Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if a vasectomy is really that bad?

134 replies

DrSeuss · 26/07/2021 19:16

I suspect it is painful and somewhat embarrassing. I should add, it isn’t DH who is making a fuss or playing the victim, he finds the leaflet we have been given as sill as I do. I just want to check that it’s usually pretty straightforward. If you tell me it’s really awful I will take care of him, I promise!
The leaflet says no driving for 48 hours, no lifting heavy things for a week. It seems to suggest that it will be very traumatic.

I have had two children, both pretty easy births but still involving pushing a human out of my fanny while already feeling shit through nine months of working as a teacher while pregnant. As is the modern way, much to my mother’s surprise, I was then expected to look after the baby completely until discharged 24 hrs later. I had it far easier than some and vividly remember seeing a woman stagger down the corridor in the maternity ward with a wheel cot in one hand and a drip stand for her blood transfusion in the other. With baby number 2, I was home a few hour after the birth. The following day I did two loads of washing and the day after that I took my son to school then drove myself and the baby to the supermarket. My husband had to work and we have no family nearby to help. I just had to get on with it. I imagine many women do something similar.
A part of me finds the vasectomy booklet hilarious but another part is annoyed that it suggests men need gentle handling while I and many others just had to crack on.
If you say I am being unfair and that he will be incapacitated then fair enough, he can sit around with an ice pack on his nads or whatever!

OP posts:
crabbingbucket · 27/07/2021 11:12

The embarrassment and uncomfortable factors can do one after all the smears, labours, piles, UTIs etc. That we go through. Any complaints about vasectomies get a short shrift from me.

My ex had one, couple of days of paracetamol and he didn't drive for a day or so then he was right as rain

ButterflyBitch · 27/07/2021 11:09

@SourAppleChew

10% of men have long term pain which is sometimes incurable.
I wonder what the percentage is of women who have long term pain/complications from pregnancy and birth? As someone else said my sympathy is slim to nil too. My husband refused to have it done so I have been sterilised. I will always think less of him for it.m after everything I went through with my pregnancies and births.
MaMelon · 27/07/2021 10:57

My first birth was painfree and to be frank orgasmic

I rather suspect that if you compare the number of pain free and orgasmic births to the ones that are painful and non-orgasmic you’ll see that you’re in a tiny, tiny minority. So while there will always be outliers, no, overall, I don’t think it depends.

pleasedonttextmyman · 27/07/2021 10:55

I can't see how the comparison with childbirth is helpful or relevant Confused

Some births and recovery are a walk in the park,
others take weeks if not months to recover, with long-lasting damage that need surgery, let alone a huge mental trauma that is too easily dismissed.

Pretending that all mothers will, and should, "crack on" is so sexist and unhelpful.

People talking about their own vasectomy are relevant, even if everyone is different.

ancientgran · 27/07/2021 10:48

@Tal45

Definitely no comparison with childbirth!! Not even in the same ball park.
Don't you think that depends? My first birth was painfree and to be frank orgasmic. I wish they'd all been the same but that's another matter.

Some vasectomies, maybe the vast majority, are simple and easy but I would bet the worst experiences would be worse than my first birth.

Youdiditanyway · 27/07/2021 10:44

Great thread, thanks for starting it. My DH is having one soon and he’s really making a big deal about it. I’ve had 3 vaginal births including forceps and 2 c-sections plus 3 rather horrible miscarriages. I think he’ll be ok Grin.

Tal45 · 27/07/2021 10:43

Definitely no comparison with childbirth!! Not even in the same ball park.

MaMelon · 27/07/2021 10:42

DH had no problems - I dropped him off at the family planning clinic, he had the procedure which did hurt a bit, and then I picked him up. A bit of tenderness for a couple of days, but that was it really. Nothing in comparison to what women go through giving birth and birth control is now very easy and straightforward - brilliant!

Tal45 · 27/07/2021 10:40

Mine drove himself home after he'd had it done. It was tender but oh so worth it.

TheFormidableMrsC · 27/07/2021 10:37

My exh had to have it done twice. It was a pity they didn't castrate him but that's another story. He took a few days to recover from the second op.

Be aware though that some very unlucky men are left in permanent pain. I think the risk is quite low but it's still there.

PieceOfString · 27/07/2021 10:36

Resting just makes it more likely the healing will be free from problems, wound opening up etc. My dh was lifting logs on the afternoon of his morning vasectomy cos he's the kind of person who takes no notice of sensible advice and hates sitting still. He got away with it and was fine. So you know, it's just about tipping the odds, you make your choice and you take your chances.

BiBabbles · 27/07/2021 10:35

Pisses me off really when you think about how hard many of us had to fight to get appropriate pain relief during labour.

As I said, it did not give appropriate pain relief - he ended up feeling part of the procedure to the point they had to stop mid procedure to top him up which is unusual for such a short procedure.

The whole reason he got it is, on the day, the anesthesiologist deemed him too heavy/fat to use a local, but didn't want to use a general either so epidural it was. My spouse argued against it because of his back injuries, but was basically given the choice of that or no vasectomy (which he'd waited over a year for and through multiple consultations was never told he might end up with an epidural).

He's really not an example of pain relief done well, it's more compared to how some women do get epidurals during labour but aren't given an appropriate dose.

Antiqueanniesmagiclanternshow · 27/07/2021 10:34

My dh had his in the gp surgery! Took 10 minutes. He rested over the weekend and went back to work on monday.

ancientgran · 27/07/2021 10:31

@Carrott21

if we only listened to negative stories the birthrate would plummet anyway because women would refuse to have babies

Yes and the same as with the vasectomy, I wish I'd listened and taken more seriously the risks of childbirth and how women are lied to.

Childbirth varies so much, which story do you believe? When I had my first I thought it was wonderful, I had no painrelief as I didn't need it. The only bit I found painful was the stitches. Couldn't wait to go through it again only the second time it was a long hard slog. Still not that bad but not fun. The next two were one EMCS, very traumatic, and one rather unpleasant forceps. Not fun at all.

By choosing which birth I told you about I could paint a truly wonderful experience or a hellish day with terrible pain.

I daresay vasectomy stories also vary.

IncludeWomenInThePrequel · 27/07/2021 09:39

Wow, I had no idea some men got epidurals for a vasectomy! DH just had local anaesthetic.

Pisses me off really when you think about how hard many of us had to fight to get appropriate pain relief during labour.

elliejjtiny · 27/07/2021 09:35

Dh was given a leaflet that said to stay in bed for 48 hours afterwards. He then couldn't drive or go to work for 2 weeks after that. When I had an emergency c-section and sepsis and spent 2 days in hdu I got a lot less looking after. Postnatal care really needs to change.

Carrott21 · 27/07/2021 09:22

if we only listened to negative stories the birthrate would plummet anyway because women would refuse to have babies

Yes and the same as with the vasectomy, I wish I'd listened and taken more seriously the risks of childbirth and how women are lied to.

qualitygirl · 27/07/2021 09:10

My dh had it done by the "no scalpal" method. Local anaesthetic so no epidural. Chatted to the doctor the whole way through. He was in work the next day....

Gladimnotcampinginthisweather · 27/07/2021 09:08

Carrot21 if we only listened to negative stories the birthrate would plummet anyway because women would refuse to have babies.

BiBabbles · 27/07/2021 09:04

My spouse had more issues with the epidural used for the vasectomy than he did with the vasectomy itself.

He gets the occasional painful testicular twinge now and then and found the recovery okay, but he already had mechanical damage to the spine and some nerve damage before the operation, had the change in plan on the day so he wasn't really prepared for it (before there was a discussion on local vs general with his size and disabilities), and the epidural got fucked up which resulted both in not getting enough during the first part of the procedure so he felt the tugging enough to flinch which thankfully prompted that being dealt with, and after there was months of back pain being harder to manage and possibly further nerve damage (the latter is hard to tell as nerve damage can be progressive, but there are signs there is a link).

It is ridiculous how most other medical situations get a lot more concern and sympathy compared to birth and related complications, but I'd rather they were more cautious with birth (even as someone who was eager to get home, far better care compared to an overstretched hospital) than be less cautious with other procedures. I think driving caution is normal when certain anesthetics are involved, and the lifting I think there might be a raised rish of testicular hernia during the healing process related to lifting.

QuentinBunbury · 27/07/2021 08:50

I thought the "take it easy" advice was to minimise bruising/swelling/pain rather than because its dangerous or a bad recovery.
To be fair a swollen black and blue scrotum doesn't look too fun! But yes, women are expected to get on with it after far worse.
I particularly enjoy the feeling like your insides might fall our after a VB Blush

Carrott21 · 27/07/2021 08:47

What I'm saying is that I had two horrendous, medicalised, traumatic births, and I was very much, it's your turn now, oh everyone is on the golf course by the afternoon etc. When it went wrong, only then did we look into all the risks etc as if they were real. We have never met anyone who's had a bad one. It's really important to look after him and not trivialise it just because we're women who have been through worse reproductively.

NautaOcts · 27/07/2021 08:46

DH did a bit too much on day 3 or so (commuted into london, went on tube etc) and so he was in a lot of pain, had a lot of soreness for about a week but then was fine

TheSockMonster · 27/07/2021 08:43

I agree with a PP who said it’s not a race to the bottom.

Maternity care is shockingly underfunded in this country and nothing to aspire to. I think the recommendations post vasectomy sound sensible and I think the focus should be on better care for women, not worse care for men.

That said, my DH was one of the lucky ones who bounced straight back and had no problems. I wish the same for your DH, OP.

BlatantlyNameChanged · 27/07/2021 08:36

10% for serious complications (source, NHS Choices) needs thorough consideration

For the purposes of balance, childbirth carries a 20% risk of long term incontinence and a 3% risk of fecal incontinence. Around 13% of women will require an emergency caesarean section (aka, major surgery) and all the risks associated with it. Approximately 90% of women having a vaginal birth will have tear, for some this will be a third or fourth degree tear which has long term effects.

Swipe left for the next trending thread