Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nosy Lodger-would you find this annoying?

82 replies

LodgerDodging · 26/07/2021 23:41

I don't know if I'm just a grouch.
I rent out my spare room. I've had several lodgers over the last few years. All different but all fine really.

I'm late thirties this one is late 50s.
He is great in that he is quite happy to look after things while I'm away or busy (including my dog if I can't take him).

He's clean and tidy, does housework, is helpful.
However he seems fascinated with things I do.

Example 1-If I ever leave the house he texts asking where I am or sometimes simply 'you've gone out, have you gone to the shop/your mums/other random thing I may have mentioned in passing?' Even though me leaving the house need not affect him at all.

Example 2-my partner was here and we went to the local pub just up the road. Once there I realised I wasn't dressed appropriately, it was very hot and I was getting bothered so I sme back home to take off my jeans and put on a dress. He was in his bedroom and heard me go in mine and shouted 'What you doing back?' And when i said 'I'm getting changed' asked me why. Why does he care?

Example 3 he heard me on the 'phone to a friend. About ten minutes after I'd hung up he came into the room and said 'Sarah?' I looked at him,puzzled and be repeated 'Sarah? The girl you speak to up the road sometimes you know, blonde hair, about 26?'
'Yes, what about her?'
'Was that her on the phone?'
(It wasn't, and the woman he meant isn't called the name he used either).

My mum was having a gathering for a birthday. She came over and we discussed it briefly. Someone rang her (I've no idea who).
A few days later lodger told me 'Your friend Pete is going to the party isn't he?'
'? No? Why??'
'I heard your Mum on the phone to him!'
My friends don't call my mum or go to family parties as a rule.

There are many more examples of this sort of thing. Is it weird or am I being a grouchy old cow?
He also told me the neighbours opposite are stuck up because they have a cleaner 'and she doesn't work!'
I said that I've spoken to them and they don't seem stuck up,and how does he know she doesn't work anyway? (Lodger doesn't work either)!

Aibu?

OP posts:
5475878237NC · 27/07/2021 17:14

I couldn't live like this!

WomanStanleyWoman · 27/07/2021 17:02

He is in his 50's so i would have expected him to at least have some savings from all those yrs working/poss previous hse sales/life generally that, he could fall back on instead of housing benefit?

Life isn’t always that simple.

girl71 · 27/07/2021 16:49

Something a bit off. I am suspicious that a man in his 50's is in such insecure housing, no job , no family apart from brother, and lodging with a younger female. Did you have references for him that all checked out? His relationship history is a question mark for me too. Is his stay with you temporary ,as in , this is a stop gap for him while he gets his own place sorted?

He may just be socially immature and have unclear boundaries but his behaviour is odd and the other things about him , feed into that for me. For you to have posted here, makes me suspect something about him and his behaviours has unnerved you. He is in his 50's so i would have expected him to at least have some savings from all those yrs working/poss previous hse sales/life generally that, he could fall back on instead of housing benefit?

I have never had lodgers or never would so maybe my view is a bit skewed. I am in my 50's and cannot imagine being in his position. That also makes me suspect he had made some poor life choices at best and that would make me suspicious. Why is he not working?

alexdgr8 · 27/07/2021 15:51

when i was a lodger i had the opposite problem.
landlady was v inquisitive and would persist with asking personal questions. i would just ignore, mumble, or be vague.
she was a very pushy domineering type, with everybody.
OP, are you sure your lodger is not going through your personal things when you are out, maybe documents, or even clothes, wardrobe.
he seems to want to know how long you will be gone. that would make me uneasy.
could you set up a covert camera in your room.
i think you need to shut down inappropriate questions.

starfishmummy · 27/07/2021 15:28

Points taken about him having had a difficult life. This is why I do try to include him in things where possible

But why on earth would you do that? This is a business arrangement and you have been treating him like a new best friend. No wonder he is having trouble with boundaries.

I've lodged, and I know you need to be friendly and get on with each other but there is a limit!

Cherrysoup · 27/07/2021 14:41

He has no boundaries. I would ignore texts asking where you are and remind him that he’s not your dad, you need to tell him where you’re going etc.

LodgerDodging · 27/07/2021 14:27

@Carrott21

Sounds like he'd planned a wank in peace.
Just noticed this Grin
OP posts:
LodgerDodging · 27/07/2021 13:24

Points taken about him having had a difficult life. This is why I do try to include him in things where possible although he usually declines.

He does have a brother who lives an hour or so away. He mentioned a few months ago that he wants to see him but he never seems to proactively arrange anything. I've even said his brother is welcome to visit in case he didn't think he was.

OP posts:
WoodPell · 27/07/2021 10:57

I have to say it's also a bit odd that you don't know much about him but he is asking you minute details down to your mum's party guestlist!

Canigooutyet · 27/07/2021 10:57

Could be that he fancies the mate up the road and was angling for an invite to your mum's party.
Texting asking where you are I would ignore and when mentioned I would say oh I thought it was for someone else.
Coming back early and asking questions I would just think he's making sure you are ok.
There could also be an element of him taking on the role of a father figure.
Him looking after the dog I would keep it in place as it's encouraging him to go out and hopefully through those walks he can meet more people. It's not your responsibility obviously but it can be incredibly hard having a social life on benefits and even more so when things were closed. Now things have reopened he has more opportunities to meet more people.

Movinghouseatlast · 27/07/2021 10:55

Gosh, it sounds like he has had a bit of a difficult life recently. He has been through the mill.

Imagine being a lodger in your 50's on housing benefit and unemployed. It means he has literally nothing doesn't it? No home of his own, no job, no money no family, no love.

Approaching retirement age having had your life collapse like that must be scary. Loosing his business may have meant he lost his previous home. Imagine that, Imagine how that would make you feel.

Personally I wouldn't have taken a male lodger that much older than me, but maybe I'm old fashioned. I would think it was quite risky.

The bloke is obviously lonely with not much of a life of his own. He might not be able to see a a way out of it which must be so difficult.

WoodPell · 27/07/2021 10:53

Absolutely agree with @FreeBritnee and her post about him being a "misfit" type. Honestly I'd never take on a lodger with no job or partner - when does he leave the house? Sounds like you're currently the vast majority of his human contact.

The stuff where he's asking about your friends by name seems like he's trying to prove he's your friend too.

SilverTotoro · 27/07/2021 10:52

I would hate someone listening to my conversations and asking about them - also pretty odd to text asking where you are on a regular basis (a one off in case you had gone to shops is a bit different). Like others have said he sounds a bit lonely and like he wants to be involved in your life. Personally I wouldn’t be comfortable with that - but I’m a bit of an introvert and value privacy. In your shoes I wouldn’t respond to any texts he sends asking where you are and if he mentioned phone conversations I’d just say ‘I’m not sure what you mean/ don’t remember the call, was there a reason you wanted to know’ assuming there wasn’t a valid reason I’d then just shrug and say I’m not sure and either leave the room or change the subject - rinse and repeat until he hopefully got the message.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 27/07/2021 10:47

When random people are intrusive I ask "why do you need to know?"
They'll normally say something like I'm interested or just making conversation or similar. Then I say oh or ok or hmm but don't answer the question and change the subject instead. They don't repeat the question.

WomanStanleyWoman · 27/07/2021 10:43

I’m surprised at how many people think that the occasional bit of dog sitting gives someone carte blanche to quiz their landlady about phone conversations, text her every time she goes out wanting to know where she is etc.

It’s not like the OP is saying she never wants to exchange so much as a hello with her lodger - she just thinks he’s overstepping the mark. And I don’t blame her.

StillWeRise · 27/07/2021 10:24

its a difficult relationship to have I think and I agree this sounds like someone who is bored/lonely and also has social skills that aren't exactly poor but aren't fine tuned to this situation.
You need to help him by setting the boundaries yourself. I can see the dog thing, wanting the dog to stay in the house. But you mentioned inviting him to the pub- this is exactly the kind of thing that gives him the impression you are friends.

FreeBritnee · 27/07/2021 10:05

He sounds like he has a mild personality disorder. He’d he called a ‘misfit’ in days gone by. Someone who hasn’t confirmed to social norms for whatever reason. These men often lived with their mother’s their whole lives. My concern is he is blurring the boundaries and I’d hate for you to get yourself into a situation where he thinks you have some sort of ‘special relationship ’. Just tread carefully.

LannieDuck · 27/07/2021 10:02

It sounds like he wants a friend. But that first example is totally overstepping and a bit creepy.

LodgerDodging · 27/07/2021 10:00

@HaveringWavering

Why doesn’t he work? Is his rent paid by housing benefit?
I'm not quite sure why he doesn't work now but I do know he had a business that folded (a family business he took over) a few years ago..and yes it is housing benefit. I guess he is better off lodging than paying for a whole house? And the housing shortage.
OP posts:
Carrott21 · 27/07/2021 09:58

Sounds like he'd planned a wank in peace.

LemonFantaGin · 27/07/2021 09:53

He sounds lonely and like he is taking a bit too much of an interest into your life because he has nothing else to do.

dottiedodah · 27/07/2021 09:52

I think often Lodgers who are a little older ,tend to possibly be a little socially awkward .It sounds like you are a very kind Landlady who wants to be friends .Does he have any family or friends at all? If not you can become close as he is obv lonely and likes to be part of a family . If you are happy with the situation then no worries .If not may have to do a rethink .

LodgerDodging · 27/07/2021 09:48

@StrangeToSee

regarding my dog I've said to him that I'm going to (partners/'do'/whatever) for the night so I'm dripping dog off at (sitter/kennels/exs house) and he'd say 'oh it's fine I'll have him!' I've never directly asked

But you’ve accepted his offers. You could have said ‘thanks but I’ve already sorted it’ or ‘oh that’s very kind but my sister’s looking forward to having dog’.

Yes true. I would always rather dog was at home if possible as he isn't so keen on staying elsewhere apart from at exs house which is a bit of a trek for me so not so often.
OP posts:
LodgerDodging · 27/07/2021 09:47

Ive read all the replies and will take on board about the awkwardness and lack of social skills.
I do always offer wirh few exceptions, if I'm going to the shop-ill shout or text if I'm out does he need anything.
I know he hasn't ever been married and hasn't got children although he did have a relationship with a woman with children at one point.

OP posts:
HunkyPunk · 27/07/2021 09:11

It's not usual for a lodger to text to see where you are, unless there's some kind of emergency, or to want to discuss overheard personal conversations. It sounds like he doesn't have much going on in his life, so he's taking a greater than normal (for a lodger) interest in yours. If you don't have any misgivings about him, other than being slightly irritated, and you are otherwise happy with the set-up, then that's fine. I think it would make a lot of people uncomfortable, though, including me!