Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this lack of flexibility is just ridiculous?

218 replies

Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 08:59

Have a bit of a predicament. There is a lot going on here at the moment.

Seven years ago my dad died very suddenly, and he left a flat he bought to my brother and I. In that time, to be fair we’ve never had any problems letting it out as it’s a lovely property in a good location. However, we did get a bit stung a while ago and somehow ended up owing money to the local council.

I rang them and gave them my address and asked for a form to be sent to allow us arrangement to pay, as I was about to leave my job.

Unfortunately they sent it to the flat instead. I forgot about it (which I recognise is my error.) We then got contact from bailiffs who absolutely wouldn’t discuss any flexibility. They decided on a minimum amount p/m and it’s pretty high for me at the moment. And I genuinely don’t know how I’m going to afford it this month (not a begging thread.)

I am due back to work next month. AIBU to think more flexibility should be granted? And my main question is where I stand legally.

OP posts:
giletrouge · 28/07/2021 14:06

Why not a loan? It's a very small amount and in two months you can pay it off. I think it's been suggested a lot of times by many posters and you have not yet said why you can't.

Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 14:03

That’s been covered @DanielTigersMummy21

If you don’t want to rtft click on Show OPs posts.

OP posts:
Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 14:03

I said proper advice. That’s not meant to state that the above isn’t intended helpfully but the way it was phrased made me think the poster was referring to something official. Tbh the options above aren’t workable apart from the FB group as explained already.

OP posts:
DanielTigersMummy21 · 28/07/2021 14:02

I wonder if OP gives flexibility to her tenants if they can't afford their monthly rent?

m0therofdragons · 28/07/2021 13:56

Can you pay on a credit card with 0% interest for 12 months?

giletrouge · 28/07/2021 13:53

What proper advice?
Short term - take out a very small loan and pay your debt.
Long term - get disentangled from your brother and being a landlord - have this as an aim.

MyFartWillGoOn · 28/07/2021 13:53

@Sweetwatermelons

What proper advice? Sorry not being obtuse. I can’t sell the property.
OP you've had SOOOO much other advice

...Facebook group
....sell some things
....ask your bro for contribution this month
....email bailiffs asking for bank details and pay small amount so paper trail
....money saving expert

I could go on....

Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 13:48

What proper advice? Sorry not being obtuse. I can’t sell the property.

OP posts:
newnortherner111 · 28/07/2021 13:46

Take proper advice as suggested. Also going forward try not to get yourself in a position that you cannot meet any sudden expenditure, recognising that may not be easy short-term.

Sweetwatermelons · 28/07/2021 13:33

If people are confused I’m sorry to hear that but I do think I’ve answered everything.

It’s perfectly fine that there isn’t a solution. I have every intention of paying but this month, well, I can’t. People saying to sell the property and that I have this as an asset isn’t practical because the time it would take to sell it, even if I had sole ownership, would mean it took a lot longer than a month! So I’m not sure why people are insisting that this is the best way!

OP posts:
Buggerthebotox · 28/07/2021 13:15

www.nationaldebtline.org/fact-sheet-library/council-tax-arrears-ew/

Take a look through this information sheet (sorry if not clicky) and take proper advice from Stepchange, National Debtline or another debt charity.

TrueRefuge · 28/07/2021 13:08

I won't add to the actual debt advice, but I'm confused. You jointly own the property with your brother and are presumably listed on the deeds? But he's leaving you to deal with the debt? Why aren't the council chasing him for the CT as well? Have bailiffs visited his property? Have you spoken to him about this situation ? I think going forward you need to consider whether it is worthwhile for you to be associated with the property? From what you've hinted at, your brother isn't contactable so when he decides to sell, who's to say you get any money? I'm just confused by the value you're getting from being associated with this property.

Do you have 8 people you could borrow £20 each from? I know it's not ideal but seems a simple solution...?

Could you sell something worth about £200? Surely you have some way to rustle up this money?

MadinMarch · 28/07/2021 13:08

*Oh I haven’t ignored it at all - as soon as I was aware there was a problem I called them and I was told the absolute minimum they could accept was £160 (it’s actually just over that - about £163) over six months.

I just honestly don’t get how this is acceptable or legal, I mean, it just seems crazy to me.*

It's not really crazy...
As a landlord, or even a non landlord did you really not know that you'd be responsible for council tax if your rental property was unoccupied.
I can't help but think you should have been more proactive when the last tenant moved out, and contated the council yourself to arrange payments.
Is the property rented out again now? If so, I suggest you put money aside for a future void periods, before you and your brother spend the profits from the rent each month.

rosinavera · 28/07/2021 12:56

@Dozer

YABU to have been so passive. Find a way to pay up.
Helpful!!
NiceTwin · 28/07/2021 12:51

Get your db to pay this month, he is taking the piss.
100% of the rental income, he should do his bit.

Dozer · 28/07/2021 12:42

YABU to have been so passive. Find a way to pay up.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 28/07/2021 12:36

My reading of this that the OP does not have a great relationship with her DB or there is some other issue that means dealing with him is not an option.

OP try the Facebook groups mentioned. Make sure you have a clear statement of your financial position.

What is the shortfall this month and what will it be by the time you can pay more?

You need to create a paper trail to the bailiffs of your current financial situation and why their plan is unaffordable. Propose what you can realistically pay.

If your DP’s car is not in your name then they can’t take it in satisfaction of your debt.

majesticallyawkward · 28/07/2021 12:35

My understanding is a bailiff can only take property to the value of the debt, so assuming your cars are worth more than the outstanding balance they shouldn't be seized.

On the payments, it's a tough one because as long as you pay something it should be accepted. I suspected the online payments are set up the way they are to get people to pay more because the bailiff will make money based on debt recovered.

Have you actually spoken to them or just tried the online payment system? I get the council not discussing it as essentially it's out of their hands now it's been handed over. The advice to speak to step change is good, do contact them.
Other than that is a bank loan an option? If you aren't approved is your dp? I can access a loan of £75k via the banking app for example. Even anti debt surely your dp would rather have a small loan for a couple of months that you repay early than bailiffs at the door and potential CCJs.

You say there is a backstory could you approach your brother to pay something towards even just this month, if it's £163 could you half it or he top up what you can't?

Iquitit · 28/07/2021 12:35

I've been in a similar situation and I sympathise because no, there is no flexibility.

I paid by standing order, a small weekly amount, directly to the council until I could afford more, they wouldn't speak to me, kept directing me to the bailiffs, but I don't think they should be refusing payment, though they do, to force you into dealing with bailiffs.
I got the payment details from my council tax bill and just paid weekly what I could afford until I could up it, sent an email saying what I was doing and I didn't deal with the bailiffs at all. I didn't ignore it, and I did pay, and although the council wouldn't accept a lower payment or talk to me directly, they couldn't stop me paying directly into their bank account or sending them an email (so I had proof) explaining my circumstances and what I was paying and when.
It worked for me as the council took back the debt and I deal with them now, pay them directly and bailiffs aren't involved.
I'd urge you to seek advice though, citizens advice I found wanted me to deal with the bailiffs, which I wasn't going to do having been stung by them before, I spoke to a few different places and found a site called Legal Beagles and money saving expert which really knew their stuff and helped, you really need advice before you do anything, anything except pay something that is, pay something, anything, today by bank transfer or standing order.

They won't not pursue this because you're telling them you can pay in a month or 2 months time, they might even believe you, but they still will pursue the debt while it's outstanding and no payment arrangements are in place - from their pov you haven't shown that you are going to pay this by even making small but regular payments to 'show willing' as it were. I get that it's crap, and I know how frustrating it is when you just hit a dead end from the council "We aren't dealing with you at all" and from the bailiffs "Pay it or we're taking your stuff" when you don't have the means to pay it, but this is unfortunately how it is and by not paying anything for the next couple of months, the situation will get worse and not better, I've been there.
The Facebook group, mse, and legal beagles are good places to start with regards to your rights regarding the bailiffs too and rights of entry etc.

OhGiveUp · 28/07/2021 12:31

The bailiffs cannot remove anything that doesn't belong to you personally, such as anything that is rented or on HP.
So for example, if you're buying a car on a finance plan or a TV is rented then they cannot take those items.
A vehicle log book unfortunately, isn't proof of ownership.

F107 · 28/07/2021 12:31

I can understand why the council are being what you deem as "inflexible". They tried to work with you in the first place and you didn't enage, so its understandable they are being tough on you now.

You state you'd stuggle to get a loan, but, I'm sure a payday loan company would be able to set in.

I've had a quick look at Fast Loan UK, if you borrowed £160 and paid it back in 28days you'd be paying £195.84. If I were in your shoes I'd take the £45.84 hit so you can move on with your life.

ivykaty44 · 28/07/2021 12:24

I just don’t see why some flexibility can’t be applied to the situation, given that my financial circumstances are currently dire but are about to improve. I sound really whiny there but it does baffle me.

you were offered a payment plan by the council

they sent the letters etc to the flat - but you knew there was a payment plan in place and didn't follow this up or make payments online, over the phone etc

council tax is a demand and not a debt or bill - and as far as tax goes its a demand that has to be paid and ignorance isn't counted as an excuse (rightly or wrongly that is how the system works)

you had the flexibility of the payment plan and you defaulted - so the council tax was taken to court and a liability order on it, you still didn't pay though and so the council then at this stage send to bailiffs

now all of a sudden you want flexibility as its gone to bailiffs

you have the income from a second property, whats happening to that income between you and your brother?

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 28/07/2021 12:23

It sounds like you are not really interested in finding ways to pay your debt but only in ways to delay the payment. This is the issue IMO.

You could

  • get a loan and pay it back next month as you say you will have the cash.
  • ask your brother to pay out of the money he receives from the property.
  • cut down on other expenses this month and pay.

But basically, you are a home owner (two properties if I understand correctly?), who is at fault of not paying council tax, just take responsibility instead of saying it is unfair.

A single mum who has nothing to her name, someone who suddenly can’t work due to illness, someone recently widowed, of course there should be ways to delay payments as they genuinely can’t pay even in good faith. In your case not so much.

HasaDigaEebowai · 28/07/2021 12:21

You don’t seem to want help OP, you seem to want someone to say you don’t have to pay the debt you owe. It isn’t going to happen.

starfishmummy · 28/07/2021 12:20

I just don’t see why some flexibility can’t be applied to the situation,

But it already has been with the payment plan.