Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that cars are the biggest cause of climate change?

230 replies

malificent7 · 27/07/2021 22:37

I didn't learn to drive till I was 30 as I was concerned about the effects of cars on global warming. Everyone thought I was mad...however now that climate change is a hot topic i wonder how many people still feel that driving isn't damaging to the planet?
Then there are the car accidents, roads are an eyesore.
I mean I drive as I live in the country but I kind of hate it too.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 28/07/2021 09:50

Sorry posted to soon.

There have been studies that say that a dog (I suspect depending on breed) has a larger carbon footprint than an SUV.

FrippEnos · 28/07/2021 09:48

@whippetwoman

I misread cars as cats for some reason. I’m glad it’s not cats as I have three of the little furry beasts and I was Shock
"Dogs and cats are responsible for a quarter of the greenhouse gas emissions caused by animal agriculture, according a new study out Wednesday, which adds up to a whopping 64 million tons of carbon-dioxide equivalent emitted in the production of their food."

From google

and something from the independent
www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/opinion/pets-uk-ownership-cats-dogs-carbon-environmental-impact-b1249610.html

thecatsatonthewall · 28/07/2021 09:38

@BlueLenka

Why we aren't massively upping RnD is hydrogen transport? cars, lorries, trains, shipping?

We are.
But you need to make the hydrogen somehow. it's either from natural gas with carbon capture- so still burning fossil fuels but capturing the CO2 OR it's electrolysis and you need MORE electricity to make the hydrogen from water than the energy cv you are getting from that hydrogen...the renewable electricity needs to be in excess in order for this to make sense..we don't have the capacity in UK yet..and it's a long journey and a lot of investment is required

No we are not, the UK govt has committed just £30m in hydrogen and Battry RnD (not manufacturing)

Yes the issues you raise are at the moment (also the case with EV too) which is why we need to matching countries like Japan or Germany.

Otherwise we will have an extensive network of EV charging stations, whilst the row moves to hydrogen.

BogRollBOGOF · 28/07/2021 09:08

@justasking111

Volcanic eruptions contribute more to climate change than anything man is doing. Iceland eruption four years worth
Although the flip side is that all the geothermal power means that the only fossil fuel usage is for vehicles. Data centres are a growing industry in Iceland because of the cheap, green power. Similar in Norway for hydropower. (Shame their populations are low and a mere blip of the world)

Where you do things matters.

Raising animals on marginal British farmland unsuituable for crops is far less damaging than industrialised indoor agriculture in parts of the USA or Middle East. British pastoral farming has a wider ecological benefit from the animals' crap in the fields fertilising them and creating habitat that supports a wider food chain of wildlife.

Cotton grown in a naturally suitable environment will have less impact than cotton grown in a dry, irrigated area.

A product made in China will have more impact than the same item made in Europe because of the difference in production standards, energy generation and waste disposal. Not all China's fault; we outsource or manufacturing there because its cheaper and dodges the costs of our higher standards

Most environmental decisions have some kind of trade-off attached to them. Reducing is better than reducing, better than recycling. Most of the best environmental decisions have wider positive consequences anyway. Reducing car use for local journeys tends to be good for fitness for example.

It is worth making personal micro decisions, but the biggest effect is from national policies and international agreements.

igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 09:00

I don't know how much driving contributes to overall climate change.

However, it definitely contributes to pollution, illness and deaths at local level and for that reason alone we need to do something about it.

If I were in charge I'd spend billions on cycle lanes and EV charging units (I know batteries are not eco-saints, but EV cars are better than petrol ones).

Malin52 · 28/07/2021 09:00

It's pretty low down the list. Adding children to the population has the biggest impact by a significant margin at 60 tonnes a year. A car adds 1 tonne per year.

I worked out I could take a return transatlantic flight 30 times a year for the rest of my life and not hit the carbon impact an additional human has.

BlueLenka · 28/07/2021 08:59

Why we aren't massively upping RnD is hydrogen transport? cars, lorries, trains, shipping?

We are.
But you need to make the hydrogen somehow. it's either from natural gas with carbon capture- so still burning fossil fuels but capturing the CO2 OR it's electrolysis and you need MORE electricity to make the hydrogen from water than the energy cv you are getting from that hydrogen...the renewable electricity needs to be in excess in order for this to make sense..we don't have the capacity in UK yet..and it's a long journey and a lot of investment is required

Cluelessasacucumber · 28/07/2021 08:57

YABU to speculate when so many highly qualified scientists have already done the research and you can easily look this up. It doesnt matter if you "think" or "believe" something, what matters here are facts.

Cars are not actually the biggest contributer to global emissions but giving up your car is one of the bigger steps you can take to reduce your personal emissions. Along with: having no/fewer children, eating a plant based diet, avoiding flights and ensuring your house is properly insulated and runs on renewable.

Iggly · 28/07/2021 08:56

@duckyla

I don't understand the not learning till you were 30 thing, what did you do before to get around?
Neither did I.

