Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Homeopathy vs home remedies

142 replies

suspiria777 · 28/07/2021 16:14

After a long time reading on MN and elsewhere, and just general chats to people at work or at weddings or whatever, I've come to the conclusion that a significant proportion of people don't really understand what homeopathy is, and think of it as roughly synonymous with 'natural medicine' or 'home remedies'.

Am i mistaken?

I can't think what else would explain the large proportion of otherwise seemingly sensible people who discuss homeopathy as if it actually has good scientific evidence base. Surely people don't back it if they realise it is just water and woo woo?

What do you think?

OP posts:
Helendee · 29/07/2021 11:30

@thatonehasalittlecar

So you think now.
😄😄

thatonehasalittlecar · 29/07/2021 11:26

@Helendee

Being an antivaxxer is as dumb as believing in magic water.

The covid vaccine is neither untested nor ineffective.

Helendee · 29/07/2021 11:20

@taliopolis

Yet the NHS is bullying people into having barely tested and seemingly ineffective ‘vaccines’ en masse! 😏

suspiria777 · 29/07/2021 10:53

[quote Helendee]@MissTrip82

What nonsense!
He actually saw patients for homeopathy through the NHS and worked at the homeopathic hospital here in Bristol.
He was an excellent doctor.[/quote]
I mean... Harold Shipman actually saw patients trough the NHS and was for a long time regarded as an excellent doctor.

Homeopathy is not a valid medical treatment, and any benefits it has are caused by chance, the natural history of the ailment (i.e. it was going to get better anyway, e.g. a cold) or the placebo effect.

OP posts:
taliopolis · 29/07/2021 10:48

[quote Helendee]@MissTrip82

What nonsense!
He actually saw patients for homeopathy through the NHS and worked at the homeopathic hospital here in Bristol.
He was an excellent doctor.[/quote]
And the NHS no longer funds homeopathy because there is no evidence to show that its effective. So he wouldn't be practicing homeopathy through the NHS now

Flyingantday · 29/07/2021 10:20

I personally think the big distinction lies not with the “medicine” itself… lots of people put trust in lots of things with no scientific basis - whether it’s rubbing mustard on the soles of your feet, mama’s chicken soup or faith based healing such as reike or laying on of hands etc. I do wonder if it is partly the comfort/sense of doing something/stress reduction element that helps people (or reduces the neuroticism of pet owners in that case).

The problem comes when people reject or are advised to reject appropriate proven treatment from qualified medical professionals and go with unproven or inappropriate treatment. This could be “woo” stuff, it could be trying to cure cancer with a paleo diet. It could even involve legitimate treatments which could turn out to be harmful in the wrong usage (eg deep tissue massage in a lymphoma patient).

There are also vulnerable, frightened or ill informed patients/parents/owners who may be suspicious of conventional medicine (eg vaccines, chemo) and would happily latch on to anyone who says - you don’t need that treatment… a b12 supplement and sprinkling lavender oil at midnight works just as well. Until you catch rabies or your cancer spreads.

So I guess this is where the responsibility of the homeopath comes in, it presumably comes very much down to their morals/ethics. Similar to a plastic surgeon who has to navigate the ethics of counselling patients for/against procedures while taking their money. I think a qualified doctor or vet who rejects the basic tenets of evidence based medicine in favour of alternative/woo stuff is not fit to practice. Or who persuades a patient to do one thing against the evidence that another course of treatment would be better. But as an example, the homeopath I know is more likely to take the view… “the homeopathy may help with tension headaches but you need antibiotics for your skin infection.”

There are a lot of unregulated health industries operating, beauticians injecting fillers and nutritionists downloading internet doctorates. I suppose having qualified doctors/vets performing homeopathy does give it more perceived efficacy, but it does also mean practitioners are accountable to professional standards/GMC/RCVS.

Helendee · 29/07/2021 09:17

@MissTrip82

What nonsense!
He actually saw patients for homeopathy through the NHS and worked at the homeopathic hospital here in Bristol.
He was an excellent doctor.

Maireas · 29/07/2021 09:13

@Parttimemostofthetime

A friend of mine child has had severe eczema for years and tried everything from the gp. Homeopathy has improved the skin so much. I never believed in it but I have seen the difference it has made to this child
My child grew out of it. In just a couple of years it was gone. No homeopathy.
Ponoka7 · 29/07/2021 09:01

@Patapouf, arnica, like aloe vera is herbal. It's important that a distinction is made. How we develop some medicines is by looking at the properties of plants and then recreating that in the lab. That way we can used a concentrated or cheaper, easier to get version than directly using plants. Herbal remedies do work and taking in those properties via our diet is nutrition, which is important.

The taking the piss out of willow earlier in the thread was insulting to indigenous people. Say exactly what you mean. Smoking is used as a way of cleansing because when water is short it kills the bacteria on the skin. Some tribes didn't wash with water, they used and still use, smoking.

knittingaddict · 29/07/2021 08:28

Yes arnica is herbal.

Homeopathy is basically water at exorbitant prices. Money for old rope.

Patapouf · 29/07/2021 08:22

So is arnica homeopathic or herbal? The latter right?

I thought homeopathic meant herbal remedies like chamomile or arnica etc in the form of a cream/paste or those teeny tiny sugar pills. Is homeopathy something different? I've never heard of diluted water ShockShock

FunnyWonder · 29/07/2021 08:16

@TriciaMcMillan that Dara O'Briain clip nails it. Brilliant!

Ponoka7 · 29/07/2021 08:16

@Parttimemostofthetime, what does she use? Is it homeopathic or herbal?

My sister bangs on about homeopathy on the basis that the Queen swears by it and it has the approval of her doctors.
I totally believe that our knowledge on some things isn't complete. We used to laugh about meditation. I had an hour to fill of an afternoon, so did crystal meditation. My meditation became deeper etc with some crystals. I'm interested in the placebo effect, because it does show that our mental health is connected to our physical health. In other words, we can heal ourselves to some degree. Which is why I don't think that Reiki should be dismissed. But as said the amounts used in homeopathy couldn't make a difference.

TeenMinusTests · 29/07/2021 08:10

@Parttimemostofthetime

A friend of mine child has had severe eczema for years and tried everything from the gp. Homeopathy has improved the skin so much. I never believed in it but I have seen the difference it has made to this child
The thing is, my DD had severe eczema. But like many children she eventually grew out of it.

People believe in homeopathy because many things do get better anyway. Which is why you need scientific studies to show effectiveness.

Quarantino · 29/07/2021 08:09

You seem to think I’m some kind of fuckwit that hands over bank details just because I am open minded! Really!?

It was a joke, but also a demonstration that obviously you do think about how things might work in that situation, and that you wouldn't believe me telling you to forget everything you know about how e.g. financial transactions work just because someone tells you it's different this time and might benefit you.

Parttimemostofthetime · 29/07/2021 07:58

A friend of mine child has had severe eczema for years and tried everything from the gp. Homeopathy has improved the skin so much. I never believed in it but I have seen the difference it has made to this child

TriciaMcMillan · 29/07/2021 07:36

The master speaks:

queenMab99 · 29/07/2021 07:30

I am quite happy to accept remedies and procedures that are proved to work, such as meditation, which lowers blood pressure and acupuncture for pain, even when no one is sure how they work, as I think that physical and mental health are so intertwined and complicated, that we really don't know half of what goes on in our bodies.

knittingaddict · 29/07/2021 07:26

I see someone mentioned Neal's Yard on an earlier post. I don't shop from them any more for similar reasons. Their stuff smells lovely and I'm a sucker for an essential oil, but I can't condone their overstepping into real woo territory.

taliopolis · 29/07/2021 07:22

@Bumblecattabbybee

This is so ignorant and narrow minded.
What is? How is it ignorant and narrow minded to think that something with no evidence whatsoever behind it may be effective, something that assumes water has "memory" would be effective? Ignorant and narrow minded or realistic ?
knittingaddict · 29/07/2021 07:19

I have definitely seen herbal remedies mixed up with homeopathy on here.
Homeopathy is clearly a ridiculous concept from start to finish.

Bumblecattabbybee · 29/07/2021 07:12

This is so ignorant and narrow minded.

thatonehasalittlecar · 29/07/2021 07:05

@Flyingantday

Placebos work because of belief and trust - in the pill, in the person administering it etc. So it would be likely in your case that the trust in your friend and her abilities was strong enough to override your skepticism and was the cause of the placebo effect.

Homeopathy may well work as a placebo in some cases, if the person believes in it / the practitioner’s ability enough.

However, when more robust, effective remedies available are eschewed in favour of these, especially on kids or animals, it’s cruel.

In these cases, homeopathy isn’t ‘harmless’.

sammylady37 · 29/07/2021 06:37

I don’t know how to insert clicky links, but look up the Mitchell and Webb skit on homeopathy. It is utter genius!

DewDew83 · 29/07/2021 02:19

There are areas of science which haven’t been totally proved yet, I think black holes are one. I just think that in time homeopathy will probably be proven. It’s just not happened yet. So I remain open minded. And if it’s a placebo that works for some, fine.
There are, of course, things that scientists don't understand. Perhaps they can observe things happening but cannot understand the cause.

That is not the case with homoeopathy. If homeopathy performed better than a placebo in trials, then you could argue that perhaps the particulars of how it works are not understood. However, time and time and time again, the outcomes of homeopathic patients have been shown to be no better than patients who were given a placebo. There is no causology to understand. It simply does not work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread