Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be rude in this situation? [Content warning added by MNHQ: Child abuse]

113 replies

Question2149 · 26/07/2021 22:24

My parents have lived on the same street since I was small as have most of the people on it.

I had two close friends growing up who lived on the same street who I still speak to now although not as close these days as we've all grown up and moved away, had families etc.

One of the girls I used to play with on the street contacted me a while ago to say that there was an investigation going ahead relating to a man on the street inappropriately touching her when we were children. It has also come to light through this that it's not the first time he's been accused, he was accused previously by someone else of the same thing but was never charged. He is also denying this accusation from my friend.

I have been asked about that time, whether I remember anything, whether anything happened to myself (I believe not) and other than checking in on my friend occasionally have not had any further involvement in the situation.

My dilemma here is his wife is always trying to say hello, ask how I am, how my DC is, ask to see my baby etc... when I go to see my parents. It's incredibly awkward and I feel like she is trying to gauge which side I'm on.

I want to tell her straight not to speak to me, that my position is that I believe my friend and want nothing to do with either of them, even small talk. He has also tried to say hello and I have blanked him completely but the grey area for me is his wife.

Would you continue to say hello, or respond when asked how you are to this woman or would you think it acceptable for me to be rude and ignore her or even just say straight up "please don't speak to me"?

I absolutely believe my friend and so to me this is a woman who's stayed with a man who's twice now been accused of this.

OP posts:
MzHz · 27/07/2021 09:24

@Question2149

They're scoping you out, either to groom you for access to your family, or to check out whether you believe his 'innocence

I believe it's the latter. That's the impression I get when she tries to talk to me. She wants to know who's 'side' I'm on.

But if you’re being blunt, surely you’re making it fairly clear…

I don’t blame you at all and I think the matter of fact statement is definitely the way to go

Muchasgracias · 27/07/2021 09:18

[quote Zebraaa]@AtrociousCircumstance and your attitude is exactly what’s wrong with the legal system.
He isn’t a paedophile because he hasn’t been charged with anything![/quote]
A legal system that has been letting women and children down for years and working to the advantage of male abusers.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 09:13

I think I'd get the whole 'its not her fault so be polite thing' if I was just a random person from the community who'd heard some rumours but didn't actually know anymore than that.

But I'm involved in this situation both because of my friend and the fact that I've also had to discuss this with police and recount whether I believe he did this to me as well when I was a child and so on... It's not a comfortable situation. I've had nights where I've been unable to sleep for wondering if this could have happened to me and I just don't remember because I was so young. I feel too close to this to be nice and polite about it.

OP posts:
AtrociousCircumstance · 27/07/2021 09:07

I’m astonished at posters telling you to be kind. Your friend was abused by her husband and she wants to merrily push her friendliness on you for her own reassurance. Seems like she has a problem with boundaries too, on a much lesser scale but still.

Ignore.

muddyford · 27/07/2021 09:00

You don't have to be rude or unkind but neither do you have to turn her into your bosom buddy. Be polite but brief. She has done nothing except stand by her husband, and what goes on in other people's marriages is always the great unknown, as reading any number of threads on MN shows.

PamTheSpam · 27/07/2021 08:51

If something makes you uncomfortable then just tell her you think it's inappropriate for you to speak to each other
Then ignore her if she continues

billy1966 · 27/07/2021 08:49

[quote fairynick]@Rosebel it isn’t really fair enough to believe a man who has been accused on two separate occasions of doing such vile things. It’s burying your head in the sand. She’s a paedophile sympathiser and she is part of the problem. Your poor parents having to live next door.
Next time you bump into her, I don’t think there’s a point in being too nice or too rude. Maybe something like “Listen, you’re standing by your husband which is your choice, but I’m standing by my friend. I think it’s best that we don’t speak”. And leave it at that.[/quote]
I can 100% understand your distaste and I wouldn't want to engage either.

How awful for your parents having him right next door.

I think the above is polite, firm, and completely your perogative.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 08:43

They're scoping you out, either to groom you for access to your family, or to check out whether you believe his 'innocence

I believe it's the latter. That's the impression I get when she tries to talk to me. She wants to know who's 'side' I'm on.

OP posts:
Ohpulltheotherone · 27/07/2021 08:42

You don’t owe anyone your time or your smiles and small talk.

No one.

Especially not someone who as far as you are concerned has stood by a man who has abused children.

Maybe she didn’t know at the time but she knows now.

And the fact that she doesn’t respect your space knowing that the woman is your friend and it’s inappropriate to speak to you says to me that she isn’t just being kind and friendly - she is trying tk gauge you or stay “on side”.
If she were a good person she would respect the fact she is mixed up in a very emotive situation concerning a friend of yours - and therefore keep her distance from you.
A smile and polite “hello” if she does happen to see you would be sufficient. She is pushing the boundaries and quite like you I’d be very uncomfortable.

She may not have done anything wrong but as far as OP is concerned she has and to be honest if someone kept trying to encroach my personal space when there’s a great big fuck off pedophile elephant shape in the room I’d be fuming.

I wonder how many pp who are telling you to be polite and that she’s done nothing wrong would change their tune if it was their neighbour and their child in question.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 08:42

Thanks. Yes when I say rude I don't mean calling her names and shouting or anything drastic like that but a simple to the point "I don't wish to speak to you because I believe my friend, please don't try and speak to me again".

The card from them both when my baby was born made me feel especially horrible. As if I'd just have that up on my mantel piece with the rest of them.

OP posts:
PegasusReturns · 27/07/2021 08:41

He isn’t a paedophile because he hasn’t been charged with anything!

Don't be absurd of course he can be a paedophile without being charged. Or do you think poor Jimmy Saville was a misunderstood nice guy?!

OP you believe your friend and it’s fine to be disgusted that this woman would stand by her husband. You don’t have to do anything other than walk away if that’s what you want.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 27/07/2021 08:41

I also would definitely have returned the gift and card signed by paedo and his wife...

Like hell, would I be (passively) encouraging any contact AT ALL with this couple.

They're scoping you out, either to groom you for access to your family, or to check out whether you believe his 'innocence'

Either is horrible.

MaMaD1990 · 27/07/2021 08:36

[quote fairynick]@Rosebel it isn’t really fair enough to believe a man who has been accused on two separate occasions of doing such vile things. It’s burying your head in the sand. She’s a paedophile sympathiser and she is part of the problem. Your poor parents having to live next door.
Next time you bump into her, I don’t think there’s a point in being too nice or too rude. Maybe something like “Listen, you’re standing by your husband which is your choice, but I’m standing by my friend. I think it’s best that we don’t speak”. And leave it at that.[/quote]
I agree with @fairynick. Being rude isn't going to accomplish much but a simple statement saying you don't want to speak is fair enough. I don't think anyone (outside of some on MN) would blame you.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 27/07/2021 08:36

[quote Zebraaa]@AtrociousCircumstance and your attitude is exactly what’s wrong with the legal system.
He isn’t a paedophile because he hasn’t been charged with anything![/quote]
Innocent to proven guilty is a LEGAL term...

It does NOT mean that they haven't done the crime...

Would you let Saville babysit your kids if he was still alive...?? As despite all the compelling evidence he was 'innocent'??

It's this sort of thinking that is behind enablers of grim assaults on people/kids.

Lots of neighbours enabled the local paedophile to assault me... (he is so nice and hasn't been convicted in court .... So we'll just behave as if he's never harmed a fly.

He did, he had....

He died before anyone could prosecute him.

He was very definitely guilty.

Nanny0gg · 27/07/2021 08:34

[quote fairynick]@Rosebel it isn’t really fair enough to believe a man who has been accused on two separate occasions of doing such vile things. It’s burying your head in the sand. She’s a paedophile sympathiser and she is part of the problem. Your poor parents having to live next door.
Next time you bump into her, I don’t think there’s a point in being too nice or too rude. Maybe something like “Listen, you’re standing by your husband which is your choice, but I’m standing by my friend. I think it’s best that we don’t speak”. And leave it at that.[/quote]
He's been accused but not convicted? Has he even been prosecuted?

DancesWithTortoises · 27/07/2021 08:31

It's up to you who you talk to but she is innocent and has had no accusation made against her. So I think You are being a bit U.

Terminallysleepdeprived · 27/07/2021 08:30

Having seen a friend go through this where her now exh was charged and subsequently found guilty of grooming I am torn.

I do understand your need to believe your friend, but equally his wife may have had absolutely no knowledge of what was going on (if indeed the accusations are true and none of us really know for sure).

I think you are wrong to be rude to her. She isn't the one who may have hurt your friend. I know how devastating it was for my friend when people would shun her in the street.

You don't have to be her friend but I do think you should be polite.

SilentPanic · 27/07/2021 08:29

You have no idea what kind of life she is living. You have no idea what kind of pressure she is under to chat to you or try and befriend you. If her husband is the kind of man who is capable of child abuse, he's automatically a master manipulator and liar. I'd say hello to her and then make my excuses. Don't punish her for being with someone who is probably making her life hell.

orangejuicer · 27/07/2021 08:26

Regardless of anything he may have done, you are not obliged to talk to anyone you don't want to. Stand your ground.

PieceOfString · 27/07/2021 08:22

"This is a person who I believe did this horrible thing to my friend and they are trying to act like nothing is happening and it just feels so wrong."

Trust your instincts, it's not rude, it's not surprising, you absolutely don't have to tolerate her desire to talk to you. Squashminus and atrocious circumstance are spot on.

AtrociousCircumstance · 27/07/2021 07:43

[quote Zebraaa]@AtrociousCircumstance and your attitude is exactly what’s wrong with the legal system.
He isn’t a paedophile because he hasn’t been charged with anything![/quote]
You’re confused - I’m not the legal system and neither is the OP. It’s her right to decide to believe her friend and not want to interact with the man who abused her or those who support him.

So you’re saying it undermines the legal system for a woman not to be a good girl and say hello nicely to someone she abhors?

Yeah ok Hmm

SquashMinusIsShit · 27/07/2021 06:47

Listen, you’re standing by your husband which is your choice, but I’m standing by my friend. I think it’s best that we don’t speak

This is good, you are being polite enough but hopefully she'll get the message. Like hell would I speak to her, she's chosen to stand by her disgusting husband and she has to live with the consequences.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 04:29

But what he is or is not in the eyes of the law is not really my concern. He likely won't be charged because this is an incident which happened many years ago and is essentially one person's word against anothers. (Which happens all the time and doesn't mean the person isn't guilty).

However to me, as a person who believes my friend completely, he is a paedophile and I don't want anything to do with him or his wife as that makes me uncomfortable.

If you believed someone had raped your friend for example, would you want to make small talk with his girlfriend or wife who had essentially called your friend a liar by believing he hadn't done it simply because he had gotten away with it in the eyes of the law and so technically was innocent?

I believe he has done this and by the sounds of it it isn't the first time either. I have made that judgement based on the information I have from the people involved and from my own gut feeling. What happens in court doesn't change that for me.

She doesn't have to divorce him or leave him that's her choice. Is it not mine to then make the decision that she's no longer a person I wish to be in contact with?

I recently had a baby and received card and gifts with his and her name signed on them! This is a person who I believe did this horrible thing to my friend and they are trying to act like nothing is happening and it just feels so wrong.

OP posts:
MissTrip82 · 27/07/2021 04:12

@Itsmeagainandagain

She won't divorce him because according to the law he's an innocent man until proven guilty..
This maxim applies in one place only: a criminal court.

Outside of that people are free to judge as they see fit.

If you think the only paedophiles are those who’ve been convicted you are very very foolish indeed.

I wouldn’t choose to engage with someone who believed this man if I did not.

Zebraaa · 27/07/2021 03:18

@AtrociousCircumstance and your attitude is exactly what’s wrong with the legal system.
He isn’t a paedophile because he hasn’t been charged with anything!

Swipe left for the next trending thread