Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask, if you are antivax (not just Covid) but use modern medicine, where is the line?

113 replies

LivingInABuildingSite · 27/07/2021 19:56

Just found out an old friend is totally antivax (not just Covid although that’s how it came up in conversation).

I asked if she’d had her kids vaccinated with the usual baby ones, no, none of them. She said she believes in homeopathy (which I’m not averse to, just wouldn’t rely on). I’m quite shocked but messaged that we’d agree to disagree on this one, as don’t want to wreck the friendship.

So thought I’d ask on here.

Now I know she had c-sections for all of her DC so it got me thinking.

If you don’t agree with using the discoveries of modern medicine in the form of vaccinations to prevent unpleasant but entirely avoidable illnesses, why is it ok to accept similar discoveries such as anaesthesia (and not just in an emergency situation)?

Where is the tipping point of what’s ok to accept and what isn’t?

I’m really interested to hear antivaxxer views, as I’ve only come across those shouting at me outside the vaccine clinic (volunteer) who aren’t up for a conversation about it, and this friend, who I don’t want to push any further.

Taking it a step further, is it ok to trust in a more natural way of things, but wear makeup? Or eat processed food (I’m sure her kids don’t eat 100% vegan, organic, etc)? Or even use the internet?

Where is the line?

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 28/07/2021 10:51

I do have my own lines too, such as not taking anti biotic as a precaution, I'd likely decline mental health medication and I'm hesitant to take medications that have any addictive qualities

That all sounds very pragmatic and sensible and I'd probably take the same position as you on all of those. But that's all grounded in scientific evidence. There's tons of evidence around how antibiotics create resistance and the science of addiction. Mental health is more of an emerging field but I can understand your reticence to medicate depression for example.

But all of this is a very different kettle of fish from saying: "mother nature will take care of it" and suggesting that you can build up your "natural immunity" by eating the right foods and taking supplements etc. Of course eating healthily gives you a better overall immune defence position but there's no evidence that your diet can confer COVID immunity or anything like that.

Mreggsworth · 28/07/2021 10:12

I get some of the logic in drawing the line with some medical interventions, as I guess I do have my own lines too, such as not taking anti biotic as a precaution, I'd likely decline mental health medication and I'm hesitant to take medications that have any addictive qualities - though I think the key word Is hesitant, I would not rule it out.

However I think vaccines fall into a different category, vaccines to me are not so much about personal risk but about contributing to a healthy society and a shared responsibility. Therefore unless theres a medical exemption, I do find it hard to respect the reasons why someone would opt out of the collaborative effort to improve society health.

Most of the reasons people give I feel are very flawed, such as the risks of clots. This is a risk women have been taking with the pill for decades, it's nothing new.

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 28/07/2021 10:01

@FriedasCarLoad

I'm uneasy about the Covid vaccinations and some others, because of the use of lines from aborted babies in their creation or their testing - I'm pro-life.

I still had the covid vaccine - and my husband and children and I have all the recommended vaccinations. On balance, we feel it's the right thing to do - no new babies would be aborted because we choose to have the vaccine, whereas lives might be saved by herd immunity.

It's stem cells taken from viable embryos discarded by IVF clinics, not "aborted babies". Do you really think they fish them out of women and package them off to be used? Absolute bollocks.

The embryos would have otherwise been completely discarded FYI, as hundreds of thousands are each day...

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 28/07/2021 09:59

I spoke to a friend who is anti-vac after his son was very ill in hospital. I said essentially what you have, you trusted doctors then, why wouldn't you trust them now, and he told me, quite proudly that they'd removed him from the ward after turning his son's oxygen off at the tap, as he didn't believe he needed it. I was Shock but he seemed to be pleased that it marked him out as an "independent thinker" and not a "sheep". Beggars belief that people like this are allowed kids, though, incidentally, he is split from their mum and doesn't see them very often now...

FriedasCarLoad · 28/07/2021 09:54

I'm uneasy about the Covid vaccinations and some others, because of the use of lines from aborted babies in their creation or their testing - I'm pro-life.

I still had the covid vaccine - and my husband and children and I have all the recommended vaccinations. On balance, we feel it's the right thing to do - no new babies would be aborted because we choose to have the vaccine, whereas lives might be saved by herd immunity.

thepeopleversuswork · 28/07/2021 09:38

Shunning modern science actually comes from a position of privelege

Absolutely.

It's pure decadence.

GabriellaMontez · 28/07/2021 09:33

Well I can't speak for these people... they're probably all motivated differently anyway. But it seems obvious that 'the line' is where benefits outweigh risks. Clearly your friend isn't going to have surgery without anaesthesia.

