Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Clueless (shockingly) in Cars! Help me to buy a car!

82 replies

SaritaBella · 29/07/2021 16:05

No males or knowledgable women around to ask besides you ladies!
I have a budget of around £6K, looking for something that will accommodate me and young DC (car seat) but I still want it to be a bit stylish rather than just a boring family car! My dream car is Nissan qashqai but this is for the future 😀 Always liked Audi, VW but seems not for my budget or rather aged.
Need Ulez complyint. Looked into hatchbacks but would prefer 5 door. Just passed my drivers license so nowhere near to drive a saloon 😀
Sniffed around various websites but don't even know what's good/bad.
Is it better a bit older but go for known brands? Understand this is individual but just need a guide on what to focus on.
AIBU to ask what you'd recommend??🤔 Help, really clueless here!

OP posts:
MaskingForIt · 30/07/2021 15:14

Looked into hatchbacks but would prefer 5 door. Just passed my drivers license so nowhere near to drive a saloon

But hatchbacks are 5 door. Do you mean an estate?
And why can’t a new driver drive a saloon? Confused

starfleet · 30/07/2021 14:54

If you've only recently passed your driving test insurance costs will also be something you'll be thinking about as well as buying your car.

Maybe a 5 door car with a smaller engine. Toyota Yaris are a decent starting point and you would get a newer model with your budget. They are reliable, roomy inside (although a little basic feature wise) and not massively expensive to maintain. DS has just got rid of a 14 year old one he'd had after passing his test 4 years ago and we didn't have to spend a fortune on it.

JaceLancs · 30/07/2021 14:34

We have 5 VW golfs DM DB DS DD DDs DP
DP and I have VW Passat
Go on for ever - don’t use a main dealer no dearer garage bills than any other make
I’ve probably spent less than £500 on mine over last 3 years and most of that has been on consumables like tyres, oil change, brake pads etc

Shade17 · 30/07/2021 14:31

they are VWs but without the price tag

That’s not necessarily a good thing. VW are generally in the bottom half of most reliability indices/surveys. Skoda seem to be the most reliable member of the VAG family.

SpnBaby1967 · 30/07/2021 13:52

Look at a SEAT, they are VWs but without the price tag

icedcoffees · 30/07/2021 13:46

Another vote for Hyundai.

I have a second-hand i20 (2016). The only work it's needed is new tyres - otherwise it runs like a dream. It's petrol, tax is £30 a year and is a nifty little thing with surprisingly good boot space and plenty of room in the back for two car seats.

My first car was a Hyundai Getz - a bit smaller but still a good little car with no mechanical issues whatsoever.

DH has had two fords in the last three years and both have been awful in terms of repairs and running costs. I would avoid like the plague.

ILoveShula · 30/07/2021 13:00

honestjohn link on car buying

Malbecfan · 30/07/2021 12:57

I'm also going to disagree on mileage. A car that has done a lot of miles isn't necessarily a bad thing. We are just about to scrap a 20 yr old Ford Ka that has only done 70k miles. We've done 30K of them in the last 5 years (not a huge amount) but it spent most of its life standing or doing very short journeys. They knacker an engine a lot more than long runs. My current car is 4.5 years old and has already done 56k, most of which were on motorways/national speed limit roads.

Malbecfan · 30/07/2021 12:51

Someone has suggested a Clio. Having owned several Renaults, don't waste your time with them.

I agree with others about Japanese/Korean cars in terms of reliability. My Dad bought DD1 a Kia Rio as her 1st car when she was still learning to drive. It was 23 months old when we got it so still had more than 5 years left on the warranty. It is a great little car, fits 5 adults in and she took me and my double bass to a concert last week. It's pretty economical too. I'm pretty sure it's ok with the ULEZ - we checked when she drove us to Wembley. The kit on Kias is impressive, you get a lot more for your money than you do with a VW (my choice atm)

Mooloolabababy · 30/07/2021 12:43

[quote BIoodyStupidJohnson]@Mooloolabababy Jukes can be cheap for a few reasons;

  • There are a lot of them, because Nissan couldn't sell them fast enough, so there's always choice on the market which drives prices down
  • The paint quality wasn't great in the early days and some of the interior finishes were a bit shonky
  • The lowest spec ones Visia I think are a bit under-equipped
  • The 2010-2013 ones had issues with timing chains, which led to a reputation for unreliability. Most likely this will have been fixed via recall by now, but it's worth checking if the timing chain has been addressed
  • The styling is very love-it-or-hate-it, and a lot of people hate it, so they don't hold their value in the way that other small crossovers do
  • They're not super-practical; a bit tight for space in the back, small boot
  • When Nissan facelifted the Juke in 2014 they upgraded the trim levels. There's a preference for post-2014 models in the market which drives down prices of the 2010-2013 ones

If you like the look of them, and they work for you practicality wise, there are far worse things you can buy for five grand. I'd just suggest being very picky on condition, history, mileage and trim level.[/quote]
That's fab, thanks for the info!

hulahooper2 · 30/07/2021 11:22

Look at Seats , Ibiza or arona

Shade17 · 30/07/2021 11:19

Nissan's are great also

Newer ones are shockingly bad. Close to the bottom of most reliability surveys now. They’ve gone massively downhill since Renault’s involvement. Avoid!

beguilingeyes · 30/07/2021 11:17

Nissan's are great also. I have a 2007 Micra which I've had since 2009 and it's never put a foot wrong. I've replace a couple of wiper blades and a battery and that's it.

Essentialironingwater · 30/07/2021 10:38

I think a Honda Jazz would be perfect for your budget but unfortunately they are not stylish at all. Incredibly reliable though!

I wouldn't worry about a larger car. You would find it terrifying for about a week or two then adjust!

BIoodyStupidJohnson · 30/07/2021 10:34

@Mooloolabababy Jukes can be cheap for a few reasons;

  • There are a lot of them, because Nissan couldn't sell them fast enough, so there's always choice on the market which drives prices down
  • The paint quality wasn't great in the early days and some of the interior finishes were a bit shonky
  • The lowest spec ones Visia I think are a bit under-equipped
  • The 2010-2013 ones had issues with timing chains, which led to a reputation for unreliability. Most likely this will have been fixed via recall by now, but it's worth checking if the timing chain has been addressed
  • The styling is very love-it-or-hate-it, and a lot of people hate it, so they don't hold their value in the way that other small crossovers do
  • They're not super-practical; a bit tight for space in the back, small boot
  • When Nissan facelifted the Juke in 2014 they upgraded the trim levels. There's a preference for post-2014 models in the market which drives down prices of the 2010-2013 ones

If you like the look of them, and they work for you practicality wise, there are far worse things you can buy for five grand. I'd just suggest being very picky on condition, history, mileage and trim level.

willstarttomorrow · 29/07/2021 20:23

44Shade17- sorry Tayota! We had one years ago which was nothing but trouble and a few people at work have loads of issues and huge repair bills. No way is this a representative survey- I know most people love their Tayota.

Floralnomad · 29/07/2021 20:22

We have a variety of Kia’s in our family , all very reliable , great warranty . Our son has just bought a new Rio , he had a 15 reg Ford before which he had from new , had done 55k miles and the gearbox needed replacing !

Mooloolabababy · 29/07/2021 20:21

I'm in a similar boat op (but with only 5k) I like the look of a Juke but my main concern is that there are so many on the market at seemingly lowish prices, so that makes me think there most be something wrong with them for them to be so much cheaper than other cars of that age!

willstarttomorrow · 29/07/2021 20:17

@44Shade17 You are probably right, I looked at both but my mechanic was firmly in the Skoda camp. You get a lot more Skoda for you money than Nissan and they are cheaper to keep on the road. I was also really surprised that Skodas really hold their value now. I would have paid a lot more through a dealership. OP, maybe have a look at a Yeti and see what you think? They rate very highly against Nissan SUVs

dementedma · 29/07/2021 19:58

Tempted by a Nissan Juke here too and the new Citroen SUV is cool.
I do too many miles for PCP, over 2000 a month

Meggie2008 · 29/07/2021 19:57

I have a Seat Ibiza, I'm on my second one actually as I loved my first one but saw a newer one in a better colour 😂😂
My next car is probably going to be a Seat Leon. Slightly bigger than the Ibiza but firmly still in the bracket of small manageable car.
Never had any issues with them at all, and both of my parents actually own Seats as well now.

SaritaBella · 29/07/2021 19:54

Thank you my lovelies for all your advices and tips.
Scanning through and checking cars at the moment Grin on a mission!

OP posts:
Shade17 · 29/07/2021 19:44

Skodas have come a long way

Indeed. They’re the most reliable VAG brand but still not a patch on a Toyota.

willstarttomorrow · 29/07/2021 19:17

Just to add, everyone will have a tale of an amazing lucky buy that cost nothing. Late DH loved Citroen for this reason which is very unusual!. Also, the fancier the car means the more there is to go wrong and can cost a lot more to fix. My 20 year old fusion kept going and could be repaired really easily (this is why they are still highly sort after).

willstarttomorrow · 29/07/2021 19:11

I know this is boring but a car is a depreciating asset that costs (a lot) of money to keep on the road. When my 20 year old trusty rusty died last year I weighed up what was important to spend my money on as a lone parent and with a limited income. It was reliability, reasonable running/repair costs and certainly not finance. So I ended up with a 4 year old skoda fabia, fully serviced with lowish milage and fsh etc.
Luckily I have a gem of a local garage I use who sourced it for me for at least £1000 of the list price and it was 2,900 less than you are looking to spend. It is a really nice car, passed its MOT no problems, cost me £60 to replace brake pads which were an advisory. It is not massively beautiful but not really ugly. Skodas have come a long way and mine happens to be a lovely colour 😁

I get wanting something you love, never imagined having a skoda when I dreamed of cars learning to drive. But when you start paying insurance and upkeep, unless money is no object or the car you drive is a priority, reality tends to kick in a bit.