Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting a wage for playing with his granddaughter

464 replies

Bigdisappointment · 28/07/2021 14:01

This is what my dad ‘Joked’ well, he wasn’t laughing about today.
Parents come to stay with us, he was playing with toddler Dd, she always wants to play with him. He played for a bit, then stood up and said he was going to the bank to get his wage. Confused, I asked ‘Wage for what?’ He said ‘For this’ meaning playing/looking after Dd,
Aibu to feel hurt that he obviously begrudges spending time with her, I'd rather he didn’t if he didn’t want to.
How involved are your parents with your kids? Feel disappointed in mine a lot.

OP posts:
butterpuffed · 29/07/2021 08:58

Why does dd want grandad all the time and not grandma? Doesn't that imply that she actually enjoys his company more/has a better relationship with him?

Toddlers usually pick up when they're not wanted and there's no interaction and graduate t someone else.

They also pick up on tension in the house.

Tiddleztheelephant · 29/07/2021 08:47

I’m seeing a great deal of misogyny on here.

Are you @AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken ??

I don't see that at all. I see one group of people arguing that if grandparents are staying in the house being looked after, the least they can do is entertain DD.

Whilst the other group are saying that grandparents don't owe you childcare, may be tired, bored, not able to play for long and that many grandparents like to see their grandchildren without being left to entertain them for long periods.

I think that discussion would have gone the same way regardless of the sex if the grandparent.

Interestingly, grandmother in this scenario isn't mentioned much at all.
Although I have got a bit lost I admit so I'm happy to be told I'm wrong about this bit Grin

Why does dd want grandad all the time and not grandma? Doesn't that imply that she actually enjoys his company more/has a better relationship with him?

LookItsMeAgain · 29/07/2021 08:47

[quote Bigdisappointment]@LookItsMeAgain Just pure tension in the house this morning. I want my space back[/quote]
Quick and guaranteed to work - tell your parents to go!

It's not working out this visit, and they shouldn't expect to be welcomed back with open arms in a few weeks time. They should look elsewhere for their next break.

It will work.

Stop being such a wuss and take the bull by the horns.

Bigdisappointment · 29/07/2021 08:42

@LookItsMeAgain Just pure tension in the house this morning. I want my space back

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 29/07/2021 08:29

I have a suspicion that the OP won't be back unless it is under a new name, complaining about how her parents are overstaying their welcome, not doing enough (in her eyes) to help her out and yet she is rolling out the red carpet and letting them walk all over her.

If I'm annoying you @Bigdisappointment, good! Perhaps you might direct some of that annoyance at your parents and finally have it out with them.

Do something about your situation.
Tell your parents that the second visit can't happen or if it is to happen they have to stay elsewhere.
But stop having "Doormat" stamped on your forehead!

Sisisimone · 29/07/2021 08:03

You have stated multiple times now that you never get a break, haven't had a break for 3 years. It's clearly something you feel very resentful about. I wonder if you expect them to completely pick up the slack when they're with you whilst they want to see you and your dd and at the same time enjoy a holiday. Have you talked to them about how much you are struggling? They are your dds grandparents but they don't owe you any childcare. You seem to think because they helped out your sister they should be helping you but this appears to be different time, different situation, different country even. Where is your DP in all of this? You mention one but he isn't present in any if the scenarios you are finding difficult, day or night. Is he any help to you at all? If you are struggling it is for you and DP to find solutions not the fault of your parents. And yes if you struggle more when they are there for too long let them know that you can only cope with a couple of weeks at a time. Telling your own parents to go to a hotel when they visit from abroad is awful though. I dont believe anyone would do that unless they were incredibly toxic which they don't seem to be.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 29/07/2021 07:58

I don’t understand some of these comments.

I have never left my children with anyone other than my husband. I’ve never expected other people to provide childcare.

But that’s not what you’re doing either! You’re expecting them to entertain her a little bit while you do dinner and other bits for them. It’s crazy that you’re expected to do it all while they sit there being waited on. Is it because you’re a woman? I can’t imagine if a dad was in your situation you’d be getting such shitty comments about “expecting other people to provide childcare”.

They’re adding to your work load, the least they can do is play with your daughter while you attend to that. You’re not asking them to get her up, dressed, fed, take her out for the day, bathed or put her to bed.

It’s not too much to ask that they play with her while they’re staying with you.

I’m seeing a great deal of misogyny on here.

niceupthedanceagain · 29/07/2021 07:56

Wtf has anyone here actually played with a toddler for 45 minutes straight ?! It's well fucking painful. I'm not surprised he wanted a break. Sounds like a massive case of PFB

bigbaggyeyes · 29/07/2021 07:39

I don't understand why you don't simply say to them that their comments are upsetting and hurtful, she's a small child that enjoys playing with her grandparents, and considering you've been cooking for them meals, washing up after them etc a little 'give and take' would go a long way. It doesn't have to be stroppy or confrontational, just a statement from you.

It's the same as the garden gate scenario, a simple 'I'm not asking you to take care of her, simply ensure her safety whilst you stay with us, isn't me palming her off in you'

I'd actually go so far as to say that they need to find alternative accommodation next time they come to stay if they find being around small children difficult

FancyFlipFlops · 29/07/2021 00:16

@Feedingthebirds1

OP putting this incident aside it seems like time to re-evaluate your relationship with your parents. You feel obliged to accede to their every demand and would feel enormous guilt if you said no, which is why you never do. You are sorted in all other areas of your life, but you almost revert to a child around them, wanting their love and approval and involvement in your life. But sometimes it doesn't work like that, and parental love comes with strings or conditions attached.

I recommend reading 'Out of the FOG' ]]. Your situation might not be as bad as some people experience, but some of it will ring bells. You'll have a better understanding of the relationship, and learn to understand your response to it and how to handle it.

Good luck.

@Bigdisappointment, I read your first thread and then this one and as a daughter with parents like yours and who spent some time living abroad I would strongly recommend the book that has been linked.
ChaBishkoot · 29/07/2021 00:08

There can be consideration for you that doesn’t involve childcare. They could do housework. They could cook.
The bit that is unreasonable is expecting them to play with your daughter when they have made it clear that they don’t like doing it. Why they don’t, well who knows.
You don’t need to make a fuss about it. Just say: granddad is tired. Play by yourself. And rinse and repeat. Yes he won’t have a relationship with his granddaughter but maybe right now he doesn’t want to.
You are tired, you have done a lot for them. They can repay your kindness in ways that doesn’t involve looking after your child or playing with her.

Bigdisappointment · 28/07/2021 23:28

@2Rebecca Right. No I don’t get a break and never ask for one, but after running around after everyone else and making everything nice for them, why no consideration for me

OP posts:
2Rebecca · 28/07/2021 23:24

You said you "never " got a break from your child which made it sound as though you never got away from her and are desperate to share the childcare

Bigdisappointment · 28/07/2021 23:19

@2Rebecca You presumed a lot of things in that post

OP posts:
2Rebecca · 28/07/2021 23:12

When you have visitors even parents you tell them how long they are staying for not vv. You sound a bit passive. If 3 weeks is too long you say "no that's not convenient I'd prefer just 1 week. " I think your father sounds a bit insensitive but just because your toddler wants to play with him constantly it doesn't follow that he wants to play with her. Few older men really do "playing". Was he playful with you? I'm not sure why he is more of a novelty than your mum if they visit together. I don't think most visitors think of their visits as designed to give their host a break. They usually see their visit as a holiday which is why prolonged visits can be draining. It sounds as though you could do with a part time job and a nursery if you feel you never get a break from your child. I presume the father isn't interested

Bigdisappointment · 28/07/2021 23:09

@nonotmenotI Sorry it’s the same for you, just feels crappy, doesn’t it? Feel so tired tonight and just the fact don’t feel supported or helped really

OP posts:
nonotmenotI · 28/07/2021 22:53

No advice, but in the same boat as you. It's hard to accept that this is what their relationship will be like.

aloris · 28/07/2021 22:26

Are you the person whose parents were coming for two separate, burdensome visits? Your parents sound like hard work. I do not think it is asking too much for them to interact pleasantly with your daughter during the day. They are guests in her home! It is not babysitting and for your father to equate the two is a bit much. Also, since this is her home, she has a right to play in it, so keeping her quiet all the time is unnecessary. If your dad finds it such a burden to have a normal toddler around, he can make his visits shorter. Sounds like a win-win to me.

His saying, or implying, that he ought to be paid for playing with her for short periods is not something I would be inclined to put up with. It's completely unacceptable to come into someone's home and act as if the presence and attention of one of the residents is an unwanted imposition. And, what kind of grandparent says that about their grandchild? Ugh.

I know it can be hard to stand up to one's own parents, but I think the very least you should force yourself to do is to say, "In future, you will need to ask me BEFORE you buy tickets to see me, whether the dates and times will work for me. Not tell me, but ask me. If I say it's not a good time, you need to understand that if you go ahead and book those tickets, you may not be able to stay in my home. Also, regarding my daughter, I understand you don't enjoy her company but I'm her mother and it is rude and insulting to me that you make it so obvious that you dislike spending time with her. If you cannot tolerate spending time with her then no one is forcing you to come here."

You can modify this to wording that works better for you but I think you need to get these two basic points across.

Mary46 · 28/07/2021 22:24

I agree firm boundaries. My mother dictates the pace so nobody brings her away!!! You be run ragged op if this keeps on. Is your husb not backing you up.

RandomMess · 28/07/2021 22:18

I wasn't sure if you were the same person with the 3 week and then the 2 week visit.

It is 100% clear they are coming for a holiday. They want a holiday experience for them at your expense in £ and time.

You need to put in boundaries and do not host them again.

Stop accommodating them, they amuse themselves they go eat out and leave you and DD and home etc etc.

StrangeLookingParasite · 28/07/2021 22:14

Funny how all the people on here just know he was joking, despite never having met the man. I'd say the OP knows him better than you do.
They sound really unpleasant people.
I tend to think visitors are like fish; after three days, they stink.

Duskydai · 28/07/2021 21:51

Ah posted too soon! They can go on walks or something during this visit regularly to get away and to give you some time to calm DD down. And please for your DDs sake explain that you don’t feel this arrangement is working and so it’s not suitable for them to book another visit!! They are welcome to visit you but must stay in a hotel as DD needs some space to calm down and your parents need some space away from her as they clearly struggle with it. Stand up for yourself!!! Do you want your DD to pick up on this dynamic where they are annoyed at her? She will as she gets older if you always let them stay with you. Children aren’t stupid

Duskydai · 28/07/2021 21:47

Just read all your comments via the see all button and YANBU. Essentially what has happened is your parents wanted to take a nice holiday to see you abroad, not even taking into consideration you have a young child and that asking would be nice but instead telling you they are coming. Then they come and you skivvy around making sure the house is clean, taking them places to show them around, making dinner every day etc and they have the bloody cheek to act like this. I would be massively pissed off with this. You aren’t palming DD off to them whilst you go off galavanting, you’re cooking for them in your own home whilst she is understandably excited to see them and is wanting to chat away and play with them... and they’re making it obvious they don’t want to even do that. And on top of all that silently judging your parenting! 3 weeks is far too long for them to be in the presence of a toddler they don’t have the energy to want to be with, and also far too long for you to try to keep your DD quiet. It’s her house, she should be as loud or playful as she wants, it’s not fair on her to try to keep her quiet just to keep the peace.

Can you not (whilst DD is napping or asleep) sit them down and explain that you don’t feel comfortable with this arrangement as 1) they didn’t ask you before making plans and 2) they are making you feel as though they don’t want your DD around them, which is unfair on her as ITS HER HOUSE and she is simply excited to see them. I would make it clear that if they would prefer not to be in the presence of a wild toddler then they are welcome to go out for walks and stuff regularly to give themselves some space

LookItsMeAgain · 28/07/2021 21:42

@Bigdisappointment - You might be seeing things more clearly but how about being more clear with your parents??

"Sorry guys, I know you were hoping to come back in 3 weeks and stay for another 3 weeks but I think we can all agree that this visit just hasn't worked. If you still plan on coming, I think you should book into a B&B or a hotel for that visit, as I will not be able to have you here".

How difficult is that to tell them both????

Really???

Bigdisappointment · 28/07/2021 21:40

@LookItsMeAgain Ok.

No I wasn’t trying to present myself as someone else, I didn’t generally want to go into the whole thing again and just wanted some perspective on the incident today.

It’s all very complex and likely goes back a long way. Ingrained habits are hard to change, but since Dd came along, I’m starting to see things more and more clearly

OP posts: