Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Homeopathy vs home remedies

142 replies

suspiria777 · 28/07/2021 16:14

After a long time reading on MN and elsewhere, and just general chats to people at work or at weddings or whatever, I've come to the conclusion that a significant proportion of people don't really understand what homeopathy is, and think of it as roughly synonymous with 'natural medicine' or 'home remedies'.

Am i mistaken?

I can't think what else would explain the large proportion of otherwise seemingly sensible people who discuss homeopathy as if it actually has good scientific evidence base. Surely people don't back it if they realise it is just water and woo woo?

What do you think?

OP posts:
DewDew83 · 29/07/2021 01:49

@Flyingantday
Calling parents of dead children f*ing idiots?
Yes. We're talking about people who have been jailed for the manslaughter of their children, having failed to seek actual medical treatment for easily treatable conditions.

I think 'fucking idiots' was fairly generous in the circumstances.

WolfFleeceSpotter · 29/07/2021 01:24

Here is a handy guide on how it works for those who are unsure of the “science”.
crispian-jago.blogspot.com/2009/09/if-homeopathy-works-ill-drink-my-own.html?m=1

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/07/2021 01:20

I’ve taken homeopathic remedies for years. Sometimes they help and sometimes they don’t.

What you mean is sometimes you get better and sometimes you don't. You know, like you would anyway.

SarahAndQuack · 29/07/2021 01:04

There are areas of science which haven’t been totally proved yet, I think black holes are one. I just think that in time homeopathy will probably be proven. It’s just not happened yet. So I remain open minded. And if it’s a placebo that works for some, fine.

No area of science has been proved. How could it be? Science isn't amenable to proof, and that has nothing to do with the placebo effect (which, demonstrably, works) or homeopathy (which, demonstrably, doesn't).

SarahAndQuack · 29/07/2021 01:02

*I’ve taken homeopathic remedies for years. Sometimes they help and sometimes they don’t.

Just because I don’t understand it doesn’t mean it isn’t real.

I don’t understand quantum physics. Yet that’s real. Look it up on Wikipedia and see if your mind is blown by what appears to be utter fantasy nonsense. How anyone could believe that is beyond me. Yet it’s real. Even though it seems barking mad.*

Um ... do you not realise that many people do understand quantum physics? You may not. Personally, I don't understand how my washing machine works. I don't presume that means it is 'utter fantasy nonsense'. I just accept I'm a bit thick when it comes to washing machine plumbing. Maybe you need to take the same approach?

taliopolis · 29/07/2021 00:51

@Elieza if you were sufficiently interested to look it up, you'd find that all the scientific studies done have shown that homeopathy is completely ineffective, except maybe for the placebo effect. That's not because science hasn't discovered the effectiveness yet, or doesn't understand it. It's because it's true.

Elieza · 29/07/2021 00:06

@Quarantino
You seem to think I’m some kind of fuckwit that hands over bank details just because I am open minded! Really!?

There are areas of science which haven’t been totally proved yet, I think black holes are one. I just think that in time homeopathy will probably be proven. It’s just not happened yet. So I remain open minded. And if it’s a placebo that works for some, fine.

Quantum physics can be presumably proved by boffins NOW. Back in the day when everyone KNEW the Earth was flat, this was not the case.

Everything has a frequency. Everything vibrates at its own frequency. That’s why they put quartz in quartz watches, to help regulate the time, apparently.

So presumably, although the remedy has been diluted, some of that must remain. Either that or the whole ‘water has memory’ thing. I don’t know. I’m not sufficiently interested to look it up to be honest.

All I’m saying is that if I don’t understand something I don’t write it off. Especially if some people benefit.

Gilead · 28/07/2021 23:52

Anyone advertising as a homeopathic doctor MUST have a standard medicine degree on top of homeopathy training.
This is absolutely untrue. I can water it down if you like; utter bollocks.

Quarantino · 28/07/2021 23:36

So I’ve come to the conclusion that sometimes weird stuff that doesn’t make sense is real. And I remain open minded to stuff that hasn’t yet been proved. It may only be a matter of time before it is.

Would you like some free money? I can't explain how it'll work, but it does involve you giving me your credit card details. Keep an open mind! I can prove it ... later...

The thing about quantum physics is that the people studying it can tell you how it works. It doesn't involve particles being sentient and having memories.

Do you believe that if you looked at a homeopathic remedy for hayfever under an appropriately strong microscope it would look different from a remedy for bruises? Do you at least acknowledge there is no difference between them (because there is no ingredient present)?

Proudboomer · 28/07/2021 23:33

A few years ago I used to follow someone on you tube called Christine Newman. She was diagnosed with triple negative breast cancer a very a aggressive form of cancer after surgery and a lymph node resection she was told she needed 6 months of chemo and radiation.
She refused these as she said she could cut herself naturally. Her doctors and even her herbalists told her she would die without the chemo but still she refused.
She latter put up a video of how much she regretted this decision and she started on chemo but by the time she came to this point it was to late and even with the chemo she died a storm time later leaving a young daughter and husband.
There is no saying if the chemo would have saved her life had she started it chemo after surgery as her doctors wanted but the survival rate without treatment is nil and the 5 year survival rate with is over 50%.
Her videos are still on YouTube and here she pretty much signs her own death certificate

Elieza · 28/07/2021 23:31

I’ve taken homeopathic remedies for years. Sometimes they help and sometimes they don’t.

Just because I don’t understand it doesn’t mean it isn’t real.

I don’t understand quantum physics. Yet that’s real. Look it up on Wikipedia and see if your mind is blown by what appears to be utter fantasy nonsense. How anyone could believe that is beyond me. Yet it’s real. Even though it seems barking mad.

