Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Homeopathy vs home remedies

142 replies

suspiria777 · 28/07/2021 16:14

After a long time reading on MN and elsewhere, and just general chats to people at work or at weddings or whatever, I've come to the conclusion that a significant proportion of people don't really understand what homeopathy is, and think of it as roughly synonymous with 'natural medicine' or 'home remedies'.

Am i mistaken?

I can't think what else would explain the large proportion of otherwise seemingly sensible people who discuss homeopathy as if it actually has good scientific evidence base. Surely people don't back it if they realise it is just water and woo woo?

What do you think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/08/2021 10:41

Considering a typical homeopathic remedy costs about £7 for a full course of treatment, I don't know why people get so worked up about it being a danger to society

Because you get imbeciles like my first ex who refused permission for DD1 to have any vaccines on the grounds that he had given her 'The Homeopathic Pre School Booster' and this would protect her.

Fortunately, my GP, who was more than happy to recommend Natural Medicine, Ayurveda or anything that he knew did work, agreed with me that this was stupidity and gave her the vaccinations himself rather than having to make an appointment with the child health vaccination clinic, as he was prepared to take any flak when the ex found out, knowing the nursing team wouldn't have been able to do them in the face of her father's refusal.

ShallWeStartTheMeeting · 06/08/2021 10:03

I have been meaning to post this for days!

m.youtube.com/watch?v=QdLOBRUwq10

KatharinaRosalie · 02/08/2021 11:54

"Scientific" evidence changes with time.

“Science knows it doesn't know everything; otherwise, it'd stop. But just because science doesn't know everything doesn't mean you can fill in the gaps with whatever fairy tale most appeals to you.”

― Dara O'Briain

DewDew83 · 02/08/2021 06:59

There speaks the voice of STEM. "Scientific" evidence changes with time, it only refers to that which is known and understood at any given period in time. Other forms of evidence include empirical evidence, meta-analyses, experimental evidence, quasi-experimental evidence, qualitative review, literature review, case study, expert opinion .... all I'm saying is, just because you don't understand it, no need to rubbish it.
Cringing so hard at this.

Science, in general terms, is the study of empirical evidence. Experimental and quasi-experimental evidence are types of experimental evidence that are used as part of the scientific method.

Case studies, literature reviews and meta analyses are not evidence in themselves, rather they are means of interpreting empirical evidence as part of the scientific method.

G5000 · 01/08/2021 22:42

there’s no profit in them for a drug company to make
You're kidding, right? Considering it's just water and you don't need to invest into anything but H2O and packaging, homeopathy is hugely profitable. Just look up Boiron's turnover and profit, quite amazing.

So perhaps that’s why there are no studies that prove the efficacy of homeopathic medicine.

There are plenty of companies very very interested in showing it works but despite of that, all studies still show that homeopathy is no better than placebo. Funny.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/08/2021 22:19

@DeleteSystem32

I was referring to blackberry bonnet.
Thanks for clarifying!
DeleteSystem32 · 01/08/2021 21:57

I was referring to blackberry bonnet.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/08/2021 20:40

This reply has been deleted

Post referecnes deleted post Talk guidelines.

DeleteSystem32 · 01/08/2021 20:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/08/2021 18:58

@Blackberrybunnet

"Scientific" is in quotes because it is not a definitive form of evidence. "Scientific" evidence is only that which is known thus far, and changes according to new information.
Scientific method can't always say what will work and how. It's pretty good for what doesn't work. Because double blind studies are excellent for that. And homeopathy doesn't work.

Chinese medicine and acupuncture though, fairly convincing evidence for effects on some diseases and disorders.

UrAWizHarry · 01/08/2021 18:31

@Blackberrybunnet

There speaks the voice of STEM. "Scientific" evidence changes with time, it only refers to that which is known and understood at any given period in time. Other forms of evidence include empirical evidence, meta-analyses, experimental evidence, quasi-experimental evidence, qualitative review, literature review, case study, expert opinion .... all I'm saying is, just because you don't understand it, no need to rubbish it.
We're pretty certain that homepathy is just water with no other benefits other than making you a bit hydrated. It's not like there have been plenty of people over the years who have tried and failed to show it works.

Yes, maybe in the future we'll suddenly get some compelling evidence that water memory isn't a complete load of bollocks but I would place the likelyhood of that somewhere around the same level of us actually finding the Loch Ness Monster.

So, for the time being because it's both nonsense and dangerous nonsense I will continue to rubbish it because it doesn't fucking work.

Blackberrybunnet · 01/08/2021 18:19

"Scientific" is in quotes because it is not a definitive form of evidence. "Scientific" evidence is only that which is known thus far, and changes according to new information.

