Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think teenagers should be cheaper than qualified people?

236 replies

Topofthepopicles · 28/07/2021 10:55

We regularly use an agency for babysitting and have a level 3 qualified registered childminder who is in her 50s babysit for us.
She is fab, but for times when we are (literally) down the road we’d love to have a cheaper babysitter in their teens. Our children have never woken up in their sleep and are in bed by the time we go out. We could literally be home in 5minutes.

Loads of people advertising their teenager sons and dds are available for babysitting on Facebook (obviously would check them out first) but AIBU to think teens these days expect a lot!
So have 3 I have casually enquired about have want more or the same as the agency rate I pay for our qualified, experienced babysitter!

I am not that old and babysat a lot in my teens - I never expected the (equivalent) rate these teens expect.

Are people going to book them? Are they out of touch or is it me who is BU?

(For record even though this is AIBU I am not in a fury and will just carry on using our babysitter - so no drama 😁)

OP posts:
Mrsjayy · 28/07/2021 14:03

I'm 50 I babysat as teen I took a fiver so£15:seems fair for a night. You can't expect a teenager to be responsible etc etc but just give them buttons can you how is that right ?

SquirmOfEels · 28/07/2021 14:00

One of my DC does £10 per hour baby sitting, which involves collecting her charges from the activity camp, bringing them home and then keeping them amused and out of the way until the WFH parent can break off.

If you compare that to the cost of an after-school nanny, it's very cheap. It's a reflection of the odd timing - it's not a slot that works well round other commitments so is always at a premium price

London, btw.

Travielkapelka · 28/07/2021 13:58

£7.50 an hour is more than ample and £25 - £30 for an evening is more than ample. They really don’t need more than that if they’re in the house with kids (not babies) who will either sleep through or watch tv or do tik toks with them.

Have teens and would be thinking parents had lost the plot for them to get more than that for sitting on their WiFi.

V happy for my kids to work Min wage at the moment. They have high aspirations and I would be extremely surprised if that was what their career salary would be but does nobody any harm whatsoever to have some work experience at a very basic level

MotionActivatedDog · 28/07/2021 13:53

YABU

The children are asleep whether the babysitter is qualified or not. The qualifications are irrelevant. You are paying for the persons time. 3 hours is the same amount of time for a 50 year old as it is for a 17 year old.

MaverickDanger · 28/07/2021 13:52

We’ve not used a babysitter yet as DS is too young, but we have a teenage neighbour who has offered when he’s old enough, and she has said she’ll do a 4-5 hour evening for £20 and snacks.

Yerra · 28/07/2021 13:52

I spent every weekend babysitting neighbours kids and family friends kids with holiday homes in area. I used to do 3 or 4 hours a night and it was pocket money. watching TV with 2 channels mainly. Probably got no more than £10 for the night but it was seen by my parents and that of the adults i was minding, that it was better than nothing. we minded from when we were 14 - kids mainly now would not do it and most of the parents of 14 year olds would not let them do it. Times have changed and the same teenagers now have their heads stuck in phones or other technology . Different world.

JustLyra · 28/07/2021 13:49

DD charged £7 per hour before midnight (minimum 3 hours) and £10 an hour plus taxi home (which is about £6/7 in our village) after midnight.

Callaird · 28/07/2021 13:47

Wow! Where are you?

I have a nanny for 45 years. I didn’t go to college or uni but I have done course since and I get paid well for working hours.

I’m not working at the moment, was looking after my parents who had different medical conditions. I looked for baby sitting whilst they were with carers, mainly to get out of the house otherwise the carers would be constantly asking question, coming for a chat as dad was antisocial and mum couldn’t speak. The most I was offered was £8 ph!

CaptSkippy · 28/07/2021 13:45

@BuffySummersReportingforSanity

I wouldn't encourage my kids to take a minimum wage either, unless it really brings something to their cvs, they need to aim higher

You're effectively encouraging them to be unemployed then. And also potentially committing yourself to funding them semi-indefinitely. A candidate with experience stocking shelves, working a checkout, bussing tables, or staffing a kids holiday club is a much more attractive prospect to someone recruiting for a "proper" entry level job with prospects than someone who has never worked. Those graduates getting shiny jobs in the City and large corporates are getting them in part on the skills and references they earned at minimum wage.

The one thing I have discovered is the higher you set your rates (as long as you don't go beyond the ridiculuous) the more likely you are to get hired and will actually be appreciated by your employer. I have done jobs for low wages and 9 out of 10 times I get treated like shit. I ask for higher, I may not get the job, but when I do I know they will appreciate the work I do and see value in me as an employee.

It sounds paradoxical, but teaching kids to value themselves if they want their employers to value them is paramount. Teaching kids that minimum is acceptable and they are "lucky" to get any job is to set them up for exploitation.

Qualified childminders could probably get 20/hr easily. You time and efforts and qualifications have value.

pleasedonttextmyman · 28/07/2021 13:43

@BuffySummersReportingforSanity

I wouldn't encourage my kids to take a minimum wage either, unless it really brings something to their cvs, they need to aim higher

You're effectively encouraging them to be unemployed then. And also potentially committing yourself to funding them semi-indefinitely. A candidate with experience stocking shelves, working a checkout, bussing tables, or staffing a kids holiday club is a much more attractive prospect to someone recruiting for a "proper" entry level job with prospects than someone who has never worked. Those graduates getting shiny jobs in the City and large corporates are getting them in part on the skills and references they earned at minimum wage.

Where did you see my kids didn't work at all? I said to aim higher and build their cv, not do nothing...

You are talking about a field I happen to know quite well... Grin

Those graduates getting shiny jobs in the City and large corporates are getting them in part on the skills and references ABSOLUTELY
they earned at minimum wage debatable...the wage not being terribly relevant in itself.

Regardless, when most families pay from £10 an hour, accepting a piss take £5 an hour is not doing anyone any favour.

FangsForTheMemory · 28/07/2021 13:38

Goodness. I used to babysit in my teens (this was in the late 70s) and for an overnight stay looking after two children I got the princely sum of £1.50. In total. This is (according to an online value of money calculator) about £13.

BathwaterBaby · 28/07/2021 13:32

I paid a local teenager £40 for 5 hours which I felt was maybe on the stingy side but she was thrilled and is desperate to do it again, her mum was asking too so clearly felt it appropriate. Unfortunately I can't usually afford to go out but have recommended her to friends at her request. £15 is absolutely insane.

glitterelf · 28/07/2021 13:15

I personally wouldn't use an under 18 to babysit and certainly wouldn't want someone who isn't trained in paediatric first aid. As you already use somebody with all the relevant training why not just stick to them ?

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 28/07/2021 13:13

I wouldn't encourage my kids to take a minimum wage either, unless it really brings something to their cvs, they need to aim higher

You're effectively encouraging them to be unemployed then. And also potentially committing yourself to funding them semi-indefinitely. A candidate with experience stocking shelves, working a checkout, bussing tables, or staffing a kids holiday club is a much more attractive prospect to someone recruiting for a "proper" entry level job with prospects than someone who has never worked. Those graduates getting shiny jobs in the City and large corporates are getting them in part on the skills and references they earned at minimum wage.

Flowerlane · 28/07/2021 13:06

Our local page has had local teenagers posting offering babysitting services recently. They are charging between £10-15 per hour. People are biting their hand off, they are now fully booked.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 28/07/2021 13:02

YANBU OP and these teenagers may well find that nobody is willing to pay £15/hr. But I don’t blame them for trying! It’s entrepreneurial…
I’ve used a couple of local teenage babysitters (aged 15/16). One asked for £6/hr - so when she did 3 hours I rounded it up and gave her £20. Another suggested £8. She was also with my children for 3 hours, but that involved putting a 6 and 9 year old to bed. I gave her £30 and her Mum (who I know) texted me after to complain I’d given her too much!!
So I guess everyone has different expectations, but I certainly wouldn’t think any teenagers around here get more than £10/hr and more likely to be around £8/hr.

Many adults with qualifications don’t earn £15/hr for daytime work, so it would seem bizarre to pay this for teenagers watching TV!

SoniaD · 28/07/2021 13:01

We pay our teenage babysitters £10/hour for our 3 children when they are awake. Between £5-7/hour when they are sleeping but I usually round it up so it always ends up closer to 10.

We also have an older babysitter who is a qualified teacher and she has always charged £10/hour if they are awake or asleep (which is more than fair!).

The kids do prefer the younger babysitters because they play with them more and I think these girls are worth every penny :)

thisgirlrides · 28/07/2021 13:01

I'm a childminder and I charge £12 an hour minimum charge £30 and my teenage son babysits and charges £7 an hour minimum £20 (snacks always welcome!) This seems to be fairly standard round my area although I am thinking about putting my rates up to £15 as I do sometimes regret giving up an evening for £30! No way would I pay a teenager £15 an hour!!

Rather than responding to ads, why not post yourself stating the rate, minimum payment and snacks included - I bet you'll be inundated with offers as so many teenagers around at the moment & all seem to want to earn some money but are struggling to get jobs

pleasedonttextmyman · 28/07/2021 12:59

On threads like this, you can still a lot of resentment about paying people for "sitting on the sofa". Well, you are free to offer your services too. It costs what it costs. Seeing people resenting others is a good lesson for kids too.

Around here, you'd struggle to find a babysitter for less than £10 an hour. Supply and demand.

You wouldn't find a cleaner for £5 an hour either, and that's not a bad thing.

pleasedonttextmyman · 28/07/2021 12:57

Conversely I think it’s an excellent idea to encourage your teenagers to work and a minimum wage job is just the incentive needed for them to try harder with their education. Any job is also excellent to learn employment skills and often come with a social life.

I disagree

they are in competition with people with superb cv, and it's their own interest to go for the best they can from a young age.
Of course they work, but not for peanuts unless it's a specific interest. It's not all about the money, it's about the big picture.

There's "crap jobs" and crap jobs.. and it's insulting to pretend you have to go the the lowest possible job to get some ambition.

CaptSkippy · 28/07/2021 12:56

They can ask whatever the want and you can hire whomever you want. If you find their rates to high, get someone else. They learn soon enough if they aren't getting any jobs. Then again, perhaps babysitters are in high demand and they can ask these high rates and still get jobs. In which case the qualified cm are getting stiffed.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/07/2021 12:48

@MereDintofPandiculation

but £5 an hour is a joke. Minimum wage for an under 18 year old is £4.62 an hour.
Yes, but they are restricted to no more than 2 hours a day on school days and Sundays, and not after 7pm at all.

So expecting a babysitter to work from 7pm until 11pm (for example) is completely outside the remit of legal employment for 16 year olds.

So the market determines the rate because you're already taking them outside legal protections.

Seems only fair to pay them extra for the unsociable hours and for the advantage they give the person who wants to save money and go out. Same way that somebody who pays a 16 year old to look after their children for more than four hours without an hour break is breaking the laws on child employment.

I don't think adults should exploit the existence of NMW to justify paying 16 year olds so little when that NMW comes with legal obligations on the part of the person paying.

AfternoonToffee · 28/07/2021 12:44

I babysat many years ago for a doctor, often he was also on call and I was left instructions on how to contact his pager if needed.

So all this "what about if X happens, so they should be paid y" doesn't cut much muster with me.

£8 a hour tops, so £25 for 3 hours (rounding up)

Imapotato · 28/07/2021 12:40

@pleasedonttextmyman

Imapotato

by being taken for a mug, I mean accepting a ridiculously low rate. £5 an hour is nowhere near enough.

(on a side note, I wouldn't encourage my kids to take a minimum wage either, unless it really brings something to their cvs, they need to aim higher)

I disagree completely.

Working crappy low wage jobs as students will make them want to aim higher and do better for themselves. Dd1 is 16 and has a low wage, part time job (which she found herself). It’s definitely made her realise she wants more from her career in the future.

And I wouldn’t be paying a teen more than £20 for an evening to sit on the sofa, eat and watch tv while my kids slept. Asking patents to fork out more is just pure greed.

FreeBritnee · 28/07/2021 12:38

That’s a nice argument @pleasedonttextmyman 🙄