Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this lack of flexibility is just ridiculous?

218 replies

Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 08:59

Have a bit of a predicament. There is a lot going on here at the moment.

Seven years ago my dad died very suddenly, and he left a flat he bought to my brother and I. In that time, to be fair we’ve never had any problems letting it out as it’s a lovely property in a good location. However, we did get a bit stung a while ago and somehow ended up owing money to the local council.

I rang them and gave them my address and asked for a form to be sent to allow us arrangement to pay, as I was about to leave my job.

Unfortunately they sent it to the flat instead. I forgot about it (which I recognise is my error.) We then got contact from bailiffs who absolutely wouldn’t discuss any flexibility. They decided on a minimum amount p/m and it’s pretty high for me at the moment. And I genuinely don’t know how I’m going to afford it this month (not a begging thread.)

I am due back to work next month. AIBU to think more flexibility should be granted? And my main question is where I stand legally.

OP posts:
giletrouge · 28/07/2021 12:15

Realistically by the time my brother has been tracked down

Whoooooa - are you saying you don't know where your brother is? The brother who's receiving ALL the profit from the property YOU'VE gone into debt for?

You know what they say OP - that is quite the massive drip feed!
And don't say it's not relevant because it really is. You basically want to magic up a solution that doesn't exist because you've got into a godawful mess you don't want to discuss here. No-one can help you unless you face the facts. I'm really sorry and I know you're suffering but you're not helping yourself or looking at this properly.

canigooutyet · 28/07/2021 12:10

You should contact your brother and tell him that the current arrangement is not sustainable. THere is a current outstanding council tax bill that realistically you both owe.
What happens if the current tenants run off leaving other unpaid utilities? If something needs repairing?
THis is why many landlords rent with council tax included to prevent them being taken to court as they pay directly.

MyFartWillGoOn · 28/07/2021 12:07

OP you've got a wealth of really great advice on here but I'm not sure what else MN can offer?

You say you've tried CAB, step change etc.

Have you joined the FB group that's been mentioned?

Have you asked the bailiffs for a statement of accounts to check they aren't overcharging you?

Have you asked for their bank details to make a payment?

Have you tried reaching out to your brother and asking, in this instance, if he can contribute a bit?

Have you got things you could sell to raise the funds?

Have you emailed the bailiffs stating you are trying to make a payment of XX but they aren't giving you details so you have a paper trail?

Have you tried going onto money saving expert as suggested?

As I said, loads of great advice but you seem to be focusing on what you can't do rather than the helpful suggestions you've had.

HasaDigaEebowai · 28/07/2021 12:07

The problem you have is that bailiffs will have been told by the court to recover (and you're a second property owner and so hardly seem like a needy case).

You need to have the money available to make payment in order to prevent the bailiffs entering. Presumably the debt is in joint names though and so your brother is equally likely to have to deal with the bailiffs?

Wishingwell75 · 28/07/2021 12:05

The OP hasn't once said she doesn't think she has to pay.
She's saying she can't pay at this moment in time but will be able to when she starts work.
Her point is that council tax debt is the only debt that you can still go to prison for not paying ( that is not what's going to happen) but it's also the most difficult to sort out because the companies the council's use are totally inflexible.
I think things need to change because I have seen working families who are on the bones of their arse and having to use food banks being hassled by very large unpleasant men - honestly think of the worst club bouncer and multiply them by ten! It sounds cliché but I think the job attracts a certain type of person, you'd have to be because I don't imagine it's that well paid.
I have dealt with 3 different councils and maybe 6 different debt collection companies and they were all almost identical!
Unless you have had the misfortune to deal with them, it's difficult to understand how rigid they can be and also how scary.

sleepygnome · 28/07/2021 12:05

You own half a flat that you normally rent out yet you can't afford to pay a debt? Just sell the flat or put the rent you currently get from letting it out towards the debt.

Ladyformation · 28/07/2021 11:57

I had a (somewhat) similar situation and Council Tax Advisors www.counciltaxadvisors.co.uk/ who were amazing. They communicated with the bailiffs, set up a payment plan which was genuinely affordable, got me back in touch with the council directly and generally just calmed down a really stressful situation. They also made sure I was only paying the correct amount as the bailiffs did try to overcharge me and the council didn't correct this when the bill was passed back. Couldn't recommend them more if the service is still the same. It was all free too. Best of luck.

Viviennemary · 28/07/2021 11:55

But the point is you have an asset but are refusing to pay a debt. I don't think courts will look favourably upon this kind of debt on a second home. There is no reason you can't get a loan. Bailiffs and taken to court will be extremely bad against your credit rating. You simply are not taking it seriously.

Elnetthairnet · 28/07/2021 11:55

Think in your position if I couldn’t get the cash any other way I’d sell my car myself and pay off the whole balance, then when I was working buy another one. Anything to get the bailiffs off my back. I’d not be considering defaulting on a debt.

Elnetthairnet · 28/07/2021 11:52

I still just don’t get it. Your minimum payment is £160, and you can’t afford it this month but soon will be able to pay the whole thing off. So what CAN you pay out of the £160, and how can you get the rest - either from your brother who seems to be profiting from this property and giving you nothing, family, friends, selling something, pawning something, getting another credit card, increasing the credit limit on your current card, short term loan…just exactly how much do you need to find because it seems like the whole thing is a bit of a non issue. You’re worried they’ll take your car but you won’t try to get the money any way you can just to pay them off? Makes no sense.

DanielTigersMummy21 · 28/07/2021 11:51

Why can't you get a loan? You own a second property so you have lots of equity. Council tax is to pay for vital public services, why do you feel that others should subsidise your contribution as a property owner.

Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 11:51

I can’t magic money @Viviennemary

Realistically by the time my brother has been tracked down, forced to sell, the property sold and the money gone to this debt we are probably looking at several months by which point I am working. So that’s a rather daft bit of advice.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 28/07/2021 11:49

No. You need to settle the debt as a priority. Get a loan and get it paid off. Or sell the property if you can't afford the upkeep.

sopositivelynegative · 28/07/2021 11:46

Suggest you ask for practical advice here: forums.moneysavingexpert.com/categories/debt-free-wannabe

Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 11:45

They aren’t interested @AwaAnBileYerHeid

They’ve set a minimum and I have to pay it. Apparently!

OP posts:
AwaAnBileYerHeid · 28/07/2021 11:45

Sorry just missed your update about step change.. although they could help you with a budgeting plan and advice on how to deal with bailiffs maybe?

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 28/07/2021 11:44

Get a budget planner online and list all your income and outgoings. Give this to them and show them what you can realistically afford. If its for council tax debt though, shouldn't the tenants be liable? Also contact a debt company, many stepchange or the likes. My concern would be additional bailiff and court fees.

Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 11:43

That’s exactly it @Wishingwell75 although step change can’t really help, it’s not that sort of debt really.

OP posts:
EvilPea · 28/07/2021 11:41

@gogohm

You need to borrow the money and pay it back, you are in debt and have been for a long time as they don't go to the bailiffs quickly. Your credit rating is being trashed by this, a normal loans is far better
In my case it took over ten years for the letters to find me. So I didn’t know I was in debt. At that point it had gone through courts and bailiffs without my knowledge
Wishingwell75 · 28/07/2021 11:41

I honestly think Councils should take more responsibility for the vile bully boy tactics these companies use.
In helping clients through my work I've had the misfortune to deal with them and they act like you've taken their own money!
It's scary - they want you to feel intimidated. They apply pressure in the hope you can just go to a friend and borrow the money!
During lockdown they backed off but seem to be back with a vengeance.
The council refuse to deal with you, the head office insist you deal with the baliffs!
Ok, but if you haven't got it, you haven't got it.
Firstly, stepchange are very good, so call them, also the FB page pp mentioned.
The very best outcome would be for it to be returned to the council or even go back to court.
Unless you do have good you could sell to cover the bill and buy again when you get sorted..
Sorry not much help but it's a horrible thing to deal with, it's the intimidation that gets me, in any other scenario you'd be calling the police on them!

EvilPea · 28/07/2021 11:40

Your brother should be responsible for 50% of the council tax debt

She’s solely and jointly responsible for it. They went after the op as she’s the one who was employed so they stand a better chance of getting it back. I had the same with my ex. The debt is now completely ops.
It’s irrelevant if they “should” be jointly liable. They aren’t.

gogohm · 28/07/2021 11:40

You need to borrow the money and pay it back, you are in debt and have been for a long time as they don't go to the bailiffs quickly. Your credit rating is being trashed by this, a normal loans is far better

EvilPea · 28/07/2021 11:37

@Sweetwatermelons

Oh they are so that’s helpful. Thanks.
Please google that to check it’s true though!

It’s so fucking stressful isn’t it. For you it’s basically £200 you need, it’s fuck all in the scheme of things isn’t it.

curiouscatgotkilled · 28/07/2021 11:35

contact StepChange they are great, and so helpful. they will be able to give you good advice and may be able to talk to the debt collectors for you.

StrawberryShortcakeAndTea · 28/07/2021 11:35

Just to straighten it out, so I’m clear on the situation.

You and your brother own the flat 50/50.
It has tenants who are paying rent.
But you aren’t getting any of the rent? Your brother is getting 100% of the rent and that’s his only source of income?
You are paying the council tax debt, 100% of the debt yourself?

Honestly, Personal situations don’t matter. The flat is 50% yours and you should be getting 50% of the rent, even if you are just saving it to cover future expenses like a new boiler or repairs.

Your brother should be responsible for 50% of the council tax debt.

The debt should be paid out of the rent money.