Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is racism against the English acceptable?

792 replies

BabyBearRus · 26/07/2021 23:58

We are currently on holiday in Wales and have just heard an altercation outside our holiday accommodation blasting the "bastard English who come to stay here". I'm shocked. I am half Welsh and half Irish, and spent much time in both countries. But also spent half my life in England. There has always been a jovial criticism of the English, e.g. during rugby internationals etc, but in recent years the tone has become more racist. I also find this resentful attitude towards the English amongst my Irish and Scottish friends. The English seem to be an acceptable people to hate. Surely this should be classed as racism? And, I'm saying this from a predominantly Welsh and Irish heritage. Yes, I am aware of the history of these isles, but when are we going to get over this? Truly baffled.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
BabyBearRus · 27/07/2021 21:49

Absolutely agree that the English have had a lot to answer for. As do many other nations, e.g. France, Spain, USA, Canada, Australia, to name a few. But when does it end? When do we reach a point where we can try to overcome the past and work towards a more harmonious future?

As previously mentioned, both sides of my family (Welsh & Irish) recall the misery of "English occupation" (a term both sides used). During the 70s and 80s, my Irish family living in London suffered racist abuse on a daily basis. There's a brilliant study called "Suspect Communities" which compares the racism experienced by the Irish during that period to the later Islamaphobia that occurred after 9/11 (but was prevalent in England before this). Racism and prejudice towards anyone is abhorrent.

And of course there are English people who I find extremely annoying, especially the arrogance of some holiday makers who prance around like they own the place. This quite rightly irks the locals. But I also have felt the same way about many people from other nations. Some people are complete dickheads regardless of their race or nationality.

But last night was uncalled for, to verbally attack an older woman on her own, on the basis of her nationality is simply wrong. All because she simply asked them not to park in front of her drive. Such prejudiced and threatening behaviour should not have to be tolerated by anyone. So, no, despite obviously being sympathetic to my Celtic history, I feel that the behaviour of the perpetrators was absolutely shameful.

For goodness sake, how can you blame an entire people for the sins of the past? Frankly, hatred perpetuates hatred and fear. Have we learnt nothing from history?

The way forward can be found at the ballot box and through education and civic duty at the community level.

OP posts:
marmaladehound · 27/07/2021 21:45

@sonjadog

French people really, really do not speak English together and switch to French just so that English people don't understand them. Grin Come on, you know that can't be true. Why would they be speaking English together when French is their native language??
I was in wales! Read the original post of you wish to comment!!!!!
foxandbee · 27/07/2021 21:45

Christ @TitchGreen and @SourAppleChew. Are you having a competition to see who can be the most offensive?

Meraas · 27/07/2021 21:45

[quote TitchGreen]@Meraas I'll have to take your critisim of my atrocious spelling and grammar on board I suppose; would you like to discuss any of the points I made or are you happy to be a meme?[/quote]

  1. I didn’t criticise you. Janie said your post was well said and I disagreed with HER due to the spelling errors.
  1. The grammar in that Matrix meme is terrible.
SchrodingersImmigrant · 27/07/2021 21:45

Not wrong @SourAppleChew Not commenting on the reparations but it does often feel like the past is more important thanpresent in this. Instead of learning from it and trying to use it to prevent currents slavery, everyone just argues about who's fault it was more.
There are reported about 46 million people affected by modern slavery. Aalvery is still pretty much alive. Also apparently a reason why qe can buy apples for a quid...

marmaladehound · 27/07/2021 21:44

Foxandbee

Well you clearly can't read very well. I did not say I was in France, I was in Wales. The people in the pub were speaking English ( their choice to do so!) and switched to Welsh once they heard the English!

Oh and for the record between myself and my husband we speak 8 languages so can pretty much travel to many parts of the world and converse in the language of the country we are in. Sorry does that ruin your over generalisation of the ignorant English?

But maybe if you actually read posts and get of your high horse been a total bitch to people ( many of your posts here!) you would never have needed to make this patronising comment in the first place.

BrozTito · 27/07/2021 21:43

Wroxie- 'condescending to you' or showing you facts when you have nothing but idpol cliches and you dont like it? Show me your counterclaim that 40% of the budget equivalent wasnt spent then, or that slavery wasnt profitable and was just presumably a huge hobby the US fought a massively bloody war over

SourAppleChew · 27/07/2021 21:41

Following on from my previous comment which was conveniently ignored, I don't understand why reparations for the non-enslaved descendants of slaves who died hundreds of years ago seems to be put ahead of liberating those currently enslaved.

It's almost like black slaves matter (more than other slaves).

foxandbee · 27/07/2021 21:35

That's such a sad story @MildredPuppy. Imagine seeing your children starve to death.

I think we can all play a part by ensuring we don't vote racists into power and by demanding our politicians do something meaningful and real to address racism and inequality.

TitchGreen · 27/07/2021 21:35

@Wroxie I didn't intend to Godwin you if I did (Don't know what that means to be fair).

I don't feel you are in anyway wrong to feel the spoils of slavery should be redistributed accordingly, I understand the rhetoric and why it would be favourable action and in the idea of justice, even be the 'right' action. I don't feel it necessary or wise to do so, see the response from MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously:
"Wrt to seizing generational wealth accrued from slavery, can we also seize wealth accrued from exploitation of the poor. Or from men for the exploitation of our female ancestors? Can England put in a claim against Denmark because the Vikings invaded us? I'm not opposed to some redistribution of wealth - anyone owning vast amounts of land is immoral to me, but the idea of taking property away on the basis of ancestral behaviour opens up a can of worms and would be very difficult to implement fairly."

This basically sums up my position on the matter.

Please don't feel I am attacking you here, I am just making a point. Can you advise me what you are doing to actively find and fix the injustices your family has commited? However small they are?
None of us have family or heritage free of sin.

My comment on Mein Kampf was not clear, I should have explained myself better. I will happily say I am wrong, but it seemed you were advocating for collective guilt and collective justice. To my mind attributing collective guilt and collective justice was what caused (not solely, but was a huge factor) the atrocities of the last century. To think that by doing the same thing now won't cause the repetition of history is just plain hubris.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 27/07/2021 21:34

Wroxie I think it's easier to return specific, individual items to their rightful owners (as in your example of a Stradivarius stolen from a Jewish musician) than something more intangible, such as inherited wealth. It would be impossible to separate out the initial value from the contributions made by subsequent generations.

DewDew83 · 27/07/2021 21:28

This prejudice, among our own countrymen and women, is completely unacceptable.
I suspect this wasn't intended to be goady, but most Welsh people don't identify as British and I think many would object to being described as 'countrymen and women' in relation to people from the other countries in the UK.

sonjadog · 27/07/2021 21:28

French people really, really do not speak English together and switch to French just so that English people don't understand them. Grin Come on, you know that can't be true. Why would they be speaking English together when French is their native language??

newnortherner111 · 27/07/2021 21:27

Prejudice or xenophobia I would call it. Though resentment about tourists and second home owners is not confined to those from a neighbouring country. Think of the resentment in Devon and Cornwall for example.

Whilst I think you should blame the system and not target the individuals who take advantage of it, I do think that policies that make more homes available for local people should be enacted.

OhHeyItsSaturday · 27/07/2021 21:24

@Clydesider

It's prejudice rather than racism but, yes, you're right, OP. I think if myself as British; born in England, one parent English and one Scottish. I live in Scotland and the way English people ste treated and spoken about by some in Scotland is appalling. The Scottish part of me finds it shameful. This prejudice, among our own countrymen and women, is completely unacceptable.
I have very recently deleted a Scottish friend off FB because of her constant 'I hate the English' statuses (I am English). I have a feeling if the boot was on the other foot and it was statuses from an English person about disliking Scottish people there would have been hell to pay from her.
MildredPuppy · 27/07/2021 21:24

@Wroxie I feel rather the same about these big estates built on the backs of slaves.

I do wonder how to square things like, say glasgow. My incredibly poor great great (not sure how many) grandfather was an ayrshire farm labourer and after his youngest 3 children starved one winter he went to the big city of glasgow to do work. I believe that the boom of the docks that created that work would have been to do with slave trade. So his other children lived in glashow slums and didnt starve.. I dont know how to repay that really. I dont have a thing to sell. I just exist because of it. I guess it has to be at a government level.

foxandbee · 27/07/2021 21:23

@Wroxie I think one of the problems you are up against here is that many English people, and to a lesser extent the rest of the UK, revere those who made/make their fortune on the backs of others. They vote them into Parliament. They turn out in their droves to see them married or buried.

Clydesider · 27/07/2021 21:19

It's prejudice rather than racism but, yes, you're right, OP. I think if myself as British; born in England, one parent English and one Scottish. I live in Scotland and the way English people ste treated and spoken about by some in Scotland is appalling. The Scottish part of me finds it shameful. This prejudice, among our own countrymen and women, is completely unacceptable.

foxandbee · 27/07/2021 21:18

@marmaladehound

It's not acceptable but it's been going on since as long as I can recall. I remember been on holiday with my parents age 7 and walking into a pub for lunch, as soon as other customers heard us, they all stopped talking in English abs started talking in Welsh. Hey ho! In my experience it's more common from the Welsh and french more than anywhere else. Never experienced it from the Irish though. But other than piss me off it doesn't affect my life in any other way. So it's not a prejudice worth giving much thought too! It's certainly not a prejudice comparable to others that are everywhere that really do impact peoples lives.
Eh? French people switch from speaking English to French when English speakers turn up?

Here's an idea, when you are on your hols in Welsh speaking parts of Wales or in France, greet people in their own language. Order your food in their language. It takes very little effort. If you have been visiting Welsh speaking parts of Wales since you were 7 on a regular basis, it's shameful that you haven't bothered to learn a few phrases. Or are you just judging the Welsh on one half remembered incident when you were 7?

Speaking your own language in your own country is not prejudice @marmaladehound

Livelovebehappy · 27/07/2021 21:17

I won’t apologise for what my ancestors did. It was a different era, with different expectations. People are obsessed with making us embarrassed to be who we are based on something that happened decades ago. It wasn’t done in my name, so I feel no shame about it.

Wroxie · 27/07/2021 21:17

@MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously I think a good place to start is where you can directly trace the ill-gotten money or property to its source.

Can you trace all the wealth in the world that was made off the backs of women? Probably not, so we probably have to take that one on the chin.

Can you trace wealth and valuables stolen from victims of the Holocaust? Yes, in many cases. So as I hope you agree it's good and important to right those wrongs and return what is possible to return and to in every case remove these things from the people who stole them.

Can you trace many fortunes and endowments and investments currently active in the UK directly back to the sale of enslaved humans? In many cases, yes. And if that is the case, how is that different than what was stolen in the Holocaust? is it just a matter of the number of years? What's the cut-off? If I have a Stradivarius stolen from a Jewish musician under my bed, do I just need to hold on to it until I'm sure the last Nazi is dead and then it's mine, no takesies-backsies? What if I manage to sell it and buy a house with the proceeds, is the house now mine? I would hope not.

So these are all obviously hypotheticals not requiring an answer, but the point is - just because it's complicated to right historical wrongs doesn't mean we shouldn't think about it and try to do it. Just because I can't do all the right things doesn't mean I should do none of the right things.

justasking111 · 27/07/2021 21:17

@Katefoster the North walians who consider themselves pure think fluent south walian speakers can't speak the language properly anyway. Only on the Lleyn is the language of heaven pure 🙄

justasking111 · 27/07/2021 21:14

@Katefoster

Are you in north wales? They hate anyone who dosent speak fluent welsh. I'm from South Wales and avoid going there tbh
Only in pockets of n Wales fortunately. We live a 30 minute drive from one pocket I make sure they realise we are locals not tourists 😂
TitchGreen · 27/07/2021 21:11

@Meraas I'll have to take your critisim of my atrocious spelling and grammar on board I suppose; would you like to discuss any of the points I made or are you happy to be a meme?

Is racism against the English acceptable?
SourAppleChew · 27/07/2021 21:08

There are about 4x more slaves currently in existence than were imported throughout the whole 400 years of the African slave trade. Seems odd that people aren't interested in tackling this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread