Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I get out of niece/nephew duty?

92 replies

Pedalpushers · 28/07/2021 17:28

My issue goes like this:

I'm an only child, husband has a brother and a sister. DH and I have no kids, BIL and SIL have between them 2 nieces and a nephew. They range from 2 to 4 years old.

Whenever I go to their family events, my MIL is constantly encouraging the children to tag onto me. Telling them 'get Pedal to read you a story' 'ask Pedal to play' 'Pedal will take you outside for a walk' etc etc.

Thing is, nothing personal to the children who are perfectly nice, but I really don't much like kids, enjoy being around them or have any nurturing instinct. There is a reason I have none of my own after nearly a decade with my husband and frankly it irritates me that my MIL is pushing her grandchildren on me so heavily and their parents don't seem to notice or care. I do it, because I'm not heartless and wouldn't tell an excitable 2 year old bringing over their book to go away, but it just means I don't enjoy going around to my in laws.

The other thing, which my DH is aware of and actually mentioned to his mum, is that she doesn't do it to him, their biological uncle. Only me, the woman. He had a word with her in as lighthearted a way as possible but it backfired as she just laughed it off and insisted it was 'good practice'. She isn't the sort to change her behaviour.

AIBU? Are you expected to suck it up and look after inlaws kids at family events? I'm the youngest in my family so I'm not sure whether this is normal and I'm being precious and mean.

OP posts:
GoldBar · 28/07/2021 18:36

I'd laugh and say something like, "You know I'm not a kid fan MIL. Even Nephew/Niece, who I like better than most kids, I can only take for a couple of minutes max".

ScottyandWestie · 28/07/2021 18:17

Oh I really feel for you, my Sister is very similar. At any family event she comes through the front door with her two kids under five and is hands off until they leave. It's awful, now as a family we start to leave the room the kids are in as no one wants to be responsible for them.
I tried the read a story and direct the kid back to the parents but the parents have skin thicker than a Rhino, so they produce another book or toy and send the kids off again. I don't want to go round when I know they will be there.

Mamanyt · 28/07/2021 18:14

Oooooh...sounds like a serious case of Granny-Lust. You may have to have DH be very direct with Granny. He may have to be so direct as to say, "You know, we have decided not to have children, and forcing the issue with DW is only going to make this worse."

Sceptre86 · 28/07/2021 18:12

My mil used to do this every time her family friend came over with her two kids. She saw it as a way of giving the family friend a break and showing me how great kids are in the hope it would encourage me to procreate, if anything it turned me off. My sil had a son by that point so she was exempt from taking care of them but I would get lumbered. My mil is a lovely women in most regards so I told her directly that I had no desire to babysit anyone else's children on a regular basis and if I did want to spend that much time with children I would have my own. I have two, expecting my 3rd and would never just dump my kids on someone else!

Notaroadrunner · 28/07/2021 18:11

YANBU. Swearing in their company would probably be a good way to avoid them being placed anywhere near you. Otherwise just tell Dh to read the story/play and you walk to the other side of the room or go to the loo or take out your phone. A few times of Dh having the kids foisted on him and I'm sure he'll be very firm in telling his family to back off. You could always cut back on attending the family events too. No need for you to go unless you actually really want to.

WhereYouLeftIt · 28/07/2021 18:10

"she just laughed it off and insisted it was 'good practice'"

Good practice? So she thinks (hopes) you're going to be having children? And probably even if you told her that you weren't, it wouldn't change anything; she'd just change the excuse to 'the parents need a break' or 'it takes a village' or 'it's faaaam-lyGrin'.

I'd just redirect them to your husband or back to granny. If she ever had the guts to speak to you directly about it (I'm guessing she hasn't so far?) I'd be straight and tell her you find it very odd that she expects you to give a fuck tend to children when you have no interest in them and you'd like her to stop.

If you don

FourTeaFallOut · 28/07/2021 18:10

Next time the two year 9ld comes over with a book say you have a better idea and upend some saucepans and give them a wooden spoon or anything as annoying as fuck so that you quickly become the last person anyone asks.

Howshouldibehave · 28/07/2021 18:06

@TheAwfuITruth

Your DH just needs to tell her more firmly.

'I know you laughed it off last time, but seriously mother- stop sending the kids to Pedal'

This.

Do they know you don’t want kids?

Applesandpears23 · 28/07/2021 18:03

Can you swear in a foreign language? Teach them.

BareGrylls · 28/07/2021 18:02

I fully understand how annoying it must be -I had the same issue years ago. Does she actually know you don't plan to have children? You might say it's none of her business but if she genuinely thinks her son is going to have a family maybe he should explain to her?

mbosnz · 28/07/2021 18:01

I got this with my great nieces and nephews, and I'd more than done my duty with their parents. I tended to pick them up, find their parents, plonk them in their arms or laps, and say, 'I think this belongs to you' - and then return to my conversation and drink.

Applesandpears23 · 28/07/2021 18:00

My Mum’s friend got out a collection of lighters when we were tiny and tried to teach us how they work. My parents never asked her to babysit again. I am now wondering if it was intentional.

Sapnupuas · 28/07/2021 17:59

@SpongebobNoPants

Just for context I have 2 children & 2 SCs ranging in age from 6-16 years old… my brother tries to pull this shit with me with my nephews… “Oh what’s one more to look after tonight, you’ve already got 4!” Or “Me & wife are tired, yours are older can you look after baby whilst we eat?”

I just laugh and tell him to fuck off 😂😂

I try this with my brother all the time.

Never works 🤣

MoiraNotRuby · 28/07/2021 17:58

"Oh yes let's do some drawing, I've got a sharpie here.

Shall we draw tattoos?

Oh bollocks thats gonna stain your arm."

Then let them sip from your wine glass (put water it in though!)

VariantL1130 · 28/07/2021 17:58

She is trying to get you to think that children are wonderful and you can't possibly live without them. As far as she is concerned, her grandchildren are adorable and anyone who spends time with them will want a child of their own.

My MIL used to do the same with me. I'd literally get a baby thrust into my arms. I'd sit there awkwardly until the sprog cried and then immediately hand it back.

I actually have my own kids now, nothing to do with MLS's efforts, but I still don't like other people's children. Funnily enough, MIL shows very little interest in my kids. She just wanted the status that comes with being able to say I have "x" amount of kids I think.

Anyway, every time it happens I'd just kindly tell the child that you can't help right now and to ask someone else. Kids are resilient, they won't suffer any long term mental distress if you don't read to them.

PivotPivotPivottt · 28/07/2021 17:56

@SpongebobNoPants

Just for context I have 2 children & 2 SCs ranging in age from 6-16 years old… my brother tries to pull this shit with me with my nephews… “Oh what’s one more to look after tonight, you’ve already got 4!” Or “Me & wife are tired, yours are older can you look after baby whilst we eat?”

I just laugh and tell him to fuck off 😂😂

This reminds me of when I was an exhausted single parent to a 5 year old and newborn and my cousin who lives away was up for the week to see his then 6 year old daughter. He managed to palm her off on me for a few hours and when he came to pick her up said to me "you could keep her for me tonight and give me a break" ShockAngry. I was like the walking dead! She did not stay over night.

This would really annoy me and I can see why you don't enjoy going to family events.

Chloemol · 28/07/2021 17:56

YANBU. I don’t particularly like kids, if they are foisted on me against my will I simply wait a minute or two, then send them back to parents, grandparents etc

I think perhaps it’s time for a chat with mil along the lines of if I want to interact with the kids I will do, please don’t offer my services in the meantime. If she continues bat it back, ‘oh no mil you read the story,play, go for a walk, after all as their grandmother I am sure you want to so end as much time with them as you can
‘ and walk away

UndeadSlut · 28/07/2021 17:54

If she says about "good practice" again, ask her "good practice for what? We are choosing not to have children" and see what she says. I'm assuming she knows this and isn't waiting for an announcement any day? Again though, this is really a DH job.

Pedalpushers · 28/07/2021 17:52

@chickenninja best answer yet I think? Now what could that be...

OP posts:
Tulips15 · 28/07/2021 17:52

She clearly hopes by doing what she is, It will make you ' want' your own DC.

I would straight up tell her ' I am not the designated babysitter at this event'.
I would also ask her to stop asking tbh.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 28/07/2021 17:49

It sounds like a passive aggressive way of commenting on your childlessness for sure.

My sister is very passive aggressive with me about my niece but its a very different set of circumstances to this, but my sympathies to you Thanks

Deflect with PERHAPS UNCLE DAVID MIGHT LIKE A WALK

or

I KNOW UNCLE DAVID HAS NEVER HEARD THIS STORY

or even

AUNTIE SUZI CANT PLAY TODAY ITS HER DAY OFF GRANNY CAN TAKE YOU OUTSIDE

Be more assertive.

TheAwfuITruth · 28/07/2021 17:49

Your DH just needs to tell her more firmly.

'I know you laughed it off last time, but seriously mother- stop sending the kids to Pedal'

Zealois · 28/07/2021 17:49

This happens in my family a little but I guess for different reasons. I end up being defaulted to watch the kids because I don't have any yet and the parents want a break. Sometimes I don't mind but the last time I really wanted to relax myself so I just started directing the kids back to their parents/grandparents, and if anyone asked me "where is X child?" I would just shrug.

chickenninja · 28/07/2021 17:48

Do something really dangerous and weird so that nobody will trust you to look after the kids Grin

Enough4me · 28/07/2021 17:47

I have secondary aged DCs, but quite honestly would not want it assumed that I would be desperate to entertain other young DC.

The way your MIL foists this on you and not her son is making me silently rage.

To break this everytime she says it say "no uncle ... wants to do it", have an agreement that he will do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread