Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New tenants are refusing to hand over my daughter’s parcels

334 replies

PerseverancePays · 27/07/2021 21:42

My daughter ordered £200 worth of clothes for herself and her baby from Next and forgot to put her new address on the order form. The courier has sent a photo of the door opened to her old flat with a man’s leg showing accepting the parcels. She asked her upstairs neighbour to pop down and get the parcels and hang on to them until I can get round there, but the new tenants have point blank said they’ve not had any parcels delivered !
I’m going round there tomorrow morning to show them the picture of them receiving them and seeing what they have to say about that.
If they still refuse, which is daylight robbery, would the police take any notice at all?
I’m also a bit nervous as I’m a short and small woman and easily intimidated. WWYD?

OP posts:
StrangeToSee · 28/07/2021 09:21

And yes this is theft and yes the police will be interested in it particularly as the delivery company has proof

The delivery company only has proof it was delivered to the address the DD ordered it to! So I doubt Next will take responsibility as they have proof they delivered it to the address on the order form.

They’re unlikely to refund £200 when they’ve delivered to the address DD told them to send it to, and have a photo of her door.

As for the tenants, if they’ve kept it yes it’s theft. But how do police prove whose leg it is in the photo? What if the new tenants had several guests or friends over that day? What if a male visitor or uncle or grandpa took the parcel in then left it lying around, it could easily get thrown away or mistaken for rubbish? (Especially if they’ve just moved in and there are boxes and packing materials lying around). Or perhaps whoever took it in realised it had the wrong name, left it outside the door for the old tenant and forgot to tell the new tenant. Someone else could have taken it. Does the building have CCTV inside?

Even if the tenants opened it and kept it (which is clearly theft) they could have hidden it away or given it to someone else. Would police honestly get a search warrant for a parcel someone sent to the wrong address?

Dohrehmee · 28/07/2021 09:10

If a package has someone else’s name on. And you have just recently moved in. It’s obvious the package is the previous tenants. In that case the new tenants should have looked at the name and said it was not them And given to the courier , Or if they’d not realised until they had package and saw the name. They could have contacted the letting agency to ask them to ask the previous tenant Mrs x to come and get their parcel or contact next to say a parcel was sent to the address but that person doesn’t live there . This is what decent humans would do.

NumberTheory · 28/07/2021 08:45

@neveradullmoment99

It is theft. It would have had her name on the parcels despite the wrong address. I had a similar situation happen to me except the owners of the house were in a home ( she was elderly) and only an occasional visit from family so they didn't know a parcel would be there. Next refunded no problem.
They can’t keep and use whatever’s in the parcel for themselves. But refusing to give it to the neighbour, or even the OP is not theft by itself and neither is lying about receiving it to the neighbour.
neveradullmoment99 · 28/07/2021 08:42

@Moonlaserbearwolf

Don’t go and immediately accuse the parcel holders of anything. It’s possible they didn’t want to give the parcel to the upstairs neighbours if they didn’t know them. They might hand over the parcel to your daughter straight away.

Unless your daughter can’t physically get there, I would leave this to your daughter to manage. It’s her name on the parcel and she should be asking for it back.

If they don’t give the parcel straight away your daughter can show them the photo evidence.

Last resort - say she will shame them on local Facebook site and/or log crime with the police.

Agree with all of this!
Ozanj · 28/07/2021 08:42

And yes this is theft and yes the police will be interested in it particularly as the delivery company has proof.

StrangeToSee · 28/07/2021 08:42

How do you know the leg in the photo wasn’t a visitor or guest opening the door, not the tenant? He could have put the package somewhere and forgotten all about it, or (if the dishonest sort) kept it without the tenant knowing anything had been delivered.

Why would a man keep hold of your daughter’s clothes and baby clothes? It seems highly unlikely he’d have any use for them!

Your DD gave the wrong address (I’ve done it before and the new tenant kindly returned my dress to the company) but I don’t think your DD has claim to items she sent to the wrong address? It’s at the goodwill of the new tenants, some people just bin mail addressed to the previous tenant.

I once opened a package that was delivered to my address but actually meant for next door! It was sandwiched between my parcels, so I didn’t realise until I’d opened it and wondered why someone had sent me several sets of lingerie in the wrong size (that I hadn’t ordered!) Then I looked at the address and realised it was for next door. I was far too embarrassed to take it round in case her husband or son opened the door and I had to explain I’d opened it by mistake, so I re-packaged it and re-posted it to her anonymously! She’s a lovely lady but I’m sure she’d be horrified if she knew I’d seen her order. Really it was the postman’s fault for not checking the addresses when he bundled the packages together with a rubber band and I signed for the whole lot thinking they were mine!

Ozanj · 28/07/2021 08:41

Knock, tell them Next have asked you to report it to the police as theft, but you wanted to make sure it definitely hasn’t been delivered first. They will bring it out.

Goldi321 · 28/07/2021 08:40

I’d take the baby around in too small clothes and explain that they were clothes for the baby!

neveradullmoment99 · 28/07/2021 08:38

It is theft.
It would have had her name on the parcels despite the wrong address. I had a similar situation happen to me except the owners of the house were in a home ( she was elderly) and only an occasional visit from family so they didn't know a parcel would be there. Next refunded no problem.

KaptainKaveman · 28/07/2021 08:38

@thedancingbear

It's theft, and your neighbours need to be a bit careful here.

It all depends on whether the local constabulary can haul themselves off their arses and find time to pop around.

Yes, because in general Police officers are massively indolent aren't they? Hmm.
Youdiditanyway · 28/07/2021 08:37

All you can do is either go round, hope they answer the door, show them the delivery pic and ask for it back. Failing that you can ask the police for advice but I don’t think it’s theft because the parcel was delivered to their address. May have to chalk it up to experience.

User56439876 · 28/07/2021 08:34

@Iminaglasscaseofemotion

Honestly, how did I know that I would open this and there would be post after post demanding to know why the dd doesn't sort it herself, and why you would be getting involved. So boringly predictable, and embarrassing that not one of them seemed to have the capacity to work out she might have moved away, or be in hospital, or be isolating, any number of reasons actually. So frustrating to read the same tripe over and over.
Of course the daughter should sort it out it was her error, if she doesn't want to do this in person, she should contact Next as the tenants could think it was a scam, we are always being warned about these type of scams.
SnoopyLights · 28/07/2021 08:31

I used to work for Next and I think they might actually be really helpful to your daughter if she just rings them and explains the situation.

The people in the call centres often have (or used to have when I was there) a lot of flexibility for helping when things go wrong, and people not updating their addresses was a very common issue.

NumberTheory · 28/07/2021 08:31

@H8H8H8

If you left your bike unlocked and someone took it, it would (normally) be theft. If you put it in their garage and they shut the door, it wouldn’t. At least, not until they did something else that made it theft.

Not true.

‘Tis true.

They need to appropriate dishonestly - which they hasn’t been done if you just put it in their garage. You can’t make thieves out of people simply by leaving things in their homes.

ChainJane · 28/07/2021 08:30

Your daughter needs to arrange for Next to contact the people it was delivered to and arrange for it to be picked up from them, delivery can then be re-arranged for the correct address. They will probably charge her for this because it's two more deliveries.

The people who received it would be idiots to hand it over to anyone other than the courier. It's such an obvious scam I'm surprised anyone thinks it reasonable to expect them hand it over to a neighbour, the OP or even her daughter.

The only party it should be given to is the original sender.

ikeepseeingit · 28/07/2021 08:29

Your daughter needs to go over, they don’t know that neighbour, maybe they didn’t want to give the parcel to someone random! She needs to go over and start by asking politely and explaining that she forgot to change the address, if that doesn’t work she can just show the photograph of the leg. Idk why you’ve assumed they’re thieves and terrible people when they might be trying to do her a favour.

LawnFever · 28/07/2021 08:25

Why would they hand it over to the neighbour? They don’t know who they are, if only hand it to someone with ID matching the name on the parcel, they might think it’s some kind of scam.

LawnFever · 28/07/2021 08:23

@thedancingbear

It's theft, and your neighbours need to be a bit careful here.

It all depends on whether the local constabulary can haul themselves off their arses and find time to pop around.

It’s hardly theft when the parcel was delivered to the address it was intended for, the courier did their job - another member of the household could’ve answered the door previously and genuinely known nothing about it.
Moonlaserbearwolf · 28/07/2021 08:21

Don’t go and immediately accuse the parcel holders of anything. It’s possible they didn’t want to give the parcel to the upstairs neighbours if they didn’t know them. They might hand over the parcel to your daughter straight away.

Unless your daughter can’t physically get there, I would leave this to your daughter to manage. It’s her name on the parcel and she should be asking for it back.

If they don’t give the parcel straight away your daughter can show them the photo evidence.

Last resort - say she will shame them on local Facebook site and/or log crime with the police.

Lostinthemail · 28/07/2021 08:21

@Amandasummers that doesn’t mean my address wasn’t used by these people to order items without paying, for example. So no way I would hand over the parcel.

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 28/07/2021 08:18

Honestly, how did I know that I would open this and there would be post after post demanding to know why the dd doesn't sort it herself, and why you would be getting involved. So boringly predictable, and embarrassing that not one of them seemed to have the capacity to work out she might have moved away, or be in hospital, or be isolating, any number of reasons actually. So frustrating to read the same tripe over and over.

changingstages · 28/07/2021 08:18

this happened to me, but it was my brother sending my (then three year old) daughter's Christmas and birthday present to our previous, rented, address (we'd only moved a few weeks before). We could not get it back. The tenant refused to admit he had it (though he'd signed for it).

He was a vicar.

JudgeJ · 28/07/2021 08:17

@Googlewasmyidea1

Jeez, there's some cold people on here! She put the wrong address by mistake, that doesn't entitle them to steal the parcels
No-one is saying that they're entitled to keep the parcels delivered to them, the question is about the police involvement when the daughter made the initial mistake.
PissedOffNeighbour22 · 28/07/2021 08:17

Definitely agree with @BlatantlyNameChanged. Good advice.

If you have no luck, it's worth speaking with next. I've had some issues with parcels lately and they've been excellent. They may send a courier to collect the parcel (it might not get handed over though) or they may refund.

Also, if you have a local Facebook page, stick it on there. There would have been plenty of shock and dismay where I used to live Grin. You never know, someone may let you know if they've been selling the goods on Facebook etc.

OhGiveUp · 28/07/2021 08:12

A parcel of mine was delivered to a neighbour of mine several doors down.
They denied all knowledge of it, despite the courier card saying it had been given to 'Jane' at number one.
I called the police and they attended.
'Jane' denied all knowledge of it.
Then during the night the parcel was thrown over my fence into my garden.
So yes, I'd call the police. Theft is theft.