Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents and property

237 replies

Fedduup32 · 28/07/2021 00:29

Please be kind I’m not in a good place at the moment mentally.

In my early 20’s my parents put a rental property in my name. Not all as good as it sounds. I’m in my 40’s now and because of this property was unable to get first time buyers mortgage when I was looking for my own place so didn’t get a good deal that I could have.

Over the years whenever I bring up any conversation it ends in my mum screaming at me and threatening to put the property in one of my siblings name instead. I’m really upset as I came to visit my mum with kids and mentioned our flat is too small and I would love to get a bigger place and asked her if i sold the property how much would I get so could use as a deposit so I can get a nicer place. She got unreasonable again which resulted in me screaming at her too, not a nice thing to be honest. In the end I managed to get info from her that the rental gets £70 profit a month so in 20 years of this I asked her if I can have my money and she starts screaming at me.

After a lot of shouting today I finally learnt truth from her that she only made me buy the property as her accountant told her it will make more sense money wise to put in one of the kids name as they would have to pay tax etc. I feel really used by her but also guilty that she’s my mum but I feel sad that she never thinks about me or any repercussions it has had in my future finances and opportunities.

She doesn’t even clearly talk to me about anything to do with the property. I don’t even know if it was hers first then she put in my name for tax or first time buyers rate. I just get made to feel unreasonable if I ask any questions. My siblings were there today as well and they made me feel I am causing trouble but also admitted they glad she didn’t put in their name as they would have missed out on first time buyers with their property. I just wa t answers from her but she threatens all sorts.

I’m lying here feeling bad I brought up the topic but why can’t she just have a conversation with me about it. I don’t know what she’s hiding as she gets defensive.

OP posts:
NettleTea · 28/07/2021 10:05

god yes, I forgot about all those interest only mortgages. Although they may have taken 100% mortgage without a deposit as this is before the 2008 crash and credit was being thrown at people.

TirisfalPumpkin · 28/07/2021 10:05

People who are like 'why would you sign that' are obv not too familiar with controlling family dynamics. They get you so mixed up that you'd sign literally anything for a crumb of kindness and respect.

They also make you feel helpless and like you're not competent or capable enough to get out of the situation - only they can guide you. That's part of the control. The last thing they want you to do is speak to someone outside the dysfunctional system who can see it for what it is.

SarahBop · 28/07/2021 10:04

You DEFINITELY need legal advice. This sounds like very complex financial abuse to be honest.

Your Mum sounds toxic and awful - shouting and controlling you, you know that is not healthy.

Seek legal advice.

MerryMarigold · 28/07/2021 10:01

OP, why did your parents pick you to do this when you are not the eldest? Are you more easily manipulated? Did your siblings refuse to do it. I imagine you must be approaching 40 if 'you' bought the house 20 years ago.

Faultymain5 · 28/07/2021 10:01

@NettleTea and others most btl landlords take out interest only mortgages, there is no guarantee the mortgage is anywhere near paid off.

korawick12345 · 28/07/2021 10:01

@NettleTea unless of course it has been remortgaged which is what the static rental return suggests. If it is highly leveraged at this point the OP could be in a world of trouble regarding CGT

LookItsMeAgain · 28/07/2021 09:59

@Fedduup32

Thank you everyone. I agree I think I might need councelling before I decide to do anything. I just feel really upset and alone. She kept saying to me yesterday she made a mistake having me as I always cause trouble. She should have stopped at her 2nd child and not had me.

All my life I’ve felt I’m the “naughty” and bad one in family.

She sounds like such a lovely caring person....NOT!

It can be for your benefit. You need to start contacting the lending institution and getting them to change the address where the statements are sent to, to your address not theirs. Change the address with the bank. The mortgage is in your name - just provide them with a change of address where the mortgage statements are to go to.
Change the address where the rent is to be paid and contact the tenants.
Be pro-active on this not reactive. Once you have taken over these details and the rent is going to you as you're the legal owner of the property, either decide to continue to rent it out but you will need to do an inspection of the property or give your tenants notice and sell.

It can be to your benefit. Then I would cut your parents out of your life as they sound so toxic it is not good to be around either of them or your siblings!

NettleTea · 28/07/2021 09:58

in addition OP says that SHE has been paying HMRC some money too each year.

I cant believe you are actually out of pocket due to this

NettleTea · 28/07/2021 09:57

@Faranth

So they are paying the mortgage?

From what OP has said, on paper the mortgage is in OPs name, the tenants are renting from OP, the rent being paid covers the mortgage and everything else, leaving £70pcm.

So on paper OP is paying the mortgage - she's just not seeing any of the £70 profit. For 20 years!!

yes this, plus of course the house will be building in equity and is probably almost at the point when the mortgage will be finished (most are around 25 years)
korawick12345 · 28/07/2021 09:56

@MySecretHistory

Bollocks. It's the person who receives the income who is liable for income tax.

No it isn't. Lots of BTL tried to say there wives were letting it out when the laws changed a few years ago. HMRC thought otherwise.

And given the money is going into a bank account in the OPs name, i think she would have fun arguing with HMRC that she wasn't receiving the income.
Sarahlou63 · 28/07/2021 09:55

Just another thought - what's to stop you moving into your house when the current tenancy ends???

MySecretHistory · 28/07/2021 09:54

Bollocks. It's the person who receives the income who is liable for income tax.

No it isn't. Lots of BTL tried to say there wives were letting it out when the laws changed a few years ago. HMRC thought otherwise.

korawick12345 · 28/07/2021 09:54

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow - it can't be her main residence she's never lived in it.

ferretface · 28/07/2021 09:53

-Involve a solicitor
-Sell the property
-Go no contact with your parents (+ siblings if they are awful too)

If you are the registered owner of the property you can get your own copies of the deeds etc, you don't need access to theirs.

EvilPea · 28/07/2021 09:50

Post redirection as presumably all letters go to you at your parents address?
Land registry check on charges against it.

Solicitors appointment for you.

If you’ve signed stuff you are aware all be it coercion. You just need to be aware of the facts, the consequences (e.g the recent rules on electricity checks) and the benefits.
As a tenant please be mindful this isn’t their doing.

hyperbole001 · 28/07/2021 09:50

It's your property OP, if it's in your name. Sell it

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 28/07/2021 09:49

@PotteringAlong

So have you paid tax on it? Because you’re liable for it if it’s in your name…

You will also have to pay capital gains tax when you sell it.

Bollocks. It's the person who receives the income who is liable for income tax.

And CGT is not payable on sale of your main residence.

Apart from that, great post 🙄

Flyingantday · 28/07/2021 09:48

This sounds like borderline financial abuse, fraud or both to me. If any conversation results in screaming and histrionics from your parents, I would maybe put it succinctly and in writing that you feel you are kept in the dark regarding the financial management of this property and you are concerned about potential financial penalties for you. Also that you can’t move on with your life and buy a home of your own to live in because of it.

I would ask for all documents pertaining to the property so you can consult a financial advisor/solicitor to discuss the best course of action for you, whether this is signing the property over to another party or ultimately putting it on the market. That it is becoming an increasing financial and emotional burden to you.

Keep all communication as evidence if there was any sort of tax/fraud investigation down the line.

If they refuse to cooperate, then I think your only option is to seek legal advice or even consider contacting the police (not sure if they have a helpline for suspected fraud/financial abuse?) although this would likely be terminal for your relationship.

So sorry OP that your parents have put you in a no-win situation.

GoldBar · 28/07/2021 09:48

It's time to end this arrangement and go no contact, I think. This isn't working for you.

Add up how much you've lost financially from the arrangement, send your mother an invoice and then offer her a choice. Either she pays you that amount and you transfer the property to her or you sell the property, keep that amount and then transfer the balance to her.

ShowMeHow · 28/07/2021 09:47

This is a shit show, I have suffered similar myself.

Place-marking incase I can help later.

So sorry - I imagine you mum is scared she is about to be exposed for how she has used you I think.

I hope you can disentangle yourself.

toocold54 · 28/07/2021 09:47

To add to this, to those saying ‘it’s not your house’ do you not think OP morally deserves some financial recompense for being financially inconvenienced for the last 20 years. If so how much?

Definitely.
I think OP needs to work out how much she’s spent on it over the years if any, how much she’s lost out by not being a part time buyer and then how much her equal share is and then tell them she wants this amount of money so they can buy it off her or she’ll sell it and keep her share and give the rest to them.

Sarahlou63 · 28/07/2021 09:46

OP, sadly you can't believe a word your mother says, including the £70 profit. Why? The property has been let out for 20 years so the rental income (and the value of the property) must have increased substantially over the years. If the mortgage is in your name they can't have remortgaged it or topped the mortgage up/put on a second charge without your knowledge/signature.

What information do you have in your possession? Do you know who the mortgage is with? If so, get in touch with them and ask for a statement to be sent to your house. Deal in facts, not emotions or suppositions or emotional blackmail

Talk to your DH. Formulate a plan of action to know your rights, your liabilities, your strategy in dealing with your family - seeking help with the former from a solicitor and the latter with a counsellor.

Then get on RightMove and fine out how much the house is worth. With 20 years of growth you could be in for a very nice windfall, even with CGT.

vivainsomnia · 28/07/2021 09:43

To add to this, to those saying ‘it’s not your house’ do you not think OP morally deserves some financial recompense for being financially inconvenienced for the last 20 years. If so how much?
Absolutely. The value of what has been lost from not being to benefit from being a first time buyer.

Leftbutcameback · 28/07/2021 09:43

And this is why there is a requirement for independent legal advice in these type of situations. Feel you’ve been badly used OP, and the screaming and shouting is horrible. Good luck sorting it all out, and if there was any issue with a solicitor acting improperly in all this consider reporting it. Also worth noting that there is no longer an issue about holding deeds assuming it’s registered, your mum will just have a copy of the register, so you can get all the relevant information from the Land Registry and that doesn’t give your mum a hold over you.

Benjispruce5 · 28/07/2021 09:43

It sounds as though it’s your parent’s property as in they bought it but didn’t intend it for you just put it in your name for tax purposes. They obviously didn’t think about the repercussions but I wouldn’t feel good about selling it. You haven’t paid for it.