Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the name 'Karen' is only considered misogynistic because it refers to white women?

663 replies

FloofyCushion · 27/07/2021 10:53

I saw a tweet that said something along the lines of black women were referred to as Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling. The only reason the name Karen is considered so offensive is because it refers to white women.

Whenever the term Karen is mentioned on here, posters will fall over themselves to say how misogynistic it is and that it silences women. But it doesn't refer to ALL women, only white women. A certain type of very entitled white woman that derives pleasure from getting people she believes to be beneath her into trouble with authority. Its also used for racist women that attempt to get black people arrested for simply existing in close proximity to them.

All of the stereotypical names for ethnic minorities were never considered misogynistic, although they were racist. Obviously calling someone a Karen for simply speaking up for herself is horrible, but isn't it more prejudice than misogyny? It seems like stereotyping women's names according to their race was never a problem until it happened to white women. Interested to hear what other people think.

OP posts:
whatisforteamum · 28/07/2021 14:51

I consider myself broad minded and not easily offended however I hate the term she is a Karen.
I hear it a lot at work from my male counterparts and it is used to put down middle aged or older women who dare to have an opinion or voice.
I hate this term.

Katedanielshasakitty · 28/07/2021 14:48

@OhWhyNot

Really being called Karen would silence you Seriously ?

What impact on our lives does this silly nickname really have. Does it hold us back from promotion, does it make people in authority behave differently towards us, does it allow police to treat our children differently, are we held back by profiling because we may fit in the category of being a Karen

It’s name calling women have always been silenced some far more than others but it’s a phase (and it is only that) on social media like gammon was.

I still think that it’s another way of telling some they have privilege that really gets them worked up

No but it makes it harder for all of us when speaking out those issues.

Throughout this thread have been examples of where 'karen' had been used to shut women up when talking about things like sexual violence, pedophiles on social media etc.

Been used to poke fun at women who are just going about their own business. And when people use it, all the mysognists in the vicinity join in.

You really don't think that impacts women, of all colours?

Its not akin to a racial slur. It doesn't automatically make white women earn less. But it makes its harder to speak on those issues. For all women. Not just 'middle aged white women'.

OhWhyNot · 28/07/2021 14:46

A racist slur comes with a whole load of history often personal

Karen is a term that I’m is popular to use at present it’s name calling so someone calling you Karen would shut you down hurt you as you know how your family have had to deal with this

Why play onto the hands of people that want to keep you quiet

Taoneusa · 28/07/2021 14:43

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

Would you believe a racist slur could shut down a BAME person from speaking?

Would you believe a homophobic slur could shut down a gay person from speaking?

Why is it beyond the realm of possibility that a misogynistic slur could shut down a woman from speaking?

There are endless slurs aimed specifically at women to shut them down. To silence them. To humiliate them. To dehumanise them. To delegitimise their concerns.

What are the male equivalents?

Women whose sexual boundaries are too open- slag/ whore/ slut/ harlot/ hussy/ trollop

Women whose sexual boundaries are too closed- Frigid

Conforms to gender stereotype too much- Bimbo

Conforms to gender stereotype too little- Dyke

Women who aren’t “nice” enough- Ice queen/ Battle axe/ dragon/ harpy

Women who haven’t conformed to society’s expectations of them- Spinster

Older women who don’t sexualise themselves enough- Frump

Older women who sexualise themselves too much- Mutton

Non-complaint women who need to be silenced for the good of everyone else:

1692- Witch

1985- Femi-Nazi

2020- TERF

2021 Karen

I don’t think there is a vocabulary to describe men, equivalent to this.

Is it naive to suggest that cancel culture could be put to good use on theses kind of labels for women?

paddlingon · 28/07/2021 14:42

Thinly veiled divisive posts like this are a huge part of the problem.

No the use of Karen is not ok no matter how it originated or whom it is directed at, and neither are the others. Trying to justify the use of them by some arbitrary scale of insult level or who deserves to be oppressed the most or least by the patriarchy is both ridiculous and counter productive.

Life is shit for so many women who still carry the burden of the majority of housework, the mental load of a marriage, the majority of childcare, the pressure to look a certain way, the pension gap, sexism in the workplace, the inability to feel safe in public spaces, domestic violence, etc etc etc.

Given that it's so shit, why make it worse for each other as the OP has attempted? Of course maybe the OP is a man who enjoys using white as a pejorative to stoke tension amongst women.