So I’ve come to the conclusion that sometimes weird stuff that doesn’t make sense is real. And I remain open minded to stuff that hasn’t yet been proved. It may only be a matter of time before it is.

And the other thing to consider is that drug companies don’t invest in homeopathic trials as these meds are not new so there’s no profit in them for a drug company to make so they don’t invest in them. So perhaps that’s why there are no studies that prove the efficacy of homeopathic medicine. Yet. Perhaps one day though. I remain open minded. If they help people whose symptoms have been failed by conventional medicine then that’s good.

Acupuncture IS scientifically proven and in regular use in GP surgeries nowadays. It has a good track record with pain and women’s reproductive systems.

Quarantino · 28/07/2021 23:17

@BoreOfWhabylon

I posted this years ago on this thread

This is reminding me of the Young Earth Creationist threads.

What is really exercising me though is not so much the worried well throwing away their money on sugar pills remembering water which remembered something else; it is the obscene way this garbage is being touted in African countries as a CURE for malaria, HIV, TB and infant diarrhoea www.theguardian.com/science/2009/jun/01/world-health-organisation-homeopathy-hiv
It is criminal, in my opinion, and yet it s being promoted and supported by homeopathic communities in this country.

Don't forget the shitshow when Neal's Yard were promoting a homeopathic malaria treatment then refused to take part in a web chat because participants made it clear they were going to ask about it and obviously they couldn't defend it. www.theguardian.com/environment/ethicallivingblog/2009/may/28/neals-yard-remedies-pr

12 years on and I haven't bought anything from them since.

Flyingantday · 28/07/2021 23:14

Calling parents of dead children f*ing idiots?

Maireas · 28/07/2021 23:10

What name calling? People are discussing the topic without calling each other names?

Flyingantday · 28/07/2021 23:08

@WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld

That domestic abuse article is terrifying. How scary the claim that they can treat MH conditions and use sugar pills for the abuser and the abusedSad I think homeopathic vets should be banned. If an adult wants to take a placebo fine but it's cruel to deny pets proper treatment
I’m still not convinced myself…. But I have a friend who is a human/veterinary homeopath. She is no-nonsense, scientific, and an excellent vet. She would never give homeopathy instead of a conventional medicine when needed, she is not an antivaxxer or anything like that, she does not push the alternative medicine but sometimes uses it in a complementary/adjunctive way.

She made a remedy for me once which I think helped despite my pessimism - although probably placebo. What I do like is the holistic approach that practitioners take, particularly taking into account previous trauma and mental health into picture - not just ailing body parts.

I would agree the nhs should not fund unproven treatment while NICE recommend proven treatments which are turned down on cost grounds.

It is a shame to see so much name calling on this thread though.

Pinchoftums · 28/07/2021 23:07

@gingerandsmall please don't equate homeopathy (load of bollocks completely discredited by RCTs) and acupuncture (sounds like bollocks but actually works and has been clinically proven for lots of things including migraine, osteoarthritis of the knee, chronic pain, and some other stuff I can't be arsed to check right now). Otherwise you will sound as silly as your professor.

Maireas · 28/07/2021 23:02

Why on earth would a person with a medical degree then undertake training to be a homeopath? How is that compatible?

Maireas · 28/07/2021 23:01

A small bottle of hayfever remedy tablets cost £10. Not cheap.

toconclude · 28/07/2021 22:58

People find reasons to believe in a lot of stuff that isn't true. And other people are eager to take their money. Put em together and...

BoreOfWhabylon · 28/07/2021 22:52

I posted this years ago on this thread

This is reminding me of the Young Earth Creationist threads.

What is really exercising me though is not so much the worried well throwing away their money on sugar pills remembering water which remembered something else; it is the obscene way this garbage is being touted in African countries as a CURE for malaria, HIV, TB and infant diarrhoea www.theguardian.com/science/2009/jun/01/world-health-organisation-homeopathy-hiv
It is criminal, in my opinion, and yet it s being promoted and supported by homeopathic communities in this country.

StillWeRise · 28/07/2021 22:48

the remedies may be cheap but the consultations aren't

midlander88 · 28/07/2021 22:43

To be fair the posts on here are pretty dismissive of a hugely established form of medicine that is still common in India, Germany, Italy, Greece, France... and even here actually.

Anyone advertising as a homeopathic doctor MUST have a standard medicine degree on top of homeopathy training.

And 'like for like' doesn't mean something that looks like an ear will treat ear infections. It means treating with a substance that would cause a body reaction similar to your symptoms in a minute dose.

Considering a typical homeopathic remedy costs about £7 for a full course of treatment, I don't know why people get so worked up about it being a danger to society. Especially in those news stories where someone says they turned to it when they were put on end of life care by the NHS and the conclusion is something like "even if they're not forgoing standard treatment, they are still being conned out of their money!"

One of the main homeopathic remedy producers in the UK still accepts payment in POSTAGE STAMPS, ala The Office. Hardly in it for the big bucks

StillWeRise · 28/07/2021 22:39

@TestingTestingWonTooFree

You're forgetting that, while there may well be 1,800 studies demonstrating that homeopathy does not work, if just one finds that it DOES work, at that sort of dilution homeopathy will be extremely powerful and effective. Grin

Presumably if water had memory we may as well just drink piss.

you forgot about the sucussing
StillWeRise · 28/07/2021 22:37

@DewDew83

OchonAgusOchonOh You're forgetting that, while there may well be 1,800 studies demonstrating that homeopathy does not work, if just one finds that it DOES work, at that sort of dilution homeopathy will be extremely powerful and effective.
this is genius
BoreOfWhabylon · 28/07/2021 22:35

Even if the magic water memory thing were true, how does dripping the magic water onto a sugar pill, which then dries out, pass the memory into the pill?

And as for harmless
whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html

Swipe left for the next trending thread