Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you'd deal with DD and DS?

57 replies

fijnere · 27/07/2021 08:58

Yesterday, DS15 and DD12 were fighting. I was at work so I didn't witness it but DS told me that she took his phone and was reading messaging between him and his girlfriend and he told her to give his phone back but DD refused. DD is denying that this happened and said that DS just went into her room and grabbed her wrist (there was a red mark on her wrist), DS admitted that he did grab her wrist but only because she wouldn't give him his phone and it was annoying him.

How would you deal with this?

OP posts:
Imcatmum · 27/07/2021 09:23

He needs to understand that he is now to big and old to EVER assault (ideally anyone but especially) a girl or woman. The power dynamic means it's completely and utterly unacceptable. I'd come down very hard on him.

Then a separate issue of invading DSs privacy (which is pretty contentious when you're 15). Your DD needs a serious punishment for that.

Both would be punished for very different reasons.

Hercisback · 27/07/2021 09:21

Sit them down and ask for the truth.

If they can't agree on a version of events then you'll take the WiFi box to work.

Seasidemumma77 · 27/07/2021 09:18

I would sit them both down together. I'd start by saying that you didn't witness what happened, and as their accounts are do different, you can't take sides. I'd then firmly make it clear to both that they have no right to take each others possessions without permission, and that neither of them has the right to lay hands on each other.

It's so hard when you have to work, and teenagers have to begin to have to resolve their own squabbles. I've had to be extremely firm about respecting each others space and possessions, and even firmer on no physical fighting.

Sapnupuas · 27/07/2021 09:15

Teach your 15 year old not to put his hands on anyone.

Cocomarine · 27/07/2021 09:13

Well, I know I’d come down a fuck of a lot harder on a 15yo physically assaulting a 12yo so badly that even after the time delay for you to get home from work, there was still a bark in her.
Your son is a violent arsehole.

I wouldn’t be impressed with the phone stealing and message reading… but does the phone not have a lock on it? How would that actually have happened?

You know your 12yo - would she do this, and would she lie? (I know mine would crumble after looking obviously guilty)

You have no proof for the phone stealing, you have all the proof you need for the assault. So I’d punish the 15yo, and if that’s unfair because she got away with it - well, even more reason for him to learn not to assault his sister 🤷🏻‍♀️

CanofCant · 27/07/2021 09:08

I'll probably be no help and I'm well aware my own experiences are colouring my reply but however annoying DD is, DS needs to know he cannot lay his hands on her. My younger brother was very violent (and much bigger than me even at 13), broke my nose by kicking me in the face, punched me multiple times, was a nightmare to live with and we had to walk on eggshells around him constantly.

Obviously this is a world away from what happened in your house and your son might be a perfectly decent person pushed to the limit by his annoying little sister but I would be mindful of things escalating and getting out of control. Were they home alone while you were at work? If they can't get along together then you might have to find childcare for your DD.

I don't have teens yet and as I say, my comment is based purely on my own experiences but hopefully a seasoned parent of teens will be along with better advice. I do feel for you, it must be rubbish being in the middle of it.

KibeththeWalker · 27/07/2021 09:03

Does DS have form for just attacking DD unprovoked? If not, DS's version of the story sounds more plausible.

Are they home alone a lot? Maybe DD needs to be in a summer camp type thing while you work.