Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is racism against the English acceptable?

792 replies

BabyBearRus · 26/07/2021 23:58

We are currently on holiday in Wales and have just heard an altercation outside our holiday accommodation blasting the "bastard English who come to stay here". I'm shocked. I am half Welsh and half Irish, and spent much time in both countries. But also spent half my life in England. There has always been a jovial criticism of the English, e.g. during rugby internationals etc, but in recent years the tone has become more racist. I also find this resentful attitude towards the English amongst my Irish and Scottish friends. The English seem to be an acceptable people to hate. Surely this should be classed as racism? And, I'm saying this from a predominantly Welsh and Irish heritage. Yes, I am aware of the history of these isles, but when are we going to get over this? Truly baffled.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SueSaid · 28/07/2021 19:43

@mbosnz

I'm sure you don't think you need 'dots joining'.

When I'm talking about NZ history, which I was clearly alluding to, it's fairly obvious, if you have any idea about British Empire History, that I was talking about the British. If you have any clue or less of a chip on the post Colonialist shoulder. . . although the only time I said 'they' was alluding to New Zealand/ers, and most particularly Tangata Whenua.

Yes, talk about the British colonisation all you like, we all find history interesting.

My point is when you say 'when it comes to colonised countries and people, they kinda take it personal' you are suggesting 'They' ie the English or the British as if they are, again, one homogenous mass. These folk you chat to who 'take it personally' don't represent all the English, you do know that right?

Much as say any negative attitudes I've witnessed from people from NZ I worked with years ago don't represent all those from NZ. It is people not nationalities or races.

I can't believe some people still don't get this.

whatthejiggeries · 28/07/2021 19:35

Actually the Welsh and Scots are a different race to the English (aside from the Cornish who are also Celts. So it is racist

mbosnz · 28/07/2021 19:29

I'm sure you don't think you need 'dots joining'.

When I'm talking about NZ history, which I was clearly alluding to, it's fairly obvious, if you have any idea about British Empire History, that I was talking about the British. If you have any clue or less of a chip on the post Colonialist shoulder. . . although the only time I said 'they' was alluding to New Zealand/ers, and most particularly Tangata Whenua.

SueSaid · 28/07/2021 19:22

@mbosnz

Good Grief. I can't be bothered to try and join the dots any closer for you. I'm guessing wilful ignorance at this point. So useful.
I don't need patronising thanks or 'dots joining'.

I don't doubt some people need your expertise re colonisation attitudes. It isn't always 'They' or The English' though is it? It is some people. Do you talk about other nationalities or races in such sweeping generalisations. 'The Asians' perhaps?

mbosnz · 28/07/2021 19:13

Good Grief. I can't be bothered to try and join the dots any closer for you. I'm guessing wilful ignorance at this point. So useful.

SueSaid · 28/07/2021 19:11

'When it comes to colonised countries and people, they kinda take it personal, when dealing with those who represent the colonisers of their country - especially when they are attempting to deal with the fallout of colonisation.'

Who do, 'The English'? Jesus. Grin

mbosnz · 28/07/2021 19:08

@JaniieJones

'It's this kind of contradictory attitude that can perhaps influence people in other countries attitudes towards 'The English/British'.

Nope, it's the kind of 'contradictory attitude' that you get with people of any nationality or any skin colour. It isn't exclusive to 'The English' 🙄.

When it comes to colonised countries and people, they kinda take it personal, when dealing with those who represent the colonisers of their country - especially when they are attempting to deal with the fallout of colonisation.
EmeraldShamrock · 28/07/2021 18:54

and what about the 44% of NI that voted Leave? This is not the thread clearly with the DUP's tongue up Boris's arse while supporting Brexit influenced the protestant vote.
That's quite a substantial proportion - they can't all have been English? Did they not "consider NI" (where they live?).
They generally think they're English more than the actual English, they adore the empire and the Queen with passion.
But no they're British not English.

SueSaid · 28/07/2021 18:51

'It's this kind of contradictory attitude that can perhaps influence people in other countries attitudes towards 'The English/British'.

Nope, it's the kind of 'contradictory attitude' that you get with people of any nationality or any skin colour. It isn't exclusive to 'The English' 🙄.

OuiOuiKitty · 28/07/2021 18:42

and what about the 44% of NI that voted Leave? That's quite a substantial proportion - they can't all have been English? Did they not "consider NI" (where they live?).

I'm not just talking about Brexit though. I'm talking about the reaction after the vote was done. The looking down on other nations for daring to raise an issue, the who the fuck do they think they are attitude. Like the looking down on european countries that was done when scientists said let's pause az whilst we investigate the clotting issue. There were articles about the spiteful EU, there were threads on here feeling sorry for the scientists at Oxford because of spiteful European scientists trying to discredit them because of Brexit like no other countries could have scientists capable of spotting an issue. And that they would put their own citizens at risk as fuck you because everything the EU does revolves around you.

There is a prevailing attitude of we are better than everyone else, just look at some of the suggestions on this thread, whole countries have no culture except hating england or the only possible issue other countries could have is jealously. Its not an attractive trait.

mbosnz · 28/07/2021 18:42

When it comes to New Zealand, I find it not so amusing how some English, particularly those who have emigrated there, can say in two consecutive breaths that NZ has no history, because it's so recent, and in the next, that Maori grievances against the Crown (which are being addressed by the New Zealand Government, because obviously the British Crown with whom the Treaty was signed would never), is ancient history and people should just get the hell over it, and move on.

It's this kind of contradictory attitude that can perhaps influence people in other countries attitudes towards 'The English/British'.

FirstIn50s · 28/07/2021 18:41

... btw... I don't mean the conquest/settlement of large parts of Ireland was a good idea. But it happened, our ancestors did it, and there are consequences for us today.

FirstIn50s · 28/07/2021 18:39

"Just don't hold the current generation responsible for historical actions." ... I don't agree with that. We do have responsibilities for what our society has done in the past.

We settled/moved a large protestant population to NI. We've continued to support them in the past, we should continue to support them going forward. You just can't wash your hands of things like that.

EmeraldShamrock · 28/07/2021 18:35

Though I will say it is shit the Irish government is being left to deal with the DUP. Let Boris sort his sorry mess out.

EmeraldShamrock · 28/07/2021 18:28

How many people considered NI when they voted for Brexit?
In fairness the DUP supported Brexit and voted accordingly shooting themselves in the foot, this enabled the sea border, the DUP and Boris are responsible for the mess.
You can't blame the average English voters for Brexits affect on NI.

MildredPuppy · 28/07/2021 17:22

My bit of England was much stronger remain than most of wales! Similar level to most of scotland.

Delphinia · 28/07/2021 17:16

How many people considered NI when they voted for Brexit?
Then blame English, Welsh, Scottish and NI brexiters. Not "the English"

TableFlowerss · 28/07/2021 17:06

@JaniieJones

'No, this is incorrect. If you challenge anything to do with English culture or history, if you say anything (self) critical about England as a nation at all, you're a nasty racist.'

Err no, this is incorrect. Challenge all you like, the culture the history etc. Just don't hold the current generation responsible for historical actions.

The problem is when people on here say 'I don't like the English because.. ' or 'white people are...'.

You just cant judge people on their skin colour or nationality you see. Unless you're a bigot, racist or xenophobe?

Judge the actions in history until the cows come home but people must have some awareness and stop saying 'The English' as if we're one homogenous mass. Would they say 'the Asians'?!

Exactly this!
DynamoKev · 28/07/2021 16:00

@OuiOuiKitty

For goodness sake, how can you blame an entire people for the sins of the past? Frankly, hatred perpetuates hatred and fear. Have we learnt nothing from history?

Mmm part of the problem for me is that it isn't just sins of the past is it? How many people considered NI when they voted for Brexit? How much scorn was poured on ROI for standing up and saying hold up there is an international peace treaty between two countries to be considered here? We were branded as being difficult and being top big for our boots for giving more of a shit about NI than the UK ever did in the Brexit talks. I know this wasn't all English people but you can bet the majority of it was. This is just one thing I can mention, it is late so won't go into more.

I'm not saying 'racism' or xenophobia is acceptable but I'm not going to sit here and pretend that all that has happened was centuries ago and should be 'left in the past' either. NI isn't in the past, the effects of Brexit will be felt in NI for a long time to come.

and what about the 44% of NI that voted Leave? That's quite a substantial proportion - they can't all have been English? Did they not "consider NI" (where they live?).
CounsellorTroi · 28/07/2021 15:53

*There’s an extra dimension in Wales though, the Welsh language. My roots are in rural west Wales and as a Welsh speaker it saddens me how much less Welsh is spoken there now than there was when I was a child

I thought the use of the Welsh language had increased a lot in recent years.*

Overall it has and it has a much higher profile. The areas I'm talking about were heartlands of the Welsh language 40 or 50 years ago where most people spoke Welsh.

igelkott2021 · 28/07/2021 15:45

There’s an extra dimension in Wales though, the Welsh language. My roots are in rural west Wales and as a Welsh speaker it saddens me how much less Welsh is spoken there now than there was when I was a child

I thought the use of the Welsh language had increased a lot in recent years.

If you challenge anything to do with English culture or history, if you say anything (self) critical about England as a nation at all, you're a nasty racist

It's fine to criticise events that happened in the past. It is not ok to say that people living now are responsible for what their ancestors may or may not have done, and it is is not ok to blame an entire country's residents for the activities of a few (like the English football fans).

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/07/2021 15:39

How can you blame an entire people for the sins of the past?

Simon Wiesenthal - a man in a position to know - rejected the concept of collective guilt, not least because it played a major part in how atrocities came to happen in the first place

Its seems some cherry pick history but sadly learn little from it; however for anyone who wishes to I recommend some of his writings (The Sunflower is especially good and very readable)

SueSaid · 28/07/2021 14:55

'No, this is incorrect. If you challenge anything to do with English culture or history, if you say anything (self) critical about England as a nation at all, you're a nasty racist.'

Err no, this is incorrect. Challenge all you like, the culture the history etc. Just don't hold the current generation responsible for historical actions.

The problem is when people on here say 'I don't like the English because.. ' or 'white people are...'.

You just cant judge people on their skin colour or nationality you see. Unless you're a bigot, racist or xenophobe?

Judge the actions in history until the cows come home but people must have some awareness and stop saying 'The English' as if we're one homogenous mass. Would they say 'the Asians'?!

Etulosba · 28/07/2021 14:36

Just in the way the English were when they subjugated half the world through violence.

The English didn’t. The British did.

Or don’t you understand the difference?

thedancingbear · 28/07/2021 14:07

@HerrenaHarridan

Fuck... other English people are embarrassing

Some of the comments here... stop fantasising about being oppressed and spend some time learning about the broken backs your privileged existence was built on.

Top tip... you can have experienced suffering in your life and still be privileged

I don’t hate anyone for where they were born, it’s the butchers flag waving idiots and those trying to centre their privileged white arses every time that get my ire... if you’re going to wave that disgraceful flag and pretend you don’t understand that it’s recognised round the world as a symbol of oppression and terror then i have nothing to say to you

No, this is incorrect. If you challenge anything to do with English culture or history, if you say anything (self) critical about England as a nation at all, you're a nasty racist.

Just in the way the English were when they subjugated half the world through violence. Oh hang on, that's different...

Some people on this thread don't know they're born.