Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that self service tills are horrible

265 replies

uglyflowers · 26/07/2021 22:20

In my area there used to be lots of individual shops and a sense of community. Then they built a massive Tesco which put all the little shops out of business. But local jobs were promised instead. Then those staff members’ hours were cut so many were part time and had their living boosted by benefits. And now they are being replaced by machines. Near me they are trialling two completely self service supermarkets. So eventually all the poor bloody ‘key workers’ who risked their health during Covid and who pay income tax etc will be replaced with machines.
And what about shops as community hubs? Can’t be the local library for that since they closed ours down. So those people who are a bit lonely won’t even get their two minutes of chat.
Additionally I don’t WANT to scan my big shops. I like someone doing it. They get paid to do it. I don’t.
I think everyone should boycott them. They won’t use them if we refuse to.

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 27/07/2021 10:21

@CounsellorTroi, another added advantage, no nicking petrol. Grin

CounsellorTroi · 27/07/2021 10:20

@Sparklingbrook

I always use the machine at the station to buy a ticket, and the 24 hour garage you can only pay at the pump between around 11pm and 7am which is great. Saves so much time. In face Pay at the Pump should be at every petrol station, all the time.
It should be because it makes it impossible to fill up and drive away without paying. The pump won’t dispense without a card.
PamTheSpam · 27/07/2021 10:18

@Kazzyhoward , I honestly don't care what profit they make that's their business but I absolutely hate self service tills

Lockheart · 27/07/2021 10:18

They are a bit miserable though. Whenever one thinks of a fully automated future one imagines that it would look like Tokyo, all seamless and gleaming with the only noise being a series of reassuring beeps. But the self service area always looks desolate, grubby and a bit shit and cluttered, with an accumulation of detritus that it isn't quite anyone's job to give a shit about, with an air of mild confusion.

That's a UK thing though (I say this as a fully paid up member of the half-English half-Welsh race), not a self-service thing.

We too could have sleek and aesthetically pleasing if we bothered enough and didn't vandalise everything at the drop of a hat.

Kazzyhoward · 27/07/2021 10:13

@PamTheSpam

I hate them and will refuse to use them if possible It's just another marketing ploy to increase their profits which is fine for them but bad news for the community I like the personal touch
Not true.

Profit per employee or per customer or per square footage of a supermarket isn't that much different to a small independent shop, in fact some smaller shops are more profitable on those metrics.

People get their knickers in a twist when they see Tesco have made £10 million profit (or whatever), but fail to "do the math" to break that down as to "per store", "per employee", "per customer", etc etc.

The only valid comparison would be to add up hundreds of random small independent stores, to accumulate to the same size of Tesco group, and then compare.

Sparklingbrook · 27/07/2021 10:13

It's all very worthy to think that by going to a real life cashier you are somehow saving jobs but that's just not the case.
Embrace the change and make things quicker for yourself. I think if people tried Scan as You Shop they would never go back.

I agree @Kazzyhoward, things move on.

Kazzyhoward · 27/07/2021 10:09

There was a time when:-

Self service didn't even exist in shops - everything was behind the counter and you asked the shop owner/assistant for it.

There were attendants at petrol stations who filled up your car for you, there was no self service.

If you wanted money out of the bank, you queued and were given at at the bank counter by a person - no cash machines.

Life moves on.

Think of all the millions of jobs worldwide of people designing, building, installing, servicing and supporting all the different "self service" machines we use today.

Sparklingbrook · 27/07/2021 09:56

I always use the machine at the station to buy a ticket, and the 24 hour garage you can only pay at the pump between around 11pm and 7am which is great. Saves so much time.
In face Pay at the Pump should be at every petrol station, all the time.

phoenixrosehere · 27/07/2021 09:56

I love them as well as the scan and shop which if you’re going to Tesco’s, you have to use them anyway to pay.

I prefer to scan and bag my own groceries because I am usually quicker. I want to get in and out and dislike having to rearrange everything during bagging because the person scanning has decided to pick over what I’ve arranged on the belt how I needed it. They do this almost every time no matter how many times I make it easy to scan the way I’ve done it. I worked at a grocery store, know how to bag groceries so easier for me to just sort it myself.

ChainJane · 27/07/2021 09:53

I disagree. I love self-service tills, other than the occasional hold up when you have alcohol to be scanned they are so much easier and quicker than using a traditional checkout. I love the fact I don't have to make bullshit small talk with someone, I love the fact I don't have someone carelessly throwing my shopping around. I often use the self-service option even if the queue is longer than at the manned checkouts.

The only negative is the aforementioned waiting for a member of staff if you are buying alcohol, or occasional weight issues. The weight problem can be solved by not placing the items directly into your bag. The alcohol issue depends on how efficient the staff are. Generally I find if the staff are efficient at normal tills they are also efficient at the self-service ones, and vice-versa. So either way, it's a slightly better experience using the DIY option.

I think the argument that it costs jobs is largely irrelevant. Low-skilled jobs are always the first to be automated, Luddites can complain but you can't stop progress. Automation is likely to make many jobs obsolete in the next few decades. The solution is not to try to fight progress and efficiency but to tax companies where automation is introduced so as to be able to afford to pay a universal basic income.

Ultimately the ideal situation would be nobody having to work if they don't want to, with a decent UBI of say £25k per annum at current levels. People who are focused on making money can work in areas that are harder to automate, people who currently work to survive can instead spend their time improving their lives, their health, their minds.

Don't fight progress, don't fear change.

SeeYaBeYa · 27/07/2021 09:38

Apparently they don't actually make people lose their jobs; they just do different things instead.

I like that it's easy to get a bag without paying for one with them. Fucked if I'm finding, selecting, scanning, packing and paying for shopping and paying for bags as well.

They are a bit miserable though. Whenever one thinks of a fully automated future one imagines that it would look like Tokyo, all seamless and gleaming with the only noise being a series of reassuring beeps. But the self service area always looks desolate, grubby and a bit shit and cluttered, with an accumulation of detritus that it isn't quite anyone's job to give a shit about, with an air of mild confusion.

RandomLondoner · 27/07/2021 09:32

Jobs don't exist so people can have salaries. Salaries exists so the jobs that need to be done get done. Paying people to do things that could be done by machines mean money is wasted. The salaries could have been spent on getting people to do more of the things that can't be done by machines.

RandomLondoner · 27/07/2021 09:29

The reasons for your objections are wrong. Machines replacing people does not raise unemployment in the long-term. (It may cause some short-term unemployment because people need to change jobs.) They do cause an increase in total wealth, some of which could be redistributed.

Sparklingbrook · 27/07/2021 09:25

The Waitrose self service tills are very relaxed. Grin

PamTheSpam · 27/07/2021 09:17

I hate them and will refuse to use them if possible
It's just another marketing ploy to increase their profits which is fine for them but bad news for the community
I like the personal touch

Bryonyshcmyony · 27/07/2021 09:17

I love scan and pay, but the self scanning tills are a PITA and often filthy

Tal45 · 27/07/2021 09:16

I like them. Waitrose ones are by far the best, they don't weigh anything any more so there's no 'unexpected item in bagging area' or it asking you to put the item in the bag when you already have. They also don't film you like our Sainsburys does. Tesco and Morrison ones are not nearly so good.

Isitsixoclockalready · 27/07/2021 09:15

There is strength in what you're saying OP but self service tills are here to stay.

icedcoffees · 27/07/2021 09:13

Jobs are lost all the time due to machines, but new ones are created in their place.

I suspect everyone on here enjoys the convenience of a car or bus/train as opposed to horse and cart Wink

Society changes and moves on. Those jobs that have disappeared will be replaced with different jobs. 'Twas ever thus.

hennybeans · 27/07/2021 09:12

I don't mind them at Sainsbury's if I've just got a small shop because their machines work well.

I can't stand the Morrison's machines as there's a delay of maybe 3-4 seconds after you scan something before you can scan the next thing. Drives me insane.

If I have a trolley full, which I mostly do, I want someone else to scan because it's so much quicker.

Where I used to live in the States, not only would there be a cashier scanning your groceries, but a ( usually) teenager standing at the end to pack them for you and wait for it.... Then push your trolley out to your car for you and load the groceries into your boot. Gasoline was also 99 cents a gallon. Two things I'll never see in my lifetime again. ( This was about 20 years ago)

Dreamstate · 27/07/2021 09:11

There is room for both. Human checkout for large shops and self check for smaller ones.

I love that my local Mayland has self checkout cos my god the queues before were horrendous so much that to even buy one item id not bother going.

What annoys me now is at my large tacos people with a full trolley use the self check out now, cuasing more queue time when they should be using the human checkouts so those of us with few items can get out quicker.

JacquelineCarlyle · 27/07/2021 09:09

YANBU Op - for all the reasons you have given.

Rosebel · 27/07/2021 09:09

I hate them. When they increased them where I work all the checkout staff had to reapply for their jobs and quite a few weren't rehired.
Also they never seem to work properly and I think supermarkets must loose so much money through people stealing.
Presumably the shops that are totally self service still have to employ staff to help on the tills for when they don't work properly.

igelkott2021 · 27/07/2021 09:08

I remember an early episode of Sherlock where Watson has a a tantrum with a self-service till. So well observed and funny :)

I like them, as it means I can get in and out of a shop quickly.

I do not like them when I want to buy an age-restricted item, although to be honest that's no better if the person on the manned till is 17,

My biggest bugbear is not being able to fill my bag as I go with some of the tills. In theory you can put your bag on the scales and fill it up' in practice it doesn't work. So you spend twice as long there as you need to which is hardly sensible during covid.

Mummyoflittledragon · 27/07/2021 09:07

@Lockheart

Machines taking jobs from humans, whatever next.

I mean it's ok for the dishwasher, the washing machine, the tumble dryer, the calculator, the tractor, the combine harvester, the automated looms, the hoover, the myriad of factory machinery too numerous to count, the bin lorry, the sewing machine, the computer and so forth...

But automated checkouts?? Alert the church elders! Truly we are seeing the fall of society. I say bring back laundrymaids and the mangle, and have clerks write everything out in ledgers again, that'll create a tonne of jobs.

These all made life easier. Self service checkouts on balance do not do so for the customer. Some love them. More definitely do not.