Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the name 'Karen' is only considered misogynistic because it refers to white women?

663 replies

FloofyCushion · 27/07/2021 10:53

I saw a tweet that said something along the lines of black women were referred to as Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling. The only reason the name Karen is considered so offensive is because it refers to white women.

Whenever the term Karen is mentioned on here, posters will fall over themselves to say how misogynistic it is and that it silences women. But it doesn't refer to ALL women, only white women. A certain type of very entitled white woman that derives pleasure from getting people she believes to be beneath her into trouble with authority. Its also used for racist women that attempt to get black people arrested for simply existing in close proximity to them.

All of the stereotypical names for ethnic minorities were never considered misogynistic, although they were racist. Obviously calling someone a Karen for simply speaking up for herself is horrible, but isn't it more prejudice than misogyny? It seems like stereotyping women's names according to their race was never a problem until it happened to white women. Interested to hear what other people think.

OP posts:
phishy · 27/07/2021 22:37

@Spindless

I don’t use the term Karen but why would I object to that woman using the term if it empowered her?

But @phishy that’s not how it’s being applied in the majority usage of it in the UK. It’s being used predominantly by men to shut women up who aren’t being racist, just strident about issues such a bins and rats. Or your teenage son leaving his crap everywhere. We are answering the OPs specific question, not doubting the validity of the origin.

I think the men who do that are scum, but the internet doesn’t have borders, and we are affected by what’s happening in other countries.
TheSlayer · 27/07/2021 22:36

Shaniqua is not widely used on social media or in real life but if I encountered it on social media I would report it for being racist as sexist comments are rarely dealt with.
I often report comments on FB about Dianne Abbott, but they get left up because they are usually misogynistic (but no doubt driven by race).

Someone also asked if we could not keep repeating it so I will only use it this once.

phishy · 27/07/2021 22:34

@TheSlayer

I don’t use the term Karen but why would I object to that woman using the term if it empowered her?

No one is objecting to that use. Although I still think clear language is better to get a clear message across.

The objection is to the more widespread British use of it as a misogynistic slur to stop a woman expressing a (non racist) opinion.

Then surely we’re in agreement? I have never used the term myself but I don’t object to it in certain circumstances.
UsedUpUsername · 27/07/2021 22:34

@Spindless

Except the Karen/can I speak to the manager haircut meme is aimed at white working class women.

You can’t presume to know what makes someone else uncomfortable, or even how something makes them feel at all.

No Karen isn’t working class. She’s middle class, upper middle class in the American sense. Not extremely educated but still financially secure.
phishy · 27/07/2021 22:33

@Pastrydame

Phishy, in that scenario why would "you're a racist" not have done just as well?
It’s very intimidating when confronted by a racist. A part of you just wants to run away.

I’m at an age where I can tell people to fuck off, that is my preferred response. But it’s clear from YouTube that many women can’t do that but do feel they can say Karen.

Novelusername · 27/07/2021 22:33

America has a specific problem with white women using their femininity to get black people in trouble. See To Kill a Mocking Bird.
Whilst I've no doubt that white women can do this, and have done this, it feels like this phenomenon is being mythologised in some way, a cautionary tale for modern America. To Kill a Mockingbird is a highly moralistic book that is read like a kind of guide for right and wrong and taught in high schools across America. On the surface it's a story about fairness and injustice, but I think it also taps into misogynistic male fears around female sexuality - that we're all evil, manipulative bitches, basically, if we show any sexual desire of our own and try to act on it. All these names for women, whatever their race, are about shaming women for asserting themselves, being lower class, being sexual. I hate how it turns women against each other.

Spindless · 27/07/2021 22:31

I don’t use the term Karen but why would I object to that woman using the term if it empowered her?

But @phishy that’s not how it’s being applied in the majority usage of it in the UK. It’s being used predominantly by men to shut women up who aren’t being racist, just strident about issues such a bins and rats. Or your teenage son leaving his crap everywhere. We are answering the OPs specific question, not doubting the validity of the origin.

Clymene · 27/07/2021 22:30

@phishy

How exactly has slagging off white women empowered black women to document white men murdering black men? confused

It’s not about ‘slagging off’. It’s about being able to speak up when being abused and call that person out. I’ve seen videos where a black woman has been able to say in a shaky voice ‘you’re a Karen’ to the white woman abusing her.

I don’t use the term Karen but why would I object to that woman using the term if it empowered her?

Because it's a misogynist term.

We are all women. We should all abhor misogyny. It doesn't help any of us.

alilstressed · 27/07/2021 22:30

I absolutely agree with you, OP. I disagree with the term Karen but there was no outrage for the many years black women have been called Shaniqua.

UsedUpUsername · 27/07/2021 22:29

@TheSlayer

White men kill black men in the USA, so British women must accept misogynistic slur.

Your logic does not resemble our earth logic.

White men do not even kill black men in large numbers.

It’s an inconvenient truth, look at FBI stats and you’ll see that black men kill other black men.

Sadly, the white American liberal either doesn’t care or wants to keep pushing a narrative that isn’t backed up by the facts.

