/2021 01:37

Haven't read all of the comments so apologies if repeating, do the younger two have any friends they could stay with to put your mind at rest? Or another responsible adult within driving distance who could be "on call" for the two of them?
I agree your eldest is being selfish to go back on her agreement, knowing your stressful circumstances and your need for a break! It's not the going out, it's the going out after agreeing to be there.
Course, you could teach her a lesson by taking the two boys away on a nice weekend break with you - she is busy that weekend and can't come!

DeflatedGinDrinker · 30/07/2021 01:36

OP YABU. If theres an emergency they can call the police/ambulance/plumber or whatever is needed, the oldest being there will not make a difference. Make sure they have food before you go. Running out of bread for 1 day and needing to go shop is not an emergency.

butterry · 30/07/2021 01:35

I don’t think a car is necessary for the weekend but you have raised a selfish and entitled eldest child. If she’s living rent free and has the car paid for, she should at least honour the agreement she made with you. It’s a complete lack of respect for others with her party taking priority over other people. I would tell her how unimpressed I am with her attitude and she can pay towards the car if she continues to be so inconsiderate. She’s old enough to know better

TreeSmuggler · 30/07/2021 01:28

It's annoying that the ambulance was 1.5 hours away that one time you called, but I don't think we can live our lives around being 20 mins away from hospital at all times. That would mean we would never go hiking, travel to many places (as pp said even some countries), go on a boat or fly on a plane. Your dcs will be alone for less than 24 hours and as presumably they sleep in late like all teens, they will be awake and alone for under 12 hours, probably sitting in their rooms on devices.

crabbingbucket · 30/07/2021 01:14

We live very rurally and have no car!

Ginandplatonic · 30/07/2021 01:09

And seriously why does everyone feel they need to tell the OP to stock the house with food - I think she can figure that out for herself and it’s completely missing the point.

Ginandplatonic · 30/07/2021 01:05

Bloody hell some people on this thread have seriously low expectations of their young adult children!

I’m with your DH - you asked her for one perfectly reasonable favour (whether other posters think it was strictly necessary is completely beside the point) and now she has backed out of a commitment she made, despite presumably knowing this would cause you stress. I would be angry and disappointed too.

You can’t force her to stay home obviously, and the other kids will undoubtedly be fine, but I would definitely be reviewing how much I did for her in future, and having a serious conversation about rights and responsibilities. And taking the car you pay for back to uni with her would be off the table for starters.

Hannsmum · 30/07/2021 00:56

I would be upset that she accepted but didn't do it.

But I don't think you need a car for an emergency.just stock up the house with enough food

Omronron · 30/07/2021 00:53

@ThinWomansBrain

I get that she's irritated you by staying she'd stay home then changing her mind - but two adults on their own for 24 hours? They should be able to survive without a trip to the shops FFS.
15 isn't an adult, but thanks anyway.
OP posts:
ThinWomansBrain · 30/07/2021 00:52

I get that she's irritated you by staying she'd stay home then changing her mind - but two adults on their own for 24 hours? They should be able to survive without a trip to the shops FFS.

SpanielRadcliffe · 30/07/2021 00:36

I'd go ahead on the trip and not worry. Maybe leave some cash for an emergency? Although I grew up rural and you couldn't even get a taxi in an emergency without booking ahead.

In your case, I'd have double checked the timing of the weekend with the oldest to make sure she was free. If you did that and chose a weekend she agreed to, then she's being awful, sorry.