Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is racism against the English acceptable?

792 replies

BabyBearRus · 26/07/2021 23:58

We are currently on holiday in Wales and have just heard an altercation outside our holiday accommodation blasting the "bastard English who come to stay here". I'm shocked. I am half Welsh and half Irish, and spent much time in both countries. But also spent half my life in England. There has always been a jovial criticism of the English, e.g. during rugby internationals etc, but in recent years the tone has become more racist. I also find this resentful attitude towards the English amongst my Irish and Scottish friends. The English seem to be an acceptable people to hate. Surely this should be classed as racism? And, I'm saying this from a predominantly Welsh and Irish heritage. Yes, I am aware of the history of these isles, but when are we going to get over this? Truly baffled.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
HereticFanjo · 28/07/2021 14:03

@stayathomer

Theres a lot of extreme delusionalism and one sidedness on this thread. Almost head in the sand. The english fans booed when the other team got the ball throughout the euros this year, and during the national anthems. The Italians made jokes, waved and smiled at the opposition throughout. It's not okay people cheered, but the average person wouldn't act quite as shocked as others are. As for people talking about history, in particular Germany, other countries only see that there is so much pride around countries being taken over, whereas Germany has always shown to want to repent. I know this is over simplifying things and nobody deserves to have people talk like that about them.
Agreed
HereticFanjo · 28/07/2021 14:02

@OuiOuiKitty

For goodness sake, how can you blame an entire people for the sins of the past? Frankly, hatred perpetuates hatred and fear. Have we learnt nothing from history?

Mmm part of the problem for me is that it isn't just sins of the past is it? How many people considered NI when they voted for Brexit? How much scorn was poured on ROI for standing up and saying hold up there is an international peace treaty between two countries to be considered here? We were branded as being difficult and being top big for our boots for giving more of a shit about NI than the UK ever did in the Brexit talks. I know this wasn't all English people but you can bet the majority of it was. This is just one thing I can mention, it is late so won't go into more.

I'm not saying 'racism' or xenophobia is acceptable but I'm not going to sit here and pretend that all that has happened was centuries ago and should be 'left in the past' either. NI isn't in the past, the effects of Brexit will be felt in NI for a long time to come.

Agreed
HereticFanjo · 28/07/2021 13:56

I think sometimes the way history is taught in Britain is through an English lens, not a British one. It covers the harm that has been done to other nations, not just overseas but also within the UK. There is a real lack of understanding of England's past and the scars left.

An English man once made a 'joke' to my Irish friend about the Famine. The Famine was like the Irish Holocaust. When she pointed this out he got all offended and somehow became the victim - classic woke bro, you know the type. The point is there is a deep, deep resentment historically towards the English and English people often are unaware of this, in the same way that some Americans automatically see themselves as 'the good guys' and avoid any self-reflection. They are unwilling to examine their own past or current actions through any lens but their own position as 'good guy'.

Obviously individuals now are not responsible for past atrocities but the scars of those atrocities run deep and have been passed down through generations, often subconsciously. It is prejudice and like any prejudice it's useful to look at where it comes from to challenge it.

Topia · 28/07/2021 13:33

Wherever you go you’ll experience bigots & xenophobes, & tolerance & compassion in equal measure. How people manifest themselves says so much more about them as a person than it does about their nationality. You get nice people & nasty people all over the place - and whether they consider themselves English or Welsh makes absolutely no difference whatsoever. What you experience is their character. Everyone has a choice about how they behave; some people are just unpleasant & if they weren’t being xenophobic it would be something else. Whereas others are accepting & as intelligent & kind.

You can’t change it. Ignore the bad eggs & see them for what they are.

HerrenaHarridan · 28/07/2021 13:32

Fuck... other English people are embarrassing

Some of the comments here... stop fantasising about being oppressed and spend some time learning about the broken backs your privileged existence was built on.

Top tip... you can have experienced suffering in your life and still be privileged

I don’t hate anyone for where they were born, it’s the butchers flag waving idiots and those trying to centre their privileged white arses every time that get my ire... if you’re going to wave that disgraceful flag and pretend you don’t understand that it’s recognised round the world as a symbol of oppression and terror then i have nothing to say to you

mbosnz · 28/07/2021 13:14

While I agree that fighting against the tyranny of modern slavery should very much be a focus, as I understand it, there is increasingly less protection for the victims, if and when found, in the UK, which of course, plays right into the slavers' hands? Re immigration policy?

Mia85 · 28/07/2021 13:01

@Meraas

How is it racism, MrsHunt? What id your legal definition?
I would guess the defintion of 'race' in the Equality Act 2010 's9(1)Race includes—(a)colour; (b)nationality; (c)ethnic or national origins.'

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/9

SorryWoman · 28/07/2021 13:00

Judging by the replies on here, it's a good job the vast majority of immigration to the UK heads to England and the south east in particular. All this "wales for welsh people" sounds a bit brexity

justasking111 · 28/07/2021 12:50

If you want affordable homes in North Wales. Then the Welsh government needs to compulsory purchase farming land then hand it over to say watkin jones, anwyl construction etc. And build.

A farmer in Conwy got planning for three plots on part of one field it was auctioned off and went for 280k per plot.

We need the old WDA back to buy land at farm prices then grant planning.

I'm not blaming the farmer for making nearly a million if that's the way the system is set up

justasking111 · 28/07/2021 12:42

@Rno3gfr

“She spends half the year at her property”

It’s go nothing to do with them being English and everything to do with that ^^

A lot of Welsh communities are sick of rich people from England buying up all the houses for their second homes, making their local areas totally unaffordable.

Then I suggest you get the planning in your councils to address this problem
Meraas · 28/07/2021 12:41

How is it racism, MrsHunt? What id your legal definition?

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 28/07/2021 12:35

It is racism though, as legally defined.

Going down the route of saying that some kinds of racism is okay, is never going to end well

Delphinia · 28/07/2021 11:24

If you hate anyone because of where they were born, you’re a fucking disgrace
This. It makes you a nasty little bigot.

Luna2021 · 28/07/2021 10:36

Let's not compare this to actual racism. Please.

Firstly, it's xenophobia not racism.

Etulosba · 28/07/2021 10:29

It’s perfectly acceptable for other countries to mock us... we conquered half the fucking world and still haven’t given sovereignty back to anyone who didn’t force us

That was Britain, not England. Uncomfortable as it may be, the other UK counties are complicit.

Add to that, many, possibly most, foreigners make no distinction between English, Welsh or Scottish. They are all English. England is Britain to them.

LINABE · 28/07/2021 10:19

@FloconDeNeige

This thread is a dog-whistle to the xenophobes, as we can see.

If you hate anyone because of where they were born, you’re a fucking disgrace.

Great post.
CounsellorTroi · 28/07/2021 10:16

@igelkott2021

A lot of Welsh communities are sick of rich people from England buying up all the houses for their second homes, making their local areas totally unaffordable

That is happening everywhere: Cornwall, Devon, Lakes, Norfolk.

Salcombe is the latest place to try to stop second home ownership and it is categorically not in Wales.

There’s an extra dimension in Wales though, the Welsh language. My roots are in rural west Wales and as a Welsh speaker it saddens me how much less Welsh is spoken there now than there was when I was a child.
LINABE · 28/07/2021 10:14

@znaika

It is xenophobia, and it takes no account of class so is definitely not kicking up. There seems to be some deluded and ignorant view that English people were all living in Downton Abbey when the reality is their villages were being destroyed too ( still are by second home owners) and their kids sliced up by heavy machinery and shoved up chimneys or in a workhouse. There are plenty of Scottish and Welsh landowners and slavers but of course blame some English guy who came from impoverished peasants who were exploited by the industrial revolution.

It's a curious kind of selectiveness. .

This
igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 10:11

We aren't responsible for the actions of our ancestors

or or the actions of other people who happen to live in the same country as we do, as many were at pains to point out on the England fans thread.

Although if people really do think that everyone who lives, or has ever lived in a certain country all act and think the same way, then work needs to be done on education systems.

igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 10:09

and/or your countryfolk wreck their country with your second homes and remote governing

???

igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 10:08

A lot of Welsh communities are sick of rich people from England buying up all the houses for their second homes, making their local areas totally unaffordable

That is happening everywhere: Cornwall, Devon, Lakes, Norfolk.

Salcombe is the latest place to try to stop second home ownership and it is categorically not in Wales.

LINABE · 28/07/2021 10:05

@JaniieJones

'Well, lot's of countries have problems with the English, and its not like theres no basis for it. No excuse to be personally rude to people, but when your ancestors killed and subjugated theirs, and/or your countryfolk wreck their country with your second homes and remote governing......it's not going to go away.'

Change 'English' for 'black, 'or 'Muslim' and you might just might see how xenophobic and offensive your comments are. You cannot generalise and attack an entire nature or race. It really is shocking that hating Engkis peope is so widespread.

We aren't responsible for the actions of our ancestors.

This for sure.
SomeKindOfFloppyWeirdo · 28/07/2021 10:01

@foxandbee

I think it is possible to believe that we as a society need to recognise the damage done by historical slavery that still has an impact today and care about modern slavery. We can and should address both of these issues. The two are not mutually exclusive.
Exactly this.

Also I’m sure @TableFlowerss and @SourAppleChew are both aware that modern slavery is illegal and punishable by law? There are even reporting systems if you suspect a car wash/nail salon/“massage” clinic/factory etc is trafficking workers.
You can even report online if you notice something, here
www.modernslaveryhelpline.org/

Historical slavery was not illegal, with no “protections” (in the sense that slave owners could be arrested and imprisoned) for people forced into slavery. I would think people would know this, and therefore know it’s not a normal comparison to make, but mumsnet is always full of surprises Smile

(To be clear - both are despicable practices. Modern slavery needs to be abolished. Thankfully, and differently to the past, there are systems in many countries to crack down on and eliminate modern slavery.)

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 28/07/2021 09:22

The point about these issues being ancient history: they're really not. A PP made an excellent point about Northern Ireland. The structural racism people experience today is a hangover from that history. Its effects are still being felt today; they are embedded within the very fabric of our society. It's possible to recognise and address that issue without descending into self-flagellating apologism. Nationality is an accident of birth. We have nothing to be either proud or ashamed of in our heritage.

But IME these threads tend to become very polarized and lacking in nuance. This one alone is a prime example of the kind of reasons why Reni Eddo-Lodge wrote ^Why I'm no Longer Talking to White People about Race'.

Also about the supposed 'whataboutery', it's hardly possible to put a post up on this site about 'racism', which isn't actually racism, and then expect people not to talk about actual racism.

foxandbee · 28/07/2021 07:46

I think it is possible to believe that we as a society need to recognise the damage done by historical slavery that still has an impact today and care about modern slavery. We can and should address both of these issues. The two are not mutually exclusive.