And none of this has anything to do with the Karen meme.

phishy · 27/07/2021 22:29

[quote VladmirsPoutine]@phishy When I say smartphones are in the top 5 inventions of ALL time this is exactly what I mean. Of course the harassment of Black people is as old as time itself but that we can now document and share it is absolutely phenomenal. Amy Cooper et al. Thank heavens for smartphones.[/quote]
Yep, as Will Smith said: Racism is not getting worse, it’s getting filmed.

paddlingon · 27/07/2021 22:29

I'm not sure that that you have thought that through phishy.

I can think of several situations where threatened people might feel empowered by using slurs against someone who is threatening them.
It wouldn't make using the slur right.

Slurs don't become okay because the person using them finds them empowering.

TheSlayer · 27/07/2021 22:28

I don’t use the term Karen but why would I object to that woman using the term if it empowered her?

No one is objecting to that use. Although I still think clear language is better to get a clear message across.

The objection is to the more widespread British use of it as a misogynistic slur to stop a woman expressing a (non racist) opinion.

Pastrydame · 27/07/2021 22:27

Phishy, in that scenario why would "you're a racist" not have done just as well?

Delphinia · 27/07/2021 22:27

@StatisticallyChallenged

It might be where it originated, but it's now used to silence women who dare to have an opinion or stand up for themselves. I only have to look at the comments under local news articles to inevitably see "shut up Karen " thrown at a woman.
True. The people who write "shut up Karen" under local news articles are far more likely to be making racist comments themselves than using Karen to call out racism IME. Not surprising really, as people who like stereotyping rarely restrict themselves to stereotyping only one group.
Spindless · 27/07/2021 22:25

America has a specific problem with white women using their femininity to get black people in trouble. See To Kill a Mocking Bird.

I agree they do. But we’re responding to OP’s question as to why the term is considered misogynistic only when applied to white women, and i’d extend that to mean white women in the UK. It’s purely because it is used in a misogynistic context now. Those who use it in the UK will use it irrespective of whether the women is white or BAME.

phishy · 27/07/2021 22:25

How exactly has slagging off white women empowered black women to document white men murdering black men? confused

It’s not about ‘slagging off’. It’s about being able to speak up when being abused and call that person out. I’ve seen videos where a black woman has been able to say in a shaky voice ‘you’re a Karen’ to the white woman abusing her.

I don’t use the term Karen but why would I object to that woman using the term if it empowered her?

TheSlayer · 27/07/2021 22:24

White men kill black men in the USA, so British women must accept misogynistic slur.

Your logic does not resemble our earth logic.

VladmirsPoutine · 27/07/2021 22:21

@phishy When I say smartphones are in the top 5 inventions of ALL time this is exactly what I mean. Of course the harassment of Black people is as old as time itself but that we can now document and share it is absolutely phenomenal. Amy Cooper et al. Thank heavens for smartphones.

CassandraX · 27/07/2021 22:20

@OneTC

Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling

If I heard anyone talking like that I'd think they were a cunt

Or a prick, presumably, if we're avoiding sexism?
Clymene · 27/07/2021 22:19

[quote phishy]@TheSlayer

The people who filmed the George Floyd incident were very brave. I would not have been able to film or argue with volatile men with guns.

A 17yo black girl filmed the murder, whilst being threatened by the white male officer. If she hadn’t filmed, they would have got away with it.

This is what the Karen meme has done - empowered black women to film and document abuse and murder.[/quote]
How exactly has slagging off white women empowered black women to document white men murdering black men? Confused

Black women in the US are killed more than any other group. And you know who's killing them? Black men.

Women - whatever their race - are predominantly at risk of harm by men.

phishy · 27/07/2021 22:18

@Novelusername

This is what the Karen meme has done - empowered black women to film and document abuse and murder. Why isn't the term 'Derek' used to shut white middle aged men down then, seeing as a man was the murderer? Woman asks to see the manager, she's the most despicable creature on the planet; man commits a racist murder, nothing. ALL these names are being used to shame and shut down women, to keep us in line. F*ck that.
Maybe because there is no meme as sweet as 23.5 years in prison for murder? That’s what the man got.

America has a specific problem with white women using their femininity to get black people in trouble. See To Kill a Mocking Bird.

OneTC · 27/07/2021 22:17

Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling

If I heard anyone talking like that I'd think they were a cunt

CassandraX · 27/07/2021 22:17

@OhWhyNot

I know how it has evolved

I don’t remember anyone getting quite so hot under the collar about the term gammon it was thrown around often because it refers to working class white men we still have many threads sneering at names considered common/chavy

But offend white non working class then it’s suddenly totally and utterly unacceptable

About five years ago it was the term white privileged. How dare anyone be called out on this the uproar it caused on MN was as passionate as the Karen threads

Does it really just take a name to shut women down. Really? No it’s what is implied that is making so many feel uncomfortable

For any and vcery person whose given name is Gammon, I apologise unverseredly for how has been used.
Novelusername · 27/07/2021 22:16

But offend white non working class then it’s suddenly totally and utterly unacceptable
You're making the assumption that all the women objecting are white and non working class, which isn't the case. Also, the people using this term just throw it around without knowing a woman's race or economic status. It's just used for any woman expressing an opinion that usually a man objects to. These are the men who really f*cking hate women who know more than them about anything, or can argue better than them. Surely you must know this.