Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that self service tills are horrible

265 replies

uglyflowers · 26/07/2021 22:20

In my area there used to be lots of individual shops and a sense of community. Then they built a massive Tesco which put all the little shops out of business. But local jobs were promised instead. Then those staff members’ hours were cut so many were part time and had their living boosted by benefits. And now they are being replaced by machines. Near me they are trialling two completely self service supermarkets. So eventually all the poor bloody ‘key workers’ who risked their health during Covid and who pay income tax etc will be replaced with machines.
And what about shops as community hubs? Can’t be the local library for that since they closed ours down. So those people who are a bit lonely won’t even get their two minutes of chat.
Additionally I don’t WANT to scan my big shops. I like someone doing it. They get paid to do it. I don’t.
I think everyone should boycott them. They won’t use them if we refuse to.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nanny0gg · 04/08/2023 14:05

Pedalpushers · 26/07/2021 22:25

Sorry, love a self service till, I'm faster than the people on the checkouts and the queues are much shorter.

I like scan as you shop, let alone the SS till!

And I fold clothes much better than any assistant I've had lately

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 14:01

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 13:19

But what about all the new jobs in designing and building the self service tills, developing and installing the software, service and maintenance workers, etc.

It's been happening throughout time. Some jobs disappear, others appear. You don't see many blacksmiths, chimney sweeps nor farriers around anymore, do you? Yes, there are a few, but nothing like a hundred years ago when they'd be in every village. We have gas heating engineers, motor mechanics, etc. instead.

I'm aware of all that, so I don't need an 'education' thanks.

Yes, things develop and new roles emerge but it seems it's the customer facing/service roles that are becoming obsolete.

As someone else has pointed out, chatting to a cashier in the supermarket might be the only interaction someone gets. We shouldn't be in a hurry to replace people with tech.

KatieB55 · 04/08/2023 13:19

I hate them too and much prefer manned checkouts. Also for some elderly people it is their only human interaction and that's important too.

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 13:19

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 13:07

Selecting your own items in a shop (otherwise known as shopping!) is a world away from doing an actual cashier's job.

As for these roles being 're-deployed', you and I both know that's not happening. Nothing is ever introduced to benefit customers and staff, it's just to cut overheads.

This also applies to using ATMs. I'll use them to get cash out on occasion - but I will always insist on seeing a cashier inside the branch for anything else.

For me, I'm happy to wait for the person serving, knowing that my patience is (hopefully) keeping them employed.

But what about all the new jobs in designing and building the self service tills, developing and installing the software, service and maintenance workers, etc.

It's been happening throughout time. Some jobs disappear, others appear. You don't see many blacksmiths, chimney sweeps nor farriers around anymore, do you? Yes, there are a few, but nothing like a hundred years ago when they'd be in every village. We have gas heating engineers, motor mechanics, etc. instead.

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 13:07

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 12:34

Do you feel the same about all the other things that we now do ourselves, such as filling a car with petrol, using a cash machine, etc? How did you feel when shops become self-service after previously been counters where the shopkeeper got everything for you?

Staff do different things, such as keeping the shelves stocked, being far more accessible for customer queries on the shop floor, tidying, picking home delivery orders, etc.

Selecting your own items in a shop (otherwise known as shopping!) is a world away from doing an actual cashier's job.

As for these roles being 're-deployed', you and I both know that's not happening. Nothing is ever introduced to benefit customers and staff, it's just to cut overheads.

This also applies to using ATMs. I'll use them to get cash out on occasion - but I will always insist on seeing a cashier inside the branch for anything else.

For me, I'm happy to wait for the person serving, knowing that my patience is (hopefully) keeping them employed.

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 12:34

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 12:16

I hate them for 2 reasons:

  1. I'm not paid to work there
  2. I'm keen to protect the jobs of the people who do work there.

Do you feel the same about all the other things that we now do ourselves, such as filling a car with petrol, using a cash machine, etc? How did you feel when shops become self-service after previously been counters where the shopkeeper got everything for you?

Staff do different things, such as keeping the shelves stocked, being far more accessible for customer queries on the shop floor, tidying, picking home delivery orders, etc.

