Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to say no kindly?

163 replies

Vanillaaddict · 29/07/2021 10:21

I was in a houseshare a few years ago with a girl who was lovely but hard work. She was untidy, not very clean, a bit awkward to live with as very fixed in her ideas. She is the kindest person you will ever meet, but expected a similar level of time and generosity back from others and got very hurt and angry when others ‘fell short’ in her eyes by failing to do things for her when asked.
I know people get flamed on here when they ‘diagnose’ others as autistic, but honestly I wouldn’t be surprised if she was, as she finds it incredibly difficult to see things from others’ point of view. Even though she is a very kind person. I’m just saying this to make it clear that she’s not just being awkward or selfish.
I am easygoing, and I understand her ways, but living with her for two years was definitely enough for me.

After we moved out of the shared house I got myself a 1 bed flat and she has been moving from one place to another, she keeps falling out with the other people she lives with, all of whom have taken issue with her untidiness and idiosyncratic routines, but instead of taking feedback on board she has been terribly offended, fallen out with them and ended up leaving. She’s currently in temporary accommodation and will need to move again in a couple of months.

She often says how “lovely” it would be if we could live together again. I like her as a friend, but there is no way I want to live with her again. I will soon be moving to a 2 bed flat and I just know that she will suggest that she come to live in the second room.

I know that “no is a complete sentence” but I don’t want to hurt her feelings. How can I let her down gently?

OP posts:
Meraas · 29/07/2021 12:37

YANBU at all. Is she even a friend? You don't have to tell her it's a 2 bed.

Be strong.

lottiegarbanzo · 29/07/2021 12:34

'Houseshares? Been there, done that, got the t-shirt! I'm loving having my own space, wouldn't go back for the world.'

Keeping it general but emphatic. Keep it about you. No room for compromise for even the loveliest ever flatmate.

She can think you're selfish all she likes but the clearer you make it that there is no spare room, never will be the quicker she'll need to move her thoughts on to looking for something else.

Branleuse · 29/07/2021 12:29

id also tell her that i value her friendship too much to risk it

BorderlineHappy · 29/07/2021 12:28

At least you have knowledge of what shes like.If you feel yourself weakening remember the houseshare and what she was like.

Shes notgoing to take kindly being told no,so you might as well be as blunt as you like.

Branleuse · 29/07/2021 12:19

Tell her that sorry but no, as you find houseshares hard and promised yourself never to do another one

pootleforPM · 29/07/2021 12:17

I've been here, tried to deal with it gently and it did unfortunately end up in a fall out anyway as my friend couldn't see past the 'Pootle has 2 bedrooms, I need somewhere to live and this is the perfect solution, how MEAN of her not to let me move in'. We didn't speak for 6 months.

She was in a houseshare where the landlord had given notice a few months notice as he was selling, all her housemates had found somewhere else, but she left it until the last minute and then claimed she couldn't find anywhere at all to live and would be homeless, lots of hysterics and tears. I said she could stay with me for 4 weeks to give her enough time to sort something, but when she then started planning where her furniture would go, and which furniture of mine I would have to move out of 'her' room to accomodate all her stuff, and came up with a rota of when our boyfriends would stay over I realised she had no intention of it being temporary.

I worded it that the 4 week offer was still open, but her furniture would need to go in storage and she would need to be out at the 4 week mark, and used exactly the wording others have given about preferring and being used to living on my own, not wanting to ruin our friendship etc, but she threw her toys out of the pram and called me all sorts of names to mutual friends.

As you say, she couldn't see past her need of moving in being 'greater' than my need for her not to move in. I wish you luck!

crystaltips98 · 29/07/2021 12:12

Is there scope for her to rent the one-bed that you are moving out of?

moofolk · 29/07/2021 12:12

Also trying to help her find somewhere, or chat and get excited with her about other possibilities might help to show that you support her and want to help her fund what's best for her (which is not living in your house).

moofolk · 29/07/2021 12:10

Just no is fine.

I have just left a house share (me, my kids, another single mum family)

It was great to start with but deteriorated for various reasons.

My friend and I have out own places now, and each live as the only adult in a single parent family, and are both really happy.

One thing we both say is that it's great that we moved out while we are still friends as sharing for a bit longer may have put paid to that.

If she is autistic and literal, she should get that.

I want to live on my own.

I love living on my own.

I love you.

I want to remain friends because I think you're brilliant.

If we live together again that may not happen.

Good luck

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 29/07/2021 12:02

House sharing is a huge commitment, even if you're not in a relationship with that person. I have a few female friends I'm very close to but living with them is another matter entirely. It's not a thing I'd be prepared to risk those friendships for, unless it was a temporary measure in a time of real hardship. Any expectation to the contrary is a huge imposition, IMO, and it's not one I'd ever want to place on any friend.

You like your privacy and your space. You've been there, done that, and that phase of your life is over.

Anyone can't accept something so reasonable is not a friend.

