Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think teenagers should be cheaper than qualified people?

236 replies

Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 10:55

We regularly use an agency for babysitting and have a level 3 qualified registered childminder who is in her 50s babysit for us.
She is fab, but for times when we are (literally) down the road we’d love to have a cheaper babysitter in their teens. Our children have never woken up in their sleep and are in bed by the time we go out. We could literally be home in 5minutes.

Loads of people advertising their teenager sons and dds are available for babysitting on Facebook (obviously would check them out first) but AIBU to think teens these days expect a lot!
So have 3 I have casually enquired about have want more or the same as the agency rate I pay for our qualified, experienced babysitter!

I am not that old and babysat a lot in my teens - I never expected the (equivalent) rate these teens expect.

Are people going to book them? Are they out of touch or is it me who is BU?

(For record even though this is AIBU I am not in a fury and will just carry on using our babysitter - so no drama 😁)

OP posts:
Seeline · 28/07/2021 11:20

You pay what you want - if there are cheaper options available and you're happy with the service, go for it. I personally don't think £10/hr is that much for someone to look after my children's lives.

I think the argument is possibly why are careers involving children so poorly paid.

QueenOfPain · 28/07/2021 11:18

You’re not paying for what does happen on a fine night where all the children sleep soundly, you’re paying for what could happen, I.e. a fire as mentioned by a PP, or one of your kids getting up and wanting to sit with the babysitter all night, etc.

Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 11:18

@Reallybadidea

£15 an hour is more than a newly-qualified paediatric nurse gets so those teenagers are expecting a lot IMO. It is much more than we were paying about 8 years ago. I'd be tempted to advertise for one, stating what you're prepared to pay and see whether you get any interest.
That’s a good idea. Might put the word around friends with teens and see if any are interested.
OP posts:
icelollycraving · 28/07/2021 11:18

I don’t use babysitters but I’d expect to pay a teenager max £8-10 an hour and very probably less. Certainly not £15 an hour Shock
I started babysitting at about 13 and although it seemed easy money, it wasn’t always.

littlebilliie · 28/07/2021 11:18

@Topofthepopicles

Sorry for drip feed.

We pay £15 per hour via an agency to childminder babysitter (which take a cut so it becomes £12 per hour plus we pay an annual fee). She has always been very happy to do more hours for us and makes positive comments. So never got the impression she feels under paid.

Teens are asking for £15/hour direct via Facebook advertising (from their mums) which is effectively more than the childminder.

I think this is overpriced given they are 16/17 years old.

My teens would be happy with £20 for the evening
Bryonyshcmyony · 28/07/2021 11:17

I'd want someone who could feed, play and interact with my child when awake plus be mature and sensible enough to deal with any issues as they arise. I always want first aid as well.

Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 11:17

@Seeline

They can ring 999 in an emergency, but they still need to to eg get the children out of the house in case of fire etc. There is a lot of responsibility involved which should be recognised surely.
Should they really earn more than many nursery nurses earn?
OP posts:
Reallybadidea · 28/07/2021 11:16

£15 an hour is more than a newly-qualified paediatric nurse gets so those teenagers are expecting a lot IMO. It is much more than we were paying about 8 years ago. I'd be tempted to advertise for one, stating what you're prepared to pay and see whether you get any interest.

Kolo · 28/07/2021 11:15

NLW is £4.62 for under 18s, so I'd say £5 ph is pretty reasonable, if it's within reasonable hours.

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 28/07/2021 11:15

The job is the same whether it is done by a qualified and experienced person or just a teenager. Ultimately all they do is ensure the child is safe for a period of time. I understand why people would pay more for an experienced person above an inexperienced one, but it's illogical to say you'd trust an inexperienced person charging £15 a night or an experienced person charging £45, but not an inexperienced person charging £45. (It's different if that's all you can afford of course, but then it's not a matter of trust.)

Well, there are other factors. I'm happy to pay my nanny her going rate, the same rate I pay her in the daytime, because 1) I know I can trust and rely on her to handle a crisis, 2) my kids know and love her. If I were hiring a teen instead, it would be because they were cheaper, and I'd have different expectations i.e. call me if anything more than very routine issues arose.

£15ph is way more than most people working in nurseries are getting for caring for people's kids, despite the fact they're dealing with awake kids and any crises and responsible for following the EYFS curriculum and being inspected, etc.

LadyCatStark · 28/07/2021 11:13

£15 per hour 😵 thank god I’ve never needed a babysitter!

IsThisNameTaken · 28/07/2021 11:13

DD(18) had DBS and paediatric first aid and only charges £7 per hour for evening babysitting - most families tend to round up to nearest fiver though.

pleasedonttextmyman · 28/07/2021 11:10

Less than £10 an hour for a teen babysitter is insulting frankly.
£15 is a bit high, but if the demand is there, why not.

I am always so shocked at how tights people are about childcare (in general, not an attack against the OP). Spend a fortune with your cleaner, your hairdresser, your nail technician, window cleaner.. fine.

Giving more than a tip for someone giving up their time to look after your children? Seriously. It's embarrassing.

Seeline · 28/07/2021 11:10

They can ring 999 in an emergency, but they still need to to eg get the children out of the house in case of fire etc. There is a lot of responsibility involved which should be recognised surely.

Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 11:10

It’s different from daytime childcare or childcare where I am unavailable because I am able to immediately drop everything and return. I don’t expect them to be great at teaching my child their numbers or come up with fantastic learning opportunities.

OP posts:
Tal45 · 28/07/2021 11:09

£15 an hour for a teenager babysitting is absolutely ridiculous - unless you only want them for an hour or so and they have to get to your house and home themselves.
I think £5 - £7 an hour is reasonable with an extra £5 on top (or round up the amount) as a thank you.

Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 11:08

I guess I just have quite minimal expectations of a teen babysitter.

  1. they don’t trash the house
  2. they ring 999 in an emergency
  3. if kids wake up/are ill then they call me and I come home within 10minutes (I would literally 5 mins away).
OP posts:
ChainJane · 28/07/2021 11:08

It's supply and demand. If their prices are too high they won't get work and will have to lower them. Their logic is sound though, why would they work three nights at £15 a time if sometimes they can make the same amount in one evening?

The job is the same whether it is done by a qualified and experienced person or just a teenager. Ultimately all they do is ensure the child is safe for a period of time. I understand why people would pay more for an experienced person above an inexperienced one, but it's illogical to say you'd trust an inexperienced person charging £15 a night or an experienced person charging £45, but not an inexperienced person charging £45. (It's different if that's all you can afford of course, but then it's not a matter of trust.)

littlepeas · 28/07/2021 11:07

I think £8 - £10 per hour for a teenage babysitter who only needs to be the house (as opposed to interacting with the dc) is plenty tbh and is actually quite a bit more than minimum wage (so probably more than they would get paid if they worked in a nursery...).

Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 11:06

^admitted

OP posts:
Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 11:06

@FawnFrenchieMum

No way would I a pay a teenager £15ph to baby sit sleeping children!
This was my reaction Shock

Have message the mum back to say as much in a polite way who seemed surprised I thought it was a lot but admired their teen hadn’t done it before. So possibly they are wrong or possibly I am cheap!

OP posts:
Bryonyshcmyony · 28/07/2021 11:06

Dd21 has a first aid qualification, can drive, cook and a health and social care qualification and charges £10 an hour.

Seeline · 28/07/2021 11:05

@FawnFrenchieMum

No way would I a pay a teenager £15ph to baby sit sleeping children!
But surely you're paying them for when the children wake up, illness strikes, something unusual happens in the house, unexpected callers, floods, fires etc?

I know most of those are unusual, but that is what they are really there for isn't it? Just because they are teens, they would still have to deal with it in the same way as someone older. If you don't think that they could, then surely you shouldn't be leaving them in charge of your children.

fruitbrewhaha · 28/07/2021 11:04

I pay £5 an hour. £10 for someone to sit in your house! My children aren't young. They would probably be ok on their own really especially as we have nice neighbours they could call on in an emergency but better to have a person with them. They just watch telly and do homework. My DC put themselves to bed

If I was paying £10 per hour I'd expect them to be doing something productive while there. I have a friend who's babysitter cleans out the kitchen cupboards or does ironing while there.

Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 11:04

Sorry for drip feed.

We pay £15 per hour via an agency to childminder babysitter (which take a cut so it becomes £12 per hour plus we pay an annual fee). She has always been very happy to do more hours for us and makes positive comments. So never got the impression she feels under paid.

Teens are asking for £15/hour direct via Facebook advertising (from their mums) which is effectively more than the childminder.

I think this is overpriced given they are 16/17 years old.

OP posts: