Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that cars are the biggest cause of climate change?

230 replies

malificent7 · 27/07/2021 22:37

I didn't learn to drive till I was 30 as I was concerned about the effects of cars on global warming. Everyone thought I was mad...however now that climate change is a hot topic i wonder how many people still feel that driving isn't damaging to the planet?
Then there are the car accidents, roads are an eyesore.
I mean I drive as I live in the country but I kind of hate it too.

OP posts:
midgemagneto · 28/07/2021 12:15

For each product there will be a location that minimises the total transportation costs , dependent on the required raw materials and the final market

I would be surprised if that location was always China

derxa · 28/07/2021 12:10

.

Badbadbunny · 28/07/2021 11:22

@EvilPea

I’m not entirely sure having one manufacturing hub (China) for the world is the best use of fuels.it needs shipping of materials there, then manufacturing, then shipping back to ports around the world, a lorry to another distribution centre and then a van to its final destination.

Then when finished with, the reverse happens for recycling.

It actually makes sense to have huge manufacturing facilities in one place. There's no where where the all the raw materials and the consumer market are in the same place. So if you move the manufacturing plants closer to raw materials, you may be moving them away from the consumer market, and vice versa. From a logistics perspective, it's much more efficient to have all manufacturing in one place. That way, the ships taking raw materials from source to manufacturing location can be loaded with finished goods to take to the consumer market, in an "efficient" triangle". You wouldn't want ships going from manufacturing to consumer and then returning empty or from raw material source to manufacture and returning empty. There'll be enormous efficiencies in having all the manufacturing plant in one location, i.e. all the support services, such as building, plant manufacturing/installation, plant/building maintenance, etc.

It would be far less efficient to have hundreds/thousands of separate smaller manufacturing facilities closer to the end consumer location. You may save on "delivery miles" between factory and consumer, but you've massively increase "delivery miles" between raw material source and factories all over the world, not to mention the loss of "economies of scale" as smaller factories would be less productive/efficient than larger ones.

midgemagneto · 28/07/2021 11:15

Cities haven't been designed around cars but our way of life has

Be that expectation to all arrive in the office at 9, expectations that all members of the household will work and so at least one person is unlikely to live close to work , expectations to live in a nice area not just close to work , expectations to have and do lots of stuff that requires you to travel because it's more cost effective for the store /cinema to be large and serve a large area...

Woeismethischristmas · 28/07/2021 11:14

@burritofan

So what happened at 30 to make you decide, “Nah, fuck the planet”?
I think what happens is it’s convenient not to drive and you can get holier than thou points for deciding it’s due to climate change. Then it’s inconvenient so becomes a necessity but oh so worrying so you don’t seem like a hypocrite.

I haven’t flown anywhere in ten years. Mainly due to finances and not wanting to travel with small children. That my carbon footprint is smaller is a good thing but I’m not going to pretend it’s my only reason cause I’m not an arse.

Briset · 28/07/2021 11:12

Well obviously there is a combination of factors causing it.

On the topic of cars though, it always amazes me how people on here will inform non drivers that their life must be impossible. I don't drive, DH can but doesn't and we have brought up 2 children who are now in their 20s, without a car, no problem at all.

Yes, we do live in London and of course that makes it easier. However, my parents live in a very rural area where I am repeatedly told it is 'impossible' to get by without a car. In fact, there are buses. Not regular and you have to walk or cycle a bit to get to the stops, but they do exist and we regularly visit and stay there (they don't have a car either so we don't rely on them as a taxi service). Also, when we go on holiday we can go where ever we want. With a combination of public transport, cycling or walking we manage just fine, We also keep fit and get closer to the scenery and local people in the process. My children grew up like that, they went to all the same after school clubs and trips and excursions, visited friends etc. and now they are in their 20s they don't drive either (incidentally very few of their friends do either).

The growth of online shopping has made things even easier. Of course there are people who have to drive because of their work, or disability or whatever, however, there are vast numbers of people who really don't need to. And I am getting more and more fed up of having to breathe the awful pollution from cars that people insist they have to have one.

Badbadbunny · 28/07/2021 11:10

@SelkieQualia

Our cities are designed around cars. This needs to change; active transport should be given priority.
It's the opposite. The main problem in cities is that they havn't been designed for cars. Most cities were "designed" in the decades/centuries before cars existed. Road systems have been squeezed in to built up areas not really suited to them. Hence the congestion, pollution, etc. Traffic management such as one way systems, pedestrianisation, etc has generally made things worse rather than better. We have huge car parks where access is ridiculously tight via narrow/winding roads etc. Not to mention some very busy one way systems that weave their way round 90 degree sharp corners to wind between buildings. In a lot of towns/cities, a few demolitions would make a massive difference to improving traffic flow thus reducing congestion/pollution, but town planners never do it. They're happy to demolish for shopping centres, car parks, bus stations, etc., but never to re-align a road bottleneck.
midgemagneto · 28/07/2021 11:08

@whistlers

Streaming tv is terrible for the environment
Really?

What worse than driving to a cinema ?

Comms / networking including laptops, tv etc is about 3% of total emission

Travel snd transport about 28% of uk emissions

So yeah steaming tv must be dreadful

EvilPea · 28/07/2021 11:06

I’m not entirely sure having one manufacturing hub (China) for the world is the best use of fuels.it needs shipping of materials there, then manufacturing, then shipping back to ports around the world, a lorry to another distribution centre and then a van to its final destination.

Then when finished with, the reverse happens for recycling.

RandomLondoner · 28/07/2021 10:58

OK, I have just found an up-to-date list of per-capita emissions by country. China is 12th-worst in the list, UK is almost the same at 13th.

So in a list just long enough to include the UK, China is the second best, after the UK.

From worst to less bad, the list is
Saudi Arabia
Australia
USA
Canada
South Korea
Russia
Japan
Germany
South Africa
Polan
Iran
China
United Kingdom

user1493494961 · 28/07/2021 10:55

Overpopulation.

whistlers · 28/07/2021 10:53

Streaming tv is terrible for the environment

12Day0fReturnImagine · 28/07/2021 10:51

Mobile phones & internet/ communications infrastructure takes lots of energy, resources & manpower to maintain, repair, upgrade

Not all data centres are based in Iceland with renewable energy or under sea

RandomLondoner · 28/07/2021 10:50

It was a while ago that I looked at data, so if my memories of the figures for per-capita emissions are wrong, I'm happy to be corrected.

RandomLondoner · 28/07/2021 10:49

I believe four nations are possibly responsible for much of the global harm. These nations being USA, India, China and Brazil.

Countries should not be in anyone's shit-list because they happen to be big. Put another way, people should not be expected to consume less than people in other countries because they happen to be in a big country.

All countries need to tighten up, but it is per-capita emissions that should be the measure. On that measure, China is not an exceptional country, but USA and Japan are countries that need to do more than others.

RandomLondoner · 28/07/2021 10:45

China depends heavily on coal to generate electricity

"China" is what Americans say to derail criticisms of themselves. The last time I checked China had comparable per-capita emissions to many respectable European countries.

USA and (surprisingly) Japan were much worse than China.

midgemagneto · 28/07/2021 10:37

Renewable plus base of nuclear plus car and giga battery storage works

midgemagneto · 28/07/2021 10:36

The uk had already seen a massive shift in electric generation

We now produce half the carbon per unit of electricity that we did 10 years ago

The need to scale demand and continue to reduce reliance on fossils is well understood and is going well

I am not working for national grid!

The availablity of car batteries actually helps as cars are parked up 90% of the time

That's the easy bit

12Day0fReturnImagine · 28/07/2021 10:32

If the future is electric cars & electric public transport

All new property should have solar panels

Roads & pavements can have solar or electric generating panels installed

Where is all the extra electricity going to be created from, because renewable energy will not supply all the need

midgemagneto · 28/07/2021 10:29

If you get an electric car today and get by on overnight charging you will most likely be on green electricity

Frymetothemoon · 28/07/2021 10:28

Textile production
Industrial farming
Unnecessary crap
Shipping unnecessary crap around the planet
Road freight

I think you'll find all of those are worse than cars

Oh and having kids, of course...

Nengineer · 28/07/2021 10:23

I'm a vegan and grow a huge amount of my own food. I don't have a brood of children. But I do have a land cruiser and an old hummer (not in UK) and even though they are thirsty, I don't believe they are murdering polar bears. It's generally the earth mums with 4 kids who smugly bicycle around in my experience. Never mind they made 4 consuming farting little darlings.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 28/07/2021 10:13

I understand global climate change is due to industrialisation and our consumer lifestyle choices for manufactured products and food sources plus the use of fossil fuels in all transportation but possible greatest negative impact is in civil and military aviation. Obviously military conflicts and wars equals death and ecological mass destruction by intent.

I believe four nations are possibly responsible for much of the global harm. These nations being USA, India, China and Brazil. The UK is a very high per capita energy intensive nation given its relative small geographical footprint but large per capita ecological footprint. The use of battery power personal transportation is only a better solution if the energy source is generated from new renewable technologies. I don’t believe much of the UK electricity generation is from renewables so therefore the electric car still runs on indirect fossil fuels plus the requirement of much finite rare earths which is mostly currently found and mined in China at great ecological expense for batteries.

Going forward our first world appetite for energy dense lifestyles is possibly not massively sustainable if the majority global poor developing nations also aspire to constantly jetting around post pandemic on inexpensive package tourism and all wish to own and importantly drive cars to American levels of ownership and mileage etc plus consumer spending habits on demand instant gratification remote order via mobile touchscreen for same day to the home delivery logistics etc. All this adds up and allows business people to play with ever bigger toys to travel further from our planet and pollute the space around us too burning excessive fossil fuels to reach these outer parts as with aviation for leisure.

In short we need to moderate our behaviours and yes perhaps the number of people on the planet is not sustainable if we all have high per capita energy and resources footprint without massive rethink on a cooperative global scale and effort. The Maldives etc may yet be survival above water as the Artic Tundra becomes a global transportation route and possibly food production etc.

Think and act marginally greener if possible and not hypocritical like doing a bit of recycling but globe trotting constantly on “ecotourism” saviour mode using as much personal carbon emissions as possible! Go greener not green washing pretence.

12Day0fReturnImagine · 28/07/2021 09:52

Space travel

12Day0fReturnImagine · 28/07/2021 09:50

I've travelled to other countries

No rubbish collection, people burn their domestic waste. Home firs for warmth & cooking

People in all countries building houses & farming on what was once green land, desert or forest

Industry

Aeroplanes, cars, motorbikes, boats, transport

The biggest must be over population ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread