Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents and property

237 replies

Fedduup32 · 28/07/2021 00:29

Please be kind I’m not in a good place at the moment mentally.

In my early 20’s my parents put a rental property in my name. Not all as good as it sounds. I’m in my 40’s now and because of this property was unable to get first time buyers mortgage when I was looking for my own place so didn’t get a good deal that I could have.

Over the years whenever I bring up any conversation it ends in my mum screaming at me and threatening to put the property in one of my siblings name instead. I’m really upset as I came to visit my mum with kids and mentioned our flat is too small and I would love to get a bigger place and asked her if i sold the property how much would I get so could use as a deposit so I can get a nicer place. She got unreasonable again which resulted in me screaming at her too, not a nice thing to be honest. In the end I managed to get info from her that the rental gets £70 profit a month so in 20 years of this I asked her if I can have my money and she starts screaming at me.

After a lot of shouting today I finally learnt truth from her that she only made me buy the property as her accountant told her it will make more sense money wise to put in one of the kids name as they would have to pay tax etc. I feel really used by her but also guilty that she’s my mum but I feel sad that she never thinks about me or any repercussions it has had in my future finances and opportunities.

She doesn’t even clearly talk to me about anything to do with the property. I don’t even know if it was hers first then she put in my name for tax or first time buyers rate. I just get made to feel unreasonable if I ask any questions. My siblings were there today as well and they made me feel I am causing trouble but also admitted they glad she didn’t put in their name as they would have missed out on first time buyers with their property. I just wa t answers from her but she threatens all sorts.

I’m lying here feeling bad I brought up the topic but why can’t she just have a conversation with me about it. I don’t know what she’s hiding as she gets defensive.

OP posts:
fabulousathome · 28/07/2021 10:51

I don't think the accountant will speak to you because you are not their client.

You need your own accountant.

Taliskerskye · 28/07/2021 10:50

Well the positive is you own a flat outright!
Use someone of the money from the sale to get therapy and go NC with them all.
Imagine how free you would be!

IceLace100 · 28/07/2021 10:48

And learn from this, don't trust them with anything financial ever again. Keep everything completely separate and don't allow them access to your personal documents.

Essentially you can't really trust them with this stuff. Sorry.

IceLace100 · 28/07/2021 10:46

And don't sign ANYTHING she puts in front of you.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 28/07/2021 10:46

Yes I suspect it’s been remortgaged several times and there may not be a lot of equity in it - leaving the op with a huge tax bill when it’s sold.

I doubt it’s a repayment mortgage - probably interest only, so it’s either the case above, or they are lying about the monthly profit.

This. Sadly I think either selling it and taking the money or transferring it into someone else's name wouldn't be that simple (they'd have to agree to it for one thing). You definitely need good legal and financial advice to find out exactly what you've been signing over the years.

So sorry you have such a shit family, no decent person would treat their child or sibling this way but you're only in your 40s, you can change this. Flowers

IceLace100 · 28/07/2021 10:44

Go and see a solicitor ASAP.

I hope you're taking care of yourself x

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/07/2021 10:42

I'd also contact the accountants and ask them for a full breakdown of what they've been doing in your name over all these years. it sounds like they might very well have been acting illegally for a long time, and might have brought their profession into disrepute - assuming they are qualified and professionally recognised, and not just some wily people who are good at manipulating numbers and their interpretation of the law. I think they could do with being exposed.

There's nothing wrong with accountants advising people to work within their advantage to make best use of their position in law - e.g. a married couple deciding together with full knowledge to split their assets to make best use of personal allowances - but you can't just keep a person in the dark and use them as a 'money mule' to do somebody else's dirty work.

ChainJane · 28/07/2021 10:42

If the mortgage is in your name then surely the deeds are with the mortgage provider? They normally keep hold of them until the mortgage is paid off.

You need proper legal advice like you said. Either you own the property and can just sell it without their permission, or you don't own it.

CornflowersInTheLongGrass · 28/07/2021 10:39

I would get independent legal advice in your situation

Ohpulltheotherone · 28/07/2021 10:36

OP I think you need legal advice to be honest.

If the mortgage is in your name then the deeds will be in your name, if you have paid the tax and everything has been done above board then you have nothing to worry about.

The issue of course will be if they’ve not had it on a BTL mortgage although it would be incredibly difficult to legitimately rent a property without all the right paper work like certificates and insurance so hopefully it is all legit.

Please get some legal advice, this property is in the eyes of the law - yours.

I’d sell it and go no contact, your family sound awful

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/07/2021 10:35

The real question here is how much do you value your relationship with your family?

I think the family have already made this decision themselves. They're treating OP as a vehicle for making money (illegally by the sounds of it) and don't care for her as a person at all. Sadly, it doesn't sound like there is any relationship to speak of.

Sorry but you are to blame for agreeing to all of this. Your parents are only controlling because you allow it.

Sorry, but this is just nasty victim-blaming. It's the equivalent of saying that a wife who is a victim of DV is to blame for allowing her husband to beat her - "why does she allow him to do it?"

OP has been groomed this way from childhood, by the sounds of it - she is not at fault.

OP, the advice that PPs have given is good. Although your parents maybe don't realise/accept it, now you're wise to their devices, the power is actually all in your hands. They stand (and deserve) to lose a great deal (not that they haven't already taken so much from you) and gaslighting and creating FOG in your life is all that they have to rely on.

Every time your mother screams at you, know that this is her way of clinging on to the power she thinks she has - and she is probably scared, especially as you're obviously starting to ask questions and realise that things are not right. Effectively, she's acting like a toddler, who has no power of their own and only has screaming as a way to try to get what they want. The difference is that, unlike a toddler, she knows what she stands to lose.

Turn her screaming back on her. She sees it as a way to end the questions; I know it's not easy, but if you can treat it as her way of being unable/unwilling to discuss things, tell her you'll need to go over her head and contact the solicitor/bank/HMRC directly if she can't/won't help you. If you can summon up the strength to do that, I think you'll see her almost visibly deflate, as she realises the game is up, and she might respond with a last-ditch attempt at being all nicey-nicey with you, maybe asking why you would do 'that' to your 'loving' parents who've 'only ever tried to help you'. Too late: go over her head anyway. The fact is that, legally, you own the house, whatever your parents might try to do. Tell the official bodies all that you've told us and see where you can go from there.

Stop trying to please your parents or siblings, because they don't care about you one bit. Make the break from them and start putting yourself first. It won't be easy after the decades of abuse, but get all the help you need and break free.

lunar1 · 28/07/2021 10:35

It's your house, the tenants are yours and you are paying the mortgage with the rent from your tenants. Remove any authority your parents have over your banking.

Go no contact with your parents, get a solicitor and sell your house then use your money to buy something suitable for yourself.

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 28/07/2021 10:26

Cut loose. You don’t need that kind of stress in your life. Sell the flat and split the profit. Go see a solicitor and get some advice. I’m afraid you need to go in to this conversation with your parents fully informed and with a clear plan in place.
Good luck

Eddielzzard · 28/07/2021 10:24

WTF!!! Your parents are total shits. Surely this is illegal? They've coerced you into this whole mess and abused you if you dare question anything. I think you need legal advice.

Mrgrinch · 28/07/2021 10:19

This is all kinds of wrong.

I'd take the house and cut contact with all of them.

MySecretHistory · 28/07/2021 10:18

@MrKlaw

£70pm profit is annoying but not something to lose sleep over. Maybe it was less in previous years, depends on the mortgage and how often it was rented out.

The fact you have to pay HMRC though compounds this. You are paying extra per year and don't get the profit back. You should at least have had enough to offset that cost that you're paying.

If the mortgage is in your name, it should hopefully be nearly done. I'd get a statement to understand how much you have left to pay on it, and then start planning around that. Either to sell and get decent equity to help you upsize your own place, or keep renting it and use the (significantly more than £70 pm) profit to go towards a larger mortgage, again letting you upsize.

Key thing is to work out how to get access to this. Mortgage is in your name but accountants seem to run it day to day. You need to get full control of that. Then make sure the profit comes to you (so once mortgage is paid off the increase comes to you too).

Yes it sounds like you're in a bad place and controlled by your parents. That won't change overnight but try and start to put things in place to change that slowly

£70pm profit is annoying but not something to lose sleep over. Maybe it was less in previous years, depends on the mortgage and how often it was rented out.

Tax is due on income not profit. Landlords used to be able to offset mortgage interest payments against rental income, but in 2015 the government announced they were phasing this out. In 2017-18 the tax relief you could claim reduced to 75 per cent. Then in 2019-20 it was only 25 per cent. Now it's gone completely.

MySecretHistory · 28/07/2021 10:17

@toocold54

I think that I'd see if it's possible to get your mane taken off everything re the house & just walk away from it.

It seems unfair but I’d be tempted to do this too.

That wouldn't work

Even if you give away a house you are liable for capital gains tax at the Market value if it is not you main residence. Similarly you cant sell it for a £1

Op- go onto the house buying and selling forum boards of money saving expert forum-you will get advice there.

MrKlaw · 28/07/2021 10:16

£70pm profit is annoying but not something to lose sleep over. Maybe it was less in previous years, depends on the mortgage and how often it was rented out.

The fact you have to pay HMRC though compounds this. You are paying extra per year and don't get the profit back. You should at least have had enough to offset that cost that you're paying.

If the mortgage is in your name, it should hopefully be nearly done. I'd get a statement to understand how much you have left to pay on it, and then start planning around that. Either to sell and get decent equity to help you upsize your own place, or keep renting it and use the (significantly more than £70 pm) profit to go towards a larger mortgage, again letting you upsize.

Key thing is to work out how to get access to this. Mortgage is in your name but accountants seem to run it day to day. You need to get full control of that. Then make sure the profit comes to you (so once mortgage is paid off the increase comes to you too).

Yes it sounds like you're in a bad place and controlled by your parents. That won't change overnight but try and start to put things in place to change that slowly

toocold54 · 28/07/2021 10:14

I think that I'd see if it's possible to get your mane taken off everything re the house & just walk away from it.

It seems unfair but I’d be tempted to do this too.

diddl · 28/07/2021 10:07

I think that I'd see if it's possible to get your mane taken off everything re the house & just walk away from it.

Thewholeshackshimmy · 28/07/2021 10:06

Whatever you decided to do with the property situation it really would be a good idea to look at counselling. I am so sorry you’ve been manipulated by the very people who you should be able to trust 100%. Your parents are not good people and you deserve to live free from any of their manipulative ways. I hope all goes well for you op.

Penners99 · 28/07/2021 10:06

OP, a land registry search is you first action. It will state who owns the property and what mortgage is attached. Only costs a few quid and is all online

MySecretHistory · 28/07/2021 10:06

Do you claim child benefit? Would the rental income (income not profit) put you above the limit?

SarahBop · 28/07/2021 10:05

@MerryMarigold

OP, why did your parents pick you to do this when you are not the eldest? Are you more easily manipulated? Did your siblings refuse to do it. I imagine you must be approaching 40 if 'you' bought the house 20 years ago.
OP states she is in her 40s now.
mm8989 · 28/07/2021 10:05

when you think about it, they could be taking loans out against the house, over draughts on the accounts etc. Do you check your credit reports OP?

I doubt there is much equity, it's been viewed as an investment, they will have been skimming off it.