Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect family to follow our parenting choices when looking after DS?

208 replies

tiredmama2020 · 27/07/2021 06:55

Will be going back to work 3 days per week in a couple of months. Husband works away from home for weeks at a time. Very lucky that my sister and MIL have offered to look after DS - it works out they’ll cover 6 days per month between then and DH will be there the rest of the month so won’t need their help.

If family look after your child - how much do you expect them to follow your parenting choices?
I’m very grateful that MIL has offered help but she’s making comments already that are making me a bit nervous that we’re going to have issues when the time comes 😓

A few examples:

  • weaning is going well. Home cooking all his meals and he’s eating a great variety and loving his food. MIL “can’t wait until she gets to be in charge and can finally get some ‘proper’ baby food into him” - she absolutely insists that baby’s NEED jars of puddings and Rusks after each meal. Obviously the odd one of these things isn’t going to do him any harm if she did give him one but personally, I don’t believe he needs any.
  • he’s 9m old currently and napping twice a day. He’s definitely a baby who thrives off routine. I’m not super strict on it at all but. If we’re home, as soon as he shows signs of being tired I’ll get him in his sleeping bag and put him down in his cot with white noice and he’ll fall asleep - occasionally he’ll need rocked to sleep. MIL says he’s being “spoiled” and that a tired baby should sleep anywhere. No reason for him to be rocked/go to his cot. At that age hers would have just fallen asleep on their mat on the floor. If I’m out a walk with him and he’s not awake by the time we get home/back to the car and I have nothing else I need to be home for them I’ll keep walking with him until he wakes up - he sleeps better when the pram is moving. I don’t see an issue with it - he gets a better sleep, I get a bit more exercise, but MIL thinks it’s absolutely ridiculous.
  • I’m also very much “baby comes first” so if I’m in the middle of doing something and he cries/fusses/wants fed etc then I’ll stop what I’m doing. MIL believes that baby should fit into your life so should be left until you’re finished what you’re doing.

There are also another couple of issues regarding car seats (she says she doesn’t want him in the backseat of her car as she’ll find it easier to have him in the front. And she thinks rear facing is ‘ridiculous’) but she won’t be looking after him at all if she doesn’t follow car seat safety so they’re not an issue.

Obviously he needs to fit in with her day but she’ll be looking after him from our house - I’ll have his meals all prepared just ready to be heated etc. AIBU to expect her to feed him what we want and to follow his normal nap routine if they’re in the house?

OP posts:
Crowsaregreat · 27/07/2021 07:40

Also - learning that different people follow different rules is a valuable and beneficial experience for kids and all part of the fun. Especially when it's grandparents being a bit more lenient. You do have to remember that for GP, their parenting choices weren't that long ago and it can come across as if you're saying they took needless risk with their kids, eg were bad mothers. No wonder they get defensive! There were different levels of acceptable risk back then, as a kid in 80s and 90s I often travelled in the boot of our estate car on the motorway, with the dog! Or going in the back seat on someone's lap. Today's parenting can seem a bit overprotective.

burritofan · 27/07/2021 07:38

If he does sleep anywhere, not a problem. If like DD he’s a “cot or fuck off” baby, MIL will soon do it your way – because no one wants to look after an overtired baby.

Car seat you’ve already put your foot down on but be careful she actually adheres to that.

I wouldn’t be thrilled at the baby jars and rusks and other pointless crap, but I would sooner eat wasps than use my MIL for childcare anyway, so ¯\(ツ)/¯

Some of this seems a lot like a weird battle where she’s saying things like “being in charge” that could mean trouble is ahead and she’s determined to use her days to do things her way because it’s about control. But it might all be fine! Just have a backup plan to use paid childcare; they’re much more likely to listen when you need them to, such as curtailing naps etc.

Sirzy · 27/07/2021 07:36

I'd also be trying to discuss changes in childrearing practice, eg how she raised her kids differently from how she was raised, how in turn that was different to how her parents were raised. It's not that many generations back that children were sent up chimneys or put to work in mills and mines!

I’m not sure patronising her with “well things have changed” is a good way to build a good relationship!

Rosebel · 27/07/2021 07:33

For 6 days a month I don't think it matters apart from the car seat. Insist she uses a rear facing one and if she must have it in the front make sure the airbag is off.
I don't think pudding 6 times a month will hurt and surely she'll use the food you provide.
I don't think it's a bad idea to get your baby used to sleeping anywhere and as your baby isn't newborn leaving him to fuss for a few minutes won't harm him either (as long as it is just a few minutes and he's safe).

Bunnycat101 · 27/07/2021 07:32

On car seats you just need to explain the benefits. You can’t expect her to realise tech abs understanding has moved on. Make sure she knows that if he’s in the front the airbag must be switched off. We have had similar discussions.

On risks, she’ll have to go out of her way to find them. I don’t think I’ve seen any tbh. If you think she’ll be determined re jars get a few of the Ella’s pouches. You may well find he’ll refuse to eat jar stuff off a spoon if he’s used to proper food. Sleep will be easier once he’s down to 1 nap. 2 naps is still quite hard logistically. Maybe compromise abs ask her to make sure 1 nap is in the cot if possible.

Crowsaregreat · 27/07/2021 07:31

Eek, if these concerns have cropped up before she even starts, it doesn't bode well!

I think you should expect her to follow your parenting choices but the things you mention aren't really choices, they're following official advice eg reduce sugar, safe car seat in the back. Naps maybe less so! Show her the official info on the other things that explains why it reduces risk.

I'd also be trying to discuss changes in childrearing practice, eg how she raised her kids differently from how she was raised, how in turn that was different to how her parents were raised. It's not that many generations back that children were sent up chimneys or put to work in mills and mines!

I would try a few short sessions where she has him for a few hours before you need to rely on it for work, that way you can sort an alternative with less stress if you need to. She might also find it's harder work than she remembers and have second thoughts!

FrenchFancie · 27/07/2021 07:30

The car seat is the only thing that’s non negotiable - it’s not that long ago that the rules changed about rear facing, I know we turned out 8yo de at about 9 months (which was legal then). So she may genuinely not be aware of current rules.

Food and naps - you won’t get this kind of control at a nursery / setting so you would be unreasonable to expect mil to follow what you want to the letter.

saywhatwhatnow · 27/07/2021 07:29

I agree about the car seats, the rest of it won't matter for a few days a month. In fact the sleep thing may work out well.

My parents have my DC (3&1) once a week, they are amazing grandparents but we've had a few 'annoying' situations. They get irritated with the rear facing car seat as it's hard to get DS in to, and have asked to turn it forwards a couple of times. I've been very firm and explained why not and they've accepted it. Mum is not the best cook so they all have a very basic lunch and I make sure I prep/leave something for the kids tea. Snacks and chocolate buttons are a free for all, but this has backfired on them a bit as a few times the kids haven't eaten any actual food and have turned feral. I explained that if they limit junk and get them to actually eat some lunch it may pan out a bit better. With naps I've just had to relax a bit, I do say no sleep after 4pm but other than that they do what they like/find easiest. I appreciate everything they do and my kids adore them and look forward to them coming every week!! We're currently isolating and DS1 started crying last night saying how much he misses Grandpa, that says it all really.

FourTeaFallOut · 27/07/2021 07:28

It's 6 days a month between your sister and mil, presumably they aren't looking after him together so what this amounts to is a few days a month of nibbling on a rusk and sleeping a little differently. That wouldn't bother me but if it bothers you then you should pay for childcare.

LonstantonSpiceMuseum · 27/07/2021 07:26

@ShinyGreenElephant

I wouldnt risk it tbh. As soon as she even suggested forward facing him she wouldn't have been having him alone ever. The other stuff is less essential but she just sounds like she has no respect for your choices so other issues will arise - not worth it imo. Just pay for childcare and they will do as they're told.
Definitely this - the issue here is she's not respecting your choices - while you might change one thing like the car seat, imagine if there was something else too? Like he had an allergy and she decided not to believe it. If you can pay for childcare, then she's not doing you a favour, it's not going to help you out if your child is tired and grumpy from changed routine and poor diet the rest of the week. It will be better in the long term. If you can't afford it, then this makes the situation different obviously.
AuntieStella · 27/07/2021 07:23

Pay for proper childcare

You will suffer the same loss of day to day control, but you'll find it much easier to deal with when it's not a close family member. And if you have to change childcare because you don't like how it's going, it won't have anything like the fallout of a dispute with DGM. So don't get into the position in the first place.

Save DGM for the odd extra day when your regular childcare is unavailable. Granny doing idifferently doesn't hurt one iota when it's only now and again.

user1471457757 · 27/07/2021 07:22

The car seat thing is ridiculous! In the UK babies have to legally be rear facing until 15 months and after that it's much safer for them to continue to be rear facing.

TidyDancer · 27/07/2021 07:21

The car seat is the only thing I would be concerned about here. The rest of it just isn't that important.

Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 07:20

I would absolutely out my foot down on the car seat situation.

The rest of it, let it go.

My mum did things differently to how I did them. My opinion was that if I trust her to look after my daughter, I trust her to make decisions she thinks is best at the time. If she mentioned something and it wasn't something I was happy with, I would te her what I prefer but back that up with 'but I wasn't there, so if you think that's the best thing that's fine'
She didn't get all offended if I said it.

If you can't trust her to to make decisions for herself, then it's probably best she doesn't have your baby.

I do think expecting people to drop everything because your baby is moaning, is a bit ridiculous. If you choose that, that's absolutely fine. But not even a nanny would do that, every single time.never mind chdminder or nursery.

Sirzy · 27/07/2021 07:20

The car seat is the only non negotiable from those things.

BUT if small things like your list are going to be issues for you then I would be looking for alternative childcare as it’s obviously going to frustrate you which will only get worse over time

mrsrichardsglasses · 27/07/2021 07:18

I've been a very similar situation with my MIL and honestly it has ruined our relationship. I can't trust her at all, I let her have the DC as little as possible and when I do (and I absolutely have to) its very stressful.
This is things like taking DC out without a car seat at all- held on her lap in the front seat with FIL driving them across town. Giving them meat when we're vegetarian. Keeping them awake for hours past their nap or bedtime because she wanted to show them off to her friends. So we're not just being overly fussy parents.
I would honestly avoid giving her the opportunity to undermine you and just send your baby to childcare.

Dontforgetyourbrolly · 27/07/2021 07:18

This comes up time and time again, other than the car seat your choices are suck it up or pay for childcare
My own mum had ds every Wednesday for years, she gave him treats that I learned to relax about and a lot more independence like playing in the garden ( I was a nervous ftm) ! In the long run it was good for him and they are very close now it's lovely
I'm still saying " please don't tell me how much chocolate he's had " lol

MarleneDietrichsSmile · 27/07/2021 07:17

Yes, the car seat situation has to be safe

But the rest, you seem very control freaky about Grin Either you are ready to let granny look after the baby, or you are not Wink

It is hard, I know!

endofjune · 27/07/2021 07:16

My baby wouldn’t be going there.

riotlady · 27/07/2021 07:16

@ShinyGreenElephant

I wouldnt risk it tbh. As soon as she even suggested forward facing him she wouldn't have been having him alone ever. The other stuff is less essential but she just sounds like she has no respect for your choices so other issues will arise - not worth it imo. Just pay for childcare and they will do as they're told.
This is fucking nuts. Why would you not just explain about the car seat? Fair enough to not let her have him if she pushed it but banning someone from having your child because they suggested having him FF (which was very common for the older generation) is massively OTT
mayblossominapril · 27/07/2021 07:15

The only thing that would worry/stop me from using MIL for childcare is the car seat. If she uses yours fitted properly fine
If you have another you wouldn’t be able to keep a todddler walking round whilst the baby slept
Food, jars won’t hurt one of mine still eats them and once they eat school/nursery dinners they eat all sorts of cheap crap you wouldn’t want them having!

readwhatiactuallysay · 27/07/2021 07:15

You sound pretty sensible and fair.

As you have she is doing it from your house, im assuming the food you want your DC will be ready for her.

Its annoying when people constantly try to go against your wishes, as you have accepted she will try and get rubbish food in your DC at some point, its only a few times a month. It still would have been infuriating to me though and a complete lack of respect.

I would have to choose a different route for childcare (if you could afford it obviously of not you will just have to keep asking her sadly) if she is showing this lack or respect now, it will only get worse.

riotlady · 27/07/2021 07:14

The food I would let go of, prep some homemade meals but expect her to be giving him some rusks

The napping is her problem really as she’ll be the one dealing with a tired baby

Crispyturtle · 27/07/2021 07:12

There’s no childcare setting thats going to look after your kid like you do, unless you pay for a nanny. For a few days a month I wouldn’t sweat about naps or food. As a pp has said, it’s really useful for a kid to be able to sleep anywhere.

But totally agree that she follows proper safety advice re the car seat. If she won’t do that you definitely need to make other arrangements.

Notimeforaname · 27/07/2021 07:10

As he is not their child and they are helping you out..I think in this instance his life has to fit around theirs.. sorry.

Of course you cant mess around with car seats or anything unsafe!! But I think giving him a jar of food or rusks...or letting him fall asleep on sofa is not something you can control. Dont go away if you want every minute of his day to go exactly how it would when you have him...