Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the name 'Karen' is only considered misogynistic because it refers to white women?

663 replies

FloofyCushion · 27/07/2021 10:53

I saw a tweet that said something along the lines of black women were referred to as Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling. The only reason the name Karen is considered so offensive is because it refers to white women.

Whenever the term Karen is mentioned on here, posters will fall over themselves to say how misogynistic it is and that it silences women. But it doesn't refer to ALL women, only white women. A certain type of very entitled white woman that derives pleasure from getting people she believes to be beneath her into trouble with authority. Its also used for racist women that attempt to get black people arrested for simply existing in close proximity to them.

All of the stereotypical names for ethnic minorities were never considered misogynistic, although they were racist. Obviously calling someone a Karen for simply speaking up for herself is horrible, but isn't it more prejudice than misogyny? It seems like stereotyping women's names according to their race was never a problem until it happened to white women. Interested to hear what other people think.

OP posts:
MarshmallowSwede · 27/07/2021 13:04

I agree 100%!

Bloodypunkrockers · 27/07/2021 13:03

[quote cinammonbuns]@znaika no one is using it as a gotcha moment for anything. We are simply pointing out that just because you have not heard of something doesn’t mean it exists. I have heard both Ling Ling and Shaniqua used in the U.K. by British people.[/quote]
Saying you've never heard of them is not saying they don't exist

I don't think anyone has said they don't exist

znaika · 27/07/2021 13:02

As I suspected you cant be rational. I posted earlier this morning about an uptick in really hate filled rhetoric about the English that is seemingly ok. It is social media phenomenon that that haa escalated as people have more time to post crap due to lockdowns. It was there before though. What i say is the op is transparently posting from a us pov directing ire at british women using us cultural references. This is not just some thing that happens.. People are sowing division on purpose. Of course some British women avidly consume us media output and know the tropes. That is not the point.

You're being dragged into to this and it is designwd to make you feel aggrieved and slighted but its propoganda. Take it from. russian - i understand this game better than you

SaskiaRembrandt · 27/07/2021 13:02

And I wonder if it deliberate...

Psst - it is!

CuriousaboutSamphire · 27/07/2021 13:01

[quote cinammonbuns]@CuriousaboutSamphire ah so additional categories are fine when talking about sex but not when talking about distinguishing by race? What? As if race does not have a big an impact by how you are fired by society. You clearly want to minimise the reality that white women do and have a long history of using their tears to get non white people into legal trouble or to garner sympathy. If you refuse to acknowledge that because you believe it will divide women then you won’t get anywhere. Women are already divided.

Also I can post as much as I want. Who made you the thread police?[/quote]
Don't make things up.

It makes you look daft!

cinammonbuns · 27/07/2021 13:01

@StatisticallyChallenged I think you were the one who failed to read @Spindless comments actually. She was not just talking about the use of the words ‘Shaniqua’ and ‘Ling Ling’ she was speaking in general terms that she focuses on issues which affect white women of her class that she knows. Which is the truth of most people, not just white women of course.
They focus on what affects them and the people like them directly.

It is just an honest departure for the lies often repeated on here that people care as much about the issues do BAME women as the issue of white women like themselves. It’s simply not true.

The honesty was refreshing.

Delphinia · 27/07/2021 13:01

The man who invented the Karen thing to get people to have a go at his ex wife must be absolutely delighted with how it's turned out and that people are using it to have a go at older women in general. He must be laughing his head off.

GrumpyTerrier · 27/07/2021 13:01

I've never encountered the others but would say they are as misogynistic as Karen now is.

I say 'now is' because what Karen started off as, and what it has become, are quite different.

I'm sure if someone on MN tried to shut a poster down by calling them Shaniqua or Ling Ling there would be utter outrage and an immeninent banning. Just cos we havent seen it on here doesn't mean people only care about Karen. They react to Karen because they see Karen all the time.

SaskiaRembrandt · 27/07/2021 13:01

@silentpool

Sort of tired of these goady posts. It's misogynistic and ageist and demeaning. Who cares if Karen is white or purple?
I think Karen's ethnic background does matter when you take into account the other names used to denigrate women from other backgrounds, because then you can see a pattern of misogyny. As I said upthread, they can all be interpreted as 'shut up, bitch'.
CuriousaboutSamphire · 27/07/2021 13:00

[quote cinammonbuns]**@DeleteSystem32* agreed. @CuriousaboutSamphire* you have a very selective memory. The everyone in bold is especially interesting when plenty defended her.[/quote]
It was in italics, not bold. And I have already agreed I could have worded it better. But nonetheless, the tone of those threads was as I described it.

But stop nitpicking. The issue isn't about individual issues, is it? It's about our language being inherently misogynistic, about SM being a fucking great vehicle for unfiltered bollocks like this, for the normalising of a whole host of nastiness . Nobody would disagree that those names are all misogynistic and racist - apart from the white women cos we have to check our privilege - and often ageist.

My point was why the fuck are we - or rather, are you - choosing to make this a more divisive issue?

Why divide 'woman' into ever more splintered categories? In this case it simply dilutes any response, derails a discussion.

ALL WOMEN are affected by such stupid naming conventions.

All women can be 'Karen' - that's misogyny

The other names, not heard them but have nor reason to douubt they are real and used in the same dismissive and patronising maner - are misogynist and racist

I am capable of challenging them all, whenever I see them. I don't have to make a choice, do I? Or would I be seen as virtue signalling, as a white woman if I did?

Can you see why I think some of this is weirdly divisive and only serves to reduce the effectiveness and the volume of the voice of women?

And I wonder if it deliberate...

HarebrightCedarmoon · 27/07/2021 13:00

It's all offensive. It's just that the other examples had not reached my ears.

Bloodypunkrockers · 27/07/2021 12:59

@Spindless

I also wonder why this word has fostered so much outrage on MN when other issues that affect non white women are not even given a second glance.

I can talk and get outraged about what is in my sphere of experience as a white woman living in a predominantly white area with white friends. That’s the reality.

I’ve never heard the other names used but fail to see how they aren’t both racist and misogynistic.

All of this
silentpool · 27/07/2021 12:57

Sort of tired of these goady posts. It's misogynistic and ageist and demeaning. Who cares if Karen is white or purple?

cinammonbuns · 27/07/2021 12:57

@CuriousaboutSamphire ah so additional categories are fine when talking about sex but not when talking about distinguishing by race? What? As if race does not have a big an impact by how you are fired by society. You clearly want to minimise the reality that white women do and have a long history of using their tears to get non white people into legal trouble or to garner sympathy. If you refuse to acknowledge that because you believe it will divide women then you won’t get anywhere. Women are already divided.

Also I can post as much as I want. Who made you the thread police?

Porcupineintherough · 27/07/2021 12:55

@aSofaNearYou I dont think the racism of white men (lynchings, shootings etc) has ever been hidden in the US. Personally I have found this lifting of the lid on the racism practiced by white women very eye opening. Just because it is also uncomfortable doesnt mean it shouldn't be labelled or talked about.

cinammonbuns · 27/07/2021 12:54

@znaika I have an agenda because I have a different way experience to you Confused. I cannot engage in rational debate with someone like you.

Everybody on the planet has an agenda in a conversation.

StatisticallyChallenged · 27/07/2021 12:53

I think @Spindless honesty is being used as an unfair gotcha when that isn't what she means.

I genuinely have never heard of the other examples used. That's not because I don't care, but because the area I grew up in was not somewhere they were used. It was a rough, mostly white council estate where racism aimed at those living there was more...overt? Violence, outright racial slurs, graffiti and so on.

We can't be expected to object to what we don't know about. I don't think the other examples are nearly as common in the uk and aren't seen in uk social media much either so it's perfectly feasible for plenty of uk based women to not be aware.

If they're used in the context described they're both racist and misogynistic but having a go at people for not being equally outraged at something they've never heard or seen just comes across as trying to silence women in a different way with a fat dose of whataboutery and accusations of hypocrisy.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 27/07/2021 12:51

@DeleteSystem32

One odd one about white women weaponising tears - American park reference I am assuming - that was widely denounced here, by every poster. No idea what their age or ethnicity as everyone agreed the woman in question was unreasonable.

I seem to remember plenty posters defending her.

Actually I think you are right - but they tended to get their arses handed to them.

The overrriding feeling on those threads was that she was a fucking fruit loop!

TheSlayer · 27/07/2021 12:51

I don't see how the word 'Karen' is better than 'racist' at communicating ideas.

Unless of course you are wedded to the inherent misogyny too.

Regardless of the girls name used I'd be calling it out as misogyny. On social media I'd have more chance of something being done on grounds of race than sexism so if I did see one of the terms in the op I'd report as a racial incident.

SaskiaRembrandt · 27/07/2021 12:51

@Meraas

You honestly can’t see why it’s empowering for a black/Hispanic/Asian person to record the person inflicting racist abuse on them and posting it on YouTube and sharing their experience of being targeted by a particular type of person known as a Karen?

Except, that isn't the context it's being used in the UK. You do understand that the UK and the US are two entirely separate countries, both geographically and culturally? How about you engage with what I actually wrote instead of waving your little sword at strawmen.

Why do you get to decide what helps them?

Where did I say that I did?

CuriousaboutSamphire · 27/07/2021 12:49

[quote cinammonbuns]@CuriousaboutSamphire there has been plenty more than one incident like that though. A new one enters on social media literally every day.

Again the minimising of the amount of incidents whereby white owned lie and gaslight Jon white propel to get them in trouble is interesting.

I can link you several which have happened in just the last month if I thought you would bother to actually watch them.[/quote]
I wasn't trying to minmise anything. Was just pointing out that tempers run high, language intended to inflame is used on most of these kinds of threads.

They always seem to divide - maybe to conquer, I don't know.

But your continued 'strident' posting is a good example of what I mean.

I don't doubt that many women weaponise tears. It is one of those sex based stereotypes we are all brought up with. I do doubt that it is only white women though.

And that's the kind of division I mean.

We can't do anything to tackle the root of that behaviour if we choose to wrangle over additional categorisations and accusations.

znaika · 27/07/2021 12:49

[quote cinammonbuns]@znaika no one is using it as a gotcha moment for anything. We are simply pointing out that just because you have not heard of something doesn’t mean it exists. I have heard both Ling Ling and Shaniqua used in the U.K. by British people.[/quote]
Really!? Im Asian and have never heard it. Get loats grief in the US largely for being Russian but also have been called wonton, someother words i wont repeat. The hardcore asian hate comes from the US. The racsim in the uk would.mention people from india and pakistan not hispanics. This how we can tell you have an agenda

aSofaNearYou · 27/07/2021 12:46

*You honestly can’t see why it’s empowering for a black/Hispanic/Asian person to record the person inflicting racist abuse on them and posting it on YouTube and sharing their experience of being targeted by a particular type of person known as a Karen?

Why do you get to decide what helps them?*

Nobody is trying to decide what helps them, but as women we ARE entitled to say their way of addressing it, and making "Karen" the poster girl for everyday racism, is throwing women under the bus. Not them specifically, but the culture.

Like another poster said, it has to do with racism being seen as worse than misogyny. I could honestly come up with a pretty extensive list of examples of times I have witnessed and experienced misogyny specifically from black men, but if I were to come up with a stereotypical name for that and make a bunch of memes I seriously doubt anyone would say that black men don't have the right to say what does and doesn't help me tackle misogyny. They would say I was racist.

cinammonbuns · 27/07/2021 12:46

*exactly

cinammonbuns · 27/07/2021 12:46

@Polkadots2021 exatuz @Tal45 unsure why you say women collectively are at the bottom for he like when it seems obvious that being non-white and a women would put you lower than other white woman.

I will pre-emptively reply to your likely response that it’s actually all women at the bottom by asking if differentiate on sex. I.e men vs women why shouldn’t we by rac?

Swipe left for the next trending thread