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/08/2023 12:16

I hate them for 2 reasons:

  1. I'm not paid to work there
  2. I'm keen to protect the jobs of the people who do work there.
girlfriend44 · 04/08/2023 11:10

They are awful, they are making you do the job of the cashier.

Kazzyhoward · 04/08/2023 10:41

Blossomtoes · 03/08/2023 09:25

It’s not much of a choice if there’s only one manned checkout and it’s got a queue like an execution. Surely that should tell them something.

Will depend on the type of shop, local, and local demographics.

In our village Co Op, virtually everyone uses the self service machines.

The shop assistants only go to the "proper" till/counter if someone's waiting there, otherwise they're all busy on the shop floor, filling shelves, tidying, helping with customer queries, etc.

From casual observation, I'd say most customers only go to the counter to buy cigarettes, lottery tickets, etc.

And this is a village with quite a significant elderly population, most of whom seem to be able to use the self service tills well enough. Though, must admit, the staff are VERY helpful and happy to spend time showing people how to use them.

Elleherd · 03/08/2023 10:42

Scan as you shop is brilliant for wheelchair users, (until staff want items from the bottom of the bag for a security check, but expect you to find somewhere else to now repack so it all fits.) It does mean having to use cards.
Self scan is a 2nd best option, and they're forcing card use through those too..

Manned belts are hell for many in wheelchairs. We have long had to battle to be allowed to pack our own shopping so it's transportable on laps and chairs, working from belts too high to properly reach, not how others want it packed, and well meaning cashiers etc interfering.
Yes they'll organize someone to take the extra bags they've created and charged me for, to my vehicle, but what am I supposed to do the other end? Their answer is often to make my day worse by insisting there must be people around to help me the other end, with the problem they've created for me.
I only buy what I can manage alone on one trip, because that's my physical limitations, so it's Tetris packed.
Choice is the simple answer.

But I don't disagree with insisting on using whatever systems you feel will keep society as a whole working best.

Blossomtoes · 03/08/2023 09:25

It’s not much of a choice if there’s only one manned checkout and it’s got a queue like an execution. Surely that should tell them something.

Northernsouloldies · 03/08/2023 05:45

You got it in one, choice. It shouldn't have to be one or the other.

Vates · 03/08/2023 05:40

I love the self-checkouts, they are really quick. I go to Asda once a week and only have a basket so it is easy to go through. There is usually one manned checkout open if you go after 8am but always a long queue. There are also 4 much larger trolley self checkouts. So a choice.

Northernsouloldies · 03/08/2023 05:35

Self service tills sold to the public as convience as you work for free scanning and packing your shopping. Not believing scan n go is quicker, I've noticed I'm out first with a weekly shop compared to some scanners that have been doddling in front of me getting in the effing way.

SirSmellyJohn · 03/08/2023 01:52

Morrison's self service tills hate me. Ditto Tesco's. Lidl, sometimes are a pain in the butt. Aldi and Asda, hardly ever. Co o p never. Co o p ones are a dream. But I can't afford a whole grocery shop there. Just bits and pieces .

Kazzyhoward · 02/08/2023 17:15

I love self service tills, and my choice of local convenience store is the one which has them, rather than the one which doesn't (both similar size, both smaller franchise chains, one a One-Stop, the other a Spar). Far quicker to use the self service tills, rather than be forced to wait in a queue behind people wanting to chat or taking forever to find their purse, or deciding they want something else and wandering back to the shelves whilst holding everyone up.

Yes, they're hard to use at first, sometimes clunky, but when you get experience in using them, where to put unscanned/scanned items, how to press buttons for weight of fruit/veg, when to present cards, etc., it gets easier and easier the more you use them.

In the store with them, the staff are actually out doing useful things on the shop floor, like stacking shelves, and are more accessible to ask questions rather than being stood behind a counter waiting for Aunt Ethel to find her purse!

Disl · 02/08/2023 15:57

I hate them and refuse to use them and will walk out of the shop without buying anything if there's no option of a staffed human checkout. However I have started using small independent grocery stores and have found some of the prices not too bad and that I actually spend a lot less as am not lured by supermarket promotions etc. In the future I can see my shopping habits changing if supermarkets don't offer choice of a manned till. Will abandon the large soulless supermarkets and use small independent shops and markets and leave the supermarkets for the shoplifters who take advantage of self service.

sst1234 · 28/07/2021 12:30

@igelkott2021

The staff absolutely are deployed elsewhere, just not where you can necessarily see them in your store. Just like the extra space from removing manned checkouts is really deployed for stocking more items. Who do you think is working in the tech sector creating this kit, engineering it, maintaining it, looking at machine learning algorithms to make sure that theft is managed

That is very different - what people are saying is that the customer facing staff are being removed. And interestingly they are generally female, and tech staff are generally male. I would also imagine the tech staff are outsourced and don't work for the shops themselves - some of the machines are the same, eg Sainsburys/Boots/WH Smith, whereas Waitrose and M&S seem to use different ones.

And the tech staff devising these machines need to do some shopping and try them out themselves.

It’s called change. It happens. Has done since the dawn of time, and will continue to do so. Checkouts cannot be retained as an exception.
LalalalalalaLand123 · 28/07/2021 12:28

I love self-service tills, I always choose to use them!

Blossomtoes · 28/07/2021 12:19

@sst1234

So basically you are complaining about automation, not self service tolls per se. I guess luddites have been around for a long time, that nothing new. Change happens, get over it. When card arrives and horse and cart coachman went out of business, I’m sure some people felt the same then.
No, I’m complaining about shit, clunky technology. They malfunction constantly, they’re as far away from intuitive as you can get and they’re using customers to trouble shoot the design. I’m far from a Luddite but tech should make life easier and smoother not more difficult.

Your point about inflation is incorrect. At the time these abominations were introduced inflation was at historic lows.

withlotsoflove · 28/07/2021 11:15

[quote Badbadbunny]**@igelkott2021* Filling the shelves can wait*

No it can't. Shoppers would soon be complaining (and they do) when shelves are empty. Having stock on the shelves is just as important as having someone on the till. In fact, moreso, because it would take the staff even more time if they have to keep nipping off into the back to find stock items that people ask them for which aren't on the shelves. Just look at the current situation in supermarkets where shelves are empty because staff are isolating. In our local village Co Op, there was a couple of days last week when the crisp stand was literally completely empty. The boxes of crisps were in the back, but they had no staff to actually put them out! If more customers used the self service tills, the counter staff would have had more time to do shelf stacking.[/quote]
Exactly!

withlotsoflove · 28/07/2021 11:14

@igelkott2021
It certainly is unfair for those on grocery to get behind on their own work / to support checkouts because Mr * is too stubborn to learn how to use them!
Queuing for one item - crazy!
Plus - l deal with the customers when they can’t find something. I know we have it in - but it hasn’t been worked!
Why? Because those colleagues are stuck on tills. So it’s very important to have products available for our customers- it’s why they’ve come in. Surely? Grin

DynamoKev · 28/07/2021 11:03

@sst1234

So basically you are complaining about automation, not self service tolls per se. I guess luddites have been around for a long time, that nothing new. Change happens, get over it. When card arrives and horse and cart coachman went out of business, I’m sure some people felt the same then.
I'd suggest doing some reading about the Luddites before casually tossing it about as an insult.

Change happens, get over it Not much use to the Luddites - no dole at the time, no affordable regular transport to travel to a different job. They and their families faced starvation - they were not just thick idiots opposed to change. Not all all progress is good for everyone (or even the majority) - as in the case of the weaving frames, it enabled the enrichment of a few capitalists at the expense of the larger population of poorly paid workers.

Badbadbunny · 28/07/2021 11:00

@igelkott2021 Filling the shelves can wait

No it can't. Shoppers would soon be complaining (and they do) when shelves are empty. Having stock on the shelves is just as important as having someone on the till. In fact, moreso, because it would take the staff even more time if they have to keep nipping off into the back to find stock items that people ask them for which aren't on the shelves. Just look at the current situation in supermarkets where shelves are empty because staff are isolating. In our local village Co Op, there was a couple of days last week when the crisp stand was literally completely empty. The boxes of crisps were in the back, but they had no staff to actually put them out! If more customers used the self service tills, the counter staff would have had more time to do shelf stacking.

AuntieMarys · 28/07/2021 10:59

Love them. Always do shop and scan at Sainsbury's.

Swipe left for the next trending thread