Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New tenants are refusing to hand over my daughter’s parcels

334 replies

PerseverancePays · 27/07/2021 21:42

My daughter ordered £200 worth of clothes for herself and her baby from Next and forgot to put her new address on the order form. The courier has sent a photo of the door opened to her old flat with a man’s leg showing accepting the parcels. She asked her upstairs neighbour to pop down and get the parcels and hang on to them until I can get round there, but the new tenants have point blank said they’ve not had any parcels delivered !
I’m going round there tomorrow morning to show them the picture of them receiving them and seeing what they have to say about that.
If they still refuse, which is daylight robbery, would the police take any notice at all?
I’m also a bit nervous as I’m a short and small woman and easily intimidated. WWYD?

OP posts:
melj1213 · 28/07/2021 01:07

@MinkeDinkie

Well until your daughter speaks to them I'd not be getting het up. They might not have wanted to hand over to a random neighbour incase they weren't genuine and just gave an excuse. Or one tenant might have put it to one side for you and the other was unaware.

Until they tell you to your face (at which point you can show them the delivery photo) it's a bit unfair calling them thieves.

^ This

They may be wholly dishonest but there may also be a breakdown in communication.

I would have your DD go round, with proof of ID and the order details and speak to the tenants before anything else.

She needs to knock, be apologetic and explain the situation - she is a former tenant and forgot to update her address for this delivery and she has been provided proof of delivery to this address. Do they have her parcel? If so, she is so sorry for the inconvenience and will ensure her address is updated in future and won't bother them again. If not then she needs to report the theft to the police since the proof of delivery from the courier shows it being accepted at this address.

xsquared · 28/07/2021 01:04

There is a common scam of people getting parcels delivered to random addresses then knocking on the door to pick them up. Parcel may have you dd's name on but their address.

@Dontfuckingsaycheese

Why would someon send a parcel to another address with their name on it but somebody else's address? The only time I have done that is if I was on holiday at my in laws and send it to their address for when I arrive.

NumberTheory · 28/07/2021 00:58

@JustLoveYourselfALittle

It is theft they could have said to the courrier 'sorry they've moved out' and let them return to sender.?
The fact they could have done something different doesn't mean it's theft.

And it may be they didn't realize the person the parcel was addressed to wasn't living at the house (if a friend housesitting answered the door for example, or if they just didn't check who it was addressed to).

So far they've had someone send them a parcel that they shouldn't have (hassle) and a random neighbour who isn't that person has come and asked them about what post they get. The fact they are not forthcoming to a nosey neighbour about what parcels they receive is hardly an indication of guilt.

Doesn't mean they aren't intending keeping the stuff. It's just they're being condemned here for, so far, doing no more than many MNers would advise them to do if they'd posted that they'd received a parcel addressed to someone they don't know.

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 28/07/2021 00:54

There is a common scam of people getting parcels delivered to random addresses then knocking on the door to pick them up. Parcel may have you dd's name on but their address. Similar happened to us. ASOS parcel. DS took it in as our neighbour often has ASOS parcels. I contacted ASOS bit of a faff and sent it back to them. Someone from our estate out on group chat who's taken in my parcel?? I pointed out it had our address on. Had no idea whose it was and had returned it. She sounded pretty arsy and said 'that was quick...' which particularly pissed me off. No apology. No thanks. Even when I supplied her with the return code. I reminded her to change address to correct one before she reordered.

Yaya26 · 28/07/2021 00:51

May have been mentioned before but I wouldn't mention if I didn't have to that the photo is only of their leg. I'd just say photo. You could also beef it up that the courier has provided a statement and description of recipient?

JustLoveYourselfALittle · 28/07/2021 00:26

It is theft they could have said to the courrier 'sorry they've moved out' and let them return to sender.?

NumberTheory · 28/07/2021 00:21

@BluebellsareBlue

Retired cop here... can't believe posters saying police wouldn't be interested, this is a simple theft. If you don't get it OP call the police they will deal with it as the theft it is
I think you may have lost some of your sharpness in retirement. This is not simple theft at all. For a start, there is no dishonest appropriation.
NumberTheory · 28/07/2021 00:18

@MinkeDinkie

Well until your daughter speaks to them I'd not be getting het up. They might not have wanted to hand over to a random neighbour incase they weren't genuine and just gave an excuse. Or one tenant might have put it to one side for you and the other was unaware.

Until they tell you to your face (at which point you can show them the delivery photo) it's a bit unfair calling them thieves.

^^ This. Your daughter needs to go round. With ID and, possibly, proof of her current address. Even then they may not want to hand it over fearing it may be a scam of some sort. So she will need to be prepared to ask them to return it to Next instead (which she might need to speak to next about, since there will be postage costs etc for something that is her fault).
MurielSpriggs · 28/07/2021 00:01

If they won't hand it over, although theft seems to have happened, it's probably going to be very difficult for the police to establish beyond reasonable doubt who the thief is, so you can forget any prosecution.

If you want to get legalistic you could threaten them with a small-claims court action in civil law - look up the tort of conversion. The burden of proof is much lower - only on the "balance of probabilities". Whether you can be arsed with any of that is another matter entirely.

A threat of section 21 eviction at the end of the term is another option.

MinkeDinkie · 27/07/2021 23:50

Well until your daughter speaks to them I'd not be getting het up. They might not have wanted to hand over to a random neighbour incase they weren't genuine and just gave an excuse. Or one tenant might have put it to one side for you and the other was unaware.

