Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People treating you differently when you’re larger- ignorant or offensive?

59 replies

Flawedperfection · 28/07/2021 22:46

I’m very fat at the moment. I used to be slim and was anorexic as a teen briefly. Now I struggle to stop eating and that is why I am the size I am. As a non-smoker, teetotal no-drug taker, I like to cook and eat.
Anyway, I’m interested if other people have this from others. So, the most troubling is men seem to be scared of talking to me, as if I’m going to fancy them and want to go out with them (I really don’t), and I thought maybe my gratitude for them being kind and polite (and not being rude about my weight) translated somehow into apparent desperation in some way? When I talk to men (irl, work etc) they seem fine then look scared and start to back off when the chat grows more animated.
Im thinking of getting a tshirt that says: “Don’t worry, I certainly do NOT fancy you- you’re safe, honest!”
Also, people assume that as a fatty (my mother’s words, not mine) I a.) eat bad stuff all the time (I actually eat healthily, just way too much, b.) I never exercise (also untrue), c.) I should be the life and soul (I’m not, I am depressed with many phobias and issues), and d.) I won’t want to/don’t have the right to dress nicely and/or be into hair/makeup- erm, why wouldn’t I?!
AIBU to think this way of thinking is fucked up? For the record, us larger ladies might like to make an effort with our appearance, might be quieter, may eat healthily and be fit and active. And lastly, we do not necessarily fancy every bloke who talks to us and be “grateful” for their attention!

OP posts:
Catflapkitkat · 29/07/2021 12:18

I believe that when you fat you either overlooked or despised because people think they will 'catch' fat. I agree with OP people do make judgements. I also think some believe it to be a 'social indicator'.

In the early 90s when Roseanne was one of the most popular shows on television, my mother refused to watch because they were 'too fat'. My ex boss (slim sporty female) once saw a photo of me 'fat' and said she would never have employed if I had been 'that way'. That makes her sound horrible but she was a great person to work with but she was very weight conscious and I think she saw being fat as a weakness.

I most definitely had more attention when slimmer - not talking male attention (believe it doesn't matter to certain men as much as we think it does) but from slimmer women.

caughtinanet · 29/07/2021 12:11

@Hoppinggreen

Are you very fat though? As a former anorexic you may have a skewed perspective

I am genuinely fat - size 16 and I don’t recognise any of the things you describe but we do all have different experiences

Do you have a skewed perspective?

While a size 16 isn't skinny I certainly wouldn't call that fat, overweight yes but not going to experience the sort of negative things the OP is talking about unless they work with runway models surely.

Hodessa · 29/07/2021 11:56

I'm pretty fat (5'2" and a size 18-20), and although my fragile ego doesn't really enjoy being completely invisible to the rest of the human race, I don't think I've experienced any of this directly!

I have the kind of face that makes strangers want to tell me their life story, but nobody wants to chat me up anymore. Ah well.

I'm more worried that I don't get taken seriously at work. With an even greater pang of disappointment that my boss is twice the size of me but is a man, so he can get on all the key committees and leadership teams with his Metallica t-shirt and many years less management experience than me.

Bitter, moi!

fat13 · 29/07/2021 11:46

When I was at university I remember dancing in a group with mixed boys and girls and it was one of those songs where everyone put their arms around the person next to them and swayed round.

The boy next to me jumped back and shouted NO. You stay there at me. Hmm

Fuuuuuck me that hurt!

BeatieBourke · 29/07/2021 11:44

You are not wrong OP. I used to be a size 8-10. Since surgical menopause at 32 I put on a bunch of weight. The pandemic hasn't helped. I'm now 13 stone and a size 16-18.

The truth is some people value thinness over any other accomplishment or achievement (often when it is neither). In the years since I put on weight I've achieved more than I have in any other time of my life, but people seem to regard me as somehow failing at life because I'm fat. They also assume that my fatness is due to laziness, and that were they me they would not be fat. I cook and eat very healthily, have little processed food, I just eat too much (a slow habit that's grown over time since meeting DH, I match his portions and he's a man who does a very physically demanding job all day) and my metabism is screwed.

People suggest that losing weight is the solution to this problem. While I might want to.lose weight for other reasons, even if I woke up a size 8 tomorrow, I would still know that certain friends and family members only value me so highly when I'm thin, and I would therefore still think they are dickheads.

Iwonder08 · 29/07/2021 11:42

I think it might be in your head. Men don't assume you fancy th just because your are polite and friendly

Hoppinggreen · 29/07/2021 11:35

Are you very fat though?
As a former anorexic you may have a skewed perspective

I am genuinely fat - size 16 and I don’t recognise any of the things you describe but we do all have different experiences

Kalvinette · 29/07/2021 11:33

That's fine and point taken but I don't know what's up with your third sentence. I drink, smoke, occasionally take drugs, and also like to cook and eat

Flawedperfection · 29/07/2021 11:27

Oh, and that we “fatties” will automatically sweat bucketloads at the mention of any physical exertion and will smell of BO just like that (again, not always, and actually the only person I’ve met with a real BO problem was v slim!).

OP posts: