Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents and property

237 replies

Fedduup32 · 28/07/2021 00:29

Please be kind I’m not in a good place at the moment mentally.

In my early 20’s my parents put a rental property in my name. Not all as good as it sounds. I’m in my 40’s now and because of this property was unable to get first time buyers mortgage when I was looking for my own place so didn’t get a good deal that I could have.

Over the years whenever I bring up any conversation it ends in my mum screaming at me and threatening to put the property in one of my siblings name instead. I’m really upset as I came to visit my mum with kids and mentioned our flat is too small and I would love to get a bigger place and asked her if i sold the property how much would I get so could use as a deposit so I can get a nicer place. She got unreasonable again which resulted in me screaming at her too, not a nice thing to be honest. In the end I managed to get info from her that the rental gets £70 profit a month so in 20 years of this I asked her if I can have my money and she starts screaming at me.

After a lot of shouting today I finally learnt truth from her that she only made me buy the property as her accountant told her it will make more sense money wise to put in one of the kids name as they would have to pay tax etc. I feel really used by her but also guilty that she’s my mum but I feel sad that she never thinks about me or any repercussions it has had in my future finances and opportunities.

She doesn’t even clearly talk to me about anything to do with the property. I don’t even know if it was hers first then she put in my name for tax or first time buyers rate. I just get made to feel unreasonable if I ask any questions. My siblings were there today as well and they made me feel I am causing trouble but also admitted they glad she didn’t put in their name as they would have missed out on first time buyers with their property. I just wa t answers from her but she threatens all sorts.

I’m lying here feeling bad I brought up the topic but why can’t she just have a conversation with me about it. I don’t know what she’s hiding as she gets defensive.

OP posts:
User5827372728 · 28/07/2021 12:22

I would speak to a counsellor and try and get support and the confidence to speak out.

I would also get proper legal advice.

igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 12:20

Sell it OP. The house is almost certainly registered so you can get the details from the Land Registry and see what the official ownership position is.

Once you know that, you can decide whether to sell it completely (and you'd have to evict the tenants which would be a complication) or sell it on with the tenants in situ. Then you can take the money left over from paying any outstanding mortgage and use it to buy your own place.

And tell your screaming mother to bog off when she screams at you again. What makes grown adults behave like toddlers?

PotteringAlong · 28/07/2021 12:13

@endofthelinefinally it might not be - I have a normal residential mortgage on the house that I rent out and then pay the mortgage company for permission to let every year.

endofthelinefinally · 28/07/2021 12:08

@kidsatuniemptynester

Something doesn't add up here. Firstly, the first time buyers rate which you keep on about has only been around for a couple of years, secondly, £70 per week profit? How? If you are being assessed on the income for tax purposes how does your Mother receive this money? If the property was bought 20 years ago why is there still such a massive mortgage that it is only paying this piffling profit?
It is probably a BTL mortgage as this is the only legal way to get a mortgage on a property you intend to rent out. So it will be interest only. The £70 will be what the parents keep after the mortgage payment comes out. This is likely to be on direct debit, but it sounds as if OP doesn't see her bank statements as she has been coerced into signing over control of the account to her parents. OP needs legal advice regarding this as banks can be difficult to deal with and have probably been told OP is o9ncapable of managing her own affairs.
Doubledoorsontogarden · 28/07/2021 12:05

How much longer is left on the mortgage?

Can your DP buy a property and get First time buyer benefits? Then when you remortgage put you on it?

headintheproverbial · 28/07/2021 12:01

Sell it!!!

kidsatuniemptynester · 28/07/2021 12:01

Something doesn't add up here. Firstly, the first time buyers rate which you keep on about has only been around for a couple of years, secondly, £70 per week profit? How? If you are being assessed on the income for tax purposes how does your Mother receive this money? If the property was bought 20 years ago why is there still such a massive mortgage that it is only paying this piffling profit?

endofthelinefinally · 28/07/2021 11:58

Also, there is every chance that OP can sell to another landlord who will happily take on the tenant. There are lots of property companies who do this. They will pay a reduced price, but they will deal with looking after the tenant and inspecting/upgrading/refurbishing the property.

amillionrosepetals · 28/07/2021 11:53

Couple of points.

  1. 3% Stamp Duty surcharge would not be payable by OP if she replaces her current main residence with a new main residence.
  2. Mortgage interest is no longer deductible from rental income. Instead, a credit equal to the mortgage int at 20% is given against the tax due. A t/p who remains liable at basic rate taking into account the full rental income will not therefore pay any more tax. Higher rate t/ps will lose out. Anyone making a loss will also lose out. If OP's parents are higher rate t/ps they will be benefiting. They would pay more income tax, and CGT, if the property was in their own names.
Grimacingfrog · 28/07/2021 11:50

Sorry but you are to blame for agreeing to all of this. Your parents are only controlling because you allow it. Get the paperwork together and sell the property

Anyone who writes this, knows absolutely nothing about coercive control. Please ignore OP.

Counselling would definitely help you to unpick the emotional hold your parents have over you and how you've been scapegoated.

You also need a solicitor to unpick the legal side.

I also agree with the PP who said that they are likely to have remortgaged several times, otherwise the rental yield should be higher than £70 a month. Is it possible that they used the equity to buy other properties without telling you?

I wouldn't have any moral compunction about selling the property and keeping the money. They have basically defrauded you and you are within your rights to be compensated. If the equity is more than you would have had if you had bought your own property, you could always return the excess. However, my fear is that there is very little equity left. I wonder if you are entitled to sue them for any equity taken out of the property without your agreement.

EvilPea · 28/07/2021 11:48

She needs proper advice before even considering selling.
She’s got a tenant in the property with a legal right to be there who thinks the op is her landlord. A contract stating as much with legal obligations to that co tract and tenant.
And that’s before she starts to unpick the family mess.

Twiglets1 · 28/07/2021 11:48

The way they are acting is very unreasonable and definitely not normal - I feel sorry for you

endofthelinefinally · 28/07/2021 11:34

You are entitled to sell the property OP. You have been paying a small amount of tax as per instructions of the accountant. Your parents haven't spent money on the property, it is mortgaged and they have been keeping the rent. You owe them nothing. You won't even make that much out of it once you have paid off the mortgage and the CGT, so your conscience is clear.
As pp have said, you can download and print the deeds yourself. CAB will help you with the technical/practical stuff.
Don't discuss it with any of your family. they all sound toxic.
Speak to the accountant in the first instance.
Then CAB.

Billybagpuss · 28/07/2021 11:32

@Fedduup32 have you signed anything else mortgage related since the original transaction?

A few pp have suggested they may have moved the mortgage around and taken additional funds out, but with everything in your name you must have agreed to this and signed stuff if they did.

So from what you’ve said I doubt very much this is the case. We bought our house 20 years ago and it has doubled in value since. It is very unlikely to be in negative equity.

You are actually in a very strong position, which I think they are beginning to realise, again hence the screaming as panic is setting in. Everything is in your name, if they want to access the equity to fund their retirement they can’t. You would have to sell and give the money back to them, which will have tax implications.

I take it from your OP you have been able to buy yourself it has just cost you more. I hope all of this advice hasn’t completely overwhelmed you, you do have some decisions to make but take your time. Get proper advice. 💐

supersop60 · 28/07/2021 11:27

OP - so sorry to hear what you have been going through.
Your parents are abusive, both emotionally and financially, and you have suffered financially with regard to buying your own property and losing ftb benefits, not to mention the tax you've had to pay.
I agree with all pp - get professional advice, your DH must support you, even if he doesn't get involved.
DO NOT tell your parents what you are thinking or doing, and at the same time, do NOT sign anything else - make an excuse, be out of the house. In fact, avoid seeing them altogether if all they do is scream at you.
They are a pair of shits, and it is not your fault. At the age of 20, I'd have signed whatever my parents told me to, because I trusted them.

DishingOutDone · 28/07/2021 11:25

@foxandbee

Sorry, haven't RTFT.
You've still commented a lot more intelligently, compassionately and with helpful info than a significant number of posters who have.
JustineMumofTwins · 28/07/2021 11:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

beigebrownblue · 28/07/2021 11:17

And yes, coercive control is a criminal offence, but it is very hard to prove indeed, and you may not even want to go down that route.

Please find a therapist.

Branleuse · 28/07/2021 11:13

theyre continuing to control you with the threat of emotional outbursts and screaming, which reduces you to feeling like a small child. You should look up transactional analysis so you can understand the tricks they are playing to manipulate you.

It would be true justice and serve them right if you sold the property and then went NC. If its in your name, then you can do that. You dont need people like that in your life. They controlled you when you were younger, but now your eyes have been opened, and with a bit of support, therapy and decent legal advice, you can break free and get what you own

diddl · 28/07/2021 11:12

@Taliskerskye

Well the positive is you own a flat outright! Use someone of the money from the sale to get therapy and go NC with them all. Imagine how free you would be!
A flat with a tenant which might be in negative equity!

Get legal advice, Op.

Who knows what was drawn up between your Mum & accountant?

Possibly a way of you not being able to just claim/sell a flat that she paid for?

Hope you can some resolution!

ralphi · 28/07/2021 11:11

Get a solicitor, sell the property, and go nc with your parents. Having a lawyer means that you are cushioned from a lot of the unpleasantness. Do not engage with them, do not take their calls or visit them until the whole sale is completed.

beigebrownblue · 28/07/2021 11:10

What concerns me is that into adulthood you feel you are still being controlled by them. Quote 'I didn't question them as I've brought up thinking they know best and I know nothing'

I don't really think this is even about the property.

I would be accessing a therapist at this point, to work through exactly what it is that kept you in this place as an adult.

I would approach a therapist who is specialised in family estrangement. There is an organisation called Stand Alone which might help.

One thing that might help you in practical terms is putting a fact file together about this situation. You don't need to tell your parents you are doing this.

Approach the Citizens Advice for free advice about what the situation actually is.

Then you need to figure out what it is you actually WANT and NEED. Quite distinct from what your parents WANT and NEED.

I don't feel you know that at the moment, hence the confusion.

You have a right as an adult person to decide this.

Sure, you may wish to take others needs into account but be clear about what yours are first.

It might well be that there was coercive control in your family.

This is a very hard thing to accept so please access emotional support

Good luck

foxandbee · 28/07/2021 11:03

Sorry, haven't RTFT.

foxandbee · 28/07/2021 11:03

They have the deeds I don’t

I have RTFT, but this doesn't matter @Fedduup32, the deeds will be stored electronically on the land registry.

Get legal advice. Sell the property.

I think your parents could be guilty of coercive control, which is a criminal offence.

www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/controlling-or-coercive-behaviour-intimate-or-family-relationship

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/07/2021 10:56

I don't think the accountant will speak to you because you are not their client.

How is she not their (albeit unwitting) client if they've been doing all of this in her name for years?

I somehow think they might be willing to talk to OP anyway, once she mentions to them about wanting to check the situation with a solicitor and HMRC....