Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People treating you differently when you’re larger- ignorant or offensive?

59 replies

Flawedperfection · 28/07/2021 22:46

I’m very fat at the moment. I used to be slim and was anorexic as a teen briefly. Now I struggle to stop eating and that is why I am the size I am. As a non-smoker, teetotal no-drug taker, I like to cook and eat.
Anyway, I’m interested if other people have this from others. So, the most troubling is men seem to be scared of talking to me, as if I’m going to fancy them and want to go out with them (I really don’t), and I thought maybe my gratitude for them being kind and polite (and not being rude about my weight) translated somehow into apparent desperation in some way? When I talk to men (irl, work etc) they seem fine then look scared and start to back off when the chat grows more animated.
Im thinking of getting a tshirt that says: “Don’t worry, I certainly do NOT fancy you- you’re safe, honest!”
Also, people assume that as a fatty (my mother’s words, not mine) I a.) eat bad stuff all the time (I actually eat healthily, just way too much, b.) I never exercise (also untrue), c.) I should be the life and soul (I’m not, I am depressed with many phobias and issues), and d.) I won’t want to/don’t have the right to dress nicely and/or be into hair/makeup- erm, why wouldn’t I?!
AIBU to think this way of thinking is fucked up? For the record, us larger ladies might like to make an effort with our appearance, might be quieter, may eat healthily and be fit and active. And lastly, we do not necessarily fancy every bloke who talks to us and be “grateful” for their attention!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
princesspenny · 30/07/2021 15:31

I was very heavy for 15 years in my 20s and 30s, size 24/26. Went down to a 12 for about 2 years now I've crept up to a 16 and settled there.

I don't identify with anything you've said in your OP about people's behaviour towards me, especially men. If anything I had a lot more romantic attention from men when I was larger (although this could've been because I was younger also)

MarianneUnfaithful · 30/07/2021 15:24

Women in general are objectified and subjected to stereotyping and prejudice. The further you get from the supposed ideal Instagrammable woman the worse it gets.

Don’t worry OP, Once you hit 45 /50 ish no one will notice you at all. They will be happy to chat but will expect check versa Tim that they fondly imagine is in ‘old dear’ category, abd on MN it will be assumed that all your thinking is of ‘that generation’, probably racist and homophobic and definitely transphobic.

The stereotypes of larger women are depressing.

Somarefuser · 30/07/2021 15:22

@RincewindsHat

"men seem to be scared of talking to me, as if I’m going to fancy them and want to go out with them"

Yep. This. Anything more than a passing casual comment and a certain type of man seems to get terrified I am trying to make a move on them or something and you get the 'Not trying to be rude or anything but I'm not looking for a girlfriend...' or similar comments. Baffling because I was just being normal and friendly, I have zero romantic interest in you and was in no way flirting.

The flip side of which is being average weight and attractiveness and being unable to have a friendly conversation, or even a comment, without many blokes taking it as an expression of sexual interest and becoming a leery pita.
Demilunary · 30/07/2021 15:16

@JellyBabiesFan

Literally nobody thinks that. If someone thought that for ten seconds, someone like you would come along and make absolutely certain they realised they were a drain on the NHS, and on them personally via taxation

@DGFB
@Demilunary

Yes they do. Obese is not healthy and more often than not it will be a drain on the NHS.

So, who do you believe thinks obesity is healthy?
JellyBabiesFan · 30/07/2021 15:15

Literally nobody thinks that. If someone thought that for ten seconds, someone like you would come along and make absolutely certain they realised they were a drain on the NHS, and on them personally via taxation

@DGFB
@Demilunary

Yes they do. Obese is not healthy and more often than not it will be a drain on the NHS.

Backofbeyond50 · 30/07/2021 14:53

To answer the OP I have been pretty lucky with other people's responses to me. The only bad contact seem to be with Medical Professionals. In the last 5 years I have gone up and down in weight from just overweight to morbidly obese. Yes I probably had more compliments at my just overweight phase but not much.

Backofbeyond50 · 30/07/2021 14:49

i'm recruiting at the moments won't be employing anyone who is very overweight as the job is quite physical and i've already had to lose someone from the department due to them not being able to do the basics. theres no reasonable adjustments to be made either
Well as a nearly morbidly obese 50 year old I have just completed a physically demanding 8 hour working day.
I also do 50KM walks for fun. Very glad the people providing me with self employed work could see through my weight.
@gardeninggirl68

JustGiveMeGin · 30/07/2021 13:34

Comparing size is pointless, a size 16 on a 5'2 person and a 5'9 person is vastly different (even not taking into account body shape).
I have been 11st and 17st. I was definitely not as attractive to men at 17st however I don't feel I was generally treated differently. I have always been able to fake confidence even if I don't feel it so maybe that has a lot to do with it!

JustLyra · 30/07/2021 09:06

@Saggybaggyaggy

I was a size 24 and now a 10 and much more attractive physically. It's gross how differently people treat me now. Awful. I am the same person inside.
I find the same. I lost 8 stone and the number of pellets who suddenly respect my opinion and don’t automatically assume I’m thick is staggering.

Men don’t chat/flirt any more or less, but they’re considerably more respectful and polite when they do. They’ve lost the “she’s fat so she’ll be grateful for anything” mentality.

IveShaggedSomeMingers · 30/07/2021 08:32

My ex was overweight and I'm towards the lower end of the normal weight range.

Neither of us changed size but we had markedly different eating patterns.

He ate a lot of more fried food and would eat takeaways several times a week. He also drank more soft drinks and I rarely have them.

Men often pile on weight just before the first baby arrives. The mother and father end up eating for two.

We probably ate the same volume of food.

RightYesButNo · 30/07/2021 08:03

I believe that when you fat you either overlooked or despised because people think they will 'catch' fat.

And studies say they will. If your partner gains weight through unhealthy habits, you are more likely to become obese, says a study from Johns Hopkins. If your wife becomes obese, you (as a husband) are 78% more likely to become obese. If your husband becomes obese, you (as a wife) are 89% more likely to become obese. (I specify because same sex couples weren’t studied).
www.huffpost.com/entry/more-proof-that-marriage-may-make-you-far_n_56268054e4b0bce347026d21

And friends have a larger influence on your weight than family. If your friends are overweight, there is a 57% chance that you may become overweight, vs just 40% if a sibling is obese, and 37% is a spouse is a obese (the first study was if a normal weight spouse becomes obese and then if affecting the other spouse):
www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/friends-and-family-can-influence-your-weight/

BUT as the second article says, people can also catch “thin” which is why you may sometimes see very successful weight loss in couples or groups of friends who have decided to lose weight and change their habits together. This is when you start to get into the psychology of weight, yes.

But the thing is, no one should be cruel to anyone else about it, or make them feel shite about it, and that’s a fact. Making people feel “less than” does not magically cause weight loss. It causes heart break, low self esteem, and maybe various types of disordered eating. There are healthy ways to lose weight and trying to get someone to cry the fat out in their tears is NOT one of them.

Hoppinggreen · 30/07/2021 07:14

No caughtinanet I don’t have a skewed perspective.
I am fat, my BMI, my rolls of flab and my aching knees confirm this
OP has said she is a former anorexic so her “fat” may be very different to the general view - an anorexic friend of mine would consider herself fat when she was barely a healthy weight
You say you don’t consider a size 16 fat, well that’s what I am and believe me it’s not healthy

Persephoned · 29/07/2021 22:09

*Do you have a skewed perspective?

While a size 16 isn't skinny I certainly wouldn't call that fat, overweight yes but not going to experience the sort of negative things the OP is talking about unless they work with runway models surely.*

@caughtinanet I am a size 16 and my BMI is obese

OP - I haven’t been experienced a lot of what you describe, however I have also judged myself a lot. And I think the odd comment hits hard and can influence a position where it increases self doubt and worry too. Honestly my best advice is to be and feel confident, that makes you attractive. Apologies, I know that sounds trite but as someone a bit bigger I found making the choice to spend a bit more on clothes, find things I felt good in made a massive difference

Feel free to DM and good luck!

Bluntness100 · 29/07/2021 18:46

I’m a ten to a twelve and have been a 16/18 and I can honestly say I was not treated any differently. I wasn’t ever treated like I was stupid, men weren’t scared of me, and as far as I know, no one made assumptions about how much I ate or exercised, not in any way they’d remotely let me know anyway.

But my confidence levels never changed, I expected to be treated the same. To be treated well. And I was.

So for me, whatever is happening here isn’t universal.

Batsy · 29/07/2021 15:52

i'm a size 24, and i do find that people tend to act genuinly surprised when they find out i've a cutting wit, high intelligence, and am quite handy.

Take today... workmen in the house doing something, and i was keeping an eye on them, whilst also dealing with my DDs broken curtain rail.. fixing it back up... have my own tool kit, getting stuck in climbing on/shifting heavy furniture to get to it (and swearing whilst working) and they were kind of.. jokingly saying it was good seeing a woman 'getting stuck in'

Then they were having an issue with something, and i asked them what was wrong, thought about it, offered a suggestion none of them had thought of... and lo.. it worked (Sigh) and they appeared genuinely gobsmacked, then got more chatty and were pretty much flirting with me by the end of the job...i even got the offer of a phonenumber before they left Grin (i declined)

But really.. i get that attitude a lot, simply because of my outward appearence of being 'fat', I shouldn't NEED to have them see me 'getting stuck in' for them to think i'm worth acknowledging as an attractive female.

LittleGwyneth · 29/07/2021 15:41

I'm at 14-16 and I don't recognise any of this - I get chatted up a fair amount if I'm in a bar and wearing nice clothes (less so if I go to the corner shop in my dungarees and a massive jumper.)

It's impossible to know how much of this is in your head and how much you're experiencing genuine fat phobia from other people because we don't know whether you're a size 32 or a size 12 with dysmorphia.

Either way - I'm glad that as someone with a previous eating disorder you've been able to find joy from food. Some people never get there.

Saggybaggyaggy · 29/07/2021 15:28

I was a size 24 and now a 10 and much more attractive physically. It's gross how differently people treat me now. Awful. I am the same person inside.

Pinkmendinilla · 29/07/2021 15:27

I totally recognise this. I've been a 10-12 at my slimmest and 18-20 at my biggest, due to essential meds. I'm now a 14. At my biggest, I worked in a very macho environment, lots of ex army. I was treated like a bloody idiot. Nobody mentioned my weight to my face but I heard in passing comments about a woman in a wheelchair who was overweight. Stupid dismissive stuff about 'ooh I know why she's in that wheelchair' I.e. because she is fat. No, it's because she had MS. Slim women were treated perfectly well but I was patronised and snapped at, ignored for opportunities. It was horrible. I was fine at my job, so realised that fat= weak and weakness was despised in that environment. Thing is that I am sturdy and strong underneath all along so have never been physically weak in my life. I couldn't get out of there quick enough.

5128gap · 29/07/2021 15:22

[quote Flawedperfection]@ShadowInVain, I’m sure you’re not unattractive. Anyway, beauty is in the eye of the beholder and remember that beauty fades. I know a once gorgeous actress (who is still v attractive but really restricts to keep herself skinny. Well, it’s showing on her face now which looks tired, drawn and wrinkly, and she has various joint issues. She is late 50s now, but still using a headshot where she looks 24. Also her best roles are behind her now, but she freely admits how hard it is for a woman when she has had extreme beauty all her life only for it to fade. And to have nothing else of “value” in her profession.[/quote]
It's a shame you make that comment OP. Almost as though you are saying that old trumps fat in the undesirable stakes. You don't need to pay the negativity you get around weight forward to older women. In the same way beauty doesn't need to be thin, it doesn't need to be young either.

Demilunary · 29/07/2021 15:22

@DGFB

Yanbu of course. But there are also huge numbers of people in this country thinking being overweight or obese is healthy. It isn’t. And eventually that costs the country and the NHS money
Literally nobody thinks that. If someone thought that for ten seconds, someone like you would come along and make absolutely certain they realised they were a drain on the NHS, and on them personally via taxation.
5128gap · 29/07/2021 15:17

I was out at the weekend and the majority of women, of all ages, were overweight, with a very high number being what would be considered to be very fat. Far from shying away, men were giving the women a lot of attention. I suppose attitudes might vary by location and age range. This was a city in the Midlands with a largely 20-30 age group.

Flawedperfection · 29/07/2021 15:00

@ShadowInVain, I’m sure you’re not unattractive. Anyway, beauty is in the eye of the beholder and remember that beauty fades. I know a once gorgeous actress (who is still v attractive but really restricts to keep herself skinny. Well, it’s showing on her face now which looks tired, drawn and wrinkly, and she has various joint issues. She is late 50s now, but still using a headshot where she looks 24. Also her best roles are behind her now, but she freely admits how hard it is for a woman when she has had extreme beauty all her life only for it to fade. And to have nothing else of “value” in her profession.

OP posts:
ILoveShula · 29/07/2021 14:59

Size 16 is neither skinny or fat. It is the size of a garment.

rubyandbel · 29/07/2021 14:51

I think its pretty obvious that if someone is quite overweight that they are not eating a healthy balanced diet. Or if they are, far too much of it than their body needs. Myself included. Iv always been a 12 and been considered quite attractive by others. As I have entered my 40s I'm now an 18. I cant say I have been treated differently by anyone but I can say I feel very differently about myself. Almost a repulsion. The weight has slowed me down and aged me. My boobs are HUGE which I don't like.

Deloresabernathy · 29/07/2021 14:48

@DGFB

Yanbu of course. But there are also huge numbers of people in this country thinking being overweight or obese is healthy. It isn’t. And eventually that costs the country and the NHS money
I've been fat my entire life and only ever had to go to the doctors for contraception (FYI being fat does not get you pregnant) and to then give birth to my children. I did need two csections, but that was because I had two babies who wanted to come out diagonally (which again is not caused by being fat AFAIK).

But aye, you're thinner so you must know better.

I do think some people are afraid of catching fatness of fat people. Like I'm going to force feed people cake or something.

I also hate that people always assume I want to lose weight. Am I eating vegetables because I want to lose weight? Nah, I like them. I'm not going to lose weight having Five Guys for lunch? Well, aren't you a clever one?!