Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents and property

237 replies

Fedduup32 · 28/07/2021 00:29

Please be kind I’m not in a good place at the moment mentally.

In my early 20’s my parents put a rental property in my name. Not all as good as it sounds. I’m in my 40’s now and because of this property was unable to get first time buyers mortgage when I was looking for my own place so didn’t get a good deal that I could have.

Over the years whenever I bring up any conversation it ends in my mum screaming at me and threatening to put the property in one of my siblings name instead. I’m really upset as I came to visit my mum with kids and mentioned our flat is too small and I would love to get a bigger place and asked her if i sold the property how much would I get so could use as a deposit so I can get a nicer place. She got unreasonable again which resulted in me screaming at her too, not a nice thing to be honest. In the end I managed to get info from her that the rental gets £70 profit a month so in 20 years of this I asked her if I can have my money and she starts screaming at me.

After a lot of shouting today I finally learnt truth from her that she only made me buy the property as her accountant told her it will make more sense money wise to put in one of the kids name as they would have to pay tax etc. I feel really used by her but also guilty that she’s my mum but I feel sad that she never thinks about me or any repercussions it has had in my future finances and opportunities.

She doesn’t even clearly talk to me about anything to do with the property. I don’t even know if it was hers first then she put in my name for tax or first time buyers rate. I just get made to feel unreasonable if I ask any questions. My siblings were there today as well and they made me feel I am causing trouble but also admitted they glad she didn’t put in their name as they would have missed out on first time buyers with their property. I just wa t answers from her but she threatens all sorts.

I’m lying here feeling bad I brought up the topic but why can’t she just have a conversation with me about it. I don’t know what she’s hiding as she gets defensive.

OP posts:
SilverOtter · 28/07/2021 09:42

What your parents are doing is financial abuse and it is ILLEGAL. Report them!

raydensolicitors.co.uk/blog/financial-abuse/

endofthelinefinally · 28/07/2021 09:40

Speak to citizen's advice first.
Your parents have used you to facilitate tax fraud, but it will be difficult to prove you are not complicit.
You will have to pay CGT when you sell the property, but that is really not a big deal, it is the fraud aspect and tax evasion that is the real problem.
CGT is about 20% and there is no tax payable on the first 11K, as far as I remember.
There must be paperwork relating to the renting out and mortgage payments. Do your parents have an accountant or a managing agent for the property?
You will need proper legal advice but CAB should be able to help you sort this out in your head first. Your parents cannot sell or give the property to anyone else. Don't sign anything they ask you to to sign.

If it is a buy to let mortgage you will have to pay it all back to the lender, but there should be some equity in the property.
You will need proof that your parents are keeping the rent though because of the tax fraud.
Don't let this go on any longer.

NotImpossible · 28/07/2021 09:39

It's not just tax here - as a landlord you have legal obligations to the tenants and failure to comply with these can have serious consequences. You really need to get the legals sorted asap and check that your parents have sone the relevant safety checks, deposit protections etc. I'd agree that legal advice and getting together whatever information you can needs to take priority. Your family is going to try to block this so you need to act without involving them.

JoborPlay · 28/07/2021 09:36

You need to seek legal advice on this because willingly or not you may be colluding in tax evasion. I know that this wasn't your intention and I know you had little choice but being controlled is not a legal defense and could seriously impact you.

You also need some mental health support die to the control and abuse you've suffered.

Personally I would sign over the house back to them and go NC, but easier said than done.

OhNoNoNoNoNo · 28/07/2021 09:36

As with many PPs have said you need to see a solicetor or accountant. My first step would be to establish what all the facts actually are. If then prepare a statement showing exactly how and why this arrangement is not ok - you need facts and figures.
For example rather than vaguely saying that this has cost you from preventing you benefitting from a better rate mortgage/stamp duty/Lisa why don't you carefully document exactly how much it's cost you. Include any tax cost.
You need to get a grip on what the situation actually is. An accountant or solicetor will help.

Have they helped you financially in other ways?

Twoforthree · 28/07/2021 09:35

Yes I suspect it’s been remortgaged several times and there may not be a lot of equity in it - leaving the op with a huge tax bill when it’s sold.

I doubt it’s a repayment mortgage - probably interest only, so it’s either the case above, or they are lying about the monthly profit.

CountryCob · 28/07/2021 09:34

If it’s £70 profit that suggests to me that there is a mortgage, whose name is this in? I agree you need to look at the title

Billybagpuss · 28/07/2021 09:33

@RincewindsHat

I don't understand all these people saying 'morally the house is not yours'. In this situation, as your parents and siblings seem to be entirely morally bankrupt themselves, morals can be put aside.

You own the property. You can take back control of it, the finances, and do what you want with it. Your parents deliberately screwed you over and continue to do so with no regard for helping you to buy your own home. It is your property, so sell it. If you feel generous, return the deposit I assume they paid (although as it seems like they bought it as a BTL maybe there was no deposit - 100% mortgages used to be a thing for BTL).

Accept that your parents are bullying, vindictive people who do not value you as you deserve to be valued and your siblings are cowardly at best and amoral at worst. You deserve to be treated better OP, and I hope you find a way to stand up for yourself here.

To add to this, to those saying ‘it’s not your house’ do you not think OP morally deserves some financial recompense for being financially inconvenienced for the last 20 years. If so how much?
thatonehasalittlecar · 28/07/2021 09:32

Did you buy a property yourself? Because you would also owe an extra 3% SDLT if you did. You really, really need to get some proper advice on this and sort it out. You could face a huge tax bill - or worse if HMRC thinks you’re part of a tax avoidance scam.

FancyAnOlive · 28/07/2021 09:30

Your mum telling you she shouldn't have had you is absolutely vile and abusive, OP. I'm so sorry you don't have parents who have your best interests in mind. Do you think you could go non contact with them? Are all your siblings completely under the thumb and brainwashed by them, or do you think there's anyone who would be more critical of their behaviour? This is a horrible situation for you, especially as you say you are not in the best place mentally. If not doing so already I would definitely find a good therapist and start to untangle some of this. This is absolutely not how loving parents and families behave.

vivariumvivariumsvivaria · 28/07/2021 09:29

Are you in Scotland? DM me if you are, I know women who's a tax lawyer, might be worth a chat.

MySecretHistory · 28/07/2021 09:29

@Fedduup32

Yes definitely in my name as the paperwork for new tent ants always has my name as landlord and and then bank details are in my name which I have no access to as they made me sign a letter that gives them authority to operate my account (it’s a business account) on my behalf.
Then you just declare all income- not profit for tax. The law changed several years go.

You must do a self assessment tax return?

Mysterylovingboy · 28/07/2021 09:28

Are you absolutely sure it's legally entirely yours? It could possibly be yours but under a usufruct or life interest type arrangement (I only know this law from another country so not sure how it works in UK, you'd need legal advice).

In this case what parents often do is 'give' the property to their child, to avoid IHT implications later. Although the property legally belongs to the child, the parents have a life interest. Interest/income from the property goes to the parents whilst they're alive, not the child, and there may be provisions that prevent the child from selling whilst the parents are still alive. When the parents die, the child inherits the property but without paying IHT (assuming parents die sufficiently long after handing property over), and the child then gets the interest/income too.

Not sure how common this is in the UK, and in balance and considering their crazy behaviour your parents are probably financially abusive instead, but it is something to ask your lawyer about.

Mindymomo · 28/07/2021 09:28

I would do a land registry search to find out exactly who the house is registered to. Who is paying the mortgage and if it’s in your name you really need the paperwork.

I’m sorry that you seem to have been duped by your parents, but I do wonder if the property is solely yours. There must have been repairs and costs involved in the rental property, and if this is in your name, you would be liable if something major needs to be done. I agree with people saying you need legal advice. It may cause you to fall out with your parents, but they don’t sound very nice and you may be better off severing all ties with them. But I really think this needs sorting out and never sign anything unless you are completely sure you know what you are signing.

RincewindsHat · 28/07/2021 09:28

I don't understand all these people saying 'morally the house is not yours'. In this situation, as your parents and siblings seem to be entirely morally bankrupt themselves, morals can be put aside.

You own the property. You can take back control of it, the finances, and do what you want with it. Your parents deliberately screwed you over and continue to do so with no regard for helping you to buy your own home. It is your property, so sell it. If you feel generous, return the deposit I assume they paid (although as it seems like they bought it as a BTL maybe there was no deposit - 100% mortgages used to be a thing for BTL).

Accept that your parents are bullying, vindictive people who do not value you as you deserve to be valued and your siblings are cowardly at best and amoral at worst. You deserve to be treated better OP, and I hope you find a way to stand up for yourself here.

MySecretHistory · 28/07/2021 09:27

The tax on rentals changed a few year ago. You have to pay tax on income not profit. Have you been doing a self assessment and declaring this income?

Capital gains. You will owe capital gains on sale. This is based on sale and purchase price.

Mortgage fraud. It sounds as if you have been complicit in mortgage fraud.

Tax fraud. You have also supported illegal tax evasion. Not avoidance (legal) but evasion.

Get a very good solicitor.

Check land registry- it will tell you how owns it and who the mortgage is with (who has a charge over it )

thebabessavedme · 28/07/2021 09:26

Regardless of who owns this property I think OP the best favour you could do yourself is to change your mind-set. Do whatever you can to get out of this situation and then walk away, the whole thing is toxic and controlling and you will never 'win'!

Your family now simply consists of you, your dh and your children and hopefully some nice in-laws, you say you have 2 dcs? then I would say that as the years go by your family will grow and flourish without including the toxic, unpleasant relatives you are really better off without! Being related by dna is not the be all and end all, surround yourself with people who truly love you and you wont go far wrong!

SixesAndEights · 28/07/2021 09:25

@Fedduup32

Thank you everyone. I agree I think I might need councelling before I decide to do anything. I just feel really upset and alone. She kept saying to me yesterday she made a mistake having me as I always cause trouble. She should have stopped at her 2nd child and not had me.

All my life I’ve felt I’m the “naughty” and bad one in family.

Doing what you can to take control of your property will probably end your relationship with them. This would be a good thing I expect, but you do need help in dealing with it.

Whilst you're organising counselling go to Land Registry and get the documentation people have recommended to find out if you're the sole owner of the property. Do small things like this just to get yourself in a better position.

If you have parents who tell you you are a mistake and are basically horrible to you, then never having contact with them going forward is a bonus!

Hoppinggreen · 28/07/2021 09:24

Well you have 2 choices
Do nothing and continue to be open to risk of prosecution due to deposits not being returned, gas certificates not being done, tax evasion etc etc etc. Not saying will be the case but you are legally responsible for all this and you have no idea what’s going on
Second choice is stand up to your family. Very hard I know but you have a husband, can’t he support you? Looks like you actually own this house so you can do what you want with it. Stop signing things when you dont know what they are
Your family will kick off, you will be accused of all sorts and the emotional blackmail will be piled on but if you are brave enough you can come out of this with what is basically a free house and you may be rid of your horrible family too

DogInATent · 28/07/2021 09:23

You're in a right pickle with this one. But you need to sort it out because tax problems can be complicated.

Start by collecting together any paperwork you might have been given. Make sure you've got the name of the accountant and any solicitor that your parents have been pushing on you.

Do you know which bank/building society the mortgage is with? and do you have any paperwork with the account number?

You need your own legal and financial advice - from people who are not your mother's solicitor or accountant. You can go direct to a local solicitor and ask if they will listen to you for free and then suggest what they could do to help you, or you could go to Citizens Advice and ask them to signpost you to an organisation that can help.

There's also a couple of nuclear options, but they could have serious consequences for your relationship with your family. I won't suggest those unless you want to know them.

You mention siblings, is your relationship with them good? are any of them aware of the situation? and is it possible that they could have been put in a similar position by your mother?

vivariumvivariumsvivaria · 28/07/2021 09:22

Ia m sorry you are in this pickle.

I'm sorry your parents aren't doing their best by you.

vivainsomnia · 28/07/2021 09:19

Legally, you agreed to become the owner of the house, legally you can do what you want with it.
Morally, you were manipulated by your parents, morally, you don't own the house.

You REALLY need to get this sorted out. You say that you are named as the landlord, do you know the implication of this? That if your parents failed to carry out electric and gas safety checks and the house burned down and killed them, YOU would be responsible and likely sent to jail?

You need to decide whether to take the legal or moral stand. If legal, get a solicitor to write to your parents and inform them of your intention to give notice to the tenants, sell the house, and use the proceeds to your benefits.

Or take the moral approach, tell you parents that you want nothing with the house any longer, and they either take on the mortgage and you do a transfer of deeds, or you sell the house and share the proceeds with your siblings.

Gilmorehill · 28/07/2021 09:16

@Fedduup32

The mortgage is in my name. Their accountant does a tax return every year with my details. I often have to pay a small value to HRMC so they must be profiting. No the £70 she keeps and has kept. Everytime I’ve ever asked her any details she screams at me.

In past when I’ve asked DH to get involved his response is they’ve taken mortgage out in my name to profit from my first time buyers rate and Even though legally it’s mine in reality they think it’s their property. My parents are very controlling so it hasn’t been easy for me to stand up to them. They have the deeds I don’t, there’s paperwork every so often I sign when new tenants come but when I question them I get screamed at and questioned why I don’t trust them.

I grew up thinking this was normal but I’m so angry they’ve taken advantage of me. I’ve asked siblings to get involved as they must know more details than I do but they don’t want the hassle.

I need to get advice on all this.

Sorry but you are to blame for agreeing to all of this. Your parents are only controlling because you allow it. Get the paperwork together and sell the property.
Phineyj · 28/07/2021 09:15

I agree with PP - people scream when they know they are in the wrong.

Stop signing paperwork you don't understand. If your DH is supportive, make sure he is there when it's likely you'll be pressurised. Gain as much knowledge as possible (you'll be amazed what you can find out). Seek professional advice.

Sounds like they picked you as the youngest and least able to stand up for yourself. If I remember correctly, up till 2012 or so, there was a loophole around putting property in DC names, although I think it may have involved setting up a trust. A solicitor will know.

GrandmaSteglitszch · 28/07/2021 09:14

Fedduup32
You have two problems - your controlling parents and your legal & financial situation re the property.
You need counseling for the parent problem and legal advice for the property problem.

(Your DH was sensible not to 'get involved' as you asked him to do. Your parents have got you into a complete mess with this.)