Until they tell you to your face (at which point you can show them the delivery photo) it's a bit unfair calling them thieves.

beigebrownblue · 27/07/2021 23:48

I've had a 'neighbour' take in a parcel and then lie
about it.

They said the babysitter 'opened it'

I never saw it again and let it drop but now wish i hadn't.

beigebrownblue · 27/07/2021 23:44

The photograph is significant.

I have orderded many things in pandemic over two years or so.
Most arrived successfully.

However one or two sent by hermes
included a photograph of a premises which was clearly not mine,
i.e. we live in a flat and the photo was of a house and parcel left on top of a shed which we do not have.

I was able to query this with sender, make a complaint and get refund or replacement parcel.

I feel you should be able to do the same.

The man;s leg was clearly a man (not your daughter)

And therefore parcel not delivered to person who ordered it.

Would complain on those grounds.

Good luck

Cherrysoup · 27/07/2021 23:44

If it's Hermes then you can just say that they put it in the bin on collection day. They probably did, after all.

Given the OP says she has a photo of the door being opened as the parcel was handed over, that’s a moot point.

Themeparklover · 27/07/2021 23:38

Even if there is a photo it doesn't mean they have the parcels, I know quite a few people who have had photos of stuff being delivered, that wasn't the drivers often submit the photo before the tenants state its not there, if anything I would be querying the delivery guy or next, we've had it a few times where I've accidentally ordered to my parents instead of mine who have refused the parcel but I'm still shown a photo of it at their front door with one of my parents opening the door in the background

memberofthewedding · 27/07/2021 23:38

This happened to me with my NDN some years ago. Parcel was mis-deliverd by the courier which I found out in a conversation with him. It had been with NDN for two weeks with no attempt to bring it around or tell me it was there.

I took my nephew with me for backup. When NDN answered the door I told her I had come for my parcel, adding that I knew she had it as I had just spoken to the courier. At first NDN denied all knowledge of it. Nephew took out his phone and suggested that she check with other family members that one of them had not taken it in and put it away by mistake. As otherwise he was going to get the police out. NDN goes inside the house and after a few minutes comes out with parcel, which had been opened. At that point we both started in on her as to why she had opened a parcel not addressed to her. It was addressed to my company name. She said "Well I didnt know it was for you." Nephew snaps "Well you bloody well knew it wasn't for you. I think I had better call the police anyway."

NDN busts into tears and insists its a misunderstanding. I told her I would take no further action on this occasion. However I was going to warn all the delivery people that she was dishonest and never to leave my packages there. Nowadays whenever Im expecting a package I watch out for it on the tracking and CCTV. I also attach a not to me door saying "DO NOT LEAVE AT NO XX - NOT HONEST". I have also warned all the local couriers.

I have also point blank refused to take in parcels for her and I tell the couriers why.

OneEpisode · 27/07/2021 23:32

Could you print out all formal-like the name and address the parcel was sent to, description of the delivery, date and photo of the open door, and ask the new tenants to sign a statement that they didn’t receive the delivery? With names, addresses etc? For the police to take action against the courier. Make it look as official as you can. If they aren’t there leave it with an envelope for them to post back to you.
I think they will find the flatmate took in the parcels.

NekoShiro · 27/07/2021 23:31

Was it supposed to be signed for? Email the courier because they should of done some kind of check if they were bothering with photographing it

BluebellsareBlue · 27/07/2021 23:30

Retired cop here... can't believe posters saying police wouldn't be interested, this is a simple theft. If you don't get it OP call the police they will deal with it as the theft it is

DoTheNextRightThing · 27/07/2021 23:26

This is what Confused.com has to say. I think the tricky part is that it was delivered to the correct address but with a name of someone who doesn't live there. A bit of a grey area. But they've still taken something which doesn't belong to them.

New tenants are refusing to hand over my daughter’s parcels
DdraigGoch · 27/07/2021 23:25

@meido

It’s only illegal to open someone else’s mail which has been delivered to your house if you intend to commit fraud (such as identify theft).

Otherwise, it isn’t illegal.

It's illegal to refuse to hand it over though. That's theft.

The police like having an easy crime to solve. It balances out all of those unsolved burglaries and improves the figures so that the Superintendent can get his promotion.

EastWestWhosBest · 27/07/2021 23:23

But they have been delivered

They have been delivered to the address they were given. As far as Next are concerned it’s not their problem.

DdraigGoch · 27/07/2021 23:22

And why the hell would that matter? Oh it's only Hermes, I can steal this! Hmm

If it's Hermes then you can just say that they put it in the bin on collection day. They probably did, after all.

Livelovebehappy · 27/07/2021 23:22

@LawnFever

I’d just go round really friendly and say the parcels have been delivered by mistake, show them the pictures and see what they say.

Don’t accuse them of anything, they haven’t really done anything wrong, it was your DDs mistake.

Any reason you’re planning on going round and not her?

Seriously?? Of course they’ve done something wrong. Unless you consider that accepting something that clearly doesn’t belong to them, with someone’ else’s name on, is all fine and dandy! How can that be ‘not wrong’? Some very skewed moral compasses on this thread.
Antwerpen · 27/07/2021 23:19

@Formaldeheidi

The police aren’t going to be interested as it’s your daughters responsibility to change her address. The best she can do is report to Next that the parcel hasn’t been delivered and get a refund/exchange.
But they have been delivered Hmm
meido · 27/07/2021 23:18

It’s only illegal to open someone else’s mail which has been delivered to your house if you intend to commit fraud (such as identify theft).

Otherwise, it isn’t illegal.