Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the name 'Karen' is only considered misogynistic because it refers to white women?

663 replies

FloofyCushion · 27/07/2021 10:53

I saw a tweet that said something along the lines of black women were referred to as Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling. The only reason the name Karen is considered so offensive is because it refers to white women.

Whenever the term Karen is mentioned on here, posters will fall over themselves to say how misogynistic it is and that it silences women. But it doesn't refer to ALL women, only white women. A certain type of very entitled white woman that derives pleasure from getting people she believes to be beneath her into trouble with authority. Its also used for racist women that attempt to get black people arrested for simply existing in close proximity to them.

All of the stereotypical names for ethnic minorities were never considered misogynistic, although they were racist. Obviously calling someone a Karen for simply speaking up for herself is horrible, but isn't it more prejudice than misogyny? It seems like stereotyping women's names according to their race was never a problem until it happened to white women. Interested to hear what other people think.

OP posts:
Dutch1e · 27/07/2021 12:00

Nothing becomes a feminist issue until it affects white women so yes, I agree with you OP.

cinammonbuns · 27/07/2021 12:00

@Celandines you keep making comparisons which have nothing to do with my comments. When did I mention anything about there being more racist women than men. Nobody would ever be able to determine either way as racism is an internal ideology and you can’t scan someone’s brain to see if they are racist. What are you even on about?

TheSlayer · 27/07/2021 12:00

Please look into the history of the word before you make sweeping generalisations about those who object to it.

I'm in a lower paid role. Am I allowed to object to it? How about my well paid mixed race friend. I know for a fact she wouldn't use it. She doesn't use gammon or woke either.
I would never call anyone a Karen. I'd call them rude.
I'd call a racist a racist.
And you op, are employing misogynistic language so...

Supertree · 27/07/2021 12:00

Aren't they all misogynistic and some both misogynist and racist? Karen has just really caught on in this country and is used to mock middle aged women (of all ethnicities) who dare to ever say anything. I've never heard anybody use the others or seen memes about their use but I regularly see and hear people referencing 'Karen'. Two Karen memes were posted on my local facebook page yesterday because a woman politely pointed out that releasing helium balloons is awful for the environment and hurts animals and suggested other, more eco friendly alternatives. She was trying really hard not to hurt anyone's feelings and clearly hoped she could appeal to their better nature. But no, she was shouted down and insulted. Know your place, woman!

Celandines · 27/07/2021 12:00

@aSofaNearYou

Are you seriously saying that women behave in more racist ways than men? What evidence do you have of that?

I think this is a good point. The fact that this type of white, racist women have been given a name, has put a lot of focus on them culturally in the discussion about racism. Should we start calling racist men Derek, after Derek Chauvin? Because as awful as these racist women are, I'm not seeing much evidence that the racism that comes from women is worse than the racism that comes from men. There are also a LOT of men who act just like your stereotypical "Karen", but there is no name for those.

It's all part of a wider culture that likes blaming women and letting men off the hook, when in fact they are often generally worse. Good to tackle racism, but not great how it's being done.

Exactly.
JaninaDuszejko · 27/07/2021 11:59

black women were referred to as Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling

These are all American terms that are not common in the UK.

I could also point out that most people from South American countries don't like the term 'Hispanic' and would rather they were identified as their own nationality. My DH is from a South American country and his family don't consider themselves 'Hispanic'. It is an American racist term itself, never mind using a name like Guadalupe (which is a name that can be used for both sexes which may explain its popularity as a racist insult). 'Hispanic' is not a significant racial group in the UK.

Also 'Ling Ling' makes no sense for an Asian woman in the UK where 'Asian' is used to mean people whose ethnicity is from the Indian subcontinent (the largest ethnic minority in the UK) and people from the rest of the continent of Asia are a much smaller minority. But I'm trying to think if I know of a name that is used as a generic racist name for Indian Asian women, I'm not aware of one but that doesn't mean there isn't one. I'm think that all these names are an American phenonenon that don't really translate to the UK and particularly in the case of Karen it's a name that in a UK context has such different class and race associations than in the US which is driving the annoyance about its use here.

And, FWIW, I'd call out someone for using the names you listed for being both racist and sexist but thankfully it's not something I've witnessed.

TotorosCatBus · 27/07/2021 11:59

Karen in the UK has a different meaning to Karen in the US.

I think that the anger against Karen is disproportionate when people here use names as stereotypes for other groups. You just need to look at the baby names forums for frequent use of chav to describe a "poor person's name", Kevin (teenager), Jocasta and Tarquin (posh children) etc

newnortherner111 · 27/07/2021 11:58

I agree with your sentiment OP, but that does not justify it or any other examples you have given. Two or more wrongs never make a right.

NotDavidTennant · 27/07/2021 11:56

Calling people names is wrong. I know some seem to want to engage in mental gymanstics to convince themselves that they are instances where calling someone a name is good because it's for the cause of social justice.

But it really isn't.

It's petty and vindictive and the social justice arguments are just a rationalisation for people who want to be petty and vindictive but go on telling themselves that they are a good person.

TheSlayer · 27/07/2021 11:56

so while the term did originate in referring to white American women who were trying to se the law to harass black people it certainly has evolved

This is not the origin. See the incel origin quoted above. You can see this for yourself if you do a Google image search. The first time Karen appears is in this context and for quite a long time afterwards. A diligent mumsnetter did it on an earlier thread.

thecatsthecats · 27/07/2021 11:56

It wasn't a race isaue at first, but a class one - women who demand to speak to the manager, and patronise, bully and belittle service staff. (I'd say lower middle class, based on the "Karen" haircut)

Obviously it's been coopted by all sorts, but I'd say that the predominant victims of "Karen" behaviour were female also. Whatever it's become, I find the MN interpretation of it as "silencing women for standing up for themselves" a bit off kilter. Because complaints about "Karens" originated from exactly that - women standing up against rude and entitled behaviour directed at them. Rude and entitled behaviour IS the target. I've never heard of a woman being labelled a Karen for doing anything reasonable.

(I'd hazard a guess that women in service roles would face different challenges from rude and entitled men, i.e. unwanted flirting or sexual advances.)

Bryonyshcmyony · 27/07/2021 11:55

I've never heard of LingLing and Guadelope used disparagingly 🙁

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 27/07/2021 11:53

So, OP, you think that those of us that object to the “Karen” meme think that calling a black woman “a Shaniqua” because she is exhibiting behaviour that is stereotypically associated with a certain “type” of woman (the idea that there are “types” is a whole other layer of misogynistic bigotry) is OK?

Do you think that those of us who object to the “Karen” meme think that women using their privilege to harm the less privileged is justifiable?

We don’t. I think you’ve enormously misunderstood, and fallen into another patriarchy trap.

If Shaniqua and Ling Ling have been misappropriated like Karen has been that’s equally unacceptable. If I heard it I would call it out.

FloofyCushion · 27/07/2021 11:53

[quote cinammonbuns]@igelkott2021 yes of course you don’t believe it happens often. I’ve never heard of children being used for slave labour where I live so surely it does not happen.

The way people on this thread are saying ‘I’ve never heard of people using this term so it doesn’t exist’ is extremely symptomatic of the point that the OP is making: if it doesn’t happen on front of middle class white women it doesn’t happen at all.[/quote]
Indeed. I think sometimes it's easier to put the blinkers on and deny something is happening than face the ugly truth that it does and that you are also a part of it.

I'm not saying that those who have never experienced it are racist, but that the fact that you haven't means you that you are privileged.

OP posts:
Wearywithteens · 27/07/2021 11:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Hoppinggreen · 27/07/2021 11:49

@Wanttocry

It isn't misogynistic, it's a name given to entitled racist white American women who harass black people and think they can get away with it. That's how it originated.

That’s how it originated but it’s not how it’s always used now. For example, I’ve seen Karen be used about someone not wearing a mask. You could argue that that’s an incorrect usage of it, but given how widespread it is, I think it’s more that the meaning has evolved.

I got called Karen for pointing out e scooters are illegal other than on Private land so while the term did originate in referring to white American women who were trying to se the law to harass black people it certainly has evolved
CassandraX · 27/07/2021 11:49

YABU. It's a US/American slur, and demographically the name Karen has been widespread much more recently in the US black community than in the US as a whole. But even if that weren't the case, why is it OK to take a popular name from another culture (Karen is the Danish variant of Catherine) and piss all over it?

White racists in the USA also deceitfully attribute the slur "Karen" to black people, co-opting the tradition in black American communities to use one person's personal name to refer to a trait that person has. They lie, though; widespread use of "Karen" comes from reddit, where a man started the subreddit "fuckyoukaren" to encourage people to threaten sexual violence against his (imaginary, as it turned out) ex-wife Karen. Go look at that site, if you're a woman, and imagine yourself in the position of any of the "karens" that get posted about. (Don't do this if you're vulnerable - it's a shit ton of full-on sexist "banter" and rape and sexual violence threats and "jokes").

The other things you mention are also problematic if and when they happen, so call them out when you see them. Your post, though, is xenophobic and racist (as well as sexist and classist), and so I'm going with the assumption that you yourself are racist and xenophobic.

TheSlayer · 27/07/2021 11:49

Never ever seen it in the UK used to 'call out racism'. Just shut women down (usually for expressing a reasonable opinion).
If you want to 'call out racism' then the words 'that is racist' followed by an explanation of why are much more direct and powerful. Calling someone names won't get them to rethink their ideas.

SaskiaRembrandt · 27/07/2021 11:48

Meraas How does denigrating another group of women help them? And I am talking about middle class white men in the UK. To give an example, sneering that one of the women who cleans their student flat is called Karen, then remarking that they're all Karens really. It's just members of an elite group belittling women they believe to be inferior. As has already been pointed out, it's misogyny dressed up as 'wokeness'.

Celandines · 27/07/2021 11:47

The way people on this thread are saying ‘I’ve never heard of people using this term so it doesn’t exist’ is extremely symptomatic of the point that the OP is making: if it doesn’t happen on front of middle class white women it doesn’t happen at all
No one at all has said it doesn't exist FFS. It's just unclear why 45+ women only have to be punished for racism by being called names if they speak out about anything at all. Last time I checked the vast majority of people on Britain First marches were men. But yeah let's use racism as an excuse to be misogynistic and ageist to 45+ women. It's not as if misogyny and ageism doesn't have a long history. People have always made up excuses for it by blaming older women for all sorts

Hoppinggreen · 27/07/2021 11:46

All those terms are misogynistic, some are racist too.
All of it unacceptable

Bloodypunkrockers · 27/07/2021 11:45

Can't comment on the other names as I've never heard or seen them used

But Karen is aimed at any woman with an opinion as a means of shutting them down

Misogynistic, ageist and classist

Anyone using the term is a bit thick if that is their level of debate

But the same would be true of the other names

aSofaNearYou · 27/07/2021 11:44

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

I agree OP. I think it's more important to support black, Asian, Hispanic victims in the US who bear the brunt of racism, and if using the term banner gives the impetus to upload their experiences of racist abuse on YouTube, then I fully support them

Surely you can support them without throwing someone else under the bus?

Yes quite. I don't see why racism or misogyny need to be considered "more important".
Meraas · 27/07/2021 11:42

@SaskiaRembrandt

Also, in the UK I've only ever seen young, white, middle class men use 'Karen' as an insult. Make of that what you will ...
That’s not the fault of black/ Hispanic/Asian people. They should be allowed to call out racism and post videos on YouTube and if using the term Karen to refer to a specific type of behaviour helps them then I fully support that.
Meraas · 27/07/2021 11:39

@Celandines

I saw a tweet that said something along the lines of black women were referred to as Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling. The only reason the name Karen is considered so offensive is because it refers to white women You and your friends might use those racist terms op but I don't know anyone who does. The fact that some people do doesn't make it OK to be misogynistic/ageist to 45+ women.
Where does OP say she or her friends use those terms?