I used my legs and public transport. It amazes me even now that people drive when I can walk it in 20 mins.

JassyRadlett · 28/07/2021 08:54

Transport (excluding international aviation and shipping) is the largest emissions sector in the UK. The overwhelming majority of that is cars. So yes, it’s an issue.

But our emissions don’t include the deforestation that takes place to grow animal feed for our meat, or to mine for components for the things we buy, or other deforestation general fuckery. Plus all of our other consumption emissions which the UK could influence through its trade policy but chooses not to.

I wouldn't have thought of cars, if making a list I'd have put air travel ahead of road travel.

You would’ve thought wrong. International aviation emissions are less than a third of road transport emissions (based on fuel use from international aviation bunkers in the UK). Domestic aviation is less than 1% of our transportation emissions.

TheVolturi · 28/07/2021 08:53

Did the op post this and then fall asleep?

vodkaredbullgirl · 28/07/2021 08:48
Hmm
justasking111 · 28/07/2021 08:47

Volcanic eruptions contribute more to climate change than anything man is doing. Iceland eruption four years worth

Sloth66 · 28/07/2021 08:47

Overpopulation and over consumption.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 28/07/2021 08:45

People need to stop going after individuals and go after the ones who are actually causing near 3/4 of the emissions.and force government's to force them develop greener technology.
As an individual you could be child free, ride bikes and be vegan and it would make 0 difference to the planet🤷🏻

ChainJane · 28/07/2021 08:43

The "top 5" for climate change are:

Overpopulation (kill off a few billion people and we'll be fine)
China (ditto)
Air travel (appalling pollution)
Streaming (Netflix, Amazon Prime, Youtube etc - the data centres alone use ridiculous amounts of energy)
Cars maybe 5th on the list

Eradicating the surplus billions of people would be the most effective step but would be unacceptable to the "woke" crowd (who ironically are often the people most concerned about climate change!) who would undoubtedly cry genocide. You couldn't even euthanise China, so that's the second target ruled out too.

This is the problem: we want to prevent climate change but are unwilling to do what is really necessary so have to poke around on the edges instead. The key point is, the planet can't support 7+ billion people living well. We either have a couple of billion people living well, or 7+ billion living in poor conditions.

Ultimately the question is, why should we accept lower living standards now to help future generations, people who might not even be born yet?

IonaLeg · 28/07/2021 08:43

Eating meat and dairy has a much bigger impact - apart from having children, it’s the single biggest contributor to a person’s carbon footprint.

But even then, the overwhelming responsibility lies with industry. A tiny number of companies are responsible for the huge majority of worldwide carbon emissions. Legislative curbing of industrial pollution is required to tackle global warming.

This is easily accessible information if it’s something that you care about.

Oblomov21 · 28/07/2021 08:43

Nope. It's quite low down the list of things that affect it.
Surely you've read up on it and seen such lists?

Notjustanymum · 28/07/2021 08:41

Cars aren’t even in the top 10 of contributors towards climate change worldwide, but in the UK, they contribute about 22%. The largest contribution to greenhouse gases in the UK is production of electricity and use of gas for commercial and domestic requirements. Quite how switching to electric vehicles might solve that is a conundrum!
Worldwide, the US, China and India are responsible for more CO2 emissions than the rest of the world.
Sweating the small stuff seems to be the UK Government’s speciality on this, and they have done a good job of convincing us that it’s our fault because of our reliance on private transport, instead of creating an infrastructure that encourages us to take public transport, cycle or walk places...

toolazytothinkofausername · 28/07/2021 08:40
LemonRoses · 28/07/2021 08:34

And a global ban on space programmes. We’ve screwed up one planet already.

LemonRoses · 28/07/2021 08:33

I think cars are part of the problem, but probably not the biggest issue.

We should be investing in global renewable energy sources and stopping deforestation. Burning fossil fuels for energy is probably the biggest overall contributor.

Fewer BBQs involving meat might help too - eating less meat, less intense farming would reduce methane emissions and be better for us.

Whoarethewho · 28/07/2021 08:28

@Losttheequipment

Overpopulation
Absolutely if the population was the same size as 200 years ago we could live in luxury everyone. Unfortunately we need poverty to keep our usage of the earth's resources at even this stupidly high level.

Despite having a gas guzzler car by having no children I am contributing only a small fraction of the greenhouse gas emissions of a family with children.

Gooriddance · 28/07/2021 08:24

It’s EVERYTHING! Our whole way of life. Flying, driving, cruise ships, overconsumption, fast fashion, too much food, too much meat, electronics, the internet, aircon everywhere, paving over nature and chopping down trees to build cities, chopping down rainforests, poisoning our rivers and oceans, overfishing, it’s all supposed to be in delicate balance and we’ve completely obliterated it.
Our way of life is not sustainable at all.

duckyla · 28/07/2021 08:21

No need to duck out though

Swipe left for the next trending thread