Man or woman, their attempt to divide should be treated with the derision it deserves.

This is a very good post.

Katedanielshasakitty · 28/07/2021 14:39

Exactly this. Sad middle aged white women trying to find some way to feel oppressed as always. But they'll say it's equal or worse to what BAME people experience as if we'll be on their side and push their problems ahead of ours

I find this interesting. You say 'sad middle aged'. So old white women and young white women don't make you feel that problems facing PoC, are not as bad as theirs?

Happy middle age women? They dont either?

When the old women were middle aged, did they do it and then just stopped?

And the young women, will they do it when they are middle aged then stop when they become 'old?

So it's not a 'white women problem' it's an age problem?

Because in my life, as a mixed race person, I couldn't put one age range on the people who have dismissed race issues.

And I find men are far more eager to dismiss race issues. Far more than women.

And in regards to this, how many people compare 'Karen' to race problems?

Because no one on here said its worse or that it has to be prioritised

Most peoples issue is that (mainly) white men (and also some women) now use it to shut any woman, of any colour, down. It is now common place for it to impact all women.

When it was just used to describe older, American racist women, no one really objected to it. Not that much, anyway.

But yes, let's keep pretending that people only have an issue because it's impacting white women and pretending it's not impacting WoC. Let's all fall out over it, while the misogynists carry on using it and laughing. Confused

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 28/07/2021 14:34

Would you believe a racist slur could shut down a BAME person from speaking?

Would you believe a homophobic slur could shut down a gay person from speaking?

Why is it beyond the realm of possibility that a misogynistic slur could shut down a woman from speaking?

There are endless slurs aimed specifically at women to shut them down. To silence them. To humiliate them. To dehumanise them. To delegitimise their concerns.

What are the male equivalents?

Women whose sexual boundaries are too open- slag/ whore/ slut/ harlot/ hussy/ trollop

Women whose sexual boundaries are too closed- Frigid

Conforms to gender stereotype too much- Bimbo

Conforms to gender stereotype too little- Dyke

Women who aren’t “nice” enough- Ice queen/ Battle axe/ dragon/ harpy

Women who haven’t conformed to society’s expectations of them- Spinster

Older women who don’t sexualise themselves enough- Frump

Older women who sexualise themselves too much- Mutton

Non-complaint women who need to be silenced for the good of everyone else:

1692- Witch

1985- Femi-Nazi

2020- TERF

2021 Karen

OhWhyNot · 28/07/2021 14:27

Really being called Karen would silence you
Seriously ?

What impact on our lives does this silly nickname really have. Does it hold us back from promotion, does it make people in authority behave differently towards us, does it allow police to treat our children differently, are we held back by profiling because we may fit in the category of being a Karen

It’s name calling women have always been silenced some far more than others but it’s a phase (and it is only that) on social media like gammon was.

I still think that it’s another way of telling some they have privilege that really gets them worked up

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 28/07/2021 14:18

Exactly this. Sad middle aged white women trying to find some way to feel oppressed as always. But they'll say it's equal or worse to what BAME people experience as if we'll be on their side and push their problems ahead of ours.

Not equal to. Not even similar. But still
Oppressive, offensive, silencing, bullying and misogynistic.

RaindropsOnRosie · 28/07/2021 14:05

@KittenKong

Nasty women mustn’t have opinions eh? They might start getting ideas or something...
I agree Smile
RaindropsOnRosie · 28/07/2021 14:04

@phishy

As a BAME person, I don't think white people have a clue what we go through. As well as overt racism, we deal with being underpaid and underpromoted compared to white female and male colleagues, patronised, uninvited, condescended, talked over and dismissed.

Yet we are still expected to prioritise the feelings of white women when they are hurt by the term Karen.

Exactly this. Sad middle aged white women trying to find some way to feel oppressed as always. But they'll say it's equal or worse to what BAME people experience as if we'll be on their side and push their problems ahead of ours.
TheWeeDonkey · 28/07/2021 13:22

@TooYoungToNotice

Of course it's misogynistic, it's now used as a slur to silence all women.

Remember women, be kind or men (and women with internalized misogyny) will shout you down.

Consider that there simply must be a reason why videos of women behaving badly surface and are subject to such public opprobrium and deserving of the original use of Karen, but you don't see the equivalent for men. For men, the incident has to be much more serious before it merits attention.

So many women are complicit in the oppression of other women. Either actively or through ignorance. You can see it on thread after thread on here. The use of terms like bitch and cow, the scorn poured on stepmothers, the scorn poured on mothers. Its endless. We've all seen the oh so useful, well why did you have kids with a loser type of rhetoric, because it's always the woman"s fault.

Women need to stop fighting other women and develop a truer sense of sisterhood. We need to stop warring over men. In the main most aren't worth it anyway.

Thinly veiled divisive posts like this are a huge part of the problem. No the use of Karen is not ok no matter how it originated or whom it is directed at, and neither are the others. Trying to justify the use of them by some arbitrary scale of insult level or who deserves to be oppressed the most or least by the patriarchy is both ridiculous and counter productive. Life is shit for so many women who still carry the burden of the majority of housework, the mental load of a marriage, the majority of childcare, the pressure to look a certain way, the pension gap, sexism in the workplace, the inability to feel safe in public spaces, domestic violence, etc etc etc. Given that it's so shit, why make it worse for each other as the OP has attempted? Of course maybe the OP is a man who enjoys using white as a pejorative to stoke tension amongst women. Man or woman, their attempt to divide should be treated with the derision it deserves.

This needs sharing again
aSofaNearYou · 28/07/2021 12:16

@TooYoungToNotice Well said!

MissyB1 · 28/07/2021 12:01

@TooYoungToNotice

Of course it's misogynistic, it's now used as a slur to silence all women.

Remember women, be kind or men (and women with internalized misogyny) will shout you down.

Consider that there simply must be a reason why videos of women behaving badly surface and are subject to such public opprobrium and deserving of the original use of Karen, but you don't see the equivalent for men. For men, the incident has to be much more serious before it merits attention.

So many women are complicit in the oppression of other women. Either actively or through ignorance. You can see it on thread after thread on here. The use of terms like bitch and cow, the scorn poured on stepmothers, the scorn poured on mothers. Its endless. We've all seen the oh so useful, well why did you have kids with a loser type of rhetoric, because it's always the woman"s fault.

Women need to stop fighting other women and develop a truer sense of sisterhood. We need to stop warring over men. In the main most aren't worth it anyway.

Thinly veiled divisive posts like this are a huge part of the problem. No the use of Karen is not ok no matter how it originated or whom it is directed at, and neither are the others. Trying to justify the use of them by some arbitrary scale of insult level or who deserves to be oppressed the most or least by the patriarchy is both ridiculous and counter productive. Life is shit for so many women who still carry the burden of the majority of housework, the mental load of a marriage, the majority of childcare, the pressure to look a certain way, the pension gap, sexism in the workplace, the inability to feel safe in public spaces, domestic violence, etc etc etc. Given that it's so shit, why make it worse for each other as the OP has attempted? Of course maybe the OP is a man who enjoys using white as a pejorative to stoke tension amongst women. Man or woman, their attempt to divide should be treated with the derision it deserves.

Yep! this times a million!!
TooYoungToNotice · 28/07/2021 11:46

Of course it's misogynistic, it's now used as a slur to silence all women.

Remember women, be kind or men (and women with internalized misogyny) will shout you down.

Consider that there simply must be a reason why videos of women behaving badly surface and are subject to such public opprobrium and deserving of the original use of Karen, but you don't see the equivalent for men. For men, the incident has to be much more serious before it merits attention.

So many women are complicit in the oppression of other women. Either actively or through ignorance. You can see it on thread after thread on here. The use of terms like bitch and cow, the scorn poured on stepmothers, the scorn poured on mothers. Its endless. We've all seen the oh so useful, well why did you have kids with a loser type of rhetoric, because it's always the woman"s fault.

Women need to stop fighting other women and develop a truer sense of sisterhood. We need to stop warring over men. In the main most aren't worth it anyway.

Thinly veiled divisive posts like this are a huge part of the problem. No the use of Karen is not ok no matter how it originated or whom it is directed at, and neither are the others. Trying to justify the use of them by some arbitrary scale of insult level or who deserves to be oppressed the most or least by the patriarchy is both ridiculous and counter productive. Life is shit for so many women who still carry the burden of the majority of housework, the mental load of a marriage, the majority of childcare, the pressure to look a certain way, the pension gap, sexism in the workplace, the inability to feel safe in public spaces, domestic violence, etc etc etc. Given that it's so shit, why make it worse for each other as the OP has attempted? Of course maybe the OP is a man who enjoys using white as a pejorative to stoke tension amongst women. Man or woman, their attempt to divide should be treated with the derision it deserves.

grey12 · 28/07/2021 10:20

@Marguerite2000

Black women in the US are killed more than any other group Wrong. It's black MEN, by a vast nargin
I think it's black women (or BAME, don't remember) who get the lowest pay though
Clymene · 28/07/2021 09:54

@Ereshkigalangcleg

Wrong. It's black MEN, by a vast nargin

I think she means of any group of women.

Yes, sorry that's what I meant. Apologies for not being clear.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 28/07/2021 09:45

Wrong. It's black MEN, by a vast nargin

I think she means of any group of women.

Marguerite2000 · 28/07/2021 09:43

Black women in the US are killed more than any other group
Wrong. It's black MEN, by a vast nargin

HereticFanjo · 28/07/2021 09:36

I have literally never heard any of the other names but Karen is slung about a lot by the hard of thinking trying to shut down discussions. If the other names are used in the same way I oppose them in the same way.

igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 09:25

Just spotted this on Twitter: twitter.com/nicolelampert/status/1420073307072831490

I really hope it's not real.

You don't need a Twitter account to see it.

KittenKong · 28/07/2021 09:12

Nasty women mustn’t have opinions eh? They might start getting ideas or something...

Hoppinggreen · 28/07/2021 09:07

@KittenKong

Divide and conquer. Because it’s woman who have all the power, eh?
No we don’t which is why it’s very interesting that a lot of men feel so threatened by us having opinions.
Spindless · 28/07/2021 09:03

women should stick together regardless of our ethnic origins and background. I agree but anticipate that BAME women, to pick up on the point OP raised, may think “you only stick together when it affects you” and I understand that sentiment.

I’ve tried in this thread to explain how for my part, that is true. Not because I’m racist, but because the problems WOC experience by virtue of their skin colour or ethnicity are not something I can directly relate to as it generally does not occur in my sphere of existence. Where I witnessed racism in my workplace, I acted and always will.

@TheSlayer using the example of her child articulated this far better than me with her post below.

*I think you're mistaking 'not an immediate concern' to 'not caring'.

As I stated before. I doubt anyone on this thread is horrible to the disabled, uses the word spastic etc.
But I doubt it's their number one priority. This doesn't mean they don't care. Perhaps many of them give to charities that help disability. Who knows. Maybe they use their time to campaign for women's rights, or BLM or whatever else their passion is.
Just because something isn't centre stage in everyone's world, doesn't mean people don't care or are 'ist'.
I don't expect cp to be top of everyone's priorities. I expect people to vote for initiatives that help people like my son and are not openly mean.
I don't expect everyone to have it at centre front(it'd be great if it was, but I understand everyone has different properties)
I fight for my son and as long as people are mindful and not discriminatory, that's all I can ask.*

The “Karen” meme distorts things. This was adopted by black women (or men too) to call out racist behaviour and so was always different to the other names OP quoted that are used as both racial and misogynistic slurs. I don’t think anyone disputes that they are both. Now Karen which, in terms of adoption by black people didn’t have roots in misogyny, has been adopted by mostly men to denigrate any woman using their voice, regardless of race and colour. So in this specific scenario, calling out the usage of it benefits all women.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/07/2021 08:06

I’m making my way through the thread. I am so sorry to read how children at school were dismissed and suffered horrible racist abuse. And how some people continue to be abused. I hope society and schools have moved on since then.

It was acceptable to be racist when I was at school. I didn’t participate. The only time I did anything to protect my friends of Pakistani origin, was to block a nasty girl in our TA class from going to say nasty things to them. Years later, I met up with one of the now women and we were talking about this girl from school and she had no idea I’d done this regularly throughout the last 2 years of secondary.

I’m not physically strong enough to put myself in danger so was never brave enough to shout on street corners. But I do the subtle things. If everyone did the same, the world would be much nicer.

As for Karen, it is a misogynistic slur used against all women. And I suspect teen girls as well. My 13 yo already knows about this term. Imo women should stick together regardless of our ethnic origins and background.

Swipe left for the next trending thread