BrozTito · 01/08/2021 17:54

Homeopathy is brilliant, i fill my cars tank with water and it remembers the petrol

Blackberrybunnet · 01/08/2021 17:50

There speaks the voice of STEM. "Scientific" evidence changes with time, it only refers to that which is known and understood at any given period in time. Other forms of evidence include empirical evidence, meta-analyses, experimental evidence, quasi-experimental evidence, qualitative review, literature review, case study, expert opinion .... all I'm saying is, just because you don't understand it, no need to rubbish it.

StillWeRise · 31/07/2021 21:44

@Parttimemostofthetime

A friend of mine child has had severe eczema for years and tried everything from the gp. Homeopathy has improved the skin so much. I never believed in it but I have seen the difference it has made to this child
mmm, I had a dc with severe eczema. We tried homeopathy because conventional treatment seemed to at best control the symptoms rather than the cause...and homeopathy claimed to get to the root of it. We paid £££s for the consultations which as PPs have said were quite comforting in themselves. We got into the realms of remedies which I had to dilute and succuss (sp?)myself. The thing was, whenever a new remedy didn't work - even when the symptoms worsened, this was explained as 'a good sign' and if things improved, that was also a good sign. So it was unfalsifiable really.

Later a friends mum gave me some homeopathic cream from her own country which she said was amazing. I checked the label. It did contain a homeopathic remedy but the base was a steroid cream ! so of course it worked.

taliopolis · 29/07/2021 19:10

[quote Helendee]@taliopolis

Yet the NHS is bullying people into having barely tested and seemingly ineffective ‘vaccines’ en masse! 😏[/quote]
Each of the three points on this statement are untrue. But I assume you have evidence to the contrary? I'm going to ask you if you can show us the evidence to prove your statement is correct. I suspect your answer to that will be something along the lines of "why I should I do the work for you" or "do your own research.
Would you care to prove me wrong?

DewDew83 · 29/07/2021 16:53

I see homeopathy as an eczema treatment has been discussed a few times. Here's a related article (with distressing content)

www.abc.net.au/news/2009-09-28/parents-jailed-over-babys-death/1445256

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/07/2021 15:39

Placebo effect does work even when people are told it's untrue. However the wording of the study was something like, "here is a pill, it has no active ingredients but some people have found it helps". So not exactly, "this is a placebo, see if it works".

Placebo isn't the only effect of course. There is nocebo, which is why many woo-meisters report additional side effects from the vaccine. White coat syndrome, which makes people ill when they see doctors. And the opposite when the performance of healthcare adds to the effect of drugs. Studies have shown even more effects when they perform more (like giving the pill to someone with thongs).

There is also reversion to the mean, which means you were going to get better anyway but sought help from a woo-idiot when you were at your worst. It's not just placebo.

I know I like my acupuncturist being kind and listening and spending time and checking in. My foot hurts less but also I feel cared for and happy, both very good for pain. And spending an hour basically meditating with needles in (can't talk or move) also helps.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/07/2021 12:17

Apparently the placebo effect works for lots of people even when they know it's a placebo. I think some people just benefit from being fussed over and homeopathy fills that gap in a way that meets their needs. But fuck knows how people spin a degree out of magic water.

Quarantino · 29/07/2021 12:14

Science literally demands an open mind which you must change if the evidence changes. Your own feelings, expectations and experiences are irrelevant.

Woo, on the other hand, feeds people a single narrative that exploits people's confirmation bias and dismisses all fact as 'part of the conspiracy'. It's literally the definition of a closed feedback system.

Great post!

thatonehasalittlecar · 29/07/2021 12:05

@Helendee

No, so the evidence shows. My thoughts are irrelevant.

chunderwunder · 29/07/2021 11:45

@coodawoodashooda

I am not a homeopath so wont even try to explain but i guarantee that is incorrect

Haha. 'dO yOuR OwN rEseArCh' - the beloved cry of all conspiracy theorists who have nothing to support their nonsense.

chunderwunder · 29/07/2021 11:40

Science literally demands an open mind which you must change if the evidence changes. Your own feelings, expectations and experiences are irrelevant.

Woo, on the other hand, feeds people a single narrative that exploits people's confirmation bias and dismisses all fact as 'part of the conspiracy'. It's literally the definition of a closed feedback system.

Yet guess which one insists they're 'open-minded' Grin

I swap between finding woo-lovers the most tedious people imaginable because their debate is completely predictable (unlike people who believe in science who will tell you fascinating, new things) and feeling that my life would be duller without them to laugh at.

DillonPanthersTexas · 29/07/2021 11:33

Generally if I meet someone who confesses to using homeopathic medicine I just quietly assume they are a bit stupid.

Maireas · 29/07/2021 11:31

@Helendee - I have a good book recommendation - "Vaxxers" by Sarah Gilbert and Catherine Green. It explains all about their work, including a list of the vaccine ingredients.
"Bullying" is a much misused term, perhaps never more so against a public health system attempting to save lives under significant pressure.