Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about repercussions from leaving bad reviews

61 replies

worrier77 · 27/07/2021 11:48

Does anyone else ever worry that leaving bad reviews on platforms like Amazon etc could lead to repercussions?

I've occasionally had disappointing experiences when buying an item online or visiting a pub/restaurant. If the issue is resolved by the seller or venue at the time then I would never leave a poor review, as I don't think that's fair.

However, on the rare occasions where they don't show any interest in attempting to resolve the situation, then I've been tempted to leave an honest review of my experience online to warn other customers.

However, what worries me is that these people know where I live and if they felt aggrieved by a bad review, they could retaliate in some shape or form.

Am I being completely paranoid or is this a legitimate worry?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jenasaurus · 28/07/2021 05:34

Just did a google and there are loads of online links to the same reviews including mine. www.familiesonline.co.uk/news/amazon-say-sorry-for-sending-batteries-and-condoms-instead-of-nintendo

Jenasaurus · 28/07/2021 05:32

I complained about an Amazon issue a couple of years ago and my friend told me that she had seen my complaint in the Sun and Daily Mirror! I was shocked as they gave my name and location, the only thing is I was one of many bad reviews about the same thing and so lots of them also appeared alongside mine in the paper.

Babycarrottt · 28/07/2021 05:20

I don't think you are being paranoid or unreasonable OP. I have an Etsy shop and there is now a website called "Karencheck" where you can put in a user ID and see the reviews left by that person. Apparently, this is to help the seller decide whether they want to proceed with the sale. I'm sure this does help in the minority of cases but it's put me off as a buyer. If I leave a bad review, it's only because it's deserved and I shouldn't be penalised for being on the receiving end of poor service etc.

ILovesPeanuts · 28/07/2021 00:08

Not paranoid OP. I left an honest and factual review of a restaurant.
A few weeks later a dreadful review appeared on Google about me for the organisation I worked for! Total lies. Couldn't work it out. Eventually discovered (via on line searches) that the fake review was left by a director of the restaurant I'd reviewed!!!
We reported the review umpteen times and wrote many letters to Google. Never got a response and review is still there to this day. Google were hopelessly unhelpful and disinterested in removing a retaliatory review from someone who'd never been a customer of the organisation.
Oddly I work using a different name to my name in the review so they went to a bit of effort.
Yes, it's put me off reviewing.

ArabellaStrange · 27/07/2021 22:14

I agree with the Amazon not allowing bad reviews. Ordered some champagne flutes on a daily deal as a birthday present for someone, only for the order to be cancelled due to 'limited stock'.
The next time I saw the company doing a daily deal, tried to leave a review telling people to not bother, Amazon refused to publish it. Despite my complaint being one hundred percent justified.

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 27/07/2021 21:24

I found Amazon don’t publish less than favourable reviews.

DHandInterview · 27/07/2021 21:14

About 12 years ago, I ordered about £150 of stuff from Dorothy Perkins. It was a big deal for me, a lot of money. The package never turned up so I ring up to enquire about it, I wasn't rude or anything like that but I asked them to replace the missing items. They reluctantly did but they blacklisted me from making any further purchases. Any orders I tried to place after that got cancelled. So I definitely think companies do sometimes retaliate.

SummerWillow · 27/07/2021 20:57

I had a terrible experience trying to buy a wedding dress years ago. Left a bad review on a third party website and nothing came of it for ages. Eventually I was contacted by website saying business asked me to remove it. I did as it was a long time previously. Business went bust shortly after! I did feel nervous like you OP as the business owner was very unpleasant.

Bookworm20 · 27/07/2021 19:44

I left a bad review once on tripadvisor for a local restaurant. At the time of complained and the chef came out and got quite aggressive, so we left snd left a review.
Think the guy was a bit of a psycho. He responded to my review but basically made himself look bad just putting us down as terrible customers. But then a few things did happen and I still wonder if it was him. Think car scratched, bike tyre slashed, front garden items stolen. All in a week. The week after the review

Username916 · 27/07/2021 19:10

I've had this issue the past week. We stayed at a campsite we found on Facebook which looked amazing and was so cheap. On arrival it was nothing like the pictures we had seen and quickly realised it was just stock images they used off Google! The owners were actually a family of ex travellers and we overheard them selling drugs to other campers. The place was a building site and the toilets revolting. It was an awful experience to be honest. I want to review to save other people the experience but they have my name, address and details and I'm nervous of them contacting me Blush

snackodactyl · 27/07/2021 19:01

had this dilemma with a landscaper who booked us in for a job and then didn’t show up. at the time i felt furious enough to want to leave a bad review on Yell where his record was spotless. but i also recall him coming over to take measurements while sporting a black eye, and thought better of it! i’m sure there will be other unsatisfied customers angry enough to speak up…

Wearethetwirl · 27/07/2021 18:22

it wasn’t worth the hassle.

Wearethetwirl · 27/07/2021 18:21

I understand your concerns and would caution against trusting reviews in general.

I bought my wedding dress from a shop which had dozens of five star reviews. Well they ruined my dress, lied about the amendments they did and then would not correct it despite selling me an “unlimited alterations package. ”

Well I thought I d write an honest review. It was taken down from yell after the shop complained. So I put a review on Google which I knew they could not remove. The owner responded with a scathing response insulting me and claiming I was lying. It was really upsetting as she got quite personal.

Then lo and behold 5 other five star reviews popped up out of the blue the very next day burying my review down the bottom of the page.

I realised they had been running a whole review scam and hiring people to write false reviews.

In the end I wished I hadn’t trustedj in the reviews nor written one as it wasn’t worth all the stress. They were just scammers and

icedcoffees · 27/07/2021 18:09

I think an anonymous site like Amazon is very different from a small local establishment.

I'm in a town where everyone knows everyone and I would never leave a poor review as it would probably cause people to boycott my own business :/

Whyo · 27/07/2021 18:05

Not unreasonable at all! I left a bad feedback for a seller on eBay. He send me a flurry of abuse referring to the fact he had my address and that I had better watch myself when I go out.

He also replied to the feedback which is public calling me the R word.

EBay’s response was to delete my bad feedback (so his score went up Confused), refused to hide my address from him, and took zero action on his account because he was still selling. A lot of “we’re sorry you feel that way” and nothing else about the threats he made and slur.

Nothing came of it thankfully but it was a really horrible experience as someone living alone. Haven’t used eBay since and I couldn’t believe there wasn’t a fairly robust protocol in place already for such a large business.

Shopaholic100 · 27/07/2021 16:54

Amazon reviews are fine. I would take any tradesperson reviews with a pinch of salt, even if they appear on seemingly reputable websites. From personal experience I tried to find a tradesperson to replace my guttering and filled out a form on a website, received a number of calls from deceitful individuals with high star ratings. One said it was a free quote, then tried to get me to pay £50, when I said I’d think about his quote. He was so forceful and wouldn’t leave but had good reviews. I didn’t post a review because I didn’t want him to come back.

user1745 · 27/07/2021 14:53

Amazon sellers are probably getting bad reviews all the time. One more won't faze them. Plus if they retaliated in any way, you could report them to Amazon and they might be banned from the platform. They're not going to risk that.

It tends to be sole traders and self-employed business owners who occasionally take negative reviews very personally and react unprofessionally.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 27/07/2021 14:46

Remember that there is a massive difference between a seller on amazon, restaurant tens of miles away and a local plumber from 2 streets away

worrier77 · 27/07/2021 14:44

I didn't leave a bad review for one shitty tradesman because I believed he'd have put nails in my car tyres, nasty piece of work.

That's just it - part of me feels really angry that people like that are allowed to get away with it; the other part feels it's not worth the worry or hassle!

OP posts:
Fairfeather · 27/07/2021 14:41

I didn't leave a bad review for one shitty tradesman because I believed he'd have put nails in my car tyres, nasty piece of work.

godmum56 · 27/07/2021 14:28

I have left a few bad reviews on Amazon, Trustpilot and Checka trade when genuinely merited.

sergeilavrov · 27/07/2021 14:20

You’re not paranoid. My Nephew left a bad review for a takeaway that charged my card, but then said it wouldn’t go through. They hung up on us etc. In his response to the review, he left my credit card details and home address - knowing he would have to delete the review.

What he didn’t know is that I work in a protected profession and he got an unpleasant visit from state security Grin Still shook me up though and I felt bad for DN who couldn’t have known what would happen.

needsomesleeppls · 27/07/2021 14:19

We had a terrible tradesman and I wouldn't leave a review online for him. He seemed a bit unhinged and I'd worry about repercussions.

My uncle bought a second hand car that had problems and when he pursued it his car was firebombed to get rid of the evidence, also setting the front of his house and neighbours house on fire so worth being wary.

crazymicrowave123 · 27/07/2021 14:19

I once left a bad review for a mechanic who had ripped me off (told me one price then after completing the work, it mysteriously went up by almost double...) anyway, many other people had left similar bad reviews and I left mine about half an hour after he completed the work and complained to him about the exact same issue so he must have known it was me.

Anyway I got a barrage of calls from a No caller ID over the period of 2 weeks and a text from a random number (not the one registered to his business) threatening to take me to court and saying they know where I live. I blocked them and eventually the calls stopped but it was scary none the less!

Wooollffff · 27/07/2021 14:17

The only time I got asked to reconsider a review was one left for my (then) GP. I took issue with the fact she turned up half an hour late for surgery, with a number of Tesco bags. Clearly shopping was more important.
Also that I was kept waiting while she saw a sales rep, and the time I was kept waiting 40 minutes so a posh family who turned up off the street could have holiday vaccines.