Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Creepy camera in the house

141 replies

chnahingnameagain · 28/07/2021 02:38

At my in-laws house last week I noticed a camera in the main family room, I felt very uncomfortable once I noticed it as I didn't know if am being recorded, it was facing the direction am sitting.
For context, my sil, Bil (both are dh siblings) and mil live in the house along with sil's dd. Dd is 9 years old.
Upon seeing it I didn't ask mil anything as most likely she won't have a clue about it, sil and bil (will call him Pete) were not home.
At the moment my other Bil (will Call him Dave)and his family have come over to stay at mil house, we went over and I noticed the camera is turned on, it records everything on to a sd card, (I looked up the camera model and description)
I asked about the camera and was told it's to keep an eye on sil's dd, sil works from home, that's fine they want to use it as a nanny cam or whatever, but here is my aibu why is the camera left turned on when everyone else is around at the house, we've had quite a few family gatherings in the last two weeks, and just makes no sense to leave the camera on. Why not have it turned off? It's recording all our conversations, myself and daves wife were having a private convo, we forgot about the camera and at the time didn't know it's always turned on, we are both extremely annoyed that we were not informed about a camera being there and recording everything. When everyone is around it is a complete invasion of privacy to keep the camera on. There's just no need as dd isn't on her own and sil isn't working now.
From what Pete said, it seems the camera will remain turned on and that's that.
Pete has form for being nosey and going through other siblings private mssgs and emails, So I very much can see him playing back the footage to see what we spoke about, yes he has a lot of time on his hands!
On the day I noticed the camera, I had a new handbag, sil was working upstairs so I didn't see her, a few days later she asked me about that bag, I asked her has she seen the bag as I don't remember having the bag with me when I last saw her, her face froze and she stopped saying anything , I realised she must've viewed me in the camera with the handbag!

Do we have a right to be annoyed? Especially seen as they never informed us we are being recorded? Or it's their house and entitled to keep it on permanently?

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 03/08/2021 09:59

My DD has a friend has one set up in the kitchen on a shelf, apparently it is for security reasons and faces the patio doors to detect any break ins; I think it is intrusive and others do. They don't mind sharing their data with all sorts of apps and gadgets but they can't share mine so I don't allow my DD to go around there anymore. It is not just the camera it is their approach to these things, for example, letting my DD use a silly photo app without my permission when she was young.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/08/2021 09:45

@WomanStanleyWoman

I would be having some very interesting conversations in front of this camera. Perhaps along the lines of ‘So Pete STILL doesn’t know?! He spends all this time watching everyone in this house, but hasn’t watched his own wife long enough to know she’s cheated with half the street? What a sap’.
Well that wouldn't be very helpful to a wife married to a man who is clearly a controlling arsehole, would it?
JustLyra · 03/08/2021 09:36

@WomanStanleyWoman

I would be having some very interesting conversations in front of this camera. Perhaps along the lines of ‘So Pete STILL doesn’t know?! He spends all this time watching everyone in this house, but hasn’t watched his own wife long enough to know she’s cheated with half the street? What a sap’.
Winding him up is one thing, but I really wouldn’t make jokes like that.

If he’s not controlling, and potentially abusive, toward his wife I’ll eat my hat.

WomanStanleyWoman · 03/08/2021 09:25

I would be having some very interesting conversations in front of this camera. Perhaps along the lines of ‘So Pete STILL doesn’t know?! He spends all this time watching everyone in this house, but hasn’t watched his own wife long enough to know she’s cheated with half the street? What a sap’.

WomanStanleyWoman · 03/08/2021 09:11

@MotionActivatedDog

It's his mum's house?

Exactly. It’s not his. His mums opinion is what matters.

Then by that token, the OP’s opinion doesn’t matter either.
StrangeToSee · 03/08/2021 09:11

I would have a huge issue being watched by my husband when he wasn't in the house!!

I would too if I hadn’t agreed to it. But the baby-cam was on the cot and made a noise if it swivelled around. So if I was in the room say bf DD on the chair or bed near the cot he’d speak through the monitor first and ask if I was there, and if I was happy for him to watch us he’d pan it round so he could see us. I didn’t think anything of it, as we could chat through it and it meant he could see our DD while he was at work. Guess I felt less alone too. The only time he might have seen me without me noticing was if I’d been changing the cot sheets or bending over the cot, which he’d see normally when he was home so it didn’t feel odd.

Plus I also had the app on my phone so had a live stream of her in the cot eg if I went into another room I could keep watch over her via the monitor, or even bring up the monitor screen on the smart TV so I could play with my phone/cook/clean while she slept.

billy1966 · 03/08/2021 09:07

Your MIL doesn't know?
Have they moved into HER house?

Watching a 9 year old all the time?
Camera in her bedroom?

Concerning for your MIL.

Age Action might be worth a call.
Your MIL is entitled to her privacy in HER home.

MzHz · 03/08/2021 09:00

I feel sorry for you all op. Not one person has the temerity to stand up for themselves and their wife etc and tell this creep that he can ftfo with his spy cam

Why on earth are you not skimming this picture frame out of the door?

Bollindger · 03/08/2021 08:47

Why are you not messing with his head.
Take bag , hid under camera, show nothing, say your rich, but your not sharing, that he will NEVER find out that he owned it, but your gonna keep the money.

GoingGently · 03/08/2021 08:40

@StrangeToSee

Many people have movement sensitive cameras that live stream so they can check on the empty house when they’re out (security), or keep an eye on elderly parents in case they fall, or monitor kids from another room. Or keep an eye on babysitters/au pairs. Usually they only record movement not audio so private conversations won’t be listened into.

Are you sure it’s recording all the time or is it just left on because it’s difficult to re-boot/re-set if they turn it off completely?

I wouldn’t be bothered by one in a lounge provided it was visible not carefully disguised and discovered by chance. Obviously in a bedroom or bathroom it’s an invasion of privacy. Saying that when DD was tiny DH used to check on us through the baby cam on his phone at work (but he said hello and we’d chat so it didn’t feel like being spied on!) plus it was focused on her cot so he could check in and look at his new daughter sleeping.

I would have a huge issue being watched by my husband when he wasn't in the house!!
StrangeToSee · 03/08/2021 08:19

Many people have movement sensitive cameras that live stream so they can check on the empty house when they’re out (security), or keep an eye on elderly parents in case they fall, or monitor kids from another room. Or keep an eye on babysitters/au pairs. Usually they only record movement not audio so private conversations won’t be listened into.

Are you sure it’s recording all the time or is it just left on because it’s difficult to re-boot/re-set if they turn it off completely?

I wouldn’t be bothered by one in a lounge provided it was visible not carefully disguised and discovered by chance. Obviously in a bedroom or bathroom it’s an invasion of privacy. Saying that when DD was tiny DH used to check on us through the baby cam on his phone at work (but he said hello and we’d chat so it didn’t feel like being spied on!) plus it was focused on her cot so he could check in and look at his new daughter sleeping.

3scape · 03/08/2021 08:10

Can you not just turn it off or remove it yourself? Though I'd definitely be meeting elsewhere with the MIL and be explicit you don't want Pete with his lack of boundaries recording you or going through your emails Why on earth does anyone just accept he's like this? It's controlling abusive and breach of trust, I'd be cutting him out of my life completely

GoingGently · 03/08/2021 08:02

I think you're being far too polite about this. I'd go ballistic!

If I were you I'd demand that he destroys all recorded footage of you and that he never films you again. Within your rights for a private surveillance camera I believe. Perhaps GDPR or other but you do have rights

BlackAlys · 03/08/2021 06:46

@ShitPoetryClub

Pete is as creepy as fuck. In what realm does anyone think its OK for him to film his 9 year old niece?
This, 100%
Themeparklover · 03/08/2021 04:22

I lived in a house share with my ex where the two homeowners lied saying they had a 'pet camera' up but would bring up conversations we had privately in the day with each other and were extremely creepy towards my ex partner , we had a 6 month contract and moved out after 3.5 months thank god

Kokeshi123 · 03/08/2021 04:16

MIL is clearly very naive and does not understand what is going on here. This is her house, right? Makes me wonder what else they are doing in there.

alexdgr8 · 03/08/2021 00:45

why do you continue meeting in that house.

Sparklfairy · 03/08/2021 00:36

And you all just sat there and let him turn the camera back round and order you all not to touch it?

That is the point you say "pete, I don't want to be filmed. The camera goes off and you can turn it back on when we leave."

Or just take a pair of scissors to the power cord.

ShitPoetryClub · 03/08/2021 00:28

Pete is as creepy as fuck.
In what realm does anyone think its OK for him to film his 9 year old niece?

worldandsky · 03/08/2021 00:04

I'M THE OP, I HAVE NAME CHANGED

so I went round to my in-laws yesterday, in the room where the camera is, was myself, two sil and bil (not Pete) so 4 of us in the room. Mid conversation i got up and turned the camera to face the wall, within seconds before I could even go back to sit down the camera was turning itself to face us again, was remotely being turned to face us, it wasn't able to fully turn to face the whole room so PETE came in the room and he actually said I've been notified someone is messing with my camera, (camera is linked to his phone) proceeded to walk in the direction of the camera, put the camera back to its original position and said leave the camera like this. And walked out!!!
I think we were all shocked and speechless!! Moments later bil that's in the room with us said it's not right that the camera is there recording everything and that there's no way us ladies could speak privately with a camera there. Obviously no one will say that to Pete. Bil covered the camera by placing a object in front of it. Few minutes later Pete came in the room, acting like he's looking for something, I think he just came in to see what's blocking the camera.

PerciphonePuma · 28/07/2021 23:22

@Hallyup6 Skip to 1:46

PerciphonePuma · 28/07/2021 23:18

@chnahingnameagain Does your MIL seriously not know that it's possible to film people?! Hmm Surely she remembers Camcorders?!?! She cannot possibly be too old to remember them? If she does, then just say it's like a mini-Camcorder which is recording in her living room all the time

Lou98 · 28/07/2021 22:49

@Bitofachinwag

people we have in our house really aren't all that interesting The point isn't whether your guests are "interesting". It's a breach of privacy. Do you know for a fact that your guests know that you are recording sound and picture at all times?

Yes actually I do, like I say it's in plain sight and we only have a select few people who are in the house who are all aware and have seen the set up on our phones etc. Like I said in my post, they are aware

Blondeshavemorefun · 28/07/2021 22:47

I didn’t think camera were allowed to record sound

Not nanny ones

Invasion of privacy

So can see but not hear

Maybe a quick pretend bonk on their sofa will make them turn it off

Or turn it round /cover it with towel when there next

Bitofachinwag · 28/07/2021 22:46

people we have in our house really aren't all that interesting
The point isn't whether your guests are "interesting". It's a breach of privacy. Do you know for a fact that your guests know that you are recording sound and picture at all times?