Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask, if you are antivax (not just Covid) but use modern medicine, where is the line?

113 replies

LivingInABuildingSite · 27/07/2021 19:56

Just found out an old friend is totally antivax (not just Covid although that’s how it came up in conversation).

I asked if she’d had her kids vaccinated with the usual baby ones, no, none of them. She said she believes in homeopathy (which I’m not averse to, just wouldn’t rely on). I’m quite shocked but messaged that we’d agree to disagree on this one, as don’t want to wreck the friendship.

So thought I’d ask on here.

Now I know she had c-sections for all of her DC so it got me thinking.

If you don’t agree with using the discoveries of modern medicine in the form of vaccinations to prevent unpleasant but entirely avoidable illnesses, why is it ok to accept similar discoveries such as anaesthesia (and not just in an emergency situation)?

Where is the tipping point of what’s ok to accept and what isn’t?

I’m really interested to hear antivaxxer views, as I’ve only come across those shouting at me outside the vaccine clinic (volunteer) who aren’t up for a conversation about it, and this friend, who I don’t want to push any further.

Taking it a step further, is it ok to trust in a more natural way of things, but wear makeup? Or eat processed food (I’m sure her kids don’t eat 100% vegan, organic, etc)? Or even use the internet?

Where is the line?

OP posts:
LivingInABuildingSite · 27/07/2021 21:37

Those cousins would make for a lively family get together!!

Tigers - see that at least is consistent. If bonkers and sad.

OP posts:
Mreggsworth · 27/07/2021 21:36

Not related to the covid vaccine, but I do remember a mum on my Facebook making a big post about why she chose to not vaccinate her children, and it went something along the lines of these points:

-The world is cleaner now and people are healthier, kids dont pick up diseases like they did in "the old days" (most stupid point ever)
-'Big pharma' make money by making people scared of illnesses that don't exist.
-We need to take responsibility for our own health
-how do we know we arent being poisoned.

  • it's all about control / corruption

When I read most of those reasons, it does make sense that they should then deny medical intervention too as being Ill is their 'failure to take responsibility for own health' and how could they trust what is being given to them to cure an illness but not prevent one?

blublub · 27/07/2021 21:36

Don’t know why I posted that tbh. I don’t think anyone who asks these questions actually cares about the answers. Just seems to turn into an excuse for people to make themselves feel good about themselves for not being an ‘anti vaxxer’, which is a ludicrous pigeon-holing term in itself. No one is defined wholeheartedly on their medical status or religious or philosophical view points in one particular area of their life. But it seems that’s the point we have reached as a society. I think that is more damaging to society than any disease.

LivingInABuildingSite · 27/07/2021 21:35

Chunder - that’s certainly the impression I get from those outside the vaccine clinics who aren’t up for a rational chat!

Blubub - I can get that logic to some degree, preemptive vs reactive use of medicine. It’s more the ‘I won’t put X into my body’ until actually I will put any old thing in. Did she interrogate the Obs/Gynae about what was in the anaesthetic to check the ingredients? Unlikely IMO.

OP posts:
TigersandTeddybears · 27/07/2021 21:33

I know of an anti vaxxer who is also a bit of a conspiracy theorist and has refused cancer treatment and is now terminal. I am really sad for them and their family and can't agree medically but also think they are less hypocritical than people who pick and choose.

lljkk · 27/07/2021 21:33

Not me but a cousin - C1... funny enough he's had the covid jab. But his kids have had none of the routine childhood vaccinations (except maybe tetanus -- or maybe not?). He's getting MSc in organic chemistry & maybe the scientific method is changing him.

cousin-1 has a brother, cousin-2 who is very specifically anti-covid jabs & pro Trump, somehow the lockdown controls etc are part of a left wing conspiracy against people like C2. But I imagine all of cousin-2's kids have had the usual jabs. The wider family is currently despairing about C2 not getting covid jab even though C1's kids are mostly unvaccinated.

C1 & C2 share a brother, cousin-3 who is very pro-vacc and conventional (a civil engineer). C3 didn't want his own baby around C1's unvacc'd kids. I don't fancy family gathering with all 3 brothers...

imho, cousin-1 does a lot of magical thinking. He's convinced that stem cell technology will make us all live forever, eventually. Not anti-science, just very skewed perception of what science can or should do.

blublub · 27/07/2021 21:31

I think the point is it is doing something that could potentially cause harm. The other stuff has already happened so you’re treating it. My take anyway. You can yell percentages until you’re blue in the face, but if you are responsible for ill effects by having a vaccine, that’s a big difference imo. No matter the balance of risks. You’re not responsible for getting a disease/needing treatment, but you are responsible for injecting yourself with something.

chunderwunder · 27/07/2021 21:25

I think you're looking at this wrong. No conspiracy theory holds up to logical scrutiny and each deluded victim will have their own 'facts' as to why they eschew this, that or the other.

There is no line. It's where people want it and it won't be based on anything supported by fact.

NB. homeopathy is bollocks.

LivingInABuildingSite · 27/07/2021 21:23

That’s what I think too Hamster - being antivax is a luxury only those who are surrounded by the vaccinated can choose.

I grew up abroad where people had limited access to medicine, they would think the antivax crowd insane. And I’m not talking about the covid jab particularly, but measles, meningitis, etc,.

OP posts:
LivingInABuildingSite · 27/07/2021 21:22

Thanks for your thoughts.

I wonder what she’d do about her kids. There’s a little lad near here that’s starting his last (hopefully) round of chemo for a brain tumour. Would she let her kids have chemo if they had cancer?

One of my children would’ve died several times over without modern medicine; would she have refused those interventions if it was her kid?

She said her kids are healthy with high school attendance, I didn’t want to fight about it but in my opinion that’s just luck not judgement.

What if her daughter caught measles in the future when pregnant? Would she take the blame for not protecting her?

I don’t think any antivaxxers will come on to comment and share their thoughts which is a shame as I’d like to know more about those who think so differently to me.

OP posts:
Hamster1111 · 27/07/2021 21:17

Great question OP. I know a raging conspiracy theorist, vaccines will kill us all, 5G, the whole shebang... chuffs away on cigarettes... I think I know which will get her first Hmm

I really hope you get some good responses to this. Why be anti vaccines but accept other medicine? What if you had cancer? Is that ok?

I suspect the line is a rather selfish one. Vaccines depend on us all having them. It's for the wider community. Anti vaxxers dont see the need for them or their children to have them because they are healthy, young etc etc etc. But if they feel they need medication they'll take it.

Pippa12 · 27/07/2021 21:06

My DH and I were discussing this at the weekend. A friend of a friend had said wasn’t getting the vaccine as ‘she didn’t believe in putting sh*t in her body and trusted her immune system’. Yet she smokes heavily, drinks alcohol and has lots of tattoos Hmm

We also wondered if those who didn’t want the vaccine also wouldn’t want the medication to help treat a person with covid. I’m a critical care nurse so have 1st hand experience exactly how much gets pumped into a covid patient to keep them alive. Most of it we’ve used for years and years, some nee/lesser used drugs?

I try to avoid these debates these days tho, I don’t have the mental strength anymore.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 27/07/2021 19:58

I think that's a really interesting question about where is the line. Hoep this will go ok because I too am curious

Swipe left for the next trending thread