Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is racism against the English acceptable?

792 replies

BabyBearRus · 26/07/2021 23:58

We are currently on holiday in Wales and have just heard an altercation outside our holiday accommodation blasting the "bastard English who come to stay here". I'm shocked. I am half Welsh and half Irish, and spent much time in both countries. But also spent half my life in England. There has always been a jovial criticism of the English, e.g. during rugby internationals etc, but in recent years the tone has become more racist. I also find this resentful attitude towards the English amongst my Irish and Scottish friends. The English seem to be an acceptable people to hate. Surely this should be classed as racism? And, I'm saying this from a predominantly Welsh and Irish heritage. Yes, I am aware of the history of these isles, but when are we going to get over this? Truly baffled.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TableFlowerss · 28/07/2021 07:14

**I think it's pretty offensive to state that the priority around slavery should be giving money to free people who were never themselves enslaved instead of helping those who are currently enslaved.

Sadly I think a lot of it comes down to the stereotypical image of the black slave in the cotton field rather than the Eastern European sex slave or the Filipino maid being abused by Arabs, so people ignore the present and focus on what happened hundreds of years ago.

The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade Database estimates that 12.5 million slaves were shipped from Africa to the New World. There are estimated to be 40 million slaves currently in the world today. Why are so many people seemingly more interested in getting their monetary compensation than fighting actual slavery I wonder**

Very true.

I was thinking about this the other day after watching a documentary about sex trafficking and rife if it.

Got me thinking about how many people are enslaved right now yet it’s hardly mentioned.

SourAppleChew · 28/07/2021 05:36

@DewDew83

Not sure why I said 'other countries' in my last post. If the UK wants to make a concerted effort to end the international slave trade, great, but unless it makes a converted effort to do so, it doesn't get to use the issue as an excuse for not tackling other injustices..
I can see how my comment does look a bit like whataboutery in an almost WATM manner. I guess it's just that these discussions almost make it sound like the slave trade is over, and there is usually almost zero discussion around current slavery aside from occasional passing reference to trafficked women - in complete contrast to the frequent discussion of the African slave trade from several centuries ago. I don't mean zero mention in these threads, because that's not the focus here, but just zero mention in general.

I certainly don't think one issue cancels out the other and probs wouldn't have even made the comment if modern was discussed even remotely as much as historic slavery.

stairway · 28/07/2021 04:24

I’ve done a fair amount of travelling and living abroad and from my experience everyone does not hate the English. I’ve only seen that really expressed here.

DewDew83 · 28/07/2021 04:02

Not sure why I said 'other countries' in my last post. If the UK wants to make a concerted effort to end the international slave trade, great, but unless it makes a converted effort to do so, it doesn't get to use the issue as an excuse for not tackling other injustices..

DewDew83 · 28/07/2021 03:59

I think it's pretty offensive to state that the priority around slavery should be giving money to free people who were never themselves enslaved instead of helping those who are currently enslaved.
Your argument on this reminds me of the (generally right wing) argument that we should stop sending foreign aid while there are still homeless or impoverished people in this country. It would be a halfway reasonable argument if the same people that made it weren't also for slashing the welfare state and instead advanced policies that further marginalize the impoverished.

If other countries want to make and fund a concerted effort to abolish modern day slavery, great. But while that isn't happening it's not a good excuse to say 'well, we can't do X Y and Z until we solve this other problem that we are taking little or no steps to solve '.

SourAppleChew · 28/07/2021 01:16

@foxandbee

Christ *@TitchGreen and @SourAppleChew*. Are you having a competition to see who can be the most offensive?
I think it's pretty offensive to state that the priority around slavery should be giving money to free people who were never themselves enslaved instead of helping those who are currently enslaved.

Sadly I think a lot of it comes down to the stereotypical image of the black slave in the cotton field rather than the Eastern European sex slave or the Filipino maid being abused by Arabs, so people ignore the present and focus on what happened hundreds of years ago.

The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade Database estimates that 12.5 million slaves were shipped from Africa to the New World. There are estimated to be 40 million slaves currently in the world today. Why are so many people seemingly more interested in getting their monetary compensation than fighting actual slavery I wonder? 🤔

TableFlowerss · 28/07/2021 00:47

is NOT going to HELP bridge the gap I mean

Fucking auto correct 🤣

DeRigueurMortis · 28/07/2021 00:46

To answer the original question, no I don't think you can call it racism, but it is xenophobic and prejudicial behaviour.

I'm Welsh married to a Scot, living in England where our children were born.

I absolutely find the intolerance towards the English very offensive.

Both DH and I have both witnessed in our respective home nations, really quite awful behaviour when visiting family.

It has to be said it happens when our children speak first and the assumption is the whole family is English.

The U-turn when either DH or myself speak as a follow up is often quite remarkable.

It makes me really sad if I'm honest.

I want the children to feel relaxed and happy in the nations where DH and I were born. I want them to enjoy visiting those places and "feel/belong" to that part of their heritage.

However, we've witness first hand that the situation is getting worse as time goes on.

I fully appreciate the pressures second home ownership and AirB&B can put on a community and my relatives in Wales have certainly been subject to this.

It is damaging on so many levels - raising house prices beyond local reach, reducing trade for local hoteliers/B&B owners, leaving villages decimated out of season and making some places undesirable to live because it's impossible to function normally when next door to a holiday home where 2am noises booze laden hot tub sessions happen every night and you need to put the children to bed/get up for work.

This absolutely needs clamping down on big time.

All that said you can't blame "the English" such as my children for wrongs done hundreds of years ago. Or for policies in Westminster.

It has sadly imho become socially acceptable to exhibit extremely prejudicial behaviour towards the English and no, I don't think it's acceptable.

TableFlowerss · 28/07/2021 00:46

is NOT going to bridge the gap I mean

TableFlowerss · 28/07/2021 00:45

I cringe myself at some of the British stereotypes like getting so drunk and making a tit of themselves abroad and football hooligans etc

But the whole hating the British now (more precisely the English…. Bizzare because it was a joint effort but hey ho) because of the Empire is just ridiculous.

Yes people suffered tremendously and it is heartbreaking, but to hate an average English person here and now and blame them is wrong.

No one living here now, committed any atrocities. Our ancestors did but we can’t be tarnished with the same brush. We weren’t born. We didn’t exist.

We just happened to be born British. It wasn’t choice. Some would say lucky others would say unlucky.

To hate people purely because of where they were born and to blame them for something that happened before they existed is terrible.

Every time there’s a thread like this, these comments are always thrown in about the wrongs that Britain did in the past (and yes they absolutely did.)

You can feel the resentment build in the posts and the blame that is then placed on the English etc and we are told this is why we are hated. But remember, it wasn’t us, the people that are hated here and now.

To be honest, people become de-sensitised to it, when they are blamed for something they didn’t do. So the sympathy that they all have had starts to wane and that’s not a great situation either.

We all need to learn from the past and try to create a better future for those whose ancestors were wronged but hating the English for simply being English is going to help bridge that gap.

BabyBearRus · 28/07/2021 00:33

"Hitler committed much atrocity, but we don't all think it's acceptable to hate the Germans. We make a distinction between the nazi government and the decisions they made, and 'germany' and its current people

Why can't we accept that the English and British governments and some of their people committed bad acts in the past, but that the 'english' and 'british' now are different."

I agree, and I'm not even English. And we are in a far better position today to bring about change. Education, more political engagement, and lobbying for a better, more inclusive future for everyone, is imo achievable.

OP posts:
YeyItsTheSummer · 28/07/2021 00:25

I'm English. I hate that everyone hates the English. I'm British. I hate that much of the world hates the Brits. I am aware of the wrongs committed by my ancestors, but I have done nothing wrong. Yet I always am made to feel guilty for the colour of my skin and where I'm from, for being privileged (which I'm not), and for what my ancestors did.

Hitler committed much atrocity, but we don't all think it's acceptable to hate the Germans. We make a distinction between the nazi government and the decisions they made, and 'germany' and its current people

Why can't we accept that the English and British governments and some of their people committed bad acts in the past, but that the 'english' and 'british' now are different.

I am not a racist. I have never done anything to harm anyone. I am sick of being made to feel guilty for being white British and not being able to fly my flag and feel proud of my nation, like every other country can, because of the connotations

Some Brits and English are nice, don't tar us all with the same brush.and make us feel guilty for things that have nothing to do with us and are from the past.

EmeraldShamrock · 28/07/2021 00:23

A lot of Welsh communities are sick of rich people from England buying up all the houses for their second homes, making their local areas totally unaffordable.
This happens all over Europe and many parts of the world.
The amount of Airbnb's holiday homes around coastal towns in Ireland and that is without the Canadian cuckoo funds buying up housing estates and apartments blocks in Dublin as they're built leaving people with no place to live.
Not saying we can't be angry about it.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 28/07/2021 00:19

[quote TableFlowerss]@thedancingbear
@SchrodingersImmigrant

Two of the most bigoted posters on this thread. Oh the irony……[/quote]
Your right to think that. I was just pointing out that the post was exactly the shit why people are not fans of English 🤷🏻

BabyBearRus · 28/07/2021 00:17

Rno3gfr as previously mentioned, many of the second homes in the area are owned by locals who rent them out as holiday lets. The woman in question inherited the house. Been in her family for three generations. She intends to permanently move there in a couple of years.

Personally, the area has thrived in recent years due to the holiday industry with many of the locals making a living from tourism. I'm not saying that is right, but until the government invests more money into the area, this is the reality.

Frankly, I loved it here years ago when it was a sleepy village with no amenities, but I also appreciate that tourism is the life blood of the village.

Incidentally, I found out today that the perpetrators are not locals, but holidaymakers from a different area of Wales renting a house nearby.

OP posts:
TableFlowerss · 28/07/2021 00:10

@thedancingbear
@SchrodingersImmigrant

Two of the most bigoted posters on this thread. Oh the irony……

TableFlowerss · 28/07/2021 00:06

@SchrodingersImmigrant

*Because at last the English are starting to show some independence. We chose not to be part of a homologous structure in Europe and instead forge ahead shedding ourselves of the bureaucratic encumbrances Europe entails. Sadly not all our nations agreed. The French don't like us cos we saved their sorry asses in two world wars and they've never got over it!*

Just want to point out, that this is why most of Europe waa cheering for Italy... Why English are not particularly liked. Oh and you couldn't save anyone's arses without the others. Also example of the weird English ww2 fetish which is also known abroad. And if it's weird...

**Yep. I think the English need to take a long, hard look at why they are pretty much universally disliked across the world.

Hint - it's not jealousy as you are manifestly a country and a nation on the wane**

Where are you from then?

Rno3gfr · 28/07/2021 00:04

“She spends half the year at her property”

It’s go nothing to do with them being English and everything to do with that ^^

A lot of Welsh communities are sick of rich people from England buying up all the houses for their second homes, making their local areas totally unaffordable.

BabyBearRus · 28/07/2021 00:04

Ultimately, it's about common decency and respect towards another human being. I seriously can't understand how anyone can condone any form of abusive and prejudiced behaviour against another human being.

OP posts:
Greydove28 · 28/07/2021 00:00

@WorraLiberty

Yes, the whataboutery began pretty quickly.

So far we have

Black people
American people
Russian people

That's not what the OP is about.

Whataboutery 🤣 So funny. I do love mumsnet terms.

I agree, its always a race to the bottom. God forbid people reply and deal with what the OP is complaining about. Theres always something much far worse and making them feel bad for posting when this is what mumsnet is for!

BabyBearRus · 27/07/2021 23:58

"HerrenaHarridan

English person here

It’s perfectly acceptable for other countries to mock us... we conquered half the fucking world and still haven’t given sovereignty back to anyone who didn’t force us

When the British museums are full of British artefacts and the Welsh aren’t under Westminster then we can talk about the poor oppressed English folks getting a mouthful in their second homes 🙄

Until then shut up and count your privileges"

What a peculiar and nasty message. Frankly, to sanction one kind of prejudice against a particular people can only lead down a very slippery slope to sanctioning other racist or prejudiced behaviour against other races or nationalities that supposedly "deserve," it.

So, if we had a homosexual English man being subjected to prejudice based on his sexuality and nationality, is this then acceptable? Does the abuse of one aspect of his makeup warrant outrage, while the other does not?

Come on people, prejudice is prejudice and is morally reprehensible.

OP posts:
stayathomer · 27/07/2021 23:51

Theres a lot of extreme delusionalism and one sidedness on this thread. Almost head in the sand. The english fans booed when the other team got the ball throughout the euros this year, and during the national anthems. The Italians made jokes, waved and smiled at the opposition throughout. It's not okay people cheered, but the average person wouldn't act quite as shocked as others are. As for people talking about history, in particular Germany, other countries only see that there is so much pride around countries being taken over, whereas Germany has always shown to want to repent. I know this is over simplifying things and nobody deserves to have people talk like that about them.

Whaam · 27/07/2021 23:50

@MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously

Whaam. I'm not missing your points, I just don't agree with them. I think class is the more important factor and it's a mistake to view events primarily through a nation perspective, since poor English people were/are not treated any better by the ruling elite than poor Welsh, Scots or Irish people. I don't dispute that there are historic grievances, some more fair than others, but these should be aimed at the establishment, not the ordinary people on the receiving end of abuse, who didn't actually do anything to deserve it! They are just normal people going about their business.Hating someone on account of their nationality is just plain wrong.

As for equality between the nations - that's purely a numbers game. If there are 6 million people in Scotland and 55 million in England, then they aren't going to be equally weighted politically. This is true for things like Brexit. Scotland might have wanted to remain in the EU but it doesn't meet the criteria for independent membership and is part of a union where the majority of people voted to leave. It can't have what it wants because it doesn't have a big enough population to get the deciding vote. It's unfortunate for those who want a different outcome but that's the nature of democracy - majority decides.

Where equality really matters is in housing, health, education and opportunities. Each devolved nation is responsible for some of this itself. Scotland hasn't been an innocent bystander in its own history, forced to collude in its own oppression - much of its issues are caused by decisions taken in Scotland by Scottish people.

I would agree though that public funded organisations that are supposed to represent all the nations of the UK ought to be less SE England centric and recognise that there are different needs in Scotland, Wales and NI which should be served fairly. I'm thinking of institutions like the BBC which was mentioned up thread, but this could apply to the UK government, which does behave as if no one lives outside of London.

I don't really disagree that if Scotland wants to leave the union it should be able to. But it's not realistic to have a vote every 10 years. The referendum was supposed to be 'once in a generation'. Politicians can't keep stirring the pot and campaigning until they get a result they like. It's destabilising imo and negates any value that a vote has. It's not like it can be easily undone if in a few years the majority indicate in polls that they've changed their minds.

@MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously I give up. If you can't see how you are missing what I'm saying, there's no point in talking. And you are missing it, not disagreeing with it. Or at least, you don't appear to understand what you think you are disagreeing with. But never mind.
OuiOuiKitty · 27/07/2021 23:49

For goodness sake, how can you blame an entire people for the sins of the past? Frankly, hatred perpetuates hatred and fear. Have we learnt nothing from history?

Mmm part of the problem for me is that it isn't just sins of the past is it? How many people considered NI when they voted for Brexit? How much scorn was poured on ROI for standing up and saying hold up there is an international peace treaty between two countries to be considered here? We were branded as being difficult and being top big for our boots for giving more of a shit about NI than the UK ever did in the Brexit talks. I know this wasn't all English people but you can bet the majority of it was. This is just one thing I can mention, it is late so won't go into more.

I'm not saying 'racism' or xenophobia is acceptable but I'm not going to sit here and pretend that all that has happened was centuries ago and should be 'left in the past' either. NI isn't in the past, the effects of Brexit will be felt in NI for a long time to come.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 27/07/2021 23:48

Whaam. I'm not missing your points, I just don't agree with them. I think class is the more important factor and it's a mistake to view events primarily through a nation perspective, since poor English people were/are not treated any better by the ruling elite than poor Welsh, Scots or Irish people. I don't dispute that there are historic grievances, some more fair than others, but these should be aimed at the establishment, not the ordinary people on the receiving end of abuse, who didn't actually do anything to deserve it! They are just normal people going about their business.Hating someone on account of their nationality is just plain wrong.

As for equality between the nations - that's purely a numbers game. If there are 6 million people in Scotland and 55 million in England, then they aren't going to be equally weighted politically. This is true for things like Brexit. Scotland might have wanted to remain in the EU but it doesn't meet the criteria for independent membership and is part of a union where the majority of people voted to leave. It can't have what it wants because it doesn't have a big enough population to get the deciding vote. It's unfortunate for those who want a different outcome but that's the nature of democracy - majority decides.

Where equality really matters is in housing, health, education and opportunities. Each devolved nation is responsible for some of this itself. Scotland hasn't been an innocent bystander in its own history, forced to collude in its own oppression - much of its issues are caused by decisions taken in Scotland by Scottish people.

I would agree though that public funded organisations that are supposed to represent all the nations of the UK ought to be less SE England centric and recognise that there are different needs in Scotland, Wales and NI which should be served fairly. I'm thinking of institutions like the BBC which was mentioned up thread, but this could apply to the UK government, which does behave as if no one lives outside of London.

I don't really disagree that if Scotland wants to leave the union it should be able to. But it's not realistic to have a vote every 10 years. The referendum was supposed to be 'once in a generation'. Politicians can't keep stirring the pot and campaigning until they get a result they like. It's destabilising imo and negates any value that a vote has. It's not like it can be easily undone if in a few years the majority indicate in polls that they've changed their minds.

Swipe left for the next trending thread