Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holidays costs when not living together

245 replies

ImMale · 29/07/2021 01:25

Looking for some advice, please.

I'm a dad of 2 young (under 10) kids, I have a girlfriend whom I've been with about 10 months and who has a 10-year-old. We do not live together.

I earn 4 or 5 times her salary.

I want to go on holiday, I can afford and am happy to pay for all 5 of us. She can't afford to contribute at all, so the option would be either we don't go, or I go with my 2 kids.

She doesn't seem to have any issues or concerns with me paying for us all.

Is this normal?

Am I being taken advantage of, or is it reasonable for me to pay for the 5 of us given the massive disparity in our incomes?

I see a future with my girlfriend but I just need someone to sanity check that I'm not being a complete idiot here.

Not sure it's important, but the price of a holiday would be around the £5-6k mark + all the extra you spend while away.

OP posts:
IsItAKindofDream · 29/07/2021 05:17

[quote ImMale]@Bumblecattabbybee

I don't think this is the is bigger issue.

It's more that I love this girl a lot. Like more than I've ever loved anyone.

And I feel that might cloud my judgement.

It's easy to say "if you love her..." but then when I've spent 1,000's and and leaves me everyone will be like "well you shouldn't have spent money on her".

All I'm asking from a group of women is if paying for a holiday in this context is deemed sane and reasonable.

I get the feeling it is, so thank you.[/quote]
You seem more worried about having wasted money (or people thinking you were stupid to spend the money) on a holiday if the relationship breaks down, than on the impact on your children.

NumberTheory · 29/07/2021 05:17

[quote ImMale]@IsItAKindofDream

I actually worried that it looked like I was being a controling guy, a single mum recently mentioned to me about a concept of men "creating a debt" by spending money on them, and making it hard to leave.

That's what I'm concerned about along with me just being stupid.

I was very hesitant about posting here as I expected to get abuse, but I really though I'd get some support, and I'm glad to say I have from some, but sadly a few (like yourself) has no interest in helping me and just wants to be negative.[/quote]
I can see how this could be an issue. Especially if you are giving her DC experiences she couldn't hope to give them without you.

Not that I'm saying you'd be deliberately try to do that, or that she is with you to get stuff for her DC. But I can see how you just including her and her DC in things that are normal for you but out of her price range might get to a point where she feels like she can't pull back for her DC's sake.

But it would be an equally dysfunctional situation if you only ever did things with her that she could easily afford and then had a sort of separate "better" life without her.

I don't have an answer for you. I'm just saying I don't think your concerns are crazy. Might have been better if you had waited another year or so to suggest something like a holiday, but it's only one thing and your relationship wil be a lot more than that.

HungryHippo11 · 29/07/2021 05:13

[quote ImMale]@HungryHippo11

We've not booked. We're unlikely to go that week. I was just giving some example days[/quote]
Ah OK I see. Well I go on a summer holiday every year and have never spent close to £6k. As stated above our camping this year will cost under £200 for the week. Obviously this is not the sort of thing you're looking for but there are all sorts of holiday options.
You seem to think I'm being judgemental, I'm not. You'll see my first post said if you're all happy with it then it doesn't matter what anyone thinks.
However if she is on a low income, she might feel more comfortable with it (and you/your friends may feel less awkward about it) if you spent less.

ImMale · 29/07/2021 05:09

@HungryHippo11

We've not booked. We're unlikely to go that week. I was just giving some example days

OP posts:
Sunflowergirl1 · 29/07/2021 05:08

@ImMale "I appreciate I've maybe not worded everything perfectly, but as a single dad meeting someone who feels near perfect, but you need to finance the vast majority of your joint life, it's a complex situation, and I hoped to find some advice here, which I think I have."

I would worry so much about the holiday but do think hard. You say she sounds perfect which is lovely, but going forward if the relationship develops, how will you feel,about the income disparity? It isn't so much about "is she a gold digger?"...she doesn't sound to be, it is just you have achieved differently in life and sometimes that can expose differences. I have seen it with two sets of friends

Bloodyhail · 29/07/2021 05:08

In your shoes my questions would be over the longer term situation. Apologies if I’ve missed it but does her kids’ dad contribute to them financially? Earning disparity can cause problems, I’ve seen it often. Blending a family against that background can be problematic

ImMale · 29/07/2021 05:08

@HungryHippo11

Find me a summer holiday less than that.

Yes she knows.

This isn't a about her. It's about me

OP posts:
HungryHippo11 · 29/07/2021 05:07

[quote ImMale]@Hopeisnotastrategy

Okay, find me a holiday for 9th August for 5 people.

What's your cheapest price?[/quote]
Depends how basic you want to go. I'm going camping on 9th August and it's costing £125 for 4 of us 🤣

Didn't realise the holiday was in 1 weeks time. It's kind of irrelevant what the etiquette is then isn't it? You can't cancel now.

HungryHippo11 · 29/07/2021 05:05

Maybe you would all feel better if you went on a cheaper Holiday? £6k is loads for a holiday for 5 people, does she know it will cost this much - she might feel embarrassed that she can't contribute.

ImMale · 29/07/2021 05:02

@Hopeisnotastrategy

Okay, find me a holiday for 9th August for 5 people.

What's your cheapest price?

OP posts:
ImMale · 29/07/2021 05:00

@Bumblecattabbybee

I don't think this is the is bigger issue.

It's more that I love this girl a lot. Like more than I've ever loved anyone.

And I feel that might cloud my judgement.

It's easy to say "if you love her..." but then when I've spent 1,000's and and leaves me everyone will be like "well you shouldn't have spent money on her".

All I'm asking from a group of women is if paying for a holiday in this context is deemed sane and reasonable.

I get the feeling it is, so thank you.

OP posts:
Hopeisnotastrategy · 29/07/2021 04:59

[quote ImMale]@pinkbubbles100

I'm sure she will have some spending money, she certainly isn't what you'd describe as "tight", just holidays cost a LOT of money.

Thanks, I feel a lot more comfortable that I'm not doing something totally out of the ordinary here.[/quote]
Holidays don't have to cost a "LOT" of money.

If you're serious about her, go somewhere cheaper.

You do sound like hard work. If this is an issue then it will always be one.

HungryHippo11 · 29/07/2021 04:53

As I said, I just don't know if this is normal? Is it normal for a guy to pay for his "new" gf and kid to go on holiday with them? I honestly don't know.

Why does it matter whether its normal? If you're happy with the arrangement and so is she, why does it matter one jot what people on the Internet consider "normal"?

Bumblecattabbybee · 29/07/2021 04:52

I feel that if you were entirely sure of this girl, you wouldn't be questioning this so much? It's not that unusual for a partner to pay for a holiday! Especially if they earn 5x the amount of their partner and can easily afford it. When I met my DH we were sure we saw a future together and constantly treated each other/shared money really early. This seems fairly common with people who are serious with their partners. Your post comes across as a little... Suspicious? Bitter? Like, you're not sure about this girl or aren't really wanting to merge your life with her. I feel like this might be part of a bigger issue.

IsItAKindofDream · 29/07/2021 04:50

[quote ImMale]@IsItAKindofDream

I actually worried that it looked like I was being a controling guy, a single mum recently mentioned to me about a concept of men "creating a debt" by spending money on them, and making it hard to leave.

That's what I'm concerned about along with me just being stupid.

I was very hesitant about posting here as I expected to get abuse, but I really though I'd get some support, and I'm glad to say I have from some, but sadly a few (like yourself) has no interest in helping me and just wants to be negative.[/quote]
I’m trying to help your kids.

If you see that as abuse, so be it. I don’t.

ImMale · 29/07/2021 04:47

@IsItAKindofDream

I actually worried that it looked like I was being a controling guy, a single mum recently mentioned to me about a concept of men "creating a debt" by spending money on them, and making it hard to leave.

That's what I'm concerned about along with me just being stupid.

I was very hesitant about posting here as I expected to get abuse, but I really though I'd get some support, and I'm glad to say I have from some, but sadly a few (like yourself) has no interest in helping me and just wants to be negative.

OP posts:
ImMale · 29/07/2021 04:44

@5475878237NC

Thanks.

OP posts:
IsItAKindofDream · 29/07/2021 04:44

[quote ImMale]@eekbumbler

Nothing at all mentioned in this thread has been about my relationship. I'm very confident and comfortable in it.

I am unsure about the appropriateness of paying for a holiday[/quote]
Remove the problem. Take your kids on holiday by yourself.
Your kids will benefit from your attention.

And no-one can potentially be looking at her as a free-loader
Or looking at you as rushing a relationship to get free childcare from her, or however you are worried it looks.

ImMale · 29/07/2021 04:43

@IsItAKindofDream Plenty of men too, I was only singling women out in the context, stop trolling.

OP posts:
ImMale · 29/07/2021 04:41

@eekbumbler

Nothing at all mentioned in this thread has been about my relationship. I'm very confident and comfortable in it.

I am unsure about the appropriateness of paying for a holiday

OP posts:
IsItAKindofDream · 29/07/2021 04:41

Where do you find someone (woman) who earns 150k and is not stuck up/wants more.

Stuck up? Wants more? WTAF. I hope you and girlfriend don’t have daughters. They don’t need this misogyny in their lives.

5475878237NC · 29/07/2021 04:40

I can't put my finger on why but this seems off. You have so much more money and suggested a holiday outside of her means. You're not being too generous to pay for it no.

ImMale · 29/07/2021 04:37

I'm sick of this "you're asking on MN", Is it not positive that someone has come here to ask for advice on decisions they are making? What's negative about asking for advice.

OP posts:
eekbumbler · 29/07/2021 04:35

[quote ImMale]@IsItAKindofDream

I'd hope she has done a Clare/Sarah Law check on me, why would any women not? If you suspect anything then you shouldn't be with the person. The whole point of that process is that you check out the people you do not suspect.

Not sure where you've seen a "rush" for me to include her child in our relationship?

Yes, me taking the risk is a valid route, but not what I chose. My kids are a massive part of my life, they live here more than they don't, it makes snese on many levels to let them form an opinion on my gf.[/quote]
It makes sense for them to form an opinion on your gf?

You haven't even formed an opinion on how your relationship will work hence you are here asking.

The kids will just get on with on with it until they don't see each other any more - and I feel sad for them.

It makes sense on so many levels for your kids to form an opinion... says a man asking what is right or wrong on a forum...

Heard it all now.

ImMale · 29/07/2021 04:33

@eekbumbler

No, I'm not David or a Solicitor!

Where do you find someone (woman) who earns 150k and is not stuck up/wants more.

From what I have seen, the very very few women who would be in that sort of salary bracket are divorced from families with significantly more so would be unhappy with a man who earned the same as her.

Regardless, I want someone who I love, not someone who's wealthy.

Is the issue with 10 months that you don't expect it to last? If he "does this with every gf", what is an acceptable length of time?

OP posts: