Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is a crazy reason to go to A&E?

156 replies

JemimaPyjamas · 28/07/2021 19:40

Bit of background; I am a (well controlled, no history of complications) Type 1 diabetic. I have had it for 40+ years and the medical assistance I have ever needed is minimal, and I have been at the same GP practice for 14 years.

I am not sure how, but I got a splinter in the end of my big toe. Not a massive splinter, or anything remotely dramatic, but it was hard to see the area where it was. I think I removed it, pretty sure, but the area was sore - probably as it's a very sensitive place - so I called the GP, apologetically, to ask if there was any chance someone could have a quick check to make sure it was okay. (I didn't have anyone else to ask, hence me pestering the GP which did seem like semi overkill in itself.)

I was told they'd call back and then got told that 'nobody at the surgery is prepared to check a wound of that nature in a diabetic and we have been told to tell you you need to go to A&E.' I reiterated that it was a double check, for something the size of a very small papercut, and it was purely precautionary rather than necessary.

I got the same reply.

Needless to say, I have not gone to A&E during a pandemic so someone could double check a splinter had gone from my toe. I have instead soaked it, felt it and double checked it and it seems fine.

AIBU to think the (quite large) surgery was bonkers...? Or

OP posts:
privateandnhsgp · 28/07/2021 22:21

It depends on what service the local CCG has commissioned. Often it's the district nurses, or a wound clinic in the community hospital. But in many/most areas GP surgeries pick this up because patients would suffer if they/we didn't.

But CCGs love it when GPs do this kind of stuff "for free". The GP surgery doesn't get paid anything extra, it comes out of Partners' income, and they don't have to bother commissioning a proper service.

MyriadeOfThings · 28/07/2021 22:20

I would have thought the OPs GP should have advised a walk in centre, minor injury unit over A&E though?!

I’m pretty sure the OP said there is no walk in centre. I would assume no minor injury clinic either.
In that case, where is she supposed to go bar A&E?

It very much feels like different services are playing pass the parcel until the situation is so critical one of them has to step up.

MyriadeOfThings · 28/07/2021 22:17

@privateandnhsgp that’s when there is a minor injury clinic where you live.

I don’t.

In that case, where do you go?

Because of A&E can’t see someone with a cat bit and GP don’t either, but there is no minor injury Clinic, there there is a huge gap in the care of people really.

MyriadeOfThings · 28/07/2021 22:15

@privateandnhsgp, I’m curious.
If GPs don’t do dressing for chronic issues such as leg ulcers, who is supposed to do it?

privateandnhsgp · 28/07/2021 22:15

[quote Libraryghost]@privateandnhsgp I visited a walk in centre for a cat bite and waited 4 hours to be seen only to be told walk in centres cannot hand out antibiotics. I ended up going A&E when it inevitably got horribly infected because I couldn't get a doctors appointment. A&E went absolutely wild and said it was a GP’s job. So my question is who was right? Classify bites for me please, where do you go?[/quote]
Minor injury - no question. So minor injuries unit, or ED (ED docs don't like the term A&E any more).

In general most hospital doctors have no idea what is in the GP contract or even that it exists (that's not a criticism, why would they?).

However what GPs should be doing is relatively well defined, it's been made worse by the fact that historically we've tripped over ourselves to help by doing anything and everything.

But it's time to stop, the £150 per year free for all has to end.

marmaladehound · 28/07/2021 22:15

Sidge

Thanks for that info. I am an ED charge nurse, I know we often refer people to practice nurses for follow up wound care, I know you are not a walk in service. Even though the GPs based in EDs everywhere are technically working as a walk in service.

It is all very confusing. Even when we have GPs in the department, what patient one GP will see, another won't! Tbh even after 22 years of nursing it's still all confusing at times!

I would have thought the OPs GP should have advised a walk in centre, minor injury unit over A&E though?!

MyriadeOfThings · 28/07/2021 22:14

@sidge, I don’t want to say but my surgery is allegedly also offering post operative wound care etc… they have no choice, hospitals don’t it.

But even before covid, they didn’t have the tools to do. And by that I mean simply an array of size of dressing to actually do the stitches removal and then covering them up again.
I’ve been told by the nurses to please go to the chemist to buy stuff for my child because they just don’t have the right sizes there. (The nurse was most apologetic about it too).

I haven’t seen anything yet that makes me say they are able to provide that sort of care appropriately :(

privateandnhsgp · 28/07/2021 22:09

@marmaladehound

There seems to be some debate about this. In general, acute wounds (not post op) that can be covered in a single appointment probably fall under the GMS contract. Chronic wounds do not, and GP practices are quite within their rights to decline dressing of things like leg ulcers - although of course in reality most practices undertake this work even if they don't have to.

There was some discussion of this issue here: www.lmc.org.uk/visageimages/guidance/2006/gpclegulcersanddistrictnursesmar06.doc

MyriadeOfThings · 28/07/2021 22:08

@cptartapp

I would class this as an emergency. GP surgeries are not emergency services. Ring them.
Aren’t they?

Do you mean that it’s ok to leave people wait for two weeks always or they need to go to A&E?

I think it’s bonkers. The role of the GPs is primary care, not chronic illness can wait a bit more care.
There are many instances where people can’t wait but aren’t A&E material. The case of the OP being one of them.

I appreciate that GPs are under strain and not coping atm. But the answer to not coping isn’t by reducing the type they are giving by stealth whilst hoping someone else, somewhere is going to pick up the pieces.

Sidge · 28/07/2021 22:04

I would not expect a GP to see this but I would expect a practice nurse to be able to do this.

Practice nurses are employed by the GPs (not the NHS) and are bound by their GP contract.

Of course they can do it, professionally speaking. But it is likely to be outwith their remit in terms of their surgery’s provision under their NHS contract terms.

There are lots of things I’m clinically professionally capable of but do not do as my employers are not contracted by the NHS to provide them!

It’s admittedly quite complicated.

@marmaladehound where I work we are contracted to provide wound care postoperatively for secondary care (eg surgical wounds, including clip and suture removal) and for chronic wounds such as leg ulcers. We also manage wounds that aren’t healing, or for follow up that might have been seen initially in MIU or ED. What we aren’t contracted to do is to provide minor injuries care. So no immediate lacerations, sprains, strains, suspected fractures, foreign bodies, eye or dental problems.

We also don’t provide emergency care for suspected strokes, hearts attacks, blood clots, bleeding emergencies, pregnancy related issues, trauma.

We are not a walk in service.

Libraryghost · 28/07/2021 22:03

@privateandnhsgp I visited a walk in centre for a cat bite and waited 4 hours to be seen only to be told walk in centres cannot hand out antibiotics. I ended up going A&E when it inevitably got horribly infected because I couldn't get a doctors appointment. A&E went absolutely wild and said it was a GP’s job. So my question is who was right? Classify bites for me please, where do you go?

AimingForSerenity · 28/07/2021 21:56

@cptartapp

Our four GP's are seeing patients every ten minutes, interspersed with telephone consultations, visiting care homes, home visits, etc. Their clinics are all full for at least two weeks. Some more. So even if they were all in today, again, no appointments soon enough. We are not a walk in service.
I work in a surgery but not a GP. Our doctors are all working at full capacity too, as are the nurse practitioners and others. We have a triage system so anyone who rings in the morning gets a call back from a clinician and is assessed if they need to be seen, signposted elsewhere or advised over the phone We do not do first aid or wound care but I suspect OP might get a routine appt for someone to check
Meltedwellie · 28/07/2021 21:54

I have a friend with diabetes. She had similar and didn’t realise how serious it was until she had sepsis. Had to have her foot amputated.

marmaladehound · 28/07/2021 21:53

@privateandnhsgp

"I would not expect a GP to see this but I would expect a practice nurse to be able to do this."

The GP contract covers GP practice nurse activity.

It doesn't matter what you expect, the service is NOT contracted to deliver this.

On a side note. Does the GP contract cover ongoing wound care for practice nurses? For either acute or chronic wounds?
PheasantsNest · 28/07/2021 21:51

My Auntie a diabetic lost her foot to a tiny cut that she left. Get it seen to.

privateandnhsgp · 28/07/2021 21:49

"I would not expect a GP to see this but I would expect a practice nurse to be able to do this."

The GP contract covers GP practice nurse activity.

It doesn't matter what you expect, the service is NOT contracted to deliver this.

JoborPlay · 28/07/2021 21:49

The issue is that type 1 diabetics are more likely to receive lower limb amputations due to small injuries (resulting in infection) than other groups. Type 1 diabetes causes nerve loss, with toes being the first to go.

Whilst you have well managed diabetes (well done you) you are still more likely to get a foot infection and that infection us more likely to cause long term damage.

I'd get it checked.

privateandnhsgp · 28/07/2021 21:47

@JemimaPyjamas

That's interesting. The GP contract isn't something aware of, and hopefully you can understand me not seeing the site if a probably removed splinter as a 'minor injury'! To me, it just seemed overkill for something that needed a minute of checking, literally just a minute, if that.
It's not your fault, in the past GP surgeries have happily taken on with that they didn't need to - for example undertaking blood tests, ecgs, post-op stitch removal etc - all NOT in the GP contract.

However things are 30pc busier than pre-pandemic, there are fewer GPs than a few years ago and the system is crumbling.

They're quite right to stick to delivering core contract.

marmaladehound · 28/07/2021 21:45

@privateandnhsgp

Your GP surgery isn't required or paid to review this kind of thing. They were right to decline and spend their time on something that they ARE contacted to do.

Minor injuries like this are NOT part of the national GP (GMS) contract.

Most of the people posting on this thread have no idea what they're talking about

I would not expect a GP to see this but I would expect a practice nurse to be able to do this.
KormasABitch · 28/07/2021 21:44

They're probably following a treatment pathway based on the risk of infections in T1D. A lot of things that would normally be covered by a surgery or practice nurse seem to be disrupted by all the COVID mayhem.

JemimaPyjamas · 28/07/2021 21:42

If something was then amiss I would, obviously, get it seen to but going somewhere other than the GP (and this includes, say, practise nurses) seemed like overkill and time wasting.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 28/07/2021 21:42

But a GP can't tell if it will become infected just by looking. They don't have magic powers.

Toddlerteaplease · 28/07/2021 21:42

My friend has had major problems in the past with his diabetic feet and nearly lost one. He recently got a tiny blister on it. His GP tried to get him into the diabetic foot clinic urgently. But was unable to, so sent him to A&E. they also referred him urgently. He finally got an appointment on the 2nd august. He e fed up seeing his own podiatrist privately. Fortunately it's now healed. But it's not the point. He needed to be seen in
A specialist clinic urgently not A&E!!

JemimaPyjamas · 28/07/2021 21:40

That's interesting. The GP contract isn't something aware of, and hopefully you can understand me not seeing the site if a probably removed splinter as a 'minor injury'! To me, it just seemed overkill for something that needed a minute of checking, literally just a minute, if that.

OP posts:
privateandnhsgp · 28/07/2021 21:37

Your GP surgery isn't required or paid to review this kind of thing. They were right to decline and spend their time on something that they ARE contacted to do.

Minor injuries like this are NOT part of the national GP (GMS) contract.

Most of the people posting on this thread have no idea what they're talking about

Swipe left for the next trending thread