AngryWhompingWillow · 29/07/2021 12:00

@Vanillaaddict

Oooh the idea of her moving into my 1-bed is genius! I don’t know why I never thought of that!!
Hmm, it's a good idea. However, I am 100% certain she will find a reason/excuse to not move into your (old) 1 bed flat. She 100% wants to live with you.
Viviennemary · 29/07/2021 12:00

I'd make an excuse like your sister or cousin might move in then when they don't say you need the second room as a guest room. I wouldn't say no sorry you're too untidy and hard work. Even if it's true.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 29/07/2021 11:59

I'd make a joke of it, "I'd like to keep our friendship, so maybe let's not live together again!"

AngryWhompingWillow · 29/07/2021 11:59

I don't know if you're renting @Vanillaaddict but when we had a big 4 bed ex-council house some years ago (renting privately at the time.) We had 2 kids, and ourselves. Me and DH had a bedroom, And our DC had one each. And there was a spare.

Our older DD (17 at the time,) wanted her friend (aged 21) from down south to come live with us. She had fallen out with her whole family and DD told her she could have the 4th bedroom, without even asking! I was fuming. I didn't even know her. And I didn't want a stranger in my house. And this wasn't a child, she was 21.

I pulled out a great reason for 'Sarah' not staying though. And it was a genuine one! The contract had a strict rule that we cannot have anyone over 18 staying here, who is not on the tenancy (it came under the 'no subletting' section.)

So 'awww, that's a shame DD, but 'Sarah' can't stay.' Sad

Is that an option Vanillaaddict Can you perhaps tell your old flatmate it's against da rooolz?! If you're renting, I would TOTALLY say that! Say your landlord does not allow anyone to live there unless they are on the tenancy agreement.

HollowTalk · 29/07/2021 11:59

Ask her if she wants you to put her in touch with your landlord, but for god's sake don't be a guarantor!

BrightYellowDaffodil · 29/07/2021 11:58

I don't think this person sounds 'kind' at all. It sounds like she gives, but only in the full expectation of repayment at her convenience. And she's clearly lacking in self-awareness if she can't twig that the common denominator in all the failed house-shares is her.

Even if you were minded to take in a lodger or tenant, she sounds someone you'd want to avoid anyway. As PPs have said, have a line prepared ("I'm sorry but I want to live alone" or similar) and just keep repeating it. Whatever you do, don't let her stay "temporarily" because it will absolutely end up being permanent.

Is there any option of gently pointing out that she's struggling with house-shares because she's not the easiest person to live with and she isn't willing to change?

Vanillaaddict · 29/07/2021 11:55

(The temporary accommodation she’s in at the moment is a summer let, not council property)

OP posts:
Standrewsschool · 29/07/2021 11:52

Be careful saying it’s for visitors, because she will then immediately ask if she can visit!

I would say that’s it’s for an office as you will be working from home etc,

Crockof · 29/07/2021 11:51

Your friendship will be more damaged if you allow her to move in.

Please don't get involved in helping her find a place because when it falls through it will be easier for her to suggest staying at yours.

Mummyoflittledragon · 29/07/2021 11:51

She’s looking in temporary accommodation, as in looking to be housed by the council? The answer there is you’d be mad to let her move in and mess up her chances of a secured tenancy.

Monicuddle · 29/07/2021 11:51

Is it possible for you to say “god no you drove me insane when we lived together. I love you loads and don’t want our friendship destroyed by going back to that situation”

I think that’s what I’d say. Honest without being nasty.

Vanillaaddict · 29/07/2021 11:51

Oooh the idea of her moving into my 1-bed is genius! I don’t know why I never thought of that!!

OP posts:
Notaroadrunner · 29/07/2021 11:50

Her living arrangements (or lack of) are not your responsibility. Do you think any of her other previous house mates are currently worried about where she's going to live after her current accommodation is up? I highly doubt it. So why are you bothering about it? Don't even tell her you are moving. Unless she turns up unannounced on your doorstep regularly then there's no immediate need for her to know you've moved. She doesn't need to visit your home when you can arrange to meet up in a bar/cafe etc.

If you do feel the need to tell her then describe the flat as a one bed. The second bedroom will be your office/home gym/hobby room/dressing room/whatever you like, so no need to describe it as a bedroom if she asks how many bedrooms. And in the event she pushes to stay for a few nights just be very firm in saying that you wont be sharing accommodation again so it's not possible. You know if you let her stay for one night you will find it very hard to get her out when she plays the poor me card.

Maybe she could rent the flat you're leaving?

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 29/07/2021 11:50

You say that she is the nicest, kindest person. Yet this is someone who continually pushes at your boundaries, won't take no for an answer and has no issues with making people feel uncomfortable as long as she gets what she wants from the situation. She doesn't sound lovely and kind to me.

AnyOldLion · 29/07/2021 11:49

@Datingandnoideahowto

I’m sorry but I don’t want to house share with anyone. It’s nothing personal.

Repeat, repeat, repeat.