Clearly

Whatisgoingonhere · 28/07/2021 09:28

LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus, I think your post is actually quite distasteful. Especially on a board for mothers, some of whom have lost children in childbirth or had sickly newborns who required medical intervention to survive, such as I did.

Good on you for aspiring to the Spartan ideal of raising strong children and exposing the weak/ill/deformed, but a little empathy wouldn’t go astray.

PromisingMiddleagedWoman · 28/07/2021 09:27

Out of the antivaxxers I know most are stupid or paranoid. Or are the type of person who hates being seen as mainstream and so will always take the minority viewpoint.

The only antivaxxer I know who doesn’t fit into any of these categories is a woman whose life experience has bred deep distrust of the medical system. She has had epilepsy since she was a teenager and has constantly struggled with finding a medical solution to control her epilepsy. Medicines don’t work, or have bad side effects, a doctor is dismissive to her, or doesn’t understand her situation etc. Decades of this mean she’s built up a lot of scepticism and distrust of mainstream medical thinking. In her context I can kind of understand her perspective (although I don’t agree with it).

rachelvbwho · 28/07/2021 09:22

@blublub I really appreciated your answer as I had never thought about it from that perspective before.

Thank you for sharing.

taliopolis · 28/07/2021 09:13

@LoislovesStewie

The reason old people wanted the vaccine wasn't because they are closer to death, but because a lot of them remember the days before effective vaccines and antibiotics. They remember kids with leg calipers as they had caught polio, or kids in iron lungs for the same reason, they remember TB and watching people die as there was no effective treatment or vaccine. And don't start on syphilis and how many people died as a result of Third Stage Syphilis as, yet again, there were no effective treatments. If you haven't done so, look at photos of babies or children with congenital syphilis. That is shocking. Sorry, but I think a lot of this is, as another said, just first world problems. We, who live in the developed world, don't see many people with polio, or TB or syphilis, or Ebola, or leprosy or any of the other truly awful infections or diseases, so we think they don't exist. My oldest has Type 1 diabetes, I thank modern medicine for developing treatment for the illness, for insulin pumps, continual blood sugar monitors and all the other medical wonders of the day. BTW my mother caught measles as a baby, she had very poor eyesight for her whole life and that was attributed to having measles. And as for testing babies during labour, thank goodness the obstetrician got out the forceps for me! And, yes, we have all had all of our vaccines.
Exactly this. My blood boils when I hear people talk about natural immunity, trusting our bodies. As for @LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus "tested by labour", there are no words. Let's see what a mother in a third world country who's lost several children in childbirth and other to preventable childhood illnesses think of these views, shall we? The phrase "we dint know we're born" comes to mind here Angry
Charliebradbury · 28/07/2021 09:05

In my experience there is no logic to anti vaxxers. Someone I know is very anti vaccine but seems fine with all other medical interventions. The thing is her child got meningitis as a toddler and it still hasn't made her change her mind.
As for the rhetoric about babies having to pass the test of birth. It's utter nonsense. My children were both born by c sections, my dd because she was stuck and my ds because my previous scar started to rupture. The idea that 2 perfectly healthy children and their mother should have died is abhorrent and coming from a nurse and midwife even worse.
My dad lost his dad when he was a toddler to polio, leaving my grandma with 3 young children to care for. My dh cousin is disabled due to meningitis, spent most of his childhood in and out of hospital having surgeries so that he could walk. His parents would have loved the meningitis vaccine believe me.

LoislovesStewie · 28/07/2021 08:59

The reason old people wanted the vaccine wasn't because they are closer to death, but because a lot of them remember the days before effective vaccines and antibiotics. They remember kids with leg calipers as they had caught polio, or kids in iron lungs for the same reason, they remember TB and watching people die as there was no effective treatment or vaccine. And don't start on syphilis and how many people died as a result of Third Stage Syphilis as, yet again, there were no effective treatments. If you haven't done so, look at photos of babies or children with congenital syphilis. That is shocking.
Sorry, but I think a lot of this is, as another said, just first world problems. We, who live in the developed world, don't see many people with polio, or TB or syphilis, or Ebola, or leprosy or any of the other truly awful infections or diseases, so we think they don't exist.
My oldest has Type 1 diabetes, I thank modern medicine for developing treatment for the illness, for insulin pumps, continual blood sugar monitors and all the other medical wonders of the day.
BTW my mother caught measles as a baby, she had very poor eyesight for her whole life and that was attributed to having measles.
And as for testing babies during labour, thank goodness the obstetrician got out the forceps for me! And, yes, we have all had all of our vaccines.

igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 08:58

Actually saying there would be "no point" giving a boy the rubella vaccine is somewhat strong. I just meant that I wouldn't consider it to be as serious an illness (having had rubella twice myself as a child before I had the vaccine at 12).

igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 08:54

I would have thought that the line is drawn where the risk of the vaccine (or not taking the medicine) is substantially less than the illness. And peoples' perceptions of that will differ.

So meningitis for me - no brainer to have the vaccine.

Rubella for a boy - leaving aside herd immunity, there would be no point.

Not taking ibuprofen for a headache when you have a stomach ulcer - very sensible and better to take an alternative or wait out the headache.

With the last example, it's also a question of convenience. If I have a headache can I go and lie down until it's gone? Or do I have work this morning and have I, for example, got to go into a school and teach several groups of 30 children? At that point you take the painkillers so you will feel ok for work.

beingsunny · 28/07/2021 08:52

This is an interesting question and I don't think it's a one size fits all answer.

I've had my first Pfizer a couple of weeks ago, I'm in Australia so only recently eligible. Since the beginning I've been hesitant, I have an autoimmune disease and was wary of a reaction, also it's new, they obviously don't know of any long term side effects the vaccine may cause. Look at the AZ Covid vaccine, we didn't know at the start that it could cause the clotting issue.

I am duly vaccinated as is my son, however when he was born I refused any drugs or pain relief, and didn't have him take the Vit K jab after birth. I'd weighed up the need and as it was a quick and easy water birth with no possible trauma I did t see the need for injecting my perfect baby with something he didn't need. It's a precautionary infusion.

He was also diagnosed with mild renal reflux, the doctors said he should be given low dose antibiotics twice a day until he was several years old 'just in case' he got a UTI, I started it but felt so uncomfortable with the idea of giving this to his small body I preferred to research the life out of symptoms for uti in small babies and take the risk.

The research on long term use of antibiotics and what damage that can do to a growing baby forming their immune system and gut flora can be serious in the long term. Not that I would suggest anyone else do the same, but we made the decision as parents together privately.

I'm not at all anti vax but do think there are occasions where a measured level of risk is a choice.

There's a difference between people lacking confidence in the Covid vaccine and the conspiracy people.

TrufflyPig · 28/07/2021 08:48

But this whole narrative that Mother Earth and "natural immunity" will provide a natural corrective to disease and therefore that science is not needed is a black whole of sinister bollocks

This! I have no idea why people think its a good idea to shun tested, regulated and effective modern medicine in favour of 'natural' remedies, an industry, which is largely unregulated.

Nature is a cruel beast, it wants you dead by 40 and expects you to have 12 kids in the hope that two or three might live to see adulthood, this was the reality before scientific advancement and is sadly still the case in some places.

Shunning modern science actually comes from a position of privelege.

snowpony · 28/07/2021 08:41

A friend of mine is completely anti-vax and yet regularly has Botox and fillers. Very much believes that Bill Gates is putting trackers in covid vaccines (and posts all this regularly on social media…) and has recently bought ivermectin tablets on line…..

thepeopleversuswork · 28/07/2021 08:08

I opted for home births as I wanted my children to be tested by labour, as I have seen in my work as a nurse and as a midwife babies who have been saved who really were meant to die, leaving them and their families with a poor quality of life. I am not accepting the Covid vaccine as I feel natural immunity is better than a vaccine, although I may change this view as I get older. I have a fully vegan diet. I try to take responsibility for my own health and accept the consequences. I feel I shouldn't have to put myself at risk of a vaccine to help others who don't look after themselves and look to the medical model to save them.

This is genuinely frightening.

I'm increasingly disturbed by the way that the "natural childbirth" lobby (which I have always distrusted) seems to be a gateway drug taking people down antivax rabbit holes. A former friend of mine who was previously pretty sensible got into this via natural childbirth and breastfeeding groups.

Long before all this I've always been highly suspicious of this rhetoric which bangs on about the "medicalization" of birth. It's an entirely positive thing that birth is medical. It's an entirely positive thing that science has been able to deliver the vaccines it has in 18 months. No vaccine is risk free and of course Big Pharma is not a philanthropic industry.

But this whole narrative that Mother Earth and "natural immunity" will provide a natural corrective to disease and therefore that science is not needed is a black whole of sinister bollocks: the point beyond which you can't have a sensible conversation. And it genuinely frightens me how prevalent these ideas have become in our society.

I don't know if the solution is more and better general science teaching in schools or better civics teaching or whatever. Maybe one just has to accept that for some people the allure of appearing "alternative" will always trump common sense and some people will always be seduced by this sort of nonsense. But I do think getting people more interested in science is absolutely essential. I can't go on listening to this stuff.

Bumblecattabbybee · 28/07/2021 08:07

@blublub

Don’t know why I posted that tbh. I don’t think anyone who asks these questions actually cares about the answers. Just seems to turn into an excuse for people to make themselves feel good about themselves for not being an ‘anti vaxxer’, which is a ludicrous pigeon-holing term in itself. No one is defined wholeheartedly on their medical status or religious or philosophical view points in one particular area of their life. But it seems that’s the point we have reached as a society. I think that is more damaging to society than any disease.
This.
LivingNextDoorToNorma · 28/07/2021 08:02

I’ve always assumed that it’s a risk versus reward decision. A vaccine protects you from something that possibly won’t happen. There is a risk to the vaccine, but not necessarily a reward. Treatment fixes a problem that is currently happening. You see the reward with your own eyes, when you (hopefully) get better.

My dc is fully vaccinated. Following the second dose of mmr, we spent a couple of days on the children’s ward. Dc’s temperature spiked scarily high, and we couldn’t bring it down. I know in my heart of hearts that vaccinating was the right choice, but I will never be able to describe the guilt I felt when he was so poorly. At the time I was incredibly aware that dc may never have caught measles etc, but at that moment they were in hospital because of mine (and dh’s) decision to consent to the vaccine.

I’m currently pregnant, and we have every intention to have this child vaccinated too. BUT having seen how scary a negative reaction to a vaccine can be, I have more understanding about how people can be conflicted about whether they’re doing the right thing.

SmokeyDevil · 28/07/2021 07:51

@LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus

Your view is definitely an odd one. It us basically let nature take its course, if they are meant to die, let them die. But I wonder how you will actually react if one of your children gets sick.

Say one of them catches meningitis, which is likely as none of them have had even one vaccine for it. That could kill them, or leave them disabled or very sick in life. Are you willing to watch them go through that? What would your decision be if the doctor said they can save your child by removing their limbs? Would you agree or not? I mean, it makes no difference really, the doctor will probably over rule you if you say no anyway.

What if they get measles mumps or rubella? Many children caught one of these diseases before the vaccine, one of my family members did. She has difficulty with her ears now at times, some people ended up deaf. That would make your children's lives harder, the vaccine wouldn't. Are you OK with taking the blame from your children?

What if you catch covid, end up with long covid with such damage done to your body you end up disabled? Or even from another disease. Not dead, but a lower quality of life anyway.

What if they do catch a disease, and they blame you for it? What if they all go no contact with you because of your beliefs? Are you still certain then that you are right?

Modern medicine does allow people to survive who wouldn't have maybe even 50-60 years ago. Assists with our over population problem. So I get your reasoning behind it. But I doubt you will stick to your beliefs if your children get sick. You have been lucky so far.

sashh · 28/07/2021 07:23

I am not accepting the Covid vaccine as I feel natural immunity is better than a vaccine, although I may change this view as I get older.

What do you perceive as the difference between 'natural immunity' and a vaccine?

saoirse31 · 28/07/2021 07:19

Am pro Vax myself but people talking about not understanding the hypocrisy of those who are anti Vax slightly amuses me. I'd think very few people are totally non hypocritical about their beliefs and decisions in modern society tbh.

Also the idea of refusing people covid treatment to people who haven't got vaccinated, really? A dangerous road to go down, should we not treat disease caused by obesity, by addiction, etc etc?

I think there's an awful lot of mocking people's perceived stupidity tbh on this issue, and I'm fairly sure it's neither totally justified nor likely to change anyones mind. I don't believe in God, but I wouldn't dream of mocking otherwise sensible people who do.

KidneyBeans · 28/07/2021 07:16

I think my main concern is taking medicine or medical advice which is prescribed to me by a doctor in good faith, which in years to come turns out to be bad, like a thalidomide for example.

I understand the concern but I do wish people would educate themselves rather than base their behaviour on fear and misunderstanding.

Thalidomide was developed as an antidote to nerve gases by a nazi war criminal during WW2. Drug regulation at that time was entirely different to today. That type of drug development system simply does not exist today - for many rather obvious reasons.

Would you also not eat beef because of the BSE/CJD risks from production systems in the 80s?

Ironically some of the drugs that people on this thread are comfortable with (inhalation anaesthetic agents) are ones that derive from that ore-drug testing/licensing time, and we still don't really know how they work!

Ironically it's entirely because of 'big pharma' and the development of rigorous safety testing and clinical trials that drugs today are so safe and one of the reasons why a thalidomide situation is incredibly unlikely.

Anyone interested in actually learning more about vaccines, thalidomide and various disease risks should have a listen to the podcast: thispodcastwillkillyou.com

They break down vaccine myths and explore the history of unethical medical research - it's certainly not an uncritical look at medical developments, but it is an evidence-based one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread