Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the name 'Karen' is only considered misogynistic because it refers to white women?

663 replies

FloofyCushion · 27/07/2021 10:53

I saw a tweet that said something along the lines of black women were referred to as Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling. The only reason the name Karen is considered so offensive is because it refers to white women.

Whenever the term Karen is mentioned on here, posters will fall over themselves to say how misogynistic it is and that it silences women. But it doesn't refer to ALL women, only white women. A certain type of very entitled white woman that derives pleasure from getting people she believes to be beneath her into trouble with authority. Its also used for racist women that attempt to get black people arrested for simply existing in close proximity to them.

All of the stereotypical names for ethnic minorities were never considered misogynistic, although they were racist. Obviously calling someone a Karen for simply speaking up for herself is horrible, but isn't it more prejudice than misogyny? It seems like stereotyping women's names according to their race was never a problem until it happened to white women. Interested to hear what other people think.

OP posts:
TheSlayer · 29/07/2021 19:48

Slang isn't ever a good way to communicate anything. If you want to 'call out' racism then the words. 'that is racist' and the word 'because' are most effective.

Racism in the UK is interlinked with class, economics and structural factors. It can look more subtle than the US.
For example, in the US they effectively have white schools and black schools, with children from respective areas being 'bussed' to schools from other areas. They have state schools and public schools, which are funded and run very differently to the UK. Teachers in the US are paid particularly poorly in some areas; running two jobs won't make a good teacher or attract the best people into the profession.

In the UK we largely have state funded infant and primary schools with a handful of private schools for this age group. We have grammars, state and independent schools, the first two of which are regulated by Ofsted. In theory this means our educational opportunities are at a more even keel.
But in practice class and race dictate your opportunities. For example, the 11+ still run by many counties to select who attends grammar is not taught in schools. A private tutor is needed to pass them; thus disadvantages lower income families. Grammars are not available throughout the whole country: so only certain areas will have access to grammar schools. Ofsted is well known amongst educators to penalize schools with a lower income catchment area-so all the good teachers gravitate towards the more affluent areas. Good teachers in schools that come under fire from Ofsted either get burnt out or pushed out. Children from certain backgrounds are more likely to be excluded or expelled: a whole lot of factors come into play here, alternative education provision being sub standard or unavailable; schools actively pushing out children who will effect their results (as Ofsted judge their effectiveness by them); resources and finding are unfair meaning schools with greater need get the same as those without.
And this is just mainly based on economic class, when you add in language and experience, extra curricular opportunities, gender(I mean sex!), race and everything else, it's a very tangled web that needs to looked at altogether. Because we're not bussing black children to one school and white children to another it looks fair, but it's really not. Inequality in the UK is far more subtle and geographical and economic factors play a big part.

So importing US politics won't solve our problems: yes we have the same loose problems. Yet they look very different and require different solutions.

And calling women Karen's unsurprisingly doesn't really come close to solving our intricate problems.

But it does make keyboard warriors feel good about themselves for doing virtually nothing to combat systematic racism and indeed sexism.

It's a pat on the back for lazy virtue signallers.

MissyB1 · 29/07/2021 19:29

@Wishes2020

No one has said ‘Karen’ since April 2020. I don’t know why MN is obsessed with it. And it refers to racist women. It’s almost as if MN want stop racism being called out.
Bollocks.
Persephonesgrove · 29/07/2021 19:24

@Wishes2020

No one has said ‘Karen’ since April 2020. I don’t know why MN is obsessed with it. And it refers to racist women. It’s almost as if MN want stop racism being called out.
That's not even vaguely true. Any of it.
SoupDragon · 29/07/2021 19:21

@Wishes2020

No one has said ‘Karen’ since April 2020. I don’t know why MN is obsessed with it. And it refers to racist women. It’s almost as if MN want stop racism being called out.
Where have you been since then?
mustlovegin · 29/07/2021 19:15

I don't understand what you are saying Wishes2020

Pastrydame · 29/07/2021 19:06
Biscuit
Wishes2020 · 29/07/2021 19:05

No one has said ‘Karen’ since April 2020. I don’t know why MN is obsessed with it. And it refers to racist women. It’s almost as if MN want stop racism being called out.

Katedanielshasakitty · 29/07/2021 18:43

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

In all honesty, I’d rather be told “shut up, stupid bitch” than called “a Karen”.

At least then they’d be saying what they really meant and people who were laughing along would realise the real message.

The underhand, smirky, deniability of “Karen” is what most offends me.

Absolutely agree.

But, I would bet money they wouldn't dare say this as freely as they call women 'karens'

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 29/07/2021 18:28

In all honesty, I’d rather be told “shut up, stupid bitch” than called “a Karen”.

At least then they’d be saying what they really meant and people who were laughing along would realise the real message.

The underhand, smirky, deniability of “Karen” is what most offends me.

UsedUpUsername · 29/07/2021 17:36

@mustlovegin

I feel like people don't understand the difference between punching up and punching down

Nobody should be 'punching' and they are equally bad in my book, no matter how much you try to justify those who punch up

It’s a really awful way to look at human relationships.

Like a weird math equation. You are black so you as a black person can make fun of these groups. You are Asian, you as an Asian can make fun of these groups ... and so on and so forth.

It really doesn’t capture the complexity of the human condition.

mustlovegin · 29/07/2021 17:24

Calling someone "Karen" is worse than "being a Karen

Good

mustlovegin · 29/07/2021 17:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

UsedUpUsername · 29/07/2021 16:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Proudboomer · 29/07/2021 15:30

I have been called a karen three time and none had anything to do with race.
The first time was when the daughter of a friend was posting some of the karen memes on Facebook and I posted why is she posting that misogynistic ageist crap and all she was doing was insulting her future self. One off her friends popped up to call me a karen.
Second time on a local Facebook selling page which specifically banned mlm sellers and recruiters.
A post must have slipped though the admin net trying to recruit for her team and flog her body butter. I got called a karen for pointing out that the group was not for mlms and she might want to take down her post before admin did. I got called a karen as I was somehow against women making money as she was offering such a great opportunity. I got called a karen again by one of her huns when I pointed out her recruitment drive failed to mention how much it would cost to join her down line.

aSofaNearYou · 29/07/2021 14:50

[quote Wroxie]@aSofaNearYou I specifically said that calling a woman Karen for non-racially charged behaviour is misogynistic.

However, at least in America, white women SPECIFICALLY have a history of weaponising their white privilege in a very specific way. It started with slave-owning women, continued through the middle of the last century (falsely scapegoating Black men leading to their lynching in particular), and through to today when you see white WOMEN specifically claiming to feel unsafe when Black people are just living their lives because they know that their white womanhood will protect them.
I understand if you don't see this - that's great that it's not as much of a thing in the UK! That makes me happy! But it IS a thing in the US and pretending that it's not doesn't make it not so.[/quote]
Yes but again, where's the campaign drawing attention to the male slave owners, or the men doing the lynching in response to female scapegoating? Context is relevant, and the context is that we live in an ongoing battle against misogyny, as well as racism. It is reductive to punch down to women by perpetuating the gaping double standards in society, in a bid to tackle racism.

And that's notwithstanding what other PPs have pointed out about the fact that that is broadly NOT the context in which the term is used in the UK.

Wroxie · 29/07/2021 14:48

@igelkott2021 I live in the bloody UK! I have for 20 years! But thanks to the internet mainly, words and slang and ideas are international. I haven't once said the cultural context of the UK is wrong. I live here. I understand it, thanks. But this is a nuanced conversation and I'll not be told I can't bring that nuance to the table.

igelkott2021 · 29/07/2021 14:34

But it IS a thing in the US and pretending that it's not doesn't make it not so

We're not pretending it doesn't happen in the US, but as I pointed out further up the thread, this is a UK website for UK residents (and mainly female ones of child-bearing age) and we discuss things in that context and it isn't helpful when people from overseas tell us we are wrong about the cultural context of the UK when we live here.

igelkott2021 · 29/07/2021 14:30

Sad middle aged white women trying to find some way to feel oppressed as always. But they'll say it's equal or worse to what BAME people experience as if we'll be on their side and push their problems ahead of ours

Asking people to stop using "Karen" as a slur does not preclude people from also being against racist slurs or behaviour.

We have rooms in our brains for more than one concern.

Wroxie · 29/07/2021 14:29

@aSofaNearYou I specifically said that calling a woman Karen for non-racially charged behaviour is misogynistic.

However, at least in America, white women SPECIFICALLY have a history of weaponising their white privilege in a very specific way. It started with slave-owning women, continued through the middle of the last century (falsely scapegoating Black men leading to their lynching in particular), and through to today when you see white WOMEN specifically claiming to feel unsafe when Black people are just living their lives because they know that their white womanhood will protect them.
I understand if you don't see this - that's great that it's not as much of a thing in the UK! That makes me happy! But it IS a thing in the US and pretending that it's not doesn't make it not so.

igelkott2021 · 29/07/2021 14:28

I will say that the increasingly widespread habit of calling women "Karen" for reasons other than them specifically wielding white privilege as a weapon is misogynistic as hell, but it's also (according to some young people I know, anyway) quickly fading away- it's "cringe", apparently. Calling someone "Karen" is worse than "being a Karen

I sincerely hope so - maybe they've grasped that women having a go at other women isn't cool (unless they are actually expressing objectionable views or behaviour).

igelkott2021 · 29/07/2021 14:26

Yeah. Yeah they are. Especially if they are younger and also female. Try walking in someone else’s shoes you might be surprised

Younger females aren't allowed an opinion either. But in the UK, the "Karen" slur is used about women over 40. So they are the demographic we are talking about in the context of the Karen slur.

Many men think women are merely playthings (and punchbags). It's a pity that some women choose to have a go at other women, rather than fighting the real problem, which is the cultural dominance of (white) men.

The slur itself isn't the real problem - the problem is the sexism and ageism behind the slur - as I have said a million times on here - women generally are not allowed to have opinions, women over 40 even less so.

aSofaNearYou · 29/07/2021 14:07

@Wroxie The problem is that women are also "punched down" to. A large amount of people using this term are men. It's disingenuous to suggest women are so commonly the perpetrators of racism, they alone deserve a special name for it. It's disingenuous to suggest that Karen is only used to call out racists. And it's disingenuous to ignore the fact that women aren't solely in a position of privilege. They are also victims of misogyny, which is as much an ongoing battle as racism is.

Wroxie · 29/07/2021 13:58

I feel like people don't understand the difference between punching up and punching down.

As an example - a working-class Black woman calling a rich white man who supports racist governmental policies a "Gammon", or a woman who uses her white privilege to threaten someone who isn't white a "Karen" - you may not like the sound of it and you may not like name-calling in general, but to pretend that's the same and "just as bad" as a rich white American calling a working-class Black American woman "Shaniqua" or a rich white American woman calling the Mexican woman who works as a cleaner in her house "one of the Marias" (as a friend's awful mother was known to do) - it's bloody not the same!

The first one is borne out of genuine frustration and anger and is one of the few ways that people with limited social capital and power can regain a little of that - laughing at the powerful and making them look ridiculous for the shitty things they do is a time-honoured tradition and if you're the one in power and you don't like it, you have the option to stop doing shitty things and to stop supporting shitty things.

The other examples - punching down at people who are less powerful than you, who have less social capital and privilege, and who haven't done anything to deserve it other than to exist in the limited roles that the powerful have tried to define for them - that's hateful, nasty, bullying behaviour and has nothing whatsoever in common with the first example.

I will say that the increasingly widespread habit of calling women "Karen" for reasons other than them specifically wielding white privilege as a weapon is misogynistic as hell, but it's also (according to some young people I know, anyway) quickly fading away- it's "cringe", apparently. Calling someone "Karen" is worse than "being a Karen".

Taoneusa · 29/07/2021 13:26

The criticism of the “Karen” haircut totally marks it as a USA meme, I think? Not a popular Brit hairstyle.

But definitely Karen isn’t just a White name, I know several black Karen’s.

Bumblenums1234 · 29/07/2021 13:22

I've never once heard people referred to as those names and I have seen many women who ate not white called a karen. I don't think it relates solely to white people at all

Swipe left for the next trending thread