Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give DD a lift to work

192 replies

ShrekandDonkey · 26/07/2021 19:53

16 year old DD finished school at the end of May and wanted to get herself a job for the summer. DH and I made her a CV, emailed it around and we she got a job as a waitress in a restaurant on the coast.

Now this restaurant is only about 5 miles away but as it is literally on the beach the roads are narrow (anyone who has been to Cornwall will understand) and the bus service is practically non existent. Because of this DH and I have been dropping and picking her up for every shift. DH is wfh so is taking time out and using his lunch break to take her and i pick her up on the way home from my job which adds on an extra 30 mins for me. It is actually quite a faff but I told her we were happy to do this short term.

To avoid drip feeding her biological father has taken her once or twice but 9 out of 10 times will say no if she asks for a lift because he's busy or working.

We talked about getting a more convenient job so she applied to the local Tesco and was offered a job. This is walking distance for her. She has turned down the job because she thinks she won't enjoy it as much. I told her I was a bit upset she doesn't appreciate all the running around we do for her and her response was " well it's my job so I can choose what I do". She has never once thanked either of us for taking her or picking her up.

Wibu to tell her if she wants to work that far away from home then she can sort herself out for getting there and back? She told me she was happy to get the bus so off she went. I don't think she realises how much the bus fayre here is! I can't work out if I'm being too harsh on a 16 year old or should it be a lesson she needs to learn?

OP posts:
TheMadGardener · 27/07/2021 01:36

I think some people here are giving you a hard time, OP. I grew up in a Cornish village. My mother wasn't prepared to ferry us around by the time we were 16. I got the bus to my summer jobs, my sister got herself a moped. YANBU.

Mzombie · 27/07/2021 01:27

Exactly. If you choose to need live somewhere where children will likely need lifts to get to activities/ work/ friends then you suck up doing it. Not fair on them otherwise. You can't dictate that they can only do activities/ get jobs/ have friends within a tiny area where that isn't required.

ClareBlue · 27/07/2021 01:17

I think most of us in Rural Ireland would find the discussion in this hard to grasp. Our teenager does shifts 12 miles away in the nearest town which we take him to and pick him up from. There are no public transport options. Very common here and just seen as part of living in a rural area. 5 miles wouldn't even be a thought.

Mzombie · 27/07/2021 01:14

@tallduckandhandsome

Why did you send her CV to this restaurant to try to get her a job there if you didn't want her to get a job there because you knew she couldn't reasonably and safely get there and back on her own and didn't want to give her lifts?

Presumably OP and DH were happy to facilitate to the cafe if it’s all the work dd could get. That’s no longer the case. Dd is 16, she should sort this herself.

Wow. Why on Earth have children if you see any help for them as such a huge inconvenience??
Mzombie · 27/07/2021 01:12

Do you other kids thank you every time you take them to their "activities" in your car OP, or is this something you only expect of your DD? Why? Surely a job is a better reason to need a lift. Or is it because she's older? If so that's a reflection on you not teaching her to be grateful not on her, and I expect your (presumably younger) other children will be equally ungrateful when they reach her stage of development. It seems like you're blaming her for you suggesting she get a job at this place, her getting it, and her behaving how you've brought her up to behave. Confused

Mzombie · 27/07/2021 01:08

@tallduckandhandsome

Jesus she is 16. It's her first job. Why are people so mean to their kids?

It’s not a question of being mean, it’s logic. It doesn’t make sense for add 30 minutes to her journey to pick up dd when DD was offered a job that pays twice as much at Tesco’s that’s within walking distance.

Yes. If it's her first ever experience of work and her parents encouraged her to take this job in the first place and she's now settled and happy there, and they're quite happy to take other siblings around in the car to activities that are just for fun not work. Then yes, it does make sense.
Lou98 · 27/07/2021 00:23

Going to go against the grain here but I do think YABU!

She's 16, it's a summer job, not her long term career.

She's said she's happy to get the bus there and back so I don't really see what the issue is - yes she should have said thank you and you should definitely talk to her about being more grateful but honestly you sound as though your bigger problem is she didn't take the Tesco job because that's what you would have done.

Logically yes the job in Tesco would have made more sense because it's closer and pays more but I agree with her that it will likely be less fun, which at 16 id say it's more important that she has a job she enjoys when it's only for a couple months for some extra money rather than her being older and needing it to pay bills etc.

Also just because you enjoyed Tesco doesn't mean she will. When I was at uni I worked in both hospitality customer facing (pubs) and also in Asda. I much preferred the atmosphere of customer facing, getting to talk to customers and colleagues etc, I hated working in Asda (I had bills at the time so couldn't prioritise enjoyment). I now have my own (well paying) job that I really enjoy so her not choosing the higher paying job now doesn't mean she won't in the future.

Let her enjoy her summer in the job she enjoys, you don't need to take her there and back. Has she thought about getting a bike?

feejee · 27/07/2021 00:05

Moped. I was in the same situation at 16, summer job in a pub kitchen, i cycled the 5 miles each way in daytime and dad drove me in the evening. It wasnt long before i got a moped. It was awesome...i could get up to 35mph going down hill!

tallduckandhandsome · 27/07/2021 00:02

*for OP to add 30 mins

tallduckandhandsome · 27/07/2021 00:01

Jesus she is 16. It's her first job. Why are people so mean to their kids?

It’s not a question of being mean, it’s logic. It doesn’t make sense for add 30 minutes to her journey to pick up dd when DD was offered a job that pays twice as much at Tesco’s that’s within walking distance.

tallduckandhandsome · 26/07/2021 23:59

Why did you send her CV to this restaurant to try to get her a job there if you didn't want her to get a job there because you knew she couldn't reasonably and safely get there and back on her own and didn't want to give her lifts?

Presumably OP and DH were happy to facilitate to the cafe if it’s all the work dd could get. That’s no longer the case. Dd is 16, she should sort this herself.

Mzombie · 26/07/2021 23:59

She's not 25, she's 16 and doing a summer job. Why do people want to make things even more miserable for teenagers who've had a year from hell?

Mzombie · 26/07/2021 23:58

@tallduckandhandsome

YANBU, you and DH have been very generous with lifts but she hasn’t valued them.

Time for her to see the consequences of taking lifts for granted.

If she doesn’t yet realise that crappy cafe wage + high bus fares make this a very poor decision on her part, then this will be a good lesson for her.

Jesus she is 16. It's her first job. Why are people so mean to their kids?
Mzombie · 26/07/2021 23:57

@ShrekandDonkey

I've already said I don't live rurally. There are buses from my town every 10 mins in any direction. Its the fact the restaurant is rural so she needs to catch another bus, which comes once every hour.

DD could easily get a job closer but is choosing not to. Which I've told her is fine but the rate she needs dropping off and picking up is not sustainable. She said she is happy to get the bus but I give it a week before she realises how easy she has had it. Maybe then she may be more appreciative.

Why did you send her CV to this restaurant to try to get her a job there if you didn't want her to get a job there because you knew she couldn't reasonably and safely get there and back on her own and didn't want to give her lifts?
tallduckandhandsome · 26/07/2021 23:57

YANBU, you and DH have been very generous with lifts but she hasn’t valued them.

Time for her to see the consequences of taking lifts for granted.

If she doesn’t yet realise that crappy cafe wage + high bus fares make this a very poor decision on her part, then this will be a good lesson for her.

OliviaNewtAndJohn · 26/07/2021 23:50

As it’s coming into August, the restaurant will probably get busier and she might get offered more shifts as her experience and confidence grows. Would you be comfortable if she were getting lifts from colleagues? Once she has money in her pocket for the bus (or a taxi at a push), I’d encourage her to work it out. Hospitality is a very transferable skill and she might spend many summers and evenings waitressing if she goes to uni. I think it’s great she is getting the work.

Taliskerskye · 26/07/2021 23:40

Meh
Let her make her own choices, no one wants to work in Tesco. It’s not a dream of a teenager.

ShrekandDonkey · 26/07/2021 23:29

I've already said I don't live rurally. There are buses from my town every 10 mins in any direction. Its the fact the restaurant is rural so she needs to catch another bus, which comes once every hour.

DD could easily get a job closer but is choosing not to. Which I've told her is fine but the rate she needs dropping off and picking up is not sustainable. She said she is happy to get the bus but I give it a week before she realises how easy she has had it. Maybe then she may be more appreciative.

OP posts:
bellabasset · 26/07/2021 23:09

I live in a village in Cornwall near the former Strawbridge farmhouse, an easy cycle ride to the beach, near the mainline rail station but 4 or 5 miles from Fowey by bus. There's a family friendly pub on the nearby beach, but far more trendy restaurants in Fowey. Definitely not a safe cycle route on unlit twisted roads.

I know from local teens that they would prefer the jobs in Fowey to the pub, and they get tips. So I'd let her arrange her travel. All of us have suffered with the pandemic so I think I'd be pleased she's doing a job she likes. I'm of the generation where we could do part-time jobs at 14 and dps helped us find jobs whilst we were at school.

transformandriseup · 26/07/2021 23:05

I do sort of see where OP is coming from. If you live in Cornwall and you are looking for work the journey to get there will likely determine what job you choose as you need to factor in cost travelling long distances, time to get there allowing for tractors and holiday traffic and if it is on a public transport route if you don't drive.

However 16 is young to have to factor all this into your life just yet and I think where you have the above issues with finding work it is not uncommon to be driven to work by parents as long as the young person is grateful for them doing so.

I am not sure if the OP knows this if her DD is still happy to take the bus she can buy a batch of bus tickets which works out at £5 a day or £2.5 if you are only travelling locally. The issue would be whether the buses are running at the time her DD starts and finishes her shifts.

babyguffingtonstrikesagain · 26/07/2021 23:02

You say she wanted to 'get herself a job'. She didn't though did she? You got it for her. I think you may be now reaping the consequences of that.

You need to explain that the lifts aren't working, apologise for encouraging her into a job in an unsuitable location and then give her a reasonable timescale in which to find a new job (at which point the lifts will stop).

Mzombie · 26/07/2021 22:54

@ShrekandDonkey

I forgot to add I do have 2 other DC who also require ferrying around for various clubs etc. It's not like I'm sat at home making DD get the bus when I could easily take her. I do have a full time job too!
But that's part of choosing to live in an area with poor public transport and several kids, surely? If you're happy to give the others lifts to fun stuff why is there an issue about giving her lifts for work?
ShrekandDonkey · 26/07/2021 22:50

I forgot to add I do have 2 other DC who also require ferrying around for various clubs etc. It's not like I'm sat at home making DD get the bus when I could easily take her. I do have a full time job too!

OP posts:
DirtyDancing · 26/07/2021 22:40

@ShrekandDonkey

And I've told her several times how proud I am of her. She has made getting a job look very easy so far tbh.

It was probably more the cocky attitude of well I will get the bus so I don't need you anyway. We also take her friend who has just started working there too, again that was just expected of us (DD told her friend we would before even asking us).

She made getting a job easy?

You said in your first post YOU did her CV and emailed it round for her.

Sounds like you've made getting a job easy for her... now she's getting ferried around. Not sure she's learning as much she could from the situation tbh

TheSkatesOfCoachBombay · 26/07/2021 22:39

If she's happy to catch the bus she's happy. Let her do it.

Does she only work sorta middle of the day. Not to sure openings or closings would be easy on a bus. That would be my only concern.

Having been a hospitality manager I can tell you the young waitresses build lovely friendships and they learn team work and helping eachother out. It's lovely to watch them grow in confidence and understanding of team work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread