Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is racism against the English acceptable?

792 replies

BabyBearRus · 26/07/2021 23:58

We are currently on holiday in Wales and have just heard an altercation outside our holiday accommodation blasting the "bastard English who come to stay here". I'm shocked. I am half Welsh and half Irish, and spent much time in both countries. But also spent half my life in England. There has always been a jovial criticism of the English, e.g. during rugby internationals etc, but in recent years the tone has become more racist. I also find this resentful attitude towards the English amongst my Irish and Scottish friends. The English seem to be an acceptable people to hate. Surely this should be classed as racism? And, I'm saying this from a predominantly Welsh and Irish heritage. Yes, I am aware of the history of these isles, but when are we going to get over this? Truly baffled.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Lndnmummy · 27/07/2021 23:37

@MNHQ think we could do with a tidy in here

znaika · 27/07/2021 23:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

CounsellorTroi · 27/07/2021 23:17

@marmaladehound

It's not acceptable but it's been going on since as long as I can recall. I remember been on holiday with my parents age 7 and walking into a pub for lunch, as soon as other customers heard us, they all stopped talking in English abs started talking in Welsh. Hey ho! In my experience it's more common from the Welsh and french more than anywhere else. Never experienced it from the Irish though. But other than piss me off it doesn't affect my life in any other way. So it's not a prejudice worth giving much thought too! It's certainly not a prejudice comparable to others that are everywhere that really do impact peoples lives.
Are you saying that you go into pubs in France and they are all talking English, and switch to French as soon as they hear you?
SunscreenCentral · 27/07/2021 23:12

@SourAppleChew

Following on from my previous comment which was conveniently ignored, I don't understand why reparations for the non-enslaved descendants of slaves who died hundreds of years ago seems to be put ahead of liberating those currently enslaved.

It's almost like black slaves matter (more than other slaves).

This.
Lndnmummy · 27/07/2021 23:08

@HerrenaHarridan

English person here

It’s perfectly acceptable for other countries to mock us... we conquered half the fucking world and still haven’t given sovereignty back to anyone who didn’t force us

When the British museums are full of British artefacts and the Welsh aren’t under Westminster then we can talk about the poor oppressed English folks getting a mouthful in their second homes 🙄

Until then shut up and count your privileges

What she said
Skysblue · 27/07/2021 23:05

@HerrenaHarridan what a stupid and nasty message. And by the way Britain gave sovereignty back to the UAE despite eg Dubai asking Britain to stay. Don’t bother to reply I won’t be checking back.

Opaljewel · 27/07/2021 23:02

In any form*

Opaljewel · 27/07/2021 23:02

Racism is any form should not be tolerated. How can we expect it to be eradicated, if people think it's acceptable towards certain groups of people? Racism has no place in this world full stop. That includes if you're English and white. The laws have to protect us all.

Skysblue · 27/07/2021 23:02

Yanbu. There are large numbers of people in Wales and Scotland who are routinely racist to English people. And it isn’t ok.

enoughforme · 27/07/2021 22:58

@HerrenaHarridan

English person here

It’s perfectly acceptable for other countries to mock us... we conquered half the fucking world and still haven’t given sovereignty back to anyone who didn’t force us

When the British museums are full of British artefacts and the Welsh aren’t under Westminster then we can talk about the poor oppressed English folks getting a mouthful in their second homes 🙄

Until then shut up and count your privileges

Exactly this!!
HerrenaHarridan · 27/07/2021 22:50

English person here

It’s perfectly acceptable for other countries to mock us... we conquered half the fucking world and still haven’t given sovereignty back to anyone who didn’t force us

When the British museums are full of British artefacts and the Welsh aren’t under Westminster then we can talk about the poor oppressed English folks getting a mouthful in their second homes 🙄

Until then shut up and count your privileges

StormingNotNorming · 27/07/2021 22:42

The whole business becomes madness because most families have a mix of ancestry. I don't consider my own family very special but...

On my Dad's side they came the England in the late 1600s after a law change in France removed legal protection for Protestants and so Protestants started to be persecuted.

On my Mum's side they moved from Germany in 1920s to escape antisemetism.

It's hard to know if I'm meant to be 'the oppressor' or the oppressed Grin. I suspect most are similar to varying degrees.

Ralf302 · 27/07/2021 22:26

As an English person living in Scotland, I was repeatedly beaten up at school for being English, Constantly made fun of etc, My life was hell purely because I am English and living in Scotland. It's horrible and still affects me over a decade later.
I wouldn't call it racism though. Definitely prejudice.

foxandbee · 27/07/2021 22:18

But last night was uncalled for, to verbally attack an older woman on her own, on the basis of her nationality is simply wrong

I agree 100%.

This bitch is off to bed. Nos da!

Whaam · 27/07/2021 22:14

@BabyBearRus

Absolutely agree that the English have had a lot to answer for. As do many other nations, e.g. France, Spain, USA, Canada, Australia, to name a few. But when does it end? When do we reach a point where we can try to overcome the past and work towards a more harmonious future?

As previously mentioned, both sides of my family (Welsh & Irish) recall the misery of "English occupation" (a term both sides used). During the 70s and 80s, my Irish family living in London suffered racist abuse on a daily basis. There's a brilliant study called "Suspect Communities" which compares the racism experienced by the Irish during that period to the later Islamaphobia that occurred after 9/11 (but was prevalent in England before this). Racism and prejudice towards anyone is abhorrent.

And of course there are English people who I find extremely annoying, especially the arrogance of some holiday makers who prance around like they own the place. This quite rightly irks the locals. But I also have felt the same way about many people from other nations. Some people are complete dickheads regardless of their race or nationality.

But last night was uncalled for, to verbally attack an older woman on her own, on the basis of her nationality is simply wrong. All because she simply asked them not to park in front of her drive. Such prejudiced and threatening behaviour should not have to be tolerated by anyone. So, no, despite obviously being sympathetic to my Celtic history, I feel that the behaviour of the perpetrators was absolutely shameful.

For goodness sake, how can you blame an entire people for the sins of the past? Frankly, hatred perpetuates hatred and fear. Have we learnt nothing from history?

The way forward can be found at the ballot box and through education and civic duty at the community level.

But at which ballot box? The system in the UK isn't fair, and doesn't really represent NI, Wales and Scotland, so voices aren't really heard in parliament, @BabyBearRus. To create harmony, an overhaul of the UK system is needed, and there needs to be a full understanding (note that I say understanding and not justification) of why people in the other three nations feel grievances.

No, prejudice is not okay, but people are often angry and blame whoever or whatever they see as representing the thing that they are angry about. It's not right, but it's often human nature. If there was more actual listening in the UK then I really think things would be better. This isn't about the past (though some people who are ignorant might blame the past because they don't know any better). It's about the feeling of smaller nations of being ignored, disrespected, trodden on, used, or made to feel unimportant in a union that is supposed to respect each of the four nations as equals. Those feelings are legitimate although the prejudice brought about by those feelings is not. Address the legitimate resentment, though, and the prejudice will also be addressed. As it stands, nobody is listening.

TitchGreen · 27/07/2021 22:10

@Wroxie I wasn't trying to suggest your family had injustices specifically regarding the slave trade that they or you needs to address. I was more referring to you mentioned regarding idea of your mother stealing something, and I agree, if the same thing happened in my family, and I found out, I would either work to fix that, or turn my mother over to the police.
I was also thinking about you tracing your families historical injustices pre slave trade, because there will be some and fix those, but as you have stated, you can only tace back to 1830, you can't trace before then, so it is not reasonable to expect you to fix those. Even if you could trace before then, it is not reasonable to expect you to fix those either.
The people who needed to fix their Karma so to speak are dead. They've been dead for a while, it can't be fixed. To expect their descendants to fix the karma on their behalf is wrong in my opinion.

marmaladehound · 27/07/2021 22:07

@LizzieW1969

Sorry, I realise now that you didn’t mean that. The thought was so funny that I couldn’t resist commenting.

I have heard others say that people switch to Welsh. But it might help to learn some Welsh?

Well in my defence I was 7 and this was the 80's and not even many Welsh young people spoke Welsh then.

The irony of this is my father, who grew up in Shropshire, could speak Welsh.

I never forget a Welsh friend of mine coming to my parents house. Despite living in England and been my friend, she hated the English. I never told my father this. When she came over, my dad just started talking to her in Welsh... you should have seen her face! An English man speaking Welsh!

Whaam · 27/07/2021 22:06

@MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously

Whaam you can't really discuss in detail hundreds of years of history on a Mumsnet post. I would agree that the political system needs reform. Fptp can be unrepresentative for many people within the UK. Maybe some form of PR would be fairer And while I do agree with you that the poll tax was awful, I would equally say that Thatcher's govt didn't act in the best interests of working class English people either. Certainly I don't recall her doing much to benefit my working class English parents! Culloden again is something the English tend to get blamed for, but iirc many Scots fought with the British army. The aftermath was awful, but we are talking about the 1700s - punishments were harsh. Particularly for treason. The Highland clearances were not the sole fault of the English. Wasn't a lot of it to do with agricultural changes and Scottish landlords? That said, I agree that a union which isn't wanted by ordinary people in either nation, causes more problems than it solves. But the fact remains that Scotland was asked and you cannot keep asking the same question every couple of years until you get a different result. What about the people who don't like the new result and argue for yet another referendum?
You are, yet again, missing both points. The first one being that it is reductionist to reduce everything to class because it doesn't explain everything. Things are more nuanced than that. The second point is that, again, the complex and nuanced history of the relationships (unequal relationships) between the constituent nations have brought about resentment, and that resentment is legitimate. I suggest you read through the previous posts and have a look at the many, many examples given by people on here. And, again, I repeat, to bring about better relations between people in all four nations, it is necessary to have a genuine, open conversation where people's grievances are equally heard. Right now, there is none of that.

Your comment about Culloden totally misses the point. I suggest that you read through the thread again. Of course Scots were involved in Culloden, as Indians were involved in the oppression of other Indians during Indian colonisation, and Africans during the colonisation of African countries. It doesn't detract from what happened and the fall out of that, i.e. the loss of culture, language and way of life etc., that had an impact for generations.

You also miss the point about Thatcher, but that is again because you are reducing everything to class and seem intent on ignoring that countries even exist. Scotland is a nation, you know. It's a country, not a region of England.

Who was talking about the Highland clearances, as it wasn't me? They are not related to anything in this conversation.

Again, with regards to another referendum, you've ignored again the points made about Brexit or about changing opinion. In fact, yes, this is exactly how democracy works. When people change their mind then there can and should be another vote. In this particular case, Brexit is a pretty big game changer - i.e. during the independence referendum, Scots are told to vote against independence to stay in the EU, but two years later are forced out because the bigger nation in the union decides that it wants to leave. That's a pretty damn big change, so if the Scots want another vote, I reckon they should have it. You also say "every couple of years" - it has been seven years since the last referendum and will likely be at least three or four before the next one. A decade is not a "couple of years".

If people don't like the result and argue for a new referendum and the polls say they are a sizeable majority, well, then there would be another referendum.

Finally, @MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously, you can't discuss in detail hundreds of years of history on MN, but you can acknowledge it and avoid reducing all arguments to one or two events in history, as you have done. I really invite you to consider the nuances of all perspectives and not just the one, rigid perspective that you appear to have. Rigid perspectives are also what breed prejudice.

foxandbee · 27/07/2021 22:04

@LizzieW1969

Sorry, I realise now that you didn’t mean that. The thought was so funny that I couldn’t resist commenting.

I have heard others say that people switch to Welsh. But it might help to learn some Welsh?

Careful, I got a right earful for suggesting that!
marmaladehound · 27/07/2021 22:04

Foxndbee

I was in response to the OPs question about prejudice to the English. I was referring to my experience this prejudice was more common from the Welsh and French than from other nationalities such as the Irish or Scottish or any other for that matter.

LizzieW1969 · 27/07/2021 21:56

Sorry, I realise now that you didn’t mean that. The thought was so funny that I couldn’t resist commenting.

I have heard others say that people switch to Welsh. But it might help to learn some Welsh?

Wroxie · 27/07/2021 21:56

@BrozTito even my kid's history GCSE materials disagree with you. It was complicated, but everyone knew slavery was a losing game at that point. Less money was being made all the time, waged labour was actually becoming more profitable than ever and more profitable than slave labour in many cases, and it would have been a bad look to be the last ones involved instead of investing in manufacturing or using ships for other purpose, hell, even the USA pulled out of the slave trade in 1808 (they didn't need any more, they had enough). I wonder why you didn't mention that?

LizzieW1969 · 27/07/2021 21:53

Eh? French people switch from speaking English to French when English speakers turn up?

I don’t believe that either lol. I studied French and spent a year in France as part of my degree. No, they would have been speaking French the whole time, same as we speak English all the time in this country. (There are, shock horror!, a lot of French people who don’t even speak English. Like a lot of English people don’t speak French. Grin)

Although when I was in France, I didn’t test out whether they had been speaking English, as I was there to improve my French.

foxandbee · 27/07/2021 21:53

@marmaladehound

Foxandbee

Well you clearly can't read very well. I did not say I was in France, I was in Wales. The people in the pub were speaking English ( their choice to do so!) and switched to Welsh once they heard the English!

Oh and for the record between myself and my husband we speak 8 languages so can pretty much travel to many parts of the world and converse in the language of the country we are in. Sorry does that ruin your over generalisation of the ignorant English?

But maybe if you actually read posts and get of your high horse been a total bitch to people ( many of your posts here!) you would never have needed to make this patronising comment in the first place.

@marmaladehound you said:

It's not acceptable but it's been going on since as long as I can recall. I remember been on holiday with my parents age 7 and walking into a pub for lunch, as soon as other customers heard us, they all stopped talking in English abs started talking in Welsh. Hey ho! In my experience it's more common from the Welsh and french more than anywhere else

Which led more than one poster to think you were talking about French people switching from English to French. If you didn't mean that, what did you mean by it's more common from the Welsh and French? What is more common?

Wroxie · 27/07/2021 21:49

@TitchGreen "Can you advise me what you are doing to actively find and fix the injustices your family has commited? However small they are?"

I can only trace my family (at least the family I know) back to about the 1830s. They lived in slavery, and then as sharecroppers (basically indentured servitude) until the late 1960s. My mother was an only child and was able to go to college. Try as I might, I can't find any injustices here that I need to address. If I did - if I found out that my mother had stolen from someone and then passed that money or that item to me then yes I would return it. Wouldn't you?
But in my case, I would think the people who need to fix their karma, so to speak, are those who owned my grandparents and kept them in indentured servitude. Here's the weird thing. I KNOW THE DESCENDANTS OF THESE PEOPLE. I went to school with some of them. I share a name with them. This isn't hypothetical to me. They still lived in a big nice house where my grandmother was a maid to their grandmother in the 1940s which overlooked fields where her grandmother worked as a chattel slave.

So I'll ask, nicely, to be let off the hook for fixing generational errors. Maybe ask my children in a few years once they've accrued a bit more distance.