Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holidays costs when not living together

245 replies

ImMale · 29/07/2021 01:25

Looking for some advice, please.

I'm a dad of 2 young (under 10) kids, I have a girlfriend whom I've been with about 10 months and who has a 10-year-old. We do not live together.

I earn 4 or 5 times her salary.

I want to go on holiday, I can afford and am happy to pay for all 5 of us. She can't afford to contribute at all, so the option would be either we don't go, or I go with my 2 kids.

She doesn't seem to have any issues or concerns with me paying for us all.

Is this normal?

Am I being taken advantage of, or is it reasonable for me to pay for the 5 of us given the massive disparity in our incomes?

I see a future with my girlfriend but I just need someone to sanity check that I'm not being a complete idiot here.

Not sure it's important, but the price of a holiday would be around the £5-6k mark + all the extra you spend while away.

OP posts:
TomAllenWife · 29/07/2021 09:18

OP you're getting a rough ride here.

Just ignore the batshit crazy ness where you need to wait 2 years before introducing your kids to anyone!!!

I am in a very similar situation. My partner earns a lot more than I do. We've been together for 3 years now and I still feel uncomfortable with some things (this weekend he gave me £200 to spend away with my kids!)
He has paid for us all to go on holiday (his children and mine), but will also take his on his own and we go on holidays without any of the kids

I think the difference with people taking the piss. I pay my way wherever possible, I will treat him to dinner, or lunch, or a night away when I can afford it. I still offer to pay half for meals out etc so if she is doing this then I think she has good morals rather than being some sort of gold digger

FawnFrenchieMum · 29/07/2021 09:18

I think it all depends on how she behaves day to day. Does she expect you to pay for everything or does she chip in and contribute.

Did she start looking at holidays she couldn’t afford and ask if you fancied it or did you put the suggestion out there? If you I don’t see any problem in it.

TalkingOutYerArse · 29/07/2021 09:17

Money well spent to see how you all get on for a decent duration of time if you ask me.

vivainsomnia · 29/07/2021 09:15

The issue is that it could indeed set precedence. She could be a lovely person who would be as happy developing a relationship with you if you had nothing at all, or the incentive to go out with you is your income and what it could offer her and her child.

Once you agree to pay everything for a holiday, what stopping her to expect it everytime. The question is with a child in school FT, what is her situation that she doesn't have a penny saved to take her child on holiday. This would raise some alarm bells for me in your shoes.

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 29/07/2021 09:14

If I was reading this as your partner, I’d be really put off.

Firstly, she’s a grown woman, don’t refer to her as a ‘girl’. 🤢
Secondly, I’d be pissed of that you were asking randoms about this. If, as you say, you’re worried that it could be seen as she owes you something, then talk to her. See how she feels about it.
Thirdly the ‘am I being too nice’ 🤢 I think you thought you’d come on here and be swooned over as this ‘lovely’ bloke, a ‘high earner’ being so kind to this low earning woman. Seriously. She’s a mum to a 10 year old, a nurse, she’s been fine without you til now. It’s patronising AF.

And my last point is that you introduced your kids to each other after a couple of months. Absolute madness, very confusing for all the kids. I never understand the rush to push kids together just because they’re parents are dating. You talk about your kids loving her, I very much doubt that. They’re just going along with things as they had no choice. It’s all very rushed. Poor kids.

The tone of your posts just doesn’t sit right with me. You sound detached, like you’re watching it happen, not actually being part of it, thinking you’re above it all. It all sounds odd.

feelingmehtoday · 29/07/2021 09:11

[quote ImMale]@CliffsofMohair

I politely disagree. I am very happy with the situation from my own perspective, I am much more concerned if what I consider to be OK is actually OK.

I'm a bit concerned you're suggesting that it's wrong for me to question my own decisions and seek advice?[/quote]

Quite. How many women post here every day questioning their lives and decisions and asking for advice? Yet a man does it - "you're obviously not happy with this relationship or wouldn't be asking on here".

🙄🤦🏼‍♀️

tempester28 · 29/07/2021 09:10

It's pretty simple - if you want to go with her but she can only go if you pay - then you either pay and go or don't pay and don't go.

TimetohittheroadJack · 29/07/2021 09:09

It's not really worth the hassle of going abroad this year especially if there's a risk she has to quarantine on the way back, so what about a long weekend in a lodge/cottage? I know everywhere is pretty fully booked but I'd bet you could get a min- fri break in a lovely place for ~1000-1500£.

You pay that and then split the food/trips out costs. That way it feels fair.

GameSetMatch · 29/07/2021 09:07

If it was me I’d pay for my partner and her child just so I’d have some adult company on holiday.

Ivy48 · 29/07/2021 09:07

Tbh if she can’t afford it then don’t go or go just with children. It’s not just the holiday it’s spending money, passport, clothing and toiletries etc which if she doesn’t already have holiday clothes could be quite expensive. Just talk to her. It’s your choice to pay if you want she’s quite clearly said it’s not in her budget. My partner paid
For our first holiday but I got my spending money and clothing together etc. Don’t force her into a hole with trying to find money she hasn’t got

ChunkySloth · 29/07/2021 09:03

[quote ImMale]@Anordinarymum

I said I want to go on holiday.

She said, "that'd be really nice".

I think there was a presumption I'd pay, but that's probably my own doing.

As I said, I just don't know if this is normal? Is it normal for a guy to pay for his "new" gf and kid to go on holiday with them? I honestly don't know.

I am happy to, but I also want to know what I'm happy with is reasonable.[/quote]
Yes it is. If you see a future with her and can envision shared finances/home/life with her then yes, pay. Why not? It's a lovely thing to do. Don't overthink it like the man hating harpies on here will make you do, I haven't read the full thread yet but no doubt someone has accused you of trying to buy and take advantage of her already 🙄

halfthesun · 29/07/2021 08:56

Hello, my bf of nine months earns 5 x my salary, I'm a teacher. Initially I insisted 50:50 on everything but recently we have come to the agreement I pay 20%. He has made it crystal clear he is happy to pay for everything but this just seems fair. We have just spent one amazing week in Portugal in a hotel there is no way I could afford to pay 50% of - this works for us. But I'm not sure how I would feel about him paying for my children ... can you find a compromise like ours? Where she contributes what she can afford?

Outbutnotoutout · 29/07/2021 08:54

It depends on what she earns.

If she is bringing home UC and is barely scraping by, hand to mouth then I wouldn't expect her to contribute.

But if she is earning a decent wage, it's just that you have a very good job, then divide the total price by 5 and she can pay her share.

Also depends on how long you have been together 1yr, go on your own. 2+ share

Lulu1919 · 29/07/2021 08:53

What sort of holiday ?
How much extra will it cost you to take two extra people ?
How about sit and chat to her....something like -we could go to ? ..I'm happy to pay for accommodation but then I thought we make a kitty for food etc ....what do you think GF ?

feelingmehtoday · 29/07/2021 08:50

@ImMale

I'm sick of this "you're asking on MN", Is it not positive that someone has come here to ask for advice on decisions they are making? What's negative about asking for advice.

Yep. With you on this one.

TeenMinusTests · 29/07/2021 08:49

I think you are over thinking.

feelingmehtoday · 29/07/2021 08:45

In fact... a woman would be told to think about and weigh it up more.

feelingmehtoday · 29/07/2021 08:45

@Roselilly36

You don’t sound particularly committed to her, if you weighing up whether you should be paying for a holiday to include her and her children. If you consider her as a partner, I don’t think it would be something you would even think about, perhaps you ought to think about that.

A comment that absolutely would never be said of a woman asking exactly the same question on here. It's fascinating on here sometimes...

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 29/07/2021 08:42

I’m not sure I’d pay if there was no offer to even pay a token amount or the expectation that because my salary was higher I’d fund it. I’d have to much pride to have it paid for me and would have said no but let’s make a plan to save together.

It seems way to soon though for the children to be mixing as you’re barely dating.

feelingmehtoday · 29/07/2021 08:35

I think it's a really kind gesture. I did similar a few months after DP and I met (no kids involved, just a holiday for the two of us, and at a third of the costs you describe) - but similar idea. I was the higher earner and I wanted us to go on holiday so I paid for it all. I saw a future for us though. 6 years later we are still together with a baby, and he now earns a similar amount to me and contributes equally. I went with my gut about the future of the relationship and the type of person he was, essentially. Not sure if that helps.

pixietinkdust · 29/07/2021 08:34

Wow some of the comments on here are really far-fetched!

OP - only you knows if you are happy in your relationship, and from what I’ve read it sounds like you are. You introduced your children early… SO WHAT! Good for you and I’m glad that they’re all getting along and you’re now blending nicely, so many struggle with this. It sounds like you’ve been in a short but intense relationship ship and I completely understand that, my partner moved in with me before 6 months. We’re still very happily together now! He is also a high earner like you, although I make £60k myself so not quite as much disparity.

What’s right for you won’t be right for everyone else, and vice versa. YOU DO YOU.

Again I’m honestly not sure where some awful judgements come from about money, although it is a touchy subject. Your girlfriend is a nurse, one of the most honourable but tiring roles there is. She sounds perfectly lovely and is a full time parent to her child, she, and only she (in the absence of the other parent), got them this far. She sounds like the kind of person I’d want to be friend with!

Book your holiday, book wherever you want to go. Don’t let people tell you a £5k holiday is ridiculous, I like nice holidays to far away destinations and I imagine you’ll be going All Inclusive as it’s far easier with kids. If you can afford it, seriously just book it. Get rid of the worries about whether it’s reasonable, you can either afford it or you can’t. Sounds like you can and therefore as long as you’re happy to do so, I hope you all have a wonderful relaxing break ❤️

notanothertakeaway · 29/07/2021 08:31

@MrsTerryPratchett

I'd be more concerned that your children are so close after such a short relationship. They should barely have met, if at all.
I thought that too
jimmyjammy001 · 29/07/2021 08:25

Will she ever be able to pay for a holiday for her and her children in future? If not then you will likely be paying for years to come, if you don't live together will she be able to pay her own way if you move in together, these are all things to think about for the future and what you are happy to pay for to support someone else

kin432 · 29/07/2021 07:52

I think you sound a nice dad and boyfriend. Not sure about the comments on women who are high earners (although we were both high earners, I earned more than my husband when we had kids and I hope I didn't fall into the categories you mentioned...ouch!). I'd try to put the income disparity to one side as it doesn't sound as if she's taking advantage.

I don't think paying for her holiday is a huge deal. You're wanting to go somewhere nice that's beyond her means so I think it's the right thing to do. However, in your shoes, I'd go away separately with my kids in the first instance as I think it's nice for them to have 100% of your time given that it's a fairly new relationship. I'd then book a long weekend or whatever with everyone to see how it goes.

I'm a bit unsure about your comment that you don't want to be a parent to her child. I understand that a step-dad is a different role but it seems a bit as if you're happy for her to be very involved in your kids' lives but wouldn't be happy to do the same. I may have misinterpreted what you wrote, in which case, apologies.

Farwest · 29/07/2021 07:49

Your friends are concerned about money. About you being taken advantage of, about how you'll feel if you spend £2k to take gf and her dc on holiday and then she breaks up with you next month. Is that right? (I have RTFT but am not clear on their objections.)

Well, you are an adult. You know she might break up with you at any time for any reason. You're not investing the money to pay off later (to make her stay with you), you are paying because you would like to go on holiday with her and the extra £2k is not an amount that affects your finances. Being generous is a virtue and not a fault, up to a point. And you're a long way off that point.

So my simple answer would be: don't overthink what is a non-issue for you. Pay for the holiday. Enjoy the holiday. Let her get in a round of ice creams or beers now and again. Have fun.

The bigger issue is money in your relationship, and at some point you and she will need to sort that out between you. You don't mention any desire to, but clearly marriage would be ill-advised: you have two children and their future and inheritence, etc, to think about, and how a long-off maybe divorce would affect your assets. At that point, it really is possible to be 'too generous'. If you decide to live together down the line, how would that work so that it takes some financial pressure off your longterm, much-loved partner but does not disadvantage you overmuch. Anyway, all that is the stuff for later.

But a holiday? Even a fairly pricey one? No problem. Do it. Hope you all have a great time.