Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is racism against the English acceptable?

792 replies

BabyBearRus · 26/07/2021 23:58

We are currently on holiday in Wales and have just heard an altercation outside our holiday accommodation blasting the "bastard English who come to stay here". I'm shocked. I am half Welsh and half Irish, and spent much time in both countries. But also spent half my life in England. There has always been a jovial criticism of the English, e.g. during rugby internationals etc, but in recent years the tone has become more racist. I also find this resentful attitude towards the English amongst my Irish and Scottish friends. The English seem to be an acceptable people to hate. Surely this should be classed as racism? And, I'm saying this from a predominantly Welsh and Irish heritage. Yes, I am aware of the history of these isles, but when are we going to get over this? Truly baffled.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
supermoonrising · 27/07/2021 07:06

Saying it’s not racism is splitting hairs really.

The English, Welsh, Irish etc have physical differences between the groups which many people could identify given, say, a group of 100 people from each country. Different culture, history etc.

In much the same way that, (for example) Japanese people hating on Chinese people or Chinese people hating on Tibetans is also racism. Yes they are the same “race” - Asian. But they are of different ethnicity and different culture, tend to have different physical identifiers, different religion etc. It’s racism.

bunnybuggs · 27/07/2021 07:06

The definition of the English
The English people are an ethnic group and nation native to England, who speak the English language and share a common history and culture. The English identity is of early medieval origin, when they were known in Old English as the Angelcynn ('race or tribe of the Angles').
we are native to our country, and an ethnic group but we are not a race. My DNA says I am mainly celtic (Welsh) but I consider myself English (and I oppress no-one).

kin432 · 27/07/2021 06:57

I'm with you, the rise in English bashing isn't acceptable. Using your football analogies, if England were knocked out of a tournament, I'd definitely support Wales and Scotland as my second teams. My Scottish friends absolutely hate England and would support any team they're playing (yet ironically still choose to live in England).

I wonder when we became almost embarrassed to be English? When I fill in forms asking for country of birth, I usually write Britain. I'm guessing most Welsh or Scottish people would write Wales or Scotland. I feel semi-awkward when I put England yet I'm proud to be English.

MumDadBingoBLUEY · 27/07/2021 06:55

I'm English and went to University in (South) Wales. Never encountered any problems in the 5 or so years I lived there, and I didn't just stick to a "safe" University bubble.

DP is Welsh, but his accent is fairly English-passing apart from certain words. We live in England, and when some English people find out he's Welsh, their attitude towards him shifts negatively.

But sure, the Welsh are the problem.

You can't be racist towards an oppressor.

Grimacingfrog · 27/07/2021 06:55

@Flamingdingus

Because at last the English are starting to show some independence. We chose not to be part of a homologous structure in Europe and instead forge ahead shedding ourselves of the bureaucratic encumbrances Europe entails. Sadly not all our nations agreed. The French don't like us cos we saved their sorry asses in two world wars and they've never got over it!

We chose to be out of a homologous structure? If by that you meant that we could not be English in the EU, that's rather odd. All the other nations have kept their individuality. France is very specifically France, Latvia is Latvia, Germany is Germany etc. All very different. Presumably the tourists that came here see our country as separate and different. We're now separate and different in a very unpleasant way.

"Sadly not all our nations agreed." Indeed, Scotland and NI saw how they benefited from EU membership and voted to preserve our EU membership. Now many of the Welsh and Cornish are also seeing what the implications are for them. Some research shows that the leave vote in Wales was mainly from English incomers.

I'd like to remind you that there was an amendment calling for the Referendum Act to have a triple lock so that all the nations had to be in agreement for such an enormous constitutional change to take place.

That amendment was rejected on the grounds that the referendum was only advisory in nature.

Now the strong feeling in Scotland is that they have been dragged out against their will and Scottish independence is looking to be a very real future.

The Good Friday Agreement has been disregarded and seen as irrelevant. Yes, the border communities are angry and justifiably so. How will this pan out? Goodness knows. Seeing a valuable peace agreement trashed and disrespected is not, very much not, good.

We saved the French's sorry asses - oh my. This is just the superior attitude that feeds much of the anti-English feeling. Um - French Resistance, the contribution of the US, the Russians ????? But no - 'England won WW2 all on our own'. Give me strength.

As for bureaucracy, we're now seeing how much bureaucracy the EU saved us. The difficulties of trading with our nearest neighbours as a non member state has reduced our exports by 68% and our imports are suffering. This is without the full implementation of the border controls that will come in next year.

OP, sorry to derail but this post was such a clear example of why the English are not universally loved.

Sorry, but I have to point out that you can't pick out the viewpoint of the dickheads in a country and then punish everyone because of them. While I would agree that there are probably more of them in England than in most countries, they still exist everywhere.

The thing about the World wars is just ridiculous, of course it wasn't the work of one nation, we were lucky being an island helped us, and there was, of course lots of resistance on the continent. I can't stand the boneheaded views of idiots such as Flamingodingus, but should I be punished for them just because I happen to have been born in the same country?

No one, but no one hates the little Englanders more than sane English people. Imagine being associated with them wherever you go? Imagine cringing at being lumped with Nigel Farage and Ann Widdecombe waving her stupid little flag in the European Parliament? Imagine seeing the football hooligans rushing the Wembley gates carrying their beer bellies and sense of entitlement with misplaced pride?

I don't mix with anyone like that though of course I've come across it and call it out when I see it. But honestly I don't think it's fair to include me as one of them, and for you to have the right to insult me because of it. It makes you no better than them.

Where I live there was a very robust vote for Remain. I'm furious about the whole mendacious Leave Campaign. I'm really fed up with the encouragement it's given xenophobes and weakminded racists. Many of us knew about the amount of bureaucracy the EU saved us. We knew about the lies perpetuated in newspapers owned by American-Australians, or Monegasque tax exiles.

So really, please don't lump us all together. It's playing the same game they do.

KingdomScrolls · 27/07/2021 06:54

My grandparents are/were Irish on one side Scottish on the other, my generation are mainly English because they emigrated, however there is still a lot of anti English sentiment which has always confused me, you have English family because you moved to England and had children.
As for the we can't afford to buy houses where we grew up, I grew up in East London can't afford to buy there had to move out. Largely because of people from everywhere else moving there and lots of foreign investment pushing up housing prices.
I'm actually in favour of independence if that's what the majority of the nations want.
As for the football everyone I know was cheering on Wales wanting to see them do well, and Scotland (other than when playing England) , so is a little disappointing when you hear in return a hive mind to just want any English sportsperson or team to fail.
There were many many nations involved in horrendous colonial behaviour but they don't seem to be held to account for it on an individual basis in the way Bob and Joan going on their caravan holiday in the Snowdonia national park are.

Claphands · 27/07/2021 06:50

It’s always been like that, we used to holiday in Wales when I was a kid and I heard it then, particularly in shops. I’ve only been back since for non holiday reasons, I’d never go on holiday there now.

sailmeaway · 27/07/2021 06:47

Not racism. I used to work in a hotel where guests from one region where almost always demanding and rude. We'd call them bloody whatever-ites and take a deep breathe when we saw a car with their licence plates arriving.
So prejudice, not racism.

lannistunut · 27/07/2021 06:41

Yes, I am aware of the history of these isles, but when are we going to get over this?

It is a) not something people just 'get over' and b) politics in England currently is increasing nationalistic feeling. Johnson is an English PM who does not seem to respect the other nations, consequently anti-English attitudes are rising.

Grimacingfrog · 27/07/2021 06:33

@TopOfTheHour

It's wearing. I'm fed up of dickheads.
This.

It's not nice at all. Equally, the English dickheads who go on about sheepshaggers and haggis botherers. It's not funny at all but the perpetrators think they're absolutely hilarious.

I pull people up on it but am generally given the impression that I'm humourless.

The really witty people I know never, ever do this.

notanatural2018 · 27/07/2021 06:32

It's xenophobia isn't it? Not racism.

UnsuitableHat · 27/07/2021 06:16

Nope, that’s not acceptable. Perhaps anti-English prejudice is sometimes legitimised as as ‘hitting up’ as the English have historically been seen as an oppressor.

LowlandLucky · 27/07/2021 05:48

Racist, xenophobic, prejudice, who bloody cares what it is called, it is wrong. Is being insulted, ignored or disregarded worse if it is to do with colour rather the nationality ?

GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou · 27/07/2021 05:22

This is all Belfast BTW.

GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou · 27/07/2021 05:21

No, I'm sorry for not elaborating on Flag-Gate. :o

In 2012 It was decided to only fly the union flag over city hall on designated days which resulted in, well, mayhem during 2013.

It got really bad in many places and there was a lot of talk about it "starting the troubles all over again".

I hope you see my point that it didn't come to that, thank God but people do like to say it.

Flamingdingus · 27/07/2021 05:09

Because at last the English are starting to show some independence. We chose not to be part of a homologous structure in Europe and instead forge ahead shedding ourselves of the bureaucratic encumbrances Europe entails. Sadly not all our nations agreed.
The French don't like us cos we saved their sorry asses in two world wars and they've never got over it!

We chose to be out of a homologous structure? If by that you meant that we could not be English in the EU, that's rather odd. All the other nations have kept their individuality. France is very specifically France, Latvia is Latvia, Germany is Germany etc. All very different. Presumably the tourists that came here see our country as separate and different. We're now separate and different in a very unpleasant way.

"Sadly not all our nations agreed." Indeed, Scotland and NI saw how they benefited from EU membership and voted to preserve our EU membership. Now many of the Welsh and Cornish are also seeing what the implications are for them. Some research shows that the leave vote in Wales was mainly from English incomers.

I'd like to remind you that there was an amendment calling for the Referendum Act to have a triple lock so that all the nations had to be in agreement for such an enormous constitutional change to take place.

That amendment was rejected on the grounds that the referendum was only advisory in nature.

Now the strong feeling in Scotland is that they have been dragged out against their will and Scottish independence is looking to be a very real future.

The Good Friday Agreement has been disregarded and seen as irrelevant. Yes, the border communities are angry and justifiably so. How will this pan out? Goodness knows. Seeing a valuable peace agreement trashed and disrespected is not, very much not, good.

We saved the French's sorry asses - oh my. This is just the superior attitude that feeds much of the anti-English feeling. Um - French Resistance, the contribution of the US, the Russians ????? But no - 'England won WW2 all on our own'. Give me strength.

As for bureaucracy, we're now seeing how much bureaucracy the EU saved us. The difficulties of trading with our nearest neighbours as a non member state has reduced our exports by 68% and our imports are suffering. This is without the full implementation of the border controls that will come in next year.

OP, sorry to derail but this post was such a clear example of why the English are not universally loved.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 05:05

That's to GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou.

Sorry.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 05:04

Sorry I don't understand.

Can you expand on that? I literally have no idea about any of it!

DewDew83 · 27/07/2021 05:02

I have an Aunt who is English but lived in Wales almost all her adult life. She's married to a Welsh man. She has become radicalised by social media in recent years and seems to have adopted Welsh as her nationality, to the point that she is regularly posting about English people taking over Wales. I have to resist the urge to point out that she is one.
So what? I know a good few English people who have moved to Wales, spent most of their lives there and some are even fluent in Welsh. If they want to call themselves Welsh and make pro-Welsh heritage posts, good on them. A world away from the holiday-home buyers and those who campaign for the language to be abolished (or turn a blind eye to the issue).

GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou · 27/07/2021 04:53

The squeaky wheels get the oil. Reports said the same thing about Flag-Gate.

It's just a bunch of nonsense trying to set us back and you are buying into it. Next year it will be something else.

VariantL1130 · 27/07/2021 04:51

I grew up on the Welsh border (English) and I think that there's always been an undercurrent of xenophobia on both sides, but recently I think it's got worse and social media is to blame.

I have an Aunt who is English but lived in Wales almost all her adult life. She's married to a Welsh man. She has become radicalised by social media in recent years and seems to have adopted Welsh as her nationality, to the point that she is regularly posting about English people taking over Wales. I have to resist the urge to point out that she is one Confused

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 04:43

@GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou

Jesus Chris Gerbil what are you on about?

I grew up in one of the most nationalist areas in Belfast. Telling wankers who make everyone else's life a misery to shut up is not the same thing as supporting marches.

And yes the only people I have ever seen abuse English people in NI for being English have been drunken scumbags.

I'm on about the recent resurgence in violence.

90 police officers have been injured so far according to my quick Google search.

Reports saying not seen anything like this since the troubles.

I must be missing something. Unionist / nationalist. One side wants free of the English. How is that not anti English sentiment.

If the situation is not due to one group having anti English sentiment then what were the bombs I remember all about?

HeartvsBrain · 27/07/2021 04:38

Sorry, far too exhausted to read the whole thread, even most of OP's. It feels like racism, but it isn't, but it IS a Hate Crime, and if as a nation we weren't so "oh no, I don't want to bother the police (or whoever any given situation would make appropriate)".

Anyone who wants to troll me over this, please don't waste your time, I won't change my mind on this, however much you insult me or my views - my views are just as relevant as yours. By the way, I do believe that far too many kidnapped/hijacked/stolen/ displaced people of colour have been murdered/raped/ tortured/Treated abhorrently in this World, and tragically many of those were by British and/or white hands. The real tragedy is (as at some stage we do all need to put history behind us, or we will forever be doing those same things county against county, state against state, areas against areas, nation against nation, country against country, continent against continent, and maybe in the future, planet against planet etc), that some of us are still treating people of colour this way. The actions of too many US police individuals are an awful example of this.

But as in another not quite so serious thread, many of us women think that the pain of childbirth - and I have been lucky enough to have had 3 successful natural childbirths (with the help of the wonderful Entonox) - is the worst pain ever, and that no man should ever dare to complain of pain, after what we have to go through, with apparently NO SYMPATHY whatsoever from anyone, except for other mothers!
(But shh, in the small print Pancreatitis is actually supposed to be worse).
So I don't think it is actually helpful to say or believe that every single person of colour has suffered at all times through history, more than any individual white person. Many individual white/Mediterranian white people, have actually suffered severely at the hands of other white people, and by the hands of - whisper it - people of colour too.
IMO some of the worst people to suffer these days, are a significant portion of Muslim women by the hands (and other body parts) of too many Muslim men. So please don't judge one atrocity against another. All hatred against others is abhorrent.

GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou · 27/07/2021 04:36

Jesus Chris Gerbil what are you on about?

I grew up in one of the most nationalist areas in Belfast. Telling wankers who make everyone else's life a misery to shut up is not the same thing as supporting marches.

And yes the only people I have ever seen abuse English people in NI for being English have been drunken scumbags.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 04:35

'@SorryWoman pretty sure that's because nearly everyone is 100% against the Holocaust, but start talking about the empire and you have all sorts of comments like, "the countries were better off as a result of being colonised" etcetera. Many British are proud of the empire to this day. Resentment exists for a reason.'

www.reuters.com/world/uk-ex-police-officer-jailed-belonging-neo-nazi-group-2021-04-30/

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/jun/09/four-uk-neo-nazis-jailed-for-membership-of-national-action

www.bbc.com/news/uk-57406673

Etc etc