Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the name 'Karen' is only considered misogynistic because it refers to white women?

663 replies

FloofyCushion · 27/07/2021 10:53

I saw a tweet that said something along the lines of black women were referred to as Shaniqua for years, Hispanics as Maria or Guadalupe, and Asian women as Ling Ling. The only reason the name Karen is considered so offensive is because it refers to white women.

Whenever the term Karen is mentioned on here, posters will fall over themselves to say how misogynistic it is and that it silences women. But it doesn't refer to ALL women, only white women. A certain type of very entitled white woman that derives pleasure from getting people she believes to be beneath her into trouble with authority. Its also used for racist women that attempt to get black people arrested for simply existing in close proximity to them.

All of the stereotypical names for ethnic minorities were never considered misogynistic, although they were racist. Obviously calling someone a Karen for simply speaking up for herself is horrible, but isn't it more prejudice than misogyny? It seems like stereotyping women's names according to their race was never a problem until it happened to white women. Interested to hear what other people think.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 27/07/2021 16:16

I don't see how white women (or BAME women for that matter) in the UK are supposed to call out these terms for being misogynistic if we've never heard of them because they're mainly used in another country to describe people in that other country

You mean YOU have never heard of them. I grew up in the UK - I am completely familiar with Shaniqua et al. Kanisha, Hyesha etc etc. Just because you've never come across it doesn't mean it doesn't pervade.

paddlingon · 27/07/2021 16:15

I currently live in the USA and the term Karen is now used as a general sexist slur here as well.

My teens have used it to describe any middle aged woman who is saying or doing something they don't like.

They don't say it anymore around me because they don't want a lecture from me.
But ageism and sexism are culturally pretty acceptable both in the UK and the USA despite the many cultural differences.

znaika · 27/07/2021 16:15

@Wroxie this is shit. It's horrid and needs to be called out. But why come on to a UK site and start having a go at british women about us issues?

My experience is that racsim is everywhere but the legacy of slavery is like a gaping wound in the us and it affects far more people than the descendanta of slaves who had to suffer undwr segregation and other diseempowering laws and structures.

I know what my eyes look like but i never realised that i was not 'white' until i went to the us, the attitudes around race are very different there. Are there race issues in europe- yes of course. But Bame women (of which i am one) in europe are not best served by importing us racial divisions and issues

MorrisZapp · 27/07/2021 16:11

@Novelusername

I don't see how white women (or BAME women for that matter) in the UK are supposed to call out these terms for being misogynistic if we've never heard of them because they're mainly used in another country to describe people in that other country Confused. You may as well bring up some sexist/racist terms from Japan or Papua New Guinea and complain we don't call them out. I don't even know what these terms mean - a Black/Asian/Hispanic woman who does what? I've no idea. I generally find reducing people to terminology like this doesn't help change anything and just turns the dialogue toxic. Even if these terms are used in the UK, as some are claiming, they're clearly not as widely known as 'Karen', so it's hardly surprising they're not being 'called out'. I'm really tired of all this toxic dialogue. There is racism to be addressed in the UK, and sexism, and these can also intersect. It would be helpful to tackle that, rather than transplanting American dialogues about race when we have a completely different culture.
That's what I should have said. Ignore my shouty rant.
MorrisZapp · 27/07/2021 16:10

Sorry to shout but

THIS IS THE UK!!! Actual Britain! I'm in Scotland myself. I'm aware that MN is international and there are users here from pretty much everywhere but it's a UK run site and the users are mostly (not all!) in the UK.

Why should we accept a slur that in this country means gobby middle aged woman with crap hairdo because in another country very far away it means something else? Not that I love the insinuation that women make male violence happen anyway but putting that aside, it's just not how the meme is used here.

Wroxie · 27/07/2021 16:09

@Novelusername

I don't see how white women (or BAME women for that matter) in the UK are supposed to call out these terms for being misogynistic if we've never heard of them because they're mainly used in another country to describe people in that other country Confused. You may as well bring up some sexist/racist terms from Japan or Papua New Guinea and complain we don't call them out. I don't even know what these terms mean - a Black/Asian/Hispanic woman who does what? I've no idea. I generally find reducing people to terminology like this doesn't help change anything and just turns the dialogue toxic. Even if these terms are used in the UK, as some are claiming, they're clearly not as widely known as 'Karen', so it's hardly surprising they're not being 'called out'. I'm really tired of all this toxic dialogue. There is racism to be addressed in the UK, and sexism, and these can also intersect. It would be helpful to tackle that, rather than transplanting American dialogues about race when we have a completely different culture.
Scroll back one page and read my post if you're actually interested in the background of the Black name stereotype slur. And as a mixed-race woman (usually just seen as Black) here in the UK I can fucking well confirm that the racism against Black-coded names on job applications and the stereotypes related to those names are 100% an issue here. I won't call you a liar if you say you have never heard a joke or witnessed racism related to Black-coded names like Shaniqua but I'm damn skeptical.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/07/2021 16:07

There is racism to be addressed in the UK, and sexism, and these can also intersect. It would be helpful to tackle that, rather than transplanting American dialogues about race when we have a completely different culture.

Yes, it's pretty tiresome. This isn't America and many of the dynamics in society aren't the same.

Karen isn't primarily a middle class name in the U.K.

AlfonsoTheMango · 27/07/2021 16:06

Yes, YABU.

Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 16:06

@Clymene

As ever, I ask myself who benefits. It sure as shit ain't women, whatever our skin colour.
This is exactly my point. As a mixed race woman I don't feel I benefit at all from any women being dragged down or bullied for expressing their opinion.

Its not a term for a woman expressing a racist opinion. Its any woman expressing any opinion.

It really doesn't feel like it helps.

But I must say. This is my opinion only. Other peoples opinions may vary. Grin

Just incase I get accused of trying to speak for whole groups of people again.

Novelusername · 27/07/2021 16:04

I don't see how white women (or BAME women for that matter) in the UK are supposed to call out these terms for being misogynistic if we've never heard of them because they're mainly used in another country to describe people in that other country Confused. You may as well bring up some sexist/racist terms from Japan or Papua New Guinea and complain we don't call them out. I don't even know what these terms mean - a Black/Asian/Hispanic woman who does what? I've no idea. I generally find reducing people to terminology like this doesn't help change anything and just turns the dialogue toxic. Even if these terms are used in the UK, as some are claiming, they're clearly not as widely known as 'Karen', so it's hardly surprising they're not being 'called out'. I'm really tired of all this toxic dialogue. There is racism to be addressed in the UK, and sexism, and these can also intersect. It would be helpful to tackle that, rather than transplanting American dialogues about race when we have a completely different culture.

worstdaughter · 27/07/2021 16:04

@Ihavehadenoughalready

Karen's are not in my experience being denigrated for "having an opinion". They are rightly denigrated for raging at store workers, calling the police on black people for gathering at a public park, or gardening on their own property, attempting to enter their own apartment buildings, using their own apartment complex swimming pool, working at their own job site and being accused of "not looking like they belong there", and on and on it goes. Abuse by white women who think they have the right and possibly the duty to question any black person for doing anything they deem "suspicious". Who think police have no right to pull them over for traffic infractions because they are an elected official or a public figure..seen a few of those.

Do try to watch Karen compilations on you tube and you will see what I'm talking about. A lot of the Karen's recently have been anti-maskers taking their rage out on store employees and end up being arrested, my opinion is that this is their intention, as many are photographing themselves.This is not "white women having an opinion". This is people purposefully thinking their own opinion trumps (ha ha) everyone else's and everyone else's rights, and that they have a right to create scenes and force police to be deployed to remove their uncooperative unruly selves from private property.

Not all Karens are white women.

But entitled white women are the stereotypical Karen, at least here in the US.

As for Shaniqua, not sure when it started, but it could have been the movie Crash. When a black woman responsible for helping a white racist man get help for his father who was deteriorating medically, told him her name was Shaniqua, he responded "Of course it is."

Crash is a movie that explores everybody's racism and how all of it interplays with events.

Shaniqua does end up helping the racist white guy when they both were able to see themselves as fellow humans.

I don't see the use of Karen as being misogynistic. I see it as a shorthand for "entitled usually white woman doing something abusive". It's certainly less awful and definitely more descriptive than being called a b#tch or worse, isn't it?

Sorry to all the actual women named Karen out there. Lots of perfectly good names have gotten a bad reputation.

just gonna say it again, it comes from a reddit user making "comedy" posts about how he hates his ex wife for misogynistic lols, c. 2016-17
Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 16:03

[quote TheSlayer]@Katedanielshasakitty yes it was genuine not sarcasm. I thought it well expressed but didn't have much more to add to it, so may have come across a little brusque.[/quote]
Sorry about that. I wasn't sure. I shouldnt have said anything. Thank you

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/07/2021 16:02

Quite, Clymene.

Clymene · 27/07/2021 16:02

As ever, I ask myself who benefits. It sure as shit ain't women, whatever our skin colour.

Ihavehadenoughalready · 27/07/2021 16:01

Karen's are not in my experience being denigrated for "having an opinion". They are rightly denigrated for raging at store workers, calling the police on black people for gathering at a public park, or gardening on their own property, attempting to enter their own apartment buildings, using their own apartment complex swimming pool, working at their own job site and being accused of "not looking like they belong there", and on and on it goes. Abuse by white women who think they have the right and possibly the duty to question any black person for doing anything they deem "suspicious". Who think police have no right to pull them over for traffic infractions because they are an elected official or a public figure..seen a few of those.

Do try to watch Karen compilations on you tube and you will see what I'm talking about. A lot of the Karen's recently have been anti-maskers taking their rage out on store employees and end up being arrested, my opinion is that this is their intention, as many are photographing themselves.This is not "white women having an opinion". This is people purposefully thinking their own opinion trumps (ha ha) everyone else's and everyone else's rights, and that they have a right to create scenes and force police to be deployed to remove their uncooperative unruly selves from private property.

Not all Karens are white women.

But entitled white women are the stereotypical Karen, at least here in the US.

As for Shaniqua, not sure when it started, but it could have been the movie Crash. When a black woman responsible for helping a white racist man get help for his father who was deteriorating medically, told him her name was Shaniqua, he responded "Of course it is."

Crash is a movie that explores everybody's racism and how all of it interplays with events.

Shaniqua does end up helping the racist white guy when they both were able to see themselves as fellow humans.

I don't see the use of Karen as being misogynistic. I see it as a shorthand for "entitled usually white woman doing something abusive". It's certainly less awful and definitely more descriptive than being called a b#tch or worse, isn't it?

Sorry to all the actual women named Karen out there. Lots of perfectly good names have gotten a bad reputation.

Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 16:01

@aSofaNearYou

Though apparently my personal thoughts and opinions haven't gone down well with some people 🤷‍♀️

Mine either! For what it's worth I found your comments very insightful too.

Thank you. That means alot.
TheSlayer · 27/07/2021 16:01

@Katedanielshasakitty yes it was genuine not sarcasm. I thought it well expressed but didn't have much more to add to it, so may have come across a little brusque.

aSofaNearYou · 27/07/2021 16:01

[quote phishy]@aSofaNearYou

How so? I haven't in the slightest

Well, you did. I shared my experience of being patronised, condescended, underpaid, under promoted as a BAME woman and you responded with ‘Nobody knows exactly what it's like to be somebody else.’

It’s just lip service, there is no allyship with BAME women on MN.[/quote]
No, I did not. My point was literally that it's possible to care about both, and that caring about issues specific to BAME women does not have to mean misogyny does not exist or matter outside of that sphere. You were the one actively admitting that you only care about your own experiences.

I do care about the experiences of BAME women. I am not one so I absolutely cannot argue with the suggestion that they have it much worse, nor would I. I just disagree that having it worse means all other misogyny doesn't matter and shouldn't be tackled.

Nobody is asking you to prioritise white women. It's your choice to not care at all about misogyny outside of your own experiences, but that can mean contributing to it.

As for allyship, you're very proud to not have that yourself.

MorrisZapp · 27/07/2021 16:01

@Ereshkigalangcleg

when used correctly

There is no "correct usage". You are using a term originally popularised by misogynistic men on Reddit with a grudge against women. There is no fabulous social justice meaning for your misogynistic slur, whoever else supports the use of it.

This, absolutely.
MorrisZapp · 27/07/2021 16:00

@VladmirsPoutine

This only benefits sexist men. It would be really easy to come up with a word to replace 'Karen' that isn't misogynistic.

There was, more a phrase: 'a subset of white women who wield their whiteness and gender to cause chaos for BAME people' but we were then told 'nOt AlL wHiTe wOmEn, aND tHaTz RaCiSt'

That isn't how Karen is used in the UK. I don't know where you live but MN is a a majority UK site.
Wroxie · 27/07/2021 15:59

Just to clarify, because most of you didn't grow up in a Black family in the US, where "stereotypical" Black female names like Shaniqua have been weaponised as slurs, this is what is meant (so you can't say you don't know any more):

Loud, brash, poor, bad parent, on welfare (benefits), ignorant, sexually promiscuous (children with multiple men), foolish with money (spending on hair and nails instead of saving), unemployed OR working in a low-paid service job and being unhelpful/having a bad attitude.

(White) people have often accused Black people of "making up" names for their children - like the aforementioned Shaniqua, or names like Tasheena or LaQuonda (both names in the Black side of my family) or my own middle name, which I won't post here but is definitely a Black coded name- never stopping to think that maybe Black people, especially during the civil rights movement, didn't want to give their children the names of the people who had enslaved their parents and grandparents, and since they had been robbed of any connection to their African history and heritage, had no traditional names of their own to choose from. So creating beautiful new names not only makes sense, it was a creative and clever idea. To then have those well-loved and carefully chosen names denigrated as a symbol of every negative stereotype about black women is especially hurtful.

I'm sure that the East Asian and Latina "stereotype" names have similar interesting and painful stories behind them, and I know a bit about that but I'll leave it to the people affected to explain them if they want to.

Anyway. If you think "Karen" as a slur is equivalent to "Shaniqua" as a slur, you should probably recalibrate your thinking a bit. Call out the misogyny on its own terms but don't try to compare it.

phishy · 27/07/2021 15:59

I'm not saying that EVERY single time someone is called a "Karen" it is justified, but the greatest majority of times I've seen it on the internet it was well deserved, embarrassingly deserved!!

Exactly @grey12

I don't think people here realise just how scary it is to be confronted by someone that filled with hate and entitlement because they believe their skin colour to be superior.

Hurt feelings over Karen just doesn't compare.

VladmirsPoutine · 27/07/2021 15:58

This only benefits sexist men. It would be really easy to come up with a word to replace 'Karen' that isn't misogynistic.

There was, more a phrase: 'a subset of white women who wield their whiteness and gender to cause chaos for BAME people' but we were then told 'nOt AlL wHiTe wOmEn, aND tHaTz RaCiSt'

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/07/2021 15:58

when used correctly

There is no "correct usage". You are using a term originally popularised by misogynistic men on Reddit with a grudge against women. There is no fabulous social justice meaning for your misogynistic slur, whoever else supports the use of it.

Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 15:58

[quote phishy]@Katedanielshasakitty

It 2 above that one. Dont assume my race because you don't like my opinion. You assumed that I was white because you disagreed. And then thought because I was white I must be trying to speak for you.

I didn’t assume your race. You said ALL women should be opposed and I asked you not to speak for me. Where is the assumption about your race?[/quote]
You did assume my race. Read it back. Especially your talk about me being more privileged than you

You said

My experience as a BAME woman differs vastly from those of white women. There is no equivalence, you are much more privileged than me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread