Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect family to follow our parenting choices when looking after DS?

208 replies

tiredmama2020 · 27/07/2021 06:55

Will be going back to work 3 days per week in a couple of months. Husband works away from home for weeks at a time. Very lucky that my sister and MIL have offered to look after DS - it works out they’ll cover 6 days per month between then and DH will be there the rest of the month so won’t need their help.

If family look after your child - how much do you expect them to follow your parenting choices?
I’m very grateful that MIL has offered help but she’s making comments already that are making me a bit nervous that we’re going to have issues when the time comes 😓

A few examples:

  • weaning is going well. Home cooking all his meals and he’s eating a great variety and loving his food. MIL “can’t wait until she gets to be in charge and can finally get some ‘proper’ baby food into him” - she absolutely insists that baby’s NEED jars of puddings and Rusks after each meal. Obviously the odd one of these things isn’t going to do him any harm if she did give him one but personally, I don’t believe he needs any.
  • he’s 9m old currently and napping twice a day. He’s definitely a baby who thrives off routine. I’m not super strict on it at all but. If we’re home, as soon as he shows signs of being tired I’ll get him in his sleeping bag and put him down in his cot with white noice and he’ll fall asleep - occasionally he’ll need rocked to sleep. MIL says he’s being “spoiled” and that a tired baby should sleep anywhere. No reason for him to be rocked/go to his cot. At that age hers would have just fallen asleep on their mat on the floor. If I’m out a walk with him and he’s not awake by the time we get home/back to the car and I have nothing else I need to be home for them I’ll keep walking with him until he wakes up - he sleeps better when the pram is moving. I don’t see an issue with it - he gets a better sleep, I get a bit more exercise, but MIL thinks it’s absolutely ridiculous.
  • I’m also very much “baby comes first” so if I’m in the middle of doing something and he cries/fusses/wants fed etc then I’ll stop what I’m doing. MIL believes that baby should fit into your life so should be left until you’re finished what you’re doing.

There are also another couple of issues regarding car seats (she says she doesn’t want him in the backseat of her car as she’ll find it easier to have him in the front. And she thinks rear facing is ‘ridiculous’) but she won’t be looking after him at all if she doesn’t follow car seat safety so they’re not an issue.

Obviously he needs to fit in with her day but she’ll be looking after him from our house - I’ll have his meals all prepared just ready to be heated etc. AIBU to expect her to feed him what we want and to follow his normal nap routine if they’re in the house?

OP posts:
Jossbow · 27/07/2021 08:00

Granny here.
I know car seat stuff is non negociable but...

Please check that is practical &Sensisble to put your car seat in her car, and its ready to roll.

Its almost impossible for an older person to bend well enough and fold themselves up, to get into the back seat of her small 3 door car
to strap down a rear facing baby/ toddler.

I have given up. dont go in the car with grandaughter, just cant do it

Illogicalmadness · 27/07/2021 08:00

She is providing you with free childcare so I think you're YABU. Pay for nursery or childminder to provide the childcare & then you'll be more in control. I'd keep your mil on standby for adhoc childcare not regular as tensions will arise.

Clymene · 27/07/2021 08:00

Car seat is a big no no. Everything else is stuff you wouldn't be able to control in paid childcare unless you have a nanny.

StepladderToHeaven · 27/07/2021 08:00

Lots of people have mentioned the car seat issue, but the other one that would really bother me is my 9 month old baby being left to cry while MIL pottered around finishing a chore Sad You're unlikely to be able to change her mind now, so for that reason I don't think I'd feel right about leaving him with her.

Naps, weaning etc - not the end of the world for a few days a month.

Dollywilde · 27/07/2021 07:59

As others say, the only one to put your foot down on is the car seat.

Babies/toddlers are amazing at knowing they have different routines with different people/in different settings. Babies who need shushing/pitch black/white noise for naps at home will go into nursery and just conk out in the daylight on a mat with other kids tearing around - I couldn’t believe it but it’s true! So having a different nap routine won’t be a problem and even if it is she’s the one dealing with an overtired baby Smile

Food - meh. It’s a handful of days a month. Convenience food isn’t the devil and neither is sugar, in moderation. It’s about learning to eat a rainbow of nutritious food and your kid is with her limited time, the lessons you teach him are more important.

Do you seriously drop everything the second your baby gets wingey though? I wouldn’t have eaten a meal/loaded the washing machine/bought a pint of milk in the last year if I did that!! I really think you’re making a rod for your own back. Your shout I guess but it won’t do your baby any harm if he’s safe and not in pain to realise that he doesn’t get fussed over the second he grumbles.

pinkcircustop · 27/07/2021 07:57

This is a disaster waiting to happen. I wouldn’t be letting her look after him because you know you can’t trust her.

JoborPlay · 27/07/2021 07:56

I'm with you on rear facing carseats though!

He can be in the front though as long as airbag is off and the manual allows- it's actually safer than the back.

junebirthdaygirl · 27/07/2021 07:55

I am a grandma. I think she is being very disrespectful saying all those things before she even gets your baby. What will she be like when she is a few weeks in? . Good GPS learn to keep their opinions to themselves!! My gds mum wrote me a schedule that suited gd and l was quite happy to follow it as was only a few days here and there. I don't like the way she is talking already so my advise is don't do it as she will constantly annoy you. When your dh is away you will be on your own dealing with her great opinions and could easily end up falling out altogether. Get childcare elsewhere.

JoborPlay · 27/07/2021 07:53

Being really honest- if I trust someone to look after my child I trust them. Full stop. I might say that DC have 2 naps at roughly X & y time but that's it.

If I want my children cared for in a particular way, I pay for childcare.

ShouldersBackChestOutChinUp · 27/07/2021 07:51

This lack of respect for your preferences is only going to get worse. Seriously.

I'd start paying for childcare. Mil doesn't care one jot about your preferences.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 27/07/2021 07:51

@tiredmama2020

Will be going back to work 3 days per week in a couple of months. Husband works away from home for weeks at a time. Very lucky that my sister and MIL have offered to look after DS - it works out they’ll cover 6 days per month between then and DH will be there the rest of the month so won’t need their help.

If family look after your child - how much do you expect them to follow your parenting choices?
I’m very grateful that MIL has offered help but she’s making comments already that are making me a bit nervous that we’re going to have issues when the time comes 😓

A few examples:

  • weaning is going well. Home cooking all his meals and he’s eating a great variety and loving his food. MIL “can’t wait until she gets to be in charge and can finally get some ‘proper’ baby food into him” - she absolutely insists that baby’s NEED jars of puddings and Rusks after each meal. Obviously the odd one of these things isn’t going to do him any harm if she did give him one but personally, I don’t believe he needs any.
  • he’s 9m old currently and napping twice a day. He’s definitely a baby who thrives off routine. I’m not super strict on it at all but. If we’re home, as soon as he shows signs of being tired I’ll get him in his sleeping bag and put him down in his cot with white noice and he’ll fall asleep - occasionally he’ll need rocked to sleep. MIL says he’s being “spoiled” and that a tired baby should sleep anywhere. No reason for him to be rocked/go to his cot. At that age hers would have just fallen asleep on their mat on the floor. If I’m out a walk with him and he’s not awake by the time we get home/back to the car and I have nothing else I need to be home for them I’ll keep walking with him until he wakes up - he sleeps better when the pram is moving. I don’t see an issue with it - he gets a better sleep, I get a bit more exercise, but MIL thinks it’s absolutely ridiculous.
  • I’m also very much “baby comes first” so if I’m in the middle of doing something and he cries/fusses/wants fed etc then I’ll stop what I’m doing. MIL believes that baby should fit into your life so should be left until you’re finished what you’re doing.

There are also another couple of issues regarding car seats (she says she doesn’t want him in the backseat of her car as she’ll find it easier to have him in the front. And she thinks rear facing is ‘ridiculous’) but she won’t be looking after him at all if she doesn’t follow car seat safety so they’re not an issue.

Obviously he needs to fit in with her day but she’ll be looking after him from our house - I’ll have his meals all prepared just ready to be heated etc. AIBU to expect her to feed him what we want and to follow his normal nap routine if they’re in the house?

I don't know about UK, but where I live it's illegal to have a child under 7 in the front seat unless every other seat is taken by a younger child. And no forward facing before 1. If you're getting free child care you have to be flexible and how they're cared for, but the car seat that's the hill to die on. I would be finding a child care place for him. She hasn't even had him yet and there's already issues.
FourTeaFallOut · 27/07/2021 07:49

It's not just an economic decision though. Having an eager, loving and willing grandparent who lives close enough to be a part of your child's life is an absolute bonus in your family.

Yes, absolutely, hold firm on the car seats but then let the brakes off a little. I'd really advise you not to undermine her confidence for the sake of pudding and nap times. The long game is that you have another trusted adult in the world who your child loves who can pick up the reins not just for a few days a month to work but potentially when you need emergency care, (or a night out) and the more familiar they are with each other alone, the better. Don't burn that bridge for pudding.

Hopeisnotastrategy · 27/07/2021 07:47

Other than the car seat these sound like minor issues. Pick your battles and be grateful for the help.

Dahlietta · 27/07/2021 07:47

All those saying “pay for childcare”, it’s not going to be easy to find childcare for 3 days a month!
I would feel like you, OP. It’s not even necessarily the things she’s said already (apart from the car seat), it’s the fact that she seems to openly scoff at your choices. That said, assuming you trust you trust her to use the car seat properly, you might just have to suck it up. Unless your sister would have him for the six days?

Hollyhead · 27/07/2021 07:46

I would agree that car safety is non negotiable. The rest of the stuff I’d let go. They change a lot between 9 and 11 months anyway, and your baby is on the cusp of toddlerhood where some of these more baby like routines get dropped/shifted anyway. It’s not unlikely that within a month or so of starting they’ll have dropped to 1 long afternoon nap instead of two etc.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 27/07/2021 07:46

The car seat you need to iron out but unless you have a nanny then no childcare provider is going to follow your exact routine as they will have others babies etc to look after.

IslandSnow · 27/07/2021 07:45

The only way to make this work is to choose your battles very carefully- and almost ignore the personal preference stuff (ie food) so you have more credit in the bank to deal with the safety stuff (ie car seat)

reluctantbrit · 27/07/2021 07:44

I would let the food issue go, it's just a handful of days. The nursery spoon-fed DD for lunch while we did BLW, 4 meals a week is hardly an issue.

I think the nap issue depends on how flexible your child is. Mine would have thrown a hissy-fit when overtired and by 9 months it worked a lot better when she had her scheduled naps or at least napping in the pram when we were out.

Fitting in your life - again, it depends what it means. An overtired or overly hungry baby is a nightmare so these things were priorities. A bit of grumpy baby is not the end of the world and I wouldn't rush at any small noise.

Car seat - absolutely not acceptable and in my opinion a deal breaker.

Saying that - I would always go for paid childcare, it is not worth destroying a family relationship over childcare differences.

ittakes2 · 27/07/2021 07:44

You'll get plenty advice about the m'n'law situation I just wanted to feed back you are making a rod for your own back saying you drop everything when he wants attention. It might be OK now as a small baby - but a crying toddler - an older child - an adult man ... expecting females and others to drop everything when he wants attention is not a good look. Especially if you are thinking of having more children...totally impossible to sustain and then he will start acting up when he doesn't get the attention levels he is used to.

VanGoSunflowers · 27/07/2021 07:43

I would not leave my child with your MIL full stop. She has zero respect (or common sense, for that matter)

MoreAloneTime · 27/07/2021 07:43

I think family childcare only really works if either the parents are very relaxed or the parents and caregivers have the same ways of doing things.

Datingandnoideahowto · 27/07/2021 07:43

Nursery or childminder aren’t going to do things the op’s way either though. For that she would need a nanny. And even then it might not work.

MadeOfStarStuff · 27/07/2021 07:41

Car seat is non negotiable but the other stuff you have to weigh up if it’s worth the cost if free childcare im your home. If it’s not then you need to pay for proper childcare

Summerfun54321 · 27/07/2021 07:40

You’re going to have to learn to let go a little if you ask family to do you a favour and look after your child. Otherwise, put them in nursery where you can comment and complain without damaging close relationships. Your MIL just needs to be brought up to date on car seat advice, it’s changed quite a bit so no harm in telling her current advice.

moita · 27/07/2021 07:40

I'd put in